A Difficult Friendship and a Test of Poetry
Keimer and I were on fairly friendly terms, and we got along well enough. He had no idea that I was planning to start a printing business of my own.
He still had many of his old religious beliefs and loved arguing about them. So we often got into debates.
I would use my Socratic method on him, leading him with a series of questions that seemed unrelated to the subject at first. Little by little, I would guide him toward the real issue until he found himself trapped in his own contradictions.
I did this so often that he eventually became ridiculously careful around me. He would hardly answer even the simplest question without first asking,
“What exactly are you trying to prove with that question?”
Still, these debates gave him such a high opinion of my ability to defeat an argument that he seriously suggested I join him in starting a new religious sect.
“You can handle all the arguments,” he told me. “I’ll preach the beliefs, and you can deal with anyone who challenges us.”
When he explained his ideas to me, however, I found several things I disagreed with.
“I’ll consider joining you,” I said, “but only if I’m allowed to change some of your doctrines and add a few of my own.”
Keimer wore his beard completely untrimmed because he had found a passage in the Mosaic law saying that the corners of a man’s beard should not be cut.
He also observed the Sabbath on Saturday.
Those two practices were especially important to him.
I disliked both of them. But I agreed to accept them if he would adopt one condition of my own: that we stop eating meat, fish, and poultry.
“I don’t think my body can handle that,” Keimer said.
“I’m sure it can,” I replied. “In fact, I think you’ll feel better for it.”
Keimer was normally a heavy eater, so I secretly looked forward to seeing how he would manage on such a restricted diet.
He agreed to try it, provided that I followed the same diet.
I did.
For three months, we ate no animal food at all.
A woman in the neighborhood prepared our meals and brought them to us regularly. I gave her a list of forty different dishes, which she prepared at different times. None of them contained fish, meat, or poultry.
The diet suited me especially well because it was extremely cheap. It cost each of us no more than eighteenpence a week.
Years later, I followed the same kind of strict diet during several Lenten seasons. I could switch from my normal diet to the restricted one, and then back again, without any difficulty.
Because of that experience, I never became convinced that people needed to change their diets gradually. I found that I could change mine immediately without any trouble.
At first, I enjoyed the experiment.
Poor Keimer did not.
He soon became miserable and tired of the whole idea. He began longing for meat as if he were starving in the wilderness.
Finally, he ordered a roast pig.
He invited me and two female friends to dinner.
But the pig arrived before we did.
Keimer simply could not resist it.
By the time we arrived, he had eaten the entire thing himself.
During this period, I was also courting Miss Read.
I had great affection and respect for her, and I had good reason to believe that she felt the same way about me.
But I was preparing to take a long voyage, and we were both very young, only a little over eighteen.
Her mother therefore thought it was wiser to keep us from becoming too serious for the time being.
If we were eventually going to marry, she believed it would be better to wait until I returned.
By then, I expected to have established my own business and would be in a better position to support a family.
Perhaps her mother also thought my confidence about my future was greater than the reality justified.
At that time, my closest friends were Charles Osborne, Joseph Watson, and James Ralph.
All three loved reading.
Watson and Osborne worked as clerks for Charles Brockden, a well-known legal writer and conveyancer in Philadelphia.
Ralph worked as a clerk for a merchant.
Watson was a religious, sensible young man with strong principles and complete honesty.
Osborne and Ralph were less strict about religion.
In fact, both Ralph and my old friend Collins had been influenced by arguments I had made against some of their beliefs, and both of them later made me pay for it in one way or another.
Osborne was intelligent, honest, straightforward, sincere, and deeply loyal to his friends.
But when it came to writing, he was far too eager to criticize other people's work.
Ralph was clever, polite, and extremely eloquent.
I don't think I had ever met anyone who could speak more beautifully.
Both Osborne and Ralph loved poetry, and they had begun writing short poems of their own.
The four of us often took pleasant Sunday walks into the woods near the Schuylkill River.
We would read what we had been reading and discuss our opinions about it.
Ralph wanted to become a poet.
