← Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin 2026 Edition
Chapter 12 · Building a Stronger Pennsylvania

Building a Stronger Pennsylvania

Chapter 12 of 19 · 3,271 words · Free

I was generally very happy with my life in Pennsylvania. Still, I saw two serious weaknesses in the province. There was no proper defense system, and there was no college where young people could receive a complete education. We had no militia and no university.

In 1743, I drew up a plan to establish an academy. I thought Reverend Mr. Peters, who was not then employed, would be a good person to run it, so I showed him my proposal.

But he had his own plans. He hoped to get a more profitable position working for the proprietors, and those plans eventually worked out. So he declined my offer.

At the time, I did not know anyone else who seemed suitable to manage such an institution. I therefore put the idea aside for a while.

I had better luck the following year, in 1744, when I proposed the creation of a Philosophical Society. The paper I wrote for that purpose will be found among my collected writings.

The question of defense was more urgent.

Spain had been at war with Great Britain for several years, and France eventually joined Spain. This put us in real danger.

Governor Thomas had spent a long time trying to persuade the Quaker Assembly to pass a militia law and take other measures to protect the province. But all his efforts had failed.

I decided to see what could be accomplished if the people themselves voluntarily organized for defense.

To encourage them, I first wrote and published a pamphlet called Plain Truth. In it, I described our defenseless situation in very clear and forceful terms. I explained why we needed unity and discipline if we wanted to protect ourselves.

I also promised that within a few days I would propose a voluntary association for the people to sign.

The pamphlet had an immediate and surprising effect.

People began asking me for the association agreement.

After working out the wording with a few friends, I arranged a meeting of citizens in the large building I had mentioned earlier.

The building was nearly full.

I had prepared many printed copies of the agreement and placed pens and ink throughout the room.

I spoke briefly about the danger we faced. Then I read the agreement and explained what it meant.

After that, I handed out the copies.

People eagerly signed them.

Not one person raised an objection.

When the meeting ended, we collected the papers and counted more than twelve hundred signatures.

We then sent copies throughout the countryside.

Before long, more than ten thousand people had signed.

As soon as they could, these men obtained weapons. They organized themselves into companies and regiments and chose their own officers.

Every week they met to practice military exercises and learn the basics of military discipline.

The women also played an important part.

They collected money among themselves to buy silk flags for the companies. Each flag was decorated with a different design and motto, which I helped provide.

The officers of the Philadelphia companies met and chose me as their colonel.

I did not think I was qualified for the position, so I refused it.

Instead, I recommended Mr. Lawrence, a respected and influential man.

They accepted my recommendation and appointed him.

I then proposed a lottery to raise money for building a battery below the city and supplying it with cannon.

The lottery filled very quickly.

Soon the battery was built. Its walls were made from logs packed with earth.

We bought several old cannon from Boston, but they were not enough.

So we wrote to England asking for more. At the same time, we asked the proprietors for financial assistance, although we did not expect much from them.

Meanwhile, the people who had joined the association chose Colonel Lawrence, William Allen, Abram Taylor, and me to travel to New York.

Our mission was to ask Governor Clinton to lend us some cannon.

At first, he flatly refused.

But later, while we were having dinner with his council, a great deal of Madeira wine was being served, as was common there at the time.

As the evening went on, the governor became more agreeable.

He finally said he would lend us six cannon.

After a few more glasses, he increased the number to ten.

Before long, he generously agreed to lend us eighteen.

They were excellent eighteen-pound cannon, complete with carriages.

We transported them to Philadelphia and mounted them on our battery.

Throughout the war, members of the association kept watch there every night.

I regularly took my turn as well, serving there as an ordinary soldier.

The governor and his council were pleased with my efforts.

They began to trust me and often asked for my advice whenever they thought my support would help the association.

I also suggested that religion should play a part in our efforts.

I proposed that the government proclaim a day of fasting so that people could reflect on their conduct, reform their behavior, and ask God to bless our efforts to defend the province.

The governor and council agreed.

But this created an unusual problem.

It was the first time anyone had ever proposed a public fast in Pennsylvania, so the secretary had no old proclamation to use as a model.

Fortunately, I had grown up in New England, where a day of fasting was proclaimed every year.

I knew exactly how such a proclamation was normally written.

So I drafted it myself.

It was translated into German, printed in both languages, and distributed throughout the province.

This gave ministers from different religious groups an opportunity to encourage their congregations to join the association.

The movement probably would have spread to almost everyone except the Quakers if peace had not arrived soon afterward.

Some of my friends worried that my military activities would anger the Quakers.

Since they held a large majority in the Assembly, my friends feared that I might lose my position as its clerk.

A young man who had friends in the Assembly and wanted my position himself came to warn me.

He told me that the Assembly had already decided to remove me at the next election.

He advised me to resign voluntarily, saying that would be more honorable than being thrown out.

I told him I had once heard of a public official who followed a simple rule:

He never asked for an office, and he never refused one when it was offered.

