Telemachus Takes a Stand
Muse, tell me about Odysseus—the clever man who wandered for years after Troy fell.
He saw countless cities and learned the ways of many people. He suffered terribly at sea while trying to save himself and bring his men home.
But he could not save them.
They destroyed themselves by slaughtering the sacred cattle of Helios, the Sun God. Helios punished them, and none of them ever reached home.
Tell us how it all began.
Every survivor of the war and the sea had returned to his own home—except Odysseus.
He was trapped on a distant island with the goddess Calypso. She kept him in her cave and wanted him to become her husband.
Odysseus wanted only one thing: to return to Ithaca, to his wife, his son, and his home.
At last, the gods decided it was time for him to go back.
Only Poseidon still hated him. The sea god had not forgiven Odysseus for blinding his son, the Cyclops Polyphemus.
While Poseidon was away among the Ethiopians, enjoying a great feast of sacrificed sheep and cattle, the other gods gathered in Zeus’s palace on Olympus.
Zeus spoke first.
“Look at how people blame us for their suffering,” he said. “Yet so often, they ruin their own lives.”
He thought of Aegisthus, the man who had seduced Agamemnon’s wife and murdered Agamemnon after the Trojan War.
“Aegisthus was warned,” Zeus continued. “Hermes told him not to kill Agamemnon, because Orestes would one day return and avenge his father. But Aegisthus ignored the warning. Now he has paid for his choices.”
Athena looked troubled.
“Father,” she said, “Aegisthus deserved his fate. But what about Odysseus?”
Her voice softened.
“My heart aches for him. He is alone on Calypso’s island, far from every friend he has. Calypso keeps trying to make him forget Ithaca, but he cannot. He only wants to see smoke rising from his own home again.”
She looked directly at Zeus.
“Odysseus honored you at Troy. He gave you sacrifices. Why are you allowing him to suffer?”
Zeus shook his head.
“My daughter, I have not forgotten him. No man alive is wiser or more generous toward the gods than Odysseus.”
“But Poseidon is still furious. Odysseus blinded Polyphemus, Poseidon’s son. Poseidon cannot kill him, but he has made certain Odysseus cannot return home.”
Zeus paused.
“Still, it is time to help him. If all of us agree, Poseidon cannot stand against us forever.”
Athena nodded.
“Then send Hermes to Calypso. Let him tell her that Odysseus must be released.”
“And I will go to Ithaca. I will give Odysseus’s son courage. Telemachus must call the people together and confront the men who are devouring his household while they compete to marry his mother.”
“I will also send him to Pylos and Sparta. Perhaps he can learn whether his father is alive.”
Athena fastened her shining golden sandals to her feet. They carried her through the air as quickly as the wind over land and sea.
She took up her bronze spear and flew down from Olympus.
In Ithaca, she appeared at Odysseus’s house disguised as Mentes, a powerful leader from Taphos.
Outside the palace, the suitors lounged on the hides of cattle they had slaughtered. They played games, drank wine, and laughed as servants hurried around them.
Inside, they treated Odysseus’s home as if it already belonged to them.
Telemachus noticed the stranger before anyone else did.
He had been sitting silently among the suitors, thinking of his father.
He imagined Odysseus walking through the doors, driving these arrogant men from the house, and reclaiming his rightful place.
When Telemachus saw the visitor waiting outside, he rose immediately.
He was ashamed that a guest had been left at the gate.
“Welcome,” he said, taking Athena’s hand. “Please come in. Eat with us first, and afterward you can tell me why you have come.”
He led her inside and placed her spear beside the many weapons that had once belonged to his father.
Then he gave her a fine chair with a footstool and sat beside her, away from the noisy suitors.
A servant brought water for them to wash their hands. Another set bread, meat, wine, and golden cups before them.
Soon the suitors entered and filled the hall.
They ate greedily. When they had finished, they demanded music.
A servant brought a lyre to the singer Phemius. The suitors forced him to sing for them.
As Phemius played, Telemachus leaned close to Athena.
“I hope you will not be offended by what I say,” he whispered. “These men enjoy music because they do not pay for any of it.”
“They eat my food, drink my wine, and waste my father’s wealth.”
“If my father returned, they would not care about money. They would only pray they could run fast enough to escape him.”
His face darkened.
“But he will not return. People still tell stories that he may be alive, but I no longer believe them.”
Then he looked at Athena.
“Tell me who you are. Where do you come from? What ship brought you here? Did you know my father?”
Athena answered calmly.
“My name is Mentes, son of Anchialus, king of the Taphians. I came here by ship on my way to trade iron for copper.”
“My ship is waiting in the harbor beneath Mount Neritum.”
She studied Telemachus.
“Your father and I were old friends. I heard he had returned home, and that is why I came. But it seems the gods are still holding him back.”
“He is not dead. I do not believe that.”
“Perhaps he is trapped on an island. Perhaps cruel people are keeping him prisoner. But Odysseus is too clever to remain trapped forever.”
She smiled slightly.
“Even if he were chained in iron, he would find a way home.”
Then she looked at him more closely.
“You resemble him. Your eyes and the shape of your head are like his. I knew him well before he sailed for Troy.”
Telemachus lowered his gaze.
“My mother says I am his son,” he said. “But no one truly knows who his father is.”
“I wish I had been born to a man who lived peacefully into old age. Instead, I am said to be the son of the most unlucky man in the world.”
Athena’s expression softened.
“Your family will not disappear while Penelope has a son like you.”
Then she glanced toward the suitors.
“But tell me—what is happening here? Is this a celebration? A wedding feast?”
“No guest brings his own food. These men behave disgracefully. They are turning your home into a place of shame.”