He had complete confidence that he could become famous and make a living from poetry.
“The greatest poets must have made plenty of mistakes when they first started,” he argued. “Why should I be any different?”
Osborne strongly disagreed.
“You have no real talent for poetry,” he told him. “You should forget about becoming a poet and concentrate on the work you've been trained to do.”
“You don't have much money now, but if you work hard and prove yourself reliable, you could find a position as a merchant's agent. Eventually, you could save enough money to start a business of your own.”
I agreed with Osborne to some extent.
“I think writing poetry can be a pleasant hobby,” I said, “and it can help improve your command of language. But I wouldn't make it your profession.”
We eventually came up with an idea.
At our next meeting, each of us would bring a piece of writing we had composed ourselves.
Then we would read them aloud and help one another improve through criticism and correction.
Since our main purpose was to practice language and style, we decided not to judge each other's originality.
Instead, we would all rewrite the same passage—the eighteenth Psalm, which describes the appearance of God in a dramatic storm.
As our next meeting approached, Ralph came to see me first.
“My piece is finished,” he said.
“I've been too busy,” I told him. “And honestly, I haven't felt much like writing, so I haven't done anything.”
Ralph then showed me his work and asked what I thought.
I read it and was genuinely impressed.
“It’s very good,” I told him. “I think you've done an excellent job.”
Ralph smiled.
“Osborne never admits that anything I write has any merit. He comes up with a thousand criticisms simply because he's jealous.”
“He doesn't seem nearly as jealous of you,” Ralph continued. “So I'd like you to do me a favor.”
“What kind of favor?”
“Take my poem and present it as your own.”
I stared at him.
“You want me to pretend I wrote it?”
“Exactly. I'll say I didn't have enough time to write anything. Then we'll see what Osborne says about your work.”
I agreed.
I immediately copied Ralph's piece in my own handwriting so that no one would suspect anything.
When we met again, Watson's work was read first.
It had some beautiful passages, but it also had plenty of weaknesses.
Then Osborne's piece was read.
His was much better.
Ralph admitted that it was good. He pointed out a few flaws, but he also praised its strengths.
Ralph himself had nothing to read.
When it was my turn, I tried to avoid the situation.
“I'd really rather be excused,” I said. “I haven't had enough time to revise anything.”
But they refused to let me escape.
“Come on. Read it.”
So I finally produced the manuscript.
They read it aloud.
Watson and Osborne quickly gave up any competition and joined together in praising the piece.
Ralph alone offered criticism and suggested several changes.
I defended every part of the writing.
Osborne immediately sided with me.
“You're no better a critic than you are a poet,” he told Ralph.
Ralph finally gave up arguing.
Later, as Osborne and Ralph walked home together, Osborne praised what he believed was my writing even more strongly.
He had apparently held back during our meeting because, as he later explained, he didn't want me to think he was simply flattering me.
“But who would have thought Franklin could write something like that?” he said.
“Such vivid descriptions! Such strength! Such passion! He actually improved the original.”
“And yet when he talks normally, he seems to struggle to find the right words. He hesitates and stumbles over his sentences.”
“But my God—look at how he writes!”
When we met again, Ralph discovered the trick we had played on him.
Osborne was embarrassed, and we had a good laugh at his expense.
The experience convinced Ralph more than ever that he should become a poet.
I did everything I could to talk him out of it.
He ignored me and continued writing verse until Pope finally cured him of his poetic ambitions.
He did, however, become a fairly good prose writer.
I will have more to say about him later.
As for the other two, I may not have another opportunity to mention them, so I will say a few words about them here.
Watson died a few years later in my arms.
His death deeply saddened me.
Of all our group, he was the best man.
Osborne eventually went to the West Indies, where he became a successful lawyer and made a considerable amount of money.
But he died young.
Osborne and I had once made a serious agreement.
Whichever of us died first would, if possible, somehow return and pay the other a friendly visit.
He would then tell the survivor what he had discovered about life after death.
Osborne died first.
But he never kept his promise.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!