The Deaths of Hermolaüs and Callisthenes
Different historians told conflicting stories about what happened to the conspirators and Callisthenes.
Aristobulus and Ptolemy both claimed that the arrested royal pages admitted Callisthenes had pushed them to carry out the risky assassination plot against Alexander.
Most other ancient writers disagreed with this version of events.
They argued that Alexander was already full of hatred for Callisthenes after their public dispute over the prostration ritual. Knowing Hermolaüs was a close follower and student of Callisthenes, the king was quick to blame the philosopher for the conspiracy, no matter the evidence.
Several historians also recorded Hermolaüs’ bold final speech before the Macedonian assembly.
Brought forward to face his accusers, Hermolaüs openly confessed to plotting to kill the king.
“I conspired against Alexander,” he admitted freely, “because no free man can endure his arrogant and tyrannical rule any longer.”
He went on to list every cruel and unjust act of Alexander’s reign, one after another.
He condemned the unlawful execution of Philotas, and the even more unjust killing of Philotas’ father Parmenio, along with all the other men put to death without fair trial.
He recalled the drunken murder of Clitus, a loyal longtime friend and general.
He criticized Alexander’s arrogant choice to wear Median royal clothing, adopting foreign tyrant customs unfit for a Macedonian king.
He also denounced the king’s forced prostration ritual—the humiliating custom they had argued over, which Alexander still refused to abandon.
Finally, he spoke out against Alexander’s endless drunken feasts and constant state of sluggish intoxication.
“I could not bear to watch our king destroy himself and our kingdom any longer,” Hermolaüs said. “I acted to free myself and all Macedonians from this tyranny.”
After his unflinching confession and public criticism of the king, Hermolaüs and all his fellow conspirators were sentenced to death. The assembled Macedonians stoned them to death on the spot.
As for Callisthenes, accounts of his death differ wildly even among the most reliable eyewitness historians.
Aristobulus wrote that Callisthenes was chained and dragged along with the army as a prisoner. He eventually died of natural causes while in captivity.
But Ptolemy, who served closely beside Alexander throughout these events, told a far grimmer story. He claimed Callisthenes was brutally tortured on the rack before being hanged.
It is striking that even these trusted historians, who lived through these events and stood in the king’s inner circle, could not agree on the details of such a major, well-known incident.
Countless other ancient writers offered even more conflicting and inconsistent details about the conspiracy and its aftermath.
For the sake of clarity, I have included all the most important facts of the story.
Though these events took place shortly after Alexander killed Clitus, I have placed them together in this part of the narrative. The conspiracy, the pages’ execution, and Callisthenes’ downfall are tightly linked to Clitus’ death and Alexander’s growing tyrannical behavior, making them inseparable in telling the full story of his reign.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!