A Conversation About the Fourth Dimension
The Time Traveller—as we shall call him—was explaining a difficult idea to us.
His grey eyes were bright with excitement, and his normally pale face had become flushed. The fire burned warmly in the room, while the soft glow from the silver lamps reflected in the bubbles rising through our glasses.
The chairs we were sitting in were his own inventions. They seemed to wrap themselves comfortably around us instead of merely giving us somewhere to sit. We had just finished dinner, and the relaxed atmosphere made it easy to let our thoughts wander without worrying too much about precision or logic.
The Time Traveller pointed at different parts of his argument with one thin finger.
“You must listen carefully. I’m going to challenge one or two ideas that almost everyone accepts without question.”
“For example, the geometry you were taught at school is based on a misunderstanding.”
Filby, a red-haired man who enjoyed arguing, immediately objected.
“Isn’t that asking rather a lot from us right at the beginning?”
“I’m not asking you to believe anything without good reason,” the Time Traveller replied.
“You’ll soon agree with me on everything I actually need you to accept.”
“You know, of course, that a mathematical line has no thickness at all. A line with zero thickness doesn’t really exist in the physical world.”
“They taught you that at school, didn’t they?”
The Psychologist nodded.
“Yes, that’s true.”
“And the same applies to a mathematical plane. It has length and width but no thickness. Such things are only ideas we use to describe the world.”
“All right,” said the Psychologist.
“Then think about a cube. A real cube has length, width, and thickness. But can a cube exist if it lasts for absolutely no time?”
Filby frowned.
“I don’t understand.”
“I mean, can a cube that exists for no time whatsoever actually exist in the real world?”
Filby fell silent and thought about it.
The Time Traveller continued.
“Obviously, any real object must exist in four dimensions.”
“It has length, width, thickness—and duration.”
“We tend to forget the fourth dimension because of a natural limitation of our minds and bodies. I’ll explain that in a moment.”
“There are really four dimensions. Three are what we call the dimensions of Space, and the fourth is Time.”
“The only reason we think Time is fundamentally different from the other three is that our consciousness moves through it in only one direction, from the beginning of our lives to the end.”
A very young man, who had been struggling to relight his cigar from the lamp, looked up.
“That… is very clear indeed.”
The Time Traveller smiled.
“It’s rather remarkable that people overlook this so completely.”
“This is what people mean by the Fourth Dimension, although some people who talk about the Fourth Dimension don’t realize that they are really talking about Time.”
“Time is simply another way of looking at the fourth dimension.”
“There is no fundamental difference between Time and the three dimensions of Space, except that our consciousness moves through Time in only one direction.”
The Psychologist leaned forward.
“But what exactly do people mean when they talk about the Fourth Dimension?”
The Time Traveller continued.
“You’ve probably heard some of the philosophical arguments about it.”
“I haven’t,” said the Provincial Mayor.
“Well, the basic idea is simple.”
“We normally say that Space has three dimensions: length, width, and thickness.”
“We can describe these using three planes, each at right angles to the other two.”
“But some philosophers have asked a very reasonable question.”
“Why should Space have exactly three dimensions?”
“Why couldn’t there be another direction, at right angles to all three?”
“Some people have even tried to develop a geometry based on four dimensions.”
“Professor Simon Newcomb was discussing this subject at the New York Mathematical Society only a month or so ago.”
“You understand that a two-dimensional creature living on a flat surface could still draw a picture representing a three-dimensional object.”
“Similarly, if we could understand the perspective properly, perhaps we could use three-dimensional models to represent something that exists in four dimensions.”
“Do you see what I mean?”
“I think so,” murmured the Provincial Mayor.
He frowned deeply and stared into space, his lips moving as though he were repeating some mysterious formula to himself.
After a while, his expression suddenly brightened.
“Yes. I think I understand it now.”
“Well,” said the Time Traveller, “I don’t mind telling you that I’ve been working on four-dimensional geometry for quite some time.”
“Some of the results are very interesting.”
“For example, imagine a portrait of a man at the age of eight.”
“Then another portrait of him at fifteen.”
“Another at seventeen.”
“Another at twenty-three.”
“And so on.”
“All of those portraits would simply be different sections of the same four-dimensional person.”
“In other words, they would be three-dimensional representations of his four-dimensional existence.”
“The complete four-dimensional person would remain a fixed and unchanging whole.”
We were silent for a moment as we tried to understand what he was saying.
The Time Traveller went on.
“Scientists already understand that Time is, in a certain sense, another form of Space.”
“Here’s a simple example.”
He picked up a popular scientific diagram showing changes in the weather.
“This line represents the movement of a barometer.”
“Yesterday the pressure was high.”
“Then last night it fell.”
“This morning it rose again.”
“And then it continued rising slowly until it reached this point.”