Telemachus let out a bitter laugh.
“If my father were here, this house would be happy and prosperous. But the gods have hidden him more completely than any man has ever been hidden.”
“I could have accepted his death if he had fallen at Troy beside his friends. The Greeks would have honored him. They would have built a tomb for him, and I would have inherited his glory.”
“But he vanished without a trace.”
“And that is not the only pain I carry.”
He looked around the hall.
“Men from Dulichium, Same, Zacynthus, and Ithaca itself have come here to marry my mother.”
“She will not refuse them directly, but she will not choose one of them either.”
“So they stay. They eat my sheep and cattle. They destroy my house. Soon they may destroy me as well.”
Athena’s eyes flashed.
“Then you need Odysseus home more than ever.”
“If he stood at this doorway as he once was—wearing his helmet, holding his shield and spears—these suitors would not have long to enjoy their wedding plans.”
She grew serious.
“Still, whether he returns is in the hands of the gods. You cannot sit still and wait.”
“Tomorrow, call an assembly of the people of Ithaca.”
“Tell everyone what these suitors are doing. Order them to leave your house and return to their own.”
“If your mother truly wishes to marry again, let her return to her father’s home. Her father can choose a husband for her and arrange the marriage gifts.”
Then Athena leaned closer.
“And you must take a ship.”
“Choose twenty good men and go in search of your father.”
“First, travel to Pylos and speak with Nestor. Then go to Sparta and ask Menelaus. He was one of the last Greek leaders to return from Troy.”
“If you learn that your father is alive, endure the suitors for one more year.”
“But if you learn that he is dead, return home. Give him a proper funeral. Build a tomb in his honor. Then let your mother marry again.”
Her voice became firm.
“After that, decide how you will deal with these men.”
“You are no longer a child, Telemachus.”
“Have you not heard how Orestes killed Aegisthus, the murderer of his father? People still praise him for it.”
“You are strong and intelligent. Show the world what you are made of.”
Telemachus listened in silence.
At last he said, “You have spoken to me with the kindness of a father. I will remember everything.”
“But please stay a little longer. Have a bath and rest. Then I will give you a gift—a beautiful gift, the kind good friends give each other.”
Athena shook her head.
“Do not delay me. I must return to my ship.”
“Keep your gift until I come back. Then I will accept it, and I will bring you one in return.”
With that, she rose.
A moment later, she flew away like a bird.
Telemachus stood still, filled with new courage.
He understood then that the stranger had been a god.
Phemius was still singing in the hall.
His song told of the Greeks’ miserable journey home from Troy.
Penelope heard it from her room upstairs.
She came down the great staircase with two servants at her side. A veil covered her face, but tears ran down her cheeks.
“Phemius,” she said, “you know many songs about gods and heroes. Sing one of those.”
“Do not sing about the Greeks returning from Troy. That song breaks my heart. It reminds me of my husband—the man I mourn every day.”
Telemachus spoke before Phemius could answer.
“Mother, let the singer choose his own song.”
“Singers do not create suffering. Zeus sends joy and sorrow as he chooses.”
“Phemius means no harm. People always like to hear new songs.”
Then his voice hardened.
“Go back upstairs. Attend to your weaving and your household work.”
“Speaking is my responsibility now. This house is mine to command.”
Penelope stared at him in surprise.
Then she turned and went back to her room.
She lay awake for a long time, grieving for Odysseus, until Athena finally gave her sleep.
The suitors grew louder as the night went on.
Each of them wanted Penelope for himself.
At last Telemachus stood before them.
“You are shameless men,” he said. “Eat and drink tonight if you wish, but stop this fighting.”
“Phemius has a voice touched by the gods. Let us listen to him.”
“Tomorrow morning, meet me at the public assembly.”
“I will tell you formally to leave this house.”
“Go feast in one another’s homes. Take turns spending your own wealth.”
“But if you keep feeding on one man’s household, then may Zeus judge you.”
“And if you die in my father’s house, no one will avenge you.”
The suitors fell silent.
They bit their lips and stared at him.
They had not expected Odysseus’s son to speak with such strength.
Antinous finally laughed.
“The gods must have taught you how to make grand speeches,” he said. “May Zeus never let you rule Ithaca as your father did.”
Telemachus faced him without fear.
“Do not mock me, Antinous.”
“If the gods allow it, I would gladly rule Ithaca. It is not the worst thing a man could wish for. A king has wealth and honor.”
“But even if someone else becomes king, I will still rule my own house.”
“I will command the servants and property my father left me.”
Eurymachus spoke next.
“The gods will decide who rules Ithaca. But no man here will deny that you are master of your own home.”
Then he looked around.
“Tell us about that visitor. Who was he? Where did he come from? Did he bring news about your father?”
“He seemed wealthy, but he left so quickly that none of us could question him.”
Telemachus answered carefully.
“My father is gone. Even if rumors reach me, I no longer trust them.”
“As for the stranger, he was Mentes, king of the Taphians—an old friend of my father.”
But in his heart, Telemachus knew the truth.
The visitor had been Athena.
The suitors returned to their singing and dancing until night finally came.
Then they left for their own homes.
Telemachus went up to his room in the high tower overlooking the courtyard.
Eurycleia, the old woman who had cared for him since he was a baby, carried torches before him.
She loved him more deeply than anyone else in the house.
When he reached his room, Telemachus took off his shirt and handed it to her.
She folded it carefully and hung it beside his bed.
Then she closed the door, fastened it with its silver latch, and slid the bolt into place.
Telemachus lay beneath a woolen blanket.
But he did not sleep quickly.
All night, he thought about the journey ahead—and the words Athena had given him.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!