“I agree with that rule,” I told him.

“But I would add one more thing. I will never ask for an office, never refuse one, and never resign one.”

“If they want someone else to have my position as clerk, they can take it away from me.”

“I will not give it up myself, because I may someday have the opportunity to repay my opponents.”

In the end, I heard nothing more about the matter.

At the next election, I was chosen unanimously, just as I had been before.

Perhaps the Quakers were unhappy about my growing friendship with the members of the governor's council. Those council members had supported the governor during his long arguments with the Assembly over military preparations.

The Assembly had suffered through those disputes for years.

They might have been pleased if I had voluntarily left them.

But they were unwilling to remove me simply because I supported the voluntary defense association, and they could not find another good reason to dismiss me.

In fact, I came to believe that most of the Quakers were not opposed to defending the province.

They simply did not want to be personally required to take part in war.

I discovered that far more Quakers than I had expected were opposed to offensive war but supported defensive action.

Many pamphlets were published arguing both sides of the question.

Some were written by respected Quakers who openly defended the right of people to protect themselves.

I believe these arguments convinced many of the younger Quakers.

I learned even more about their true feelings from something that happened in our fire company.

Someone had suggested that we support the battery project by investing the company's existing funds, about sixty pounds, in lottery tickets.

Our rules said that money could not be spent until the meeting after the proposal had been made.

Our company had thirty members.

Twenty-two were Quakers, while only eight belonged to other religious groups.

The eight of us arrived at the meeting on time.

We thought some of the Quakers might support us, but we were not certain that we would have enough votes.

Only one Quaker, Mr. James Morris, openly opposed the proposal.

He was very upset that the idea had even been raised.

“Friends are completely opposed to this,” he said.

“If we vote on it, it will create such disagreement that the company might break apart.”

We told him there was no reason to fear that.

“We are the minority,” we said.

“If the Friends oppose the proposal and vote against us, we will accept the decision, just as members of any organization are expected to do.”

When the time came to conduct business, someone moved that we take the vote.

Mr. Morris admitted that the rules allowed us to do so.

“But I can assure you,” he said, “that several members intend to come here specifically to oppose this measure.”

“It would only be fair to give them a little more time to arrive.”

While we were discussing this, a waiter came to tell me that two gentlemen downstairs wanted to speak with me.

I went down and found two of our Quaker members.

“There are eight of us gathered at the tavern nearby,” they told me.

“We have decided to come and vote with you if necessary.”

“We hope you will not need our help.”

“If possible, please do not call us in. If we openly vote for this measure, we could get into serious trouble with our elders and other Friends.”

Now that I knew we had enough votes, I went back upstairs.

I pretended to hesitate for a little while.

Then I agreed to wait another hour before taking the vote.

Mr. Morris said this was extremely fair.

But none of the Quakers who were supposedly coming to oppose us ever appeared.

Mr. Morris was clearly surprised.

When the extra hour had passed, we held the vote.

The proposal passed eight to one.

Of the twenty-two Quakers in the company, eight had been ready to vote with us.

Thirteen others stayed away, which showed that they were not willing to oppose the proposal.

Only Mr. Morris actually voted against it.

From this experience, I later estimated that perhaps only one Quaker out of twenty-one sincerely opposed defensive measures.

All of these men were regular members of their religious society and were respected by their fellow Quakers.

They had also been properly informed about the proposal.

The honorable and learned Mr. Logan, who had always been a Quaker, was another man who openly supported defensive war.

He wrote an address to the Quakers explaining his position and gave many strong arguments in its favor.

He also gave me sixty pounds to invest in lottery tickets for the battery.

He instructed me to use any prize money entirely for the battery project.

Mr. Logan once told me an interesting story about his old master, William Penn.

When Logan was a young man, he had come from England with Penn and served as his secretary.

It was wartime, and their ship was being chased by an armed vessel that they believed was an enemy.

The captain prepared the ship for battle.

But he told William Penn and the other Quakers that he did not expect them to help.

They could go into the cabin if they wished.

They did so, except for James Logan.

Logan chose to remain on deck and was assigned to a cannon.

Fortunately, the ship following them turned out to be a friend, so no battle took place.

When Logan went below to tell the others that there was no danger, William Penn strongly criticized him for staying on deck and helping to defend the ship.

Penn reminded him that this was against Quaker principles, especially since the captain had never asked him to fight.

Being criticized in front of everyone embarrassed Logan.

He answered,

“I am thy servant. Why did thee not order me to come below?”

“But when thee thought there was danger, thee was perfectly willing for me to stay and help defend the ship.”

My many years in the Assembly, where the majority were Quakers, gave me plenty of opportunities to see the difficulties their beliefs created for them.

Whenever the Crown asked the Assembly to provide money for military purposes, the Quakers found themselves trapped between two loyalties.

On one side, they did not want to anger the government by refusing.

On the other, they did not want to anger their fellow Quakers by openly supporting something their religion opposed.