“Now tell me—did the mercury physically trace that line through any of the three ordinary dimensions of Space?”
The Medical Man stared thoughtfully into the fire.
“No.”
“Exactly,” said the Time Traveller.
“And yet the mercury did trace a line.”
“So that line must have existed along the fourth dimension—the dimension of Time.”
The Medical Man looked at him.
“But if Time is really just a fourth dimension of Space, why has everyone always treated it as something completely different?”
“And why can’t we move through Time in the same way we move through Space?”
The Time Traveller smiled.
“Are you certain that we can move freely through Space?”
“We can move right and left.”
“We can move forward and backward.”
“People have always been able to do that.”
“So I’ll agree that we can move freely in two dimensions.”
“But what about moving upward and downward?”
“Gravity limits us there.”
“Not completely,” said the Medical Man.
“We have balloons.”
“Yes, but before balloons existed, apart from jumping and dealing with the uneven surface of the ground, people had very little freedom to move vertically.”
“They could still move a little up and down,” the Medical Man argued.
“Much more easily downward than upward.”
“Exactly.”
The Time Traveller leaned back.
“And you say we cannot move through Time at all because we are trapped in the present moment.”
“My dear fellow, that is exactly where you are mistaken.”
“That is where almost everyone has made the same mistake.”
“We are constantly moving away from the present.”
“Our mental existence has no physical dimensions, yet it travels steadily along the dimension of Time, from the moment we are born until the moment we die.”
“It is no different from saying that we would move downward if we began our existence fifty miles above the surface of the Earth.”
The Psychologist interrupted.
“But surely the real problem is this.”
“We can move in every direction through Space.”
“But we cannot move freely through Time.”
“That,” said the Time Traveller, “is the very heart of my discovery.”
“But you are still wrong to say that we cannot move through Time.”
“For example, suppose I remember an event from my childhood very vividly.”
“For a moment, I return to the exact instant when that event happened.”
“I become absent-minded, as you might say.”
“In a sense, I jump backward in Time.”
“Of course, I can’t remain there.”
“Just as a wild animal cannot remain six feet above the ground.”
“But civilization has given us ways to overcome limitations that once seemed impossible.”
“A civilized man can rise into the air in a balloon despite gravity.”
“So why shouldn’t we eventually discover a way to stop or speed up our movement through Time?”
“Perhaps we might even be able to turn around and travel backward through it.”
Filby shook his head.
“Oh, come on. This is all—”
“Why not?” the Time Traveller asked.
“Because it goes against reason.”
“What reason?” asked the Time Traveller.
“You could argue that black is white,” Filby said stubbornly.
“You might even make your argument sound convincing.”
“But you’ll never make me believe this.”
“Perhaps not,” said the Time Traveller calmly.
“But now you can begin to understand why I’ve been studying four-dimensional geometry.”
“Many years ago, I had a vague idea for a machine.”
The Very Young Man suddenly sat upright.
“A machine for travelling through Time!”
“A machine that could travel in any direction through Space or Time, depending entirely on the person controlling it.”
Filby laughed.
The Time Traveller ignored him.
“But I have experimental evidence.”
The Psychologist looked intrigued.
“That would certainly be useful to historians.”
“You could travel into the past and find out whether the accepted story of the Battle of Hastings was actually true.”
The Medical Man frowned.
“Wouldn’t you attract a great deal of attention?”
“People in the past weren’t exactly tolerant of someone who appeared to belong to the wrong period.”
The Very Young Man became excited.
“You could hear Greek directly from Homer or Plato.”
“In that case,” said the Medical Man, “they’d probably fail you in your Greek examinations.”
“The German scholars have already improved Greek so much.”
The Very Young Man laughed.
“And what about the future?”
“Just imagine what you could do.”
“You could invest all your money, leave it earning interest, and then travel far into the future.”
“I,” I said, “would like to discover a society built entirely on communist principles.”
The Psychologist stared at me.
“What an outrageous idea!”
“Yes,” I said.
“That’s exactly what I thought too.”
“So I never mentioned it until—”
“Experimental evidence!” I interrupted.
“You’re actually going to test the machine?”
“The experiment!” Filby exclaimed.
He looked exhausted by the whole discussion.
“Show us the experiment, at least,” said the Psychologist.
“Even though I’m sure it’s all nonsense.”
The Time Traveller smiled at all of us.
Without saying another word, he slipped both hands into his trouser pockets and slowly walked out of the room.
We listened as his slippers shuffled along the long passage toward his laboratory.
The Psychologist looked around at us.
“I wonder what he’s got in there.”
“Probably some cheap magic trick,” said the Medical Man.
Filby immediately began telling us about a magician he had once seen in Burslem.
But he had barely started his story when the Time Traveller returned.
Filby stopped talking at once.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!