← The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes 2026 Edition
Chapter 9 · The Engineer’s Missing Thumb

The Engineer’s Missing Thumb

Chapter 9 of 12 · 5,557 words · Free

Of all the strange cases I brought to Sherlock Holmes during the years we knew each other, only two came to him through me. One was the case of Colonel Warburton’s madness. The other was the terrible adventure of Victor Hatherley, a young hydraulic engineer who nearly lost his life—and did lose his thumb.

The case was so unusual, and the danger so real, that I have always felt it deserved to be recorded.

It happened in the summer of 1889, shortly after my marriage. I had returned to medical practice and was living not far from Paddington Station. One of my patients there had been cured by me and had become so enthusiastic about my abilities that he was constantly sending other railway workers my way.

One morning, just before seven, my maid knocked on my bedroom door.

“Doctor, two gentlemen have come from Paddington. They’re waiting in the consulting room.”

I dressed quickly and hurried downstairs.

As I reached the bottom of the stairs, my old railway friend came out of the consulting room and shut the door behind him.

“I’ve got him in there,” he whispered, pointing over his shoulder. “He’s all right.”

“What’s wrong with him?”

“It’s a new patient. I thought I’d bring him here myself so he couldn’t disappear. He’s safe and sound. I must get back to work, Doctor.”

Before I could thank him, he was gone.

I entered the consulting room.

A young man was sitting beside the table. He wore a neat tweed suit and a soft cloth cap. One hand was wrapped in a blood-soaked handkerchief.

He looked no more than twenty-five. His face was strong and masculine, but he was terribly pale. He seemed to be fighting hard to keep himself under control.

“I’m sorry to wake you so early, Doctor,” he said. “I had a serious accident during the night. I arrived at Paddington by train this morning and asked where I could find a doctor. That good fellow kindly brought me here.”

“You’re quite welcome.”

He pointed toward the side table.

“I left my card there.”

I picked it up.

“Mr. Victor Hatherley, hydraulic engineer, 16A Victoria Street.”

“I’m sorry you had to wait,” I said. “I understand you’ve just come off a night train.”

“Oh, my night could hardly be called boring.”

He suddenly burst out laughing.

It was a loud, hysterical laugh. He leaned back in his chair and shook with it.

Every medical instinct I had reacted at once.

“Stop!” I said sharply. “Pull yourself together.”

I poured him a glass of water.

But he could not stop.

It was the sort of hysterical laughter that can seize a strong man after he has survived something terrifying. Eventually he came back to himself, exhausted and even paler than before.

“I’m making a fool of myself,” he gasped.

“Not at all. Drink this.”

I added some brandy to the water.

Slowly, colour returned to his face.

“That’s better,” he said. “Now, Doctor, perhaps you could look at my thumb.”

He hesitated.

“Or rather, at the place where my thumb used to be.”

He removed the handkerchief.

Even after all I had seen as a doctor, the injury made me recoil.

Four fingers remained, but where the thumb should have been there was a terrible, raw wound. The thumb had been torn completely away from the root.

“Good heavens!” I cried. “That’s a dreadful injury. You must have lost a great deal of blood.”

“I did. I fainted when it happened. I must have been unconscious for quite some time. When I woke up, it was still bleeding, so I tied my handkerchief tightly around my wrist and used a small branch to keep it firm.”

“Excellent work. You should have been a surgeon.”

He gave a weak smile.

“It was a matter of hydraulics, you see. That sort of emergency falls within my profession.”

I examined the wound.

“This was caused by something very heavy and sharp.”

“Something like a cleaver.”

“It was an accident?”

“No.”

“You mean someone attacked you?”

“Yes. Someone tried to kill me.”

“You horrify me.”

I cleaned the wound, treated it, and wrapped it carefully in bandages. He hardly flinched, though he occasionally bit his lip.

“How does it feel?”

“Much better. Between your brandy and your bandage, I feel almost like a new man. But I’ve been through quite a lot.”

“Perhaps you shouldn’t talk about it yet. It has clearly been a terrible experience.”

“No, I have to tell the police anyway. But between ourselves, Doctor, I doubt they’ll believe me.”

“Why not?”

“Because my story is so extraordinary. The wound proves that something happened, but I have very little other evidence. Even if they believe me, the clues I can give them are vague. I’m not sure they’ll ever find the people responsible.”

I immediately thought of my old friend.

“If you’re facing a mystery that needs solving, you should see Mr. Sherlock Holmes before you go to the police.”

