Prison Rules: Obey Them or Be Crushed
Life inside a prison has its own public opinion.
In many ways, it is no different from the opinion of people outside the walls.
A prisoner who accepts his situation and decides to make the best of it soon earns a reputation as a sensible man.
He does not cause trouble.
He does not interfere with others.
And he does not want others interfering with him.
Such a man is rarely bothered.
Patient endurance also creates sympathy.
Even the most ignorant or brutal prison officer will usually hesitate to torment a prisoner who quietly accepts his punishment.
A man who walks calmly along the difficult road ahead of him, without fighting every step of the way, is much less likely to attract trouble.
He knows there are thorns on the road.
He does not expect to find roses.
But a prisoner who insists on fighting the system will quickly discover that the prison has plenty of ways to fight back.
An English prison was an enormous machine.
To that machine, an individual prisoner meant almost nothing.
The prison did not see him as a human being with feelings, hopes, and fears.
He was simply another object that had to be moved through the system and kept in the place assigned to him.
There was little room for kindness.
The machine continued moving whether a man was happy, miserable, sick, or desperate.
If you moved with it, things were easier.
If you resisted, you were crushed.
It was like standing on a railway track while an express train came toward you.
The train did not hate you.
It did not care about you.
It simply kept moving.
The prison system was much the same.
It could be cold, harsh, and completely without pity.
If a prisoner died, his body would be taken away and buried.
Within minutes, the system would continue as if he had never existed.
For a man who openly rebelled, the consequences could be brutal.
There were hard wooden beds.
There was the punishment crank.
There was a diet of bread and water.
There were beatings by warders, sometimes officially forbidden but still carried out.
There were punishment cells so cold that the chill seemed to reach the bones.
There was hunger.
There was sickness.
And there was death, often without sympathy.
Some prisoners were foolish enough to challenge the system despite knowing what awaited them.
Fortunately, there were fewer such men than in earlier years.
Education in England had improved considerably.
Charitable organizations and private individuals had also done much to help prisoners.
The authorities had another policy that had an unexpected effect as well.
Many released prisoners were quickly sent out of the country.
These measures helped reduce the number of men returning to English prisons.
Public opinion also forced judges to become less severe than they had once been.
That made a significant difference inside the prisons.
The sentences handed down by judges could be astonishingly inconsistent.
The law often gave judges a wide range of choices.
A statute might say that a prisoner could receive life imprisonment or any sentence of at least five years.
That meant two men could commit exactly the same crime under almost identical circumstances and receive completely different sentences.
One judge might give a man five years.
Another might give another man twenty.
There was another serious problem.
England had no proper court of appeal where a prisoner could ask for his sentence to be reviewed.
Once an unjust or wildly excessive sentence had been handed down, there was very little the prisoner could do.
His only hope was to petition the Home Secretary.
And that was often little more than a desperate hope.
I had seen strange examples of this injustice myself.
I once saw a man who had received five years for murder working beside another prisoner who had received twenty years for a crime against property.
How could such differences fail to create resentment?
For some prisoners, they became proof that the system was persecuting them.
Eventually, a few men decided that there was no point obeying rules they considered unjust.
They resisted.
But their resistance usually made their lives even worse.
I always believed the prison authorities had made a fundamental mistake.
The Board of Directors, established in 1864, seemed to believe that prison discipline had to be based on one principle above all others:
"Force. Nothing but force."
One governor actually described it as "iron force."
But most prisoners did not need that kind of treatment.
The great majority would obey reasonable rules without being brutalized.
Even the difficult prisoners could usually be controlled without turning the prison into a place of cruelty.
Prison discipline certainly had to involve punishment.
But punishment did not have to mean deliberate suffering.
Starving a man was not necessary.
Forcing him to turn a crank for hours was not necessary.
Giving him a hard plank instead of a proper bed was not necessary.
Freezing him in a punishment cell was not necessary.
Yet these things were part of the English prison system.
The rules seemed designed to discover every possible way of making a prisoner suffer.
They were intended to break him physically and mentally.
The prisons were not simply places where men lost their freedom.
They were places where suffering itself seemed to be the main purpose.
The directors demanded that their regulations be followed exactly.
But each prison also had its own resident governor and deputy governor.
These men were usually respectable members of society, often retired army officers who had spent their lives managing and commanding other men.
Most of them were not naturally cruel.
They generally tried to enforce the rules while showing as much consideration as the rules allowed.
Unfortunately, even the governor had limited freedom to change things.
Still, he saw the prisoners every day.
He got to know them as human beings.
He could see that many of them were not so different from people outside the prison.
Sometimes he even found a prisoner to be a better man than people he knew in ordinary society.
He knew that some men behind bars did not deserve all the cruelty being forced upon them.
For that reason, many governors were reluctant to make an already difficult life even harder.
I heard more than one governor openly criticize the starvation system.
I also heard governors object to the unnecessarily brutal treatment of men who would eventually be released and return to society.
Under a reasonable governor, a new prisoner quickly learned an important lesson.
To some extent, his own behavior determined how difficult his life would be.
Of course, no man could turn prison suffering into pleasure.
No one could simply convince himself that hunger, cold, and pain were enjoyable.
Pain is pain.
Even if someone argued that suffering was not an absolute evil, it was certainly a very convincing imitation of one.
A wise philosopher with a toothache suffers just as much as the most foolish man alive.
Inside prison walls, there was no escaping that simple truth.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!