Ahab and Starbuck Argue in the Captain’s Cabin
The next morning, the crew started the routine job of pumping seawater out of the ship. But as they worked, they spotted something worrying: a large amount of oil was mixing with the water coming up from below deck. The oil barrels in the hold had sprung serious leaks.
Everyone on board grew concerned. First Mate Starbuck headed down to the captain’s cabin to report the bad news.
(For context: Sperm whale ships carrying large oil loads follow a standard twice-weekly routine. Crews run hoses down into the hold and soak the oil casks with seawater. They later pump the water back out at regular intervals. This keeps the wooden barrels swollen and tightly sealed. More importantly, changes in the pumped-out water let sailors spot dangerous leaks in their precious oil cargo right away.)
At this time, the Pequod was sailing southwest, drawing close to Formosa and the Bashee Islands. The stretch of water between these islands forms one of the tropical passages connecting China’s coastal waters to the vast Pacific Ocean.
When Starbuck stepped into the cabin, he found Captain Ahab hunched over spread-out charts. One map showed the entire network of East Asian island chains. Another detailed the long eastern coastlines of Japan’s main islands: Niphon, Matsmai, and Sikoke.
Ahab braced his new snow-white ivory leg against the screwed leg of his table. In his hand, he held a folding knife with a long hooked blade. With his back to the cabin doorway, the weathered old captain frowned deeply, tracing over his old sailing routes on the charts again and again.
He heard footsteps at the door but did not turn around.
“Who’s there?” he snapped. “Get back on deck! Leave me be!”
“You’re mistaken, Captain. It’s me, Starbuck.” The mate stepped further into the room. “The oil barrels in the hold are leaking badly, sir. We need to rig the Burton pumps and break open the hold to fix it right away.”
Ahab’s jaw tightened with irritation.
“Rig the pumps and tear apart the hold? Now? We’re finally nearing Japan. You want us to stop here for a full week just to patch up a bunch of old barrel hoops?”
“We have no choice, sir,” Starbuck insisted firmly. “If we don’t fix the leaks now, we’ll lose more oil in a single day than we can collect in an entire year out here. We sailed twenty thousand miles for this cargo—it’s too valuable to waste.”
Ahab muttered darkly, his eyes still fixed on the charts.
“True enough. If we actually get to keep it.”
“I’m talking about the leaking oil in our hold, Captain.”
“And I’m not thinking about that at all!” Ahab shot back sharply. “Let it leak! I am leaking too. My whole being is full of cracks and spills—endless leaks!”
“It’s not just our barrels that are broken. This whole ship is flawed, and that’s a far worse trouble than spilled oil, Starbuck. Yet I don’t stop my journey to plug my own leaks. Who could fix the cracks in a soul weighed down with grief and obsession? Who could seal those wounds in this storm-tossed life?”
“My answer is final. We will NOT rig the Burton pumps.”
Starbuck’s expression turned grave and anxious.
“What will the ship’s owners say when they find out, sir?”
“Let the owners stand on Nantucket’s shore and scream against the typhoons for all I care!” Ahab scoffed. “What do I owe those greedy men? You’re always going on about the owners, Starbuck—as if their petty profits are my conscience!”
“Listen to me. The true owner of any ship is its captain. My conscience lives in this ship’s very keel and frame. Now get back on deck!”
Starbuck’s face flushed red. He stepped fully into the small cabin, his tone respectful but unshakable. He spoke carefully, holding back every trace of open defiance, yet standing firm in his conviction.
“A better man than I would overlook faults in you that he would never tolerate in a younger, happier sailor, Captain Ahab.”
Ahab’s temper flared instantly.
“Damnation! Do you dare to judge me? Get on deck, at once!”
“No, sir—not yet. I beg you to hear me out,” Starbuck pleaded. “I dare to ask you to be patient and reasonable. Can we not understand each other better than we have so far?”
In an instant, Ahab snatched a loaded musket from the gun rack—standard furniture for most long-distance South Sea ship cabins. He leveled the gun straight at Starbuck’s chest, his voice cold and thunderous.
“There is one God who rules over all the earth. And there is one captain who rules over the Pequod. Now get on deck!”
Starbuck’s eyes flashed with fire, and his cheeks burned red. For a split second, he looked as if the musket’s muzzle flash had already seared him. But he quickly reined in his rage and mastered his emotions.
He stood slowly and turned to leave. Pausing at the cabin door, he spoke in a quiet, heavy tone.
“You have wronged me, not merely insulted me, sir. I do not warn you to fear me—you would only laugh it off. But I beg you to fear yourself, Ahab. Watch your own darkness, old man.”
As Starbuck’s footsteps faded away, Ahab muttered to himself.
“He grows bold, yet he still obeys. A careful, cautious kind of courage.”
He replayed Starbuck’s warning in his head, his brow furrowed again.
“‘Ahab beware of Ahab.’ There’s truth in those words.”
Unconsciously, he used the loaded musket as a walking stick, pacing back and forth across the cramped cabin with a hard, stern face. After a long moment, the tight tension in his forehead softened. He set the gun back on its rack and headed up to the deck.
He spotted Starbuck and spoke to him in a low, gruff voice.
“You’re a good man, Starbuck.”
Then he raised his voice to address the entire crew, barking out clear orders.
“Furl the upper gallant sails! Tie down and reef all topsails, fore and aft! Swing the main yard backward! Rig the Burton pumps and break open the main hold!”
No one could say for certain what had shifted in Ahab’s mind to make him reverse his order. It might have been a fleeting moment of honest clarity. Or it might have been cold calculation—he could not afford open defiance from his first officer, not even for a second, on this critical voyage.
Whatever the reason, the crew moved at once to follow his commands, and the Burton pumps were hoisted into place.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!