← Moby Dick 2026 Edition
Chapter 89 · Claiming Whales: The Rules of Ownership

Claiming Whales: The Rules of Ownership

Chapter 89 of 135 · 1,420 words · Free

The last chapter mentioned marker poles and abandoned whale claims. To make sense of those, we first need to understand the unwritten rules of whaling. These simple rules are the backbone of every claim, dispute, and right of possession on the open ocean.

Whaling ships often sail and hunt in groups, and tricky situations happen all the time.

One ship might harpoon a whale, only for the wounded creature to break free and swim away. Later, a completely different ship might catch and kill that same whale.

Countless smaller versions of this problem pop up every day.

A crew might chase and subdue a whale through stormy, deadly seas, only for rough weather to tear the whale loose from their ship. The dead whale drifts far away on the wind and waves, until another whaler finds it in calm waters. The second crew simply tows it home safely, with no risk and no hard work.

Without a clear, universal set of rules to settle these conflicts, fights and bitter arguments between whalers would be endless.

Very few official laws have ever governed whaling. The only government-approved whaling code came from Holland, passed by their national parliament all the way back in 1695.

No other country ever wrote formal whaling legislation. American whalers simply made up their own rules, and everyone on the ocean abided by them.

Their unwritten code is shockingly concise, yet covers every possible scenario better than complex legal textbooks or strict societal bylaws. The rules are so simple you could practically carve them on a coin or the tip of a harpoon and wear them around your neck.

Rule one: If a whale is firmly held by someone, that whale belongs to them.

Rule two: If a whale is free and unclaimed, anyone who catches it first gets to keep it.

These two rules sound far too simple for such a dangerous, competitive trade. Their extreme brevity is what causes endless confusion and debate. Whole arguments and unspoken interpretations exist just to explain what these two short lines actually mean out at sea.

So what exactly counts as a “held whale”?

Legally speaking, a whale is yours, alive or dead, if your crew has any kind of controllable connection to it. It doesn’t matter what the connection is — a ship mast, an oar, a thick rope, a thin cable, even a tiny strand of rope. If your crew can control it and pull the whale in, the whale is secured to you.

A whale also counts as held if you’ve marked it with an official claim buoy or any recognized ownership symbol. This only applies, though, if you clearly have the ability and intention to come back and collect it at any time.

Lawyers might debate these fine points formally, but whalers settle most disputes with loud words and even louder fists. Their version of legal precedent is simple brute force.

To their credit, honest, honorable whalers will make exceptions for unfair cases. They’ll step back if one crew did all the dangerous work of chasing and wounding a whale, only for another crew to steal it easily. But plenty of greedy sailors have no such morals and will exploit every loophole.

Around fifty years ago, a famous whale ownership lawsuit unfolded in England, and it perfectly sums up these messy rules.

The suing crew told their side of the story. They’d chased a whale relentlessly through rough northern seas. They’d finally harpooned it, but the fight turned so deadly that they were forced to cut loose. They abandoned their ropes, their harpoons, and even their small boat just to save their own lives.

Right after they fled, another ship’s crew sailed up. They harpooned the wounded whale, killed it, and claimed it entirely for themselves — all while the original crew watched helplessly from a distance.

When the first crew protested and demanded their gear and the whale back, the second ship’s captain mocked them openly. He bragged that he was keeping their whale, their ropes, their harpoons, and their abandoned boat as a final insult.

The original crew took the case to court, suing to get compensated for their lost whale and all their equipment.

The famous lawyer Erskine represented the defending ship’s crew, and Lord Ellenborough presided as judge.

During the trial, Erskine made a clever, shocking comparison to argue his case. He referenced a recent adultery court case.

In that case, a man had tried and failed to control his wife’s reckless behavior. He’d finally given up and left her. Years later, he tried to take her back to claim her as his own.

Erskine argued against that man’s right to reclaim his wife. He explained that even though the man had once “owned” and controlled her, he’d abandoned her completely. Once abandoned, she became free game for anyone else.

When another man stepped in and took her, she legally belonged to her new partner — just like any gear left attached to her would transfer over too.

Erskine insisted the whale case worked exactly the same way.

After hearing arguments from both sides, the judge issued his official ruling.

He gave the abandoned small boat back to the original crew. They’d only left it behind to save their lives, so they still held rightful ownership of it.

But the whale, the harpoons, and the ropes all belonged to the second crew.

The judge explained that once the first crew fled and let the whale escape, the whale became free and unclaimed. Any gear the whale carried with it became attached to the free whale, and whoever caught the whale afterward had full rights to everything attached to it.

Most ordinary people would think this ruling is wildly unfair. But stripped down to its core, these two simple whaling rules form the foundation of almost every legal system in human society.

All complex laws and legal systems are just fancy decorations. At their core, they stand on only two pillars: the rule of the held claim, and the rule of the free claim.

Everyone knows the saying: possession is nine-tenths of the law. In many cases, possession is the entire law — no matter how you took hold of something in the first place.

What are oppressed workers and enslaved people, if not claimed possessions where ownership alone makes the law valid?

What is a greedy landlord’s theft of a poor widow’s last coins, if not a simple held claim that no one can challenge?

What about a wealthy criminal’s fancy mansion, hidden from justice and marked as his own? It is nothing but a secured, held claim.

Think of the cruel interest a loan shark forces a starving bankrupt family to pay, just to keep them from homelessness. That unfair profit is another unchallenged held claim.

Consider a high-ranking clergyman’s massive yearly income, squeezed from the tiny wages of countless poor laborers. That huge sum is just another secured possession.

A nobleman’s inherited towns and villages, ruled by birthright alone? All held claims.

The powerful British empire’s grip on struggling Ireland? A held claim.

America’s early takeover of Texas? Just another unchallenged possession.

In every single one of these cases, simple possession acts as the entire law.

If the rules of held possessions apply widely in life, the rules of free, unclaimed things apply even more broadly — across every country and every corner of the globe.

What was the entire continent of America in 1492, before colonization? A completely free, unclaimed whale. Columbus simply planted a Spanish flag on it to stake a royal claim.

What was Poland to the Russian tsar? A free prize waiting to be taken.

What was Greece to the Turkish empire? An unclaimed opportunity.

What was India to Britain? What will Mexico one day become to the United States? All free game for whoever has the power to seize them.

What are human rights and personal freedoms, if not free, unclaimed things that anyone can try to take or define?

What are people’s personal thoughts, beliefs, and religious views? Unbound, free possessions, up for grabs to anyone who can influence or control them.

What are the original ideas of great thinkers, to people who twist and exploit them for profit? Free, unclaimed prey.

The entire world itself is a free, shifting claim.

And what about you, the reader?

You are both a free, unclaimed soul floating in the world — and also a secured, held possession, bound by countless unspoken rules of ownership and control.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!