The Choice That Changed My Life
By this time, we had almost stopped paying attention to our real business.
Our real work seemed to happen at night, when we treated pleasure as seriously as other men treated their jobs.
Before long, the money in our firm began to disappear.
Not once.
Not twice.
Three different times, we completely ran out of money.
We borrowed what we could, but that was not enough.
In the end, Ed's parents had to rescue us with generous amounts of money.
His father was a cheerful, kindhearted old gentleman.
Whenever we got into trouble, he seemed to think it was perfectly natural for him to write another check and pull us out.
Ed took the whole situation calmly.
I couldn't.
I had no wealthy father waiting behind me with an open checkbook.
I was beginning to worry seriously about our finances.
Strangely, though, I never thought about reducing my own spending.
I continued living just as extravagantly as before.
I ate expensive meals, drank expensive wine, and accepted every invitation to be entertained.
I was spending money I didn't have simply because I was afraid my friends might realize I was running short.
Then a man entered my life who would eventually have a disastrous influence on me.
His name was James Irving, though everyone called him Jimmy Irving.
At the time, he was chief of the New York Detective Force.
One cold January evening, I was with several friends at the Fifth Avenue Hotel when Irving walked in.
One of my friends knew him and introduced us.
Irving was about average height and rather heavy.
He had a blond mustache, pleasant-looking eyes, and a weak chin.
His flushed face suggested that he drank heavily and lived a life of excess.
New York was then under the political control of Boss Tweed, and corruption was everywhere.
Under such conditions, a man like Irving could rise to one of the most powerful positions in the city's police force.
He had been only an ordinary detective before political connections helped him become chief.
The position gave him enormous power.
Irving was hardly a man anyone would normally consider fit to lead a major police department.
He had spent much of his life around bars and gambling houses and had little of the character or discipline one would expect from a police chief.
But politics mattered more than qualifications.
New York was going through a wild period.
The Civil War had ended only recently, and the country was still struggling to recover.
Huge amounts of government money had flooded the economy.
Business was booming.
Money was everywhere.
At the same time, crime, gambling, prostitution, and corruption were spreading openly through the city.
The Tenderloin district became famous for its nightlife and vice.
The police were deeply involved.
Instead of simply enforcing the law, many officers collected money from gambling houses, brothels, and other businesses in exchange for protection.
A police captain in the Tenderloin could make an enormous amount of money from this system.
The captain might collect around a thousand dollars a week.
Part of that money went to police headquarters and was divided among senior officials and their political allies.
Even lower-ranking officers received their share.
A lieutenant might receive around a hundred dollars a week.
A sergeant might receive fifty.
A patrolman might collect smaller amounts directly from the women working the streets.
Anyone who refused to pay could be arrested.
The arrest could be violent.
The woman might be thrown into a filthy cell overnight and then brought before a magistrate who was often connected to the same political machine.
The result was usually a quick conviction and several months in jail.
Gambling houses worked in much the same way.
From Spring Street to Tenth Street, Broadway was filled with faro games and other gambling operations.
Many paid heavily for police protection.
But the police were not the only ones taking money.
Politicians and their friends demanded their share too.
The more respectable gambling houses operated openly around Broadway.
Further downtown, there were countless dishonest gambling operations in places like the Bowery, Chatham Square, Houston Street, and Prince Street.
Everyone seemed to have a hand in the business.
Police captains, politicians, aldermen, councilmen, and their associates all wanted their percentage.
This was the world of the man I was beginning to know.
After my first meeting with Irving, our group stayed together for some time.
Before the evening ended, he had opened three bottles of wine.
Before we separated, I invited him to visit me at the St. Nicholas Hotel.
The next day, he came to see me.
“Come for a drive with me next Sunday,” he said.
I agreed.
The following Sunday, Irving arrived in a magnificent carriage pulled by a fast trotting horse.
Everything about it was elegant.
As we drove along, he casually mentioned:
“I paid a thousand dollars for this outfit.”
I knew roughly what a police chief earned.
His salary was only about two thousand dollars a year.
I quickly did the math.
The carriage, horse, and diamond pin he wore must have cost him roughly a year's salary.
But it was a beautiful morning.
The air was cold and fresh, and the day was perfect for driving.
We originally planned to go to Fordham.
Then Irving changed his mind.
“Let's go to High Bridge instead.”
We drove through Harlem and continued far out into Westchester County.
On the way back, we stopped at O'Brien's Hotel for dinner.
The meal was excellent.
In fact, the whole day was luxurious.
Irving paid for everything.
I enjoyed myself enormously.
He was a fascinating storyteller.
Because of his position, he knew countless people and had heard endless stories about New York life.
Many of the people we passed that day were personally known to him.
Some were wealthy and fashionable.
Others had once lived on the wrong side of the law or had suffered through terrible changes in fortune.
Irving seemed to know the stories behind all of them.
After dark, we returned to my hotel.
After dinner, we lit cigars and headed for Police Headquarters.
Irving had some routine business to handle there.
He introduced me to two of his senior detectives.
For the purposes of this story, I will call them Stanley and White.
They would appear again later, and their actions would show what kind of men they really were.
For the next eight weeks, my life continued much as before.
Our business made some money.
Then one bad investment wiped out our entire capital.
Things became even worse when Ed's health began to fail.