As a result, they developed all kinds of clever ways to avoid the problem.

When they were eventually forced to provide money, they tried to hide what the money was actually for.

Their usual solution was to approve the money simply as being “for the king's use.”

They never asked how the money was spent.

But when the request did not come directly from the Crown, even that wording was difficult to use.

So they had to invent another excuse.

Once, for example, New England needed gunpowder, possibly for the garrison at Louisburg.

The New England government asked Pennsylvania for some.

Governor Thomas strongly urged the Assembly to provide it.

But the Assembly could not directly approve money for gunpowder because gunpowder was clearly connected with war.

So they voted to give New England three thousand pounds instead.

They ordered that the money be used by the governor to buy bread, flour, wheat, or other grain.

Some members of the council wanted to make things even more difficult.

They advised Governor Thomas not to accept the food because that was not what New England had actually requested.

But the governor understood perfectly well what the Assembly meant.

“I will take the money,” he said.

“I understand very well what they mean. Their ‘other grain’ is gunpowder.”

He used the money to buy gunpowder, and the Assembly never complained.

I remembered this story when our fire company was debating whether to support the battery lottery.

I said to my friend Mr. Syng,

“If we fail, let us suggest that the company use the money to buy a fire engine.”

“The Quakers certainly cannot object to that.”

“Then, if you nominate me and I nominate you to serve on the purchasing committee, we can buy a large cannon.”

“After all, a cannon is certainly a kind of fire engine.”

Syng laughed.

“I can see that your many years in the Assembly have taught you something,” he said.

“Your clever trick would be a perfect match for their ‘wheat or other grain.’”

The Quakers had created these difficulties for themselves because they had publicly declared that all war was unlawful.

Once they had made that principle official, they could not easily abandon it, even when their opinions later changed.

This reminded me of what I consider a much wiser approach taken by another religious group among us, the Dunkers.

I knew one of their founders, Michael Welfare, not long after their society appeared.

He complained that members of other religions were spreading terrible lies about them.

People accused the Dunkers of following disgusting beliefs and practices that had nothing to do with them.

I told him that new religious groups were almost always treated this way.

“If you want to stop these rumors,” I said, “perhaps you should publish a clear statement of your beliefs and the rules of your society.”

He told me the idea had already been discussed among them.

“But we decided not to do it,” he said.

“When we first came together as a religious society, God gave us enough understanding to see that some things we had once believed were true were actually false.”

“And some things we had once rejected as false turned out to be true.”

“Since then, God has continued to give us greater understanding.”

“Our beliefs have gradually improved, and our mistakes have gradually decreased.”

“But we do not know whether we have reached the final stage of spiritual or religious knowledge.”

“We are afraid that if we print a formal statement of our beliefs, we will feel trapped by it.”

“We might become unwilling to accept new understanding.”

“And our successors might be even more unwilling to change, because they could treat anything written by their founders as sacred and permanent.”

I thought this was an unusually humble attitude for a religious group.

Most other sects believe they already possess the whole truth and that anyone who disagrees with them must be wrong.

It is like a man traveling through thick fog.

He can see people far ahead of him on the road, and they all seem lost in the fog.

He can also see people behind him and people working in the fields on either side, and they appear lost too.

But everything close to him looks perfectly clear.

He does not realize that he is standing in exactly the same fog as everyone else.

To avoid this kind of problem, the Quakers have gradually begun withdrawing from public positions in the Assembly and the courts.

They would rather give up political power than abandon their principles.

There is another event that, chronologically, I should have mentioned earlier.

In 1742, I invented an open stove designed to heat rooms more efficiently while using less fuel.

Fresh air entered the stove, became warm as it passed through, and then circulated into the room.

I gave the model to one of my old friends, Mr. Robert Grace.

He owned an iron furnace, and he soon discovered that making the iron plates for these stoves could be profitable because demand for them was increasing.

To encourage that demand, I wrote and published a pamphlet explaining the new stove.

I described how it was built, how it worked, why it was better than other methods of heating rooms, and how to answer the objections people had raised against it.

The pamphlet worked well.

Governor Thomas was so impressed by the stove that he offered to give me a patent allowing me to sell it exclusively for a number of years.

I refused.

I had a principle that I always tried to follow in such matters.

We benefit greatly from the inventions and discoveries of other people.

So when we invent something useful ourselves, we should be happy to let others benefit from it too.

We should share such inventions freely and generously.

Later, however, an ironmonger in London took much of the material from my pamphlet, rewrote it as his own, made a few changes to the stove, and obtained a patent for it in England.

Unfortunately, his changes actually made the stove work less effectively.

I was told that he nevertheless made a small fortune from it.

This was not the only time someone else obtained a patent for one of my inventions.

The results were not always so successful.

I never challenged them.

I had no desire to make money from patents, and I disliked legal disputes.

The stoves became widely used in Pennsylvania and the neighboring colonies.

They saved the inhabitants a great deal of firewood, and they continue to do so.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!