Socialism, Population, and the Real Causes of Poverty
John Stuart Mill once admitted that the facts surrounding poverty and inequality seemed to make a frightening case against either the existing social system or humanity’s condition in the world.
The real question, however, is how much of this suffering is caused by society itself and how much comes from the basic conditions of human life.
The strongest argument can still be exaggerated. Many Socialist writers make serious and valid criticisms, but some of their conclusions come from a misunderstanding of economics—not from rejecting economic policies, but from misunderstanding how economic forces actually work.
It is certainly true that, throughout Europe, ordinary workers often earned far too little to enjoy a decent physical and moral standard of living.
But Socialists went further. They argued that wages were continually falling.
That claim was not supported by the facts.
There was no civilized country in which ordinary wages, measured either in money or in the amount of goods workers could buy, were steadily declining. In many countries, wages were actually rising, and the increase was becoming faster rather than slower.
Some industries did suffer falling wages when new technology or changing demand made their work less necessary.
But those situations were usually temporary.
When one kind of work became less valuable, new and better-paid opportunities often appeared elsewhere. The fall in wages in one occupation was frequently the result of higher productivity or better opportunities in another.
To prove that wages were falling across society, it was often necessary to compare a particularly bad month or year with an unusually prosperous period from the past.
Economic downturns were certainly painful.
But they were not a new feature of modern society. Earlier generations had experienced fluctuations that were just as frequent and sometimes even more severe.
The difference was that modern economies were much larger. When a downturn occurred, far more people were affected, making the crisis appear greater.
Yet the larger number of victims did not necessarily mean that each individual worker suffered more than workers had suffered in the past.
In fact, there was considerable evidence that the living standards of European workers were improving.
There was no equally reliable evidence showing a general long-term deterioration.
Whenever conditions appeared to be getting worse, the cause could usually be traced to a local problem, a temporary disaster, a bad law, or some foolish government policy.
Those problems could be corrected.
The long-term forces of economic development were generally pushing living standards upward.
Louis Blanc was more thoughtful than the old generation of egalitarian and democratic reformers because he understood that low wages were connected with excessively rapid population growth.
But he still made an important mistake.
He assumed that because population could increase faster than the supply of food and other necessities, pressure on those resources must continually become worse.
The earlier followers of Malthus had made the same mistake.
Their conclusion was that this pressure could not be escaped.
Louis Blanc believed it could be controlled, but only through Communism.
Even so, it was an important step forward that he recognized population growth as a problem that Communism would also have to solve.
The leading Socialist thinkers understood this point.
Robert Owen, Charles Fourier, and Louis Blanc all admitted that population pressure was a serious problem.
Each believed that his own system could deal with it better than the existing system.
Whether they were right was another question.
Experience already showed that, under the existing social order, population pressure was not becoming steadily worse.
Population growth could contribute to low wages, but civilization was creating new forces that worked in the opposite direction.
As economies developed, they created more opportunities to employ and support workers.
Workers also gained greater freedom to move to new countries where land and jobs were available.
At the same time, education gradually improved people’s intelligence, judgment, and ability to plan their families and their futures.
These changes were slow.
But the fact that they were happening at all was encouraging.
And society was only beginning the great movement toward educating the entire population.
As education spread, it would strengthen the very forces that were already improving living conditions.
The real question, therefore, was not whether poverty existed.
It clearly did.
The more important question was which form of society could deal with population pressure most effectively.
On that question, Socialism had a legitimate argument to make.
Indeed, the problem that had once seemed to be Socialism’s greatest weakness might eventually become one of its greatest strengths.
But Socialists could not honestly claim that their system was the only possible way to prevent humanity from sinking into ever greater poverty and degradation.
Society was not moving downward into such an abyss.
It was slowly climbing out of it.
The progress was imperfect and painfully slow, but it was real.
And if governments avoided passing harmful laws that interfered with economic and social development, there was every reason to believe that the improvement would continue.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!