Our constant drinking, late dinners, lack of sleep, and irregular lifestyle had finally begun to destroy his already weak constitution.
One Saturday, he suddenly told me:
“I've decided to leave the partnership.”
I was stunned.
“What are you going to do?”
“I'm going to Europe for a while. I need to get away.”
There was almost nothing left to divide between us except the furniture in our office.
Ed gave it all to me.
The following Wednesday, he sailed for Europe with two members of his family.
I went to the wharf to see him off.
We shook hands and said goodbye.
Neither of us knew that it would be the last time we would ever say farewell.
I walked away from the dock feeling terribly lonely.
A year later, Ed died in Italy.
He was another victim of the reckless life we had been living.
I survived.
But I learned nothing from his death.
By then I was already well down the road of self-destruction.
Looking back many years later, I often wished I had possessed the courage to start over.
I should have stopped spending recklessly.
I should have lived honestly, worked hard, and accepted a simpler life.
Instead, I became even more extravagant.
I was afraid that my friends would discover how badly I was doing financially.
How much better it would have been if I had simply called them together and said:
“Gentlemen, I can't afford this life anymore. We have to part company.”
But I didn't.
Meanwhile, I continued seeing Irving from time to time.
He treated me with great attention.
I was young and foolish enough to enjoy being noticed by a powerful man.
One evening, I ran into him as I was leaving Wallack's Theatre.
He greeted me warmly.
“Come and have supper with me.”
We went to the upper Delmonico's.
Afterward, we walked toward the St. Denis Hotel on Broadway near Eleventh Street.
There we found Detectives Stanley and White.
Wine was ordered.
We stayed together long after midnight.
Before we finally separated, they asked me to dine with them the following evening.
“We have something we'd like to discuss with you,” they said.
I agreed.
The next evening, White came to find me.
“We won't go to Delmonico's tonight,” he said. “We'll have dinner at a restaurant near Sixth Avenue and Thirty-First Street.”
Then he left.
“Be there later,” he told me.
At eleven o'clock, I arrived at the restaurant.
A waiter immediately recognized me, as if he had been expecting me.
He led me upstairs to a private room.
White was already there.
A little later, Irving and Stanley arrived.
We ordered supper.
Wine, of course, followed.
After we had been drinking for a while, the conversation became more personal.
Eventually, they began talking about money.
They asked questions until they managed to get me to admit the truth.
I had very little money left.
The wine and excitement had loosened my tongue.
Suddenly I shouted:
“By God, I want money!”
Stanley grabbed my hand.
“Of course you do,” he said. “A man is a fool without money.”
Irving leaned toward me.
“Are you willing to do us a favor?”
“What kind of favor?”
“You could make ten thousand dollars for yourself.”
I stared at him.
“Ten thousand? How?”
Irving lowered his voice.
“Go to Europe for us.”
I waited.
“We have some stolen bonds. Take them there and sell them.”
For ten thousand dollars, they wanted me to help them commit a serious crime.
I was horrified.
“No.”
The reaction on their faces told me they had not expected such a strong response.
They were clearly disappointed that I had reacted so badly.
They had also made a terrible mistake by telling me their secret.
More wine was ordered.
Before the night ended, I promised not to reveal what they had told me.
Worse, I also promised to think about their offer and give them my answer the following evening.
The next morning, my financial troubles suddenly became impossible to ignore.
My landlord's agent came to my office.
“You're behind on your rent,” he said. “We need the money.”
Not long afterward, a tradesman came looking for payment.
“You've owed me this money for some time,” he said. “I need you to settle the bill.”
I was desperate for cash.
Suddenly, ten thousand dollars seemed like an enormous amount of money.
It also seemed like an easy solution.
I will never forget that day.
Every minute seemed to crawl by as I fought with myself.
Again and again, one thought came into my mind:
“What couldn't I do with ten thousand dollars?”
I imagined all the things that money could buy.
I could pay my debts.
I could live comfortably again.
I could return to the life I had been enjoying.
Then another thought came.
The owner of those bonds had already lost them.
Why shouldn't I get some of the money instead of letting those crooked detectives keep everything?
I kept trying to reassure myself.
“This is only a business deal.”
“I don't really have to do anything.”
“I'll never actually go through with it.”
But I knew I was lying to myself.
That evening, the stars finally appeared.
I left my office and began walking alone up Broadway toward Fifth Avenue and the Park.
I doubt many people had ever walked through that Park carrying the kind of battle that was raging inside me.
I was young.
I loved pleasure.
And I was terrified of being poor.
Over and over, I told myself:
“I can't do this.”
Then another voice answered:
“But how will I pay my debts?”
“How can I continue living the way I have been living?”
I had allowed my financial problems to become an enemy inside my own mind.
They were controlling me.
I walked back and forth for hours.
From eight o'clock until eleven, I wandered through the Park, arguing with myself.
The more I thought about poverty, the more frightening it became.
I drank heavily that night, which only made my judgment worse.
By the time I left the Park, one idea had completely taken control of me.
I could not bear the thought of being poor.
I returned to meet Irving, Stanley, and White.
They asked me again:
“Well? Will you do it for us?”
I hesitated.
Then I heard myself say:
“Of course I will.”
And with those words, I took another long step down the road that would eventually lead me toward ruin.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!