“I’ve heard of him,” Hatherley replied. “I’d be delighted if he would take the case. Of course, I’ll still have to inform the police. Would you introduce me?”

“I’ll do better. I’ll take you there myself.”

“I’d be extremely grateful.”

“We can take a cab. We should arrive in time for breakfast. Are you strong enough?”

“Yes. I won’t feel comfortable until I’ve told someone exactly what happened.”

I hurried upstairs, briefly explained everything to my wife, and within five minutes I was in a hansom cab with Hatherley, heading for Baker Street.

As I expected, Sherlock Holmes was sitting in his room wearing his dressing gown. He was reading the personal advertisements in The Times and smoking his usual morning pipe, filled with bits of tobacco he had saved from the previous day.

He welcomed us warmly.

“Breakfast,” he ordered. “Fresh eggs and bacon.”

Soon we were sitting around the table.

After breakfast, Holmes settled Hatherley on the sofa, put a pillow beneath his head, and placed a glass of brandy and water beside him.

“It’s obvious that you’ve been through something extraordinary, Mr. Hatherley,” Holmes said. “Make yourself comfortable. Tell us everything you can remember, but stop if you become tired.”

“Thank you,” Hatherley replied. “I feel much stronger now. Your breakfast has finished what the doctor started. I’ll get straight to the point.”

Holmes sat back in his armchair, his eyelids heavy and his expression almost bored. But I knew that behind that calm face his mind was working intensely.

I sat opposite him.

Then Hatherley began.

“I’m an orphan and a bachelor. I live alone in London. I’m a hydraulic engineer, and I spent seven years training with Venner & Matheson, a respected engineering firm in Greenwich.

“Two years ago, I finished my training and received some money after my father died. I decided to start my own business and rented an office in Victoria Street.

“My first years as an independent engineer have been miserable.

“In two years, I received only three consultations and one small job.

“That’s all.

“My total income from the business has been twenty-seven pounds and ten shillings.

“Every day I sat in my little office from nine until four, waiting for work that never came.

“Eventually I began to believe I would never succeed.

“But yesterday, just as I was preparing to leave, my clerk came in.

“‘There’s a gentleman waiting to see you, sir.’

“He handed me a card.

“The name on it was Colonel Lysander Stark.

“The man himself followed my clerk into the room.

“He was slightly taller than average, but unbelievably thin. I don’t think I had ever seen such a thin man.

“His face seemed to narrow into his nose and chin. The skin of his cheeks was stretched tightly over his bones.

“Yet he did not look sick.

“His eyes were bright. He moved quickly. He carried himself confidently.

“He was simply dressed, perhaps around forty years old, and he spoke with a slight German accent.

“‘Mr. Hatherley?’ he asked.

“‘Yes.’

“‘I have heard that you are not only a skilled engineer, but also a discreet man who knows how to keep a secret.’

“I was flattered.

“‘May I ask who recommended me?’

“‘Perhaps I shouldn’t tell you yet. But I know that you are an orphan, a bachelor, and live alone in London.’

“‘That’s true,’ I said. ‘But I don’t see what that has to do with my engineering work.’

“‘Everything I’ve said is relevant. I have a professional job for you. But absolute secrecy is essential. A man who lives alone is easier to trust with a secret than a man with a family.’

“‘If I give you my word, you can trust me.’

“He stared at me suspiciously.

“‘Do you promise?’

“‘Yes.’

“‘Complete silence before, during, and after the job? No mention of it in conversation or writing?’

“‘You have my word.’

“‘Very good.’

“He suddenly jumped up and rushed across the room. He opened the door and looked into the hallway.

“No one was there.

“‘Good,’ he said. ‘Clerks can be curious about their employers’ business. Now we can speak freely.’

“He came back and pulled his chair close to mine.

“I was beginning to feel uneasy around this strange, skeletal man.

“‘Please tell me what you want me to do,’ I said. ‘My time is valuable.’

“‘Would fifty guineas for one night’s work interest you?’

“‘Very much.’

“‘Actually, it may take only an hour. I want your opinion about a hydraulic press that has stopped working properly. Once you tell us what’s wrong, we can repair it ourselves.’

“‘That sounds like easy work for excellent pay.’

“‘Exactly. I need you to come tonight on the last train.’

“‘Where?’

“‘Eyford, in Berkshire. It’s near the Oxfordshire border, about seven miles from Reading. There’s a train from Paddington that arrives around 11:15.’

“‘All right.’

“‘I’ll meet you at the station in a carriage.’

“‘So the house is some distance from the station?’

“‘About seven miles through the countryside.’

“‘Then it will be close to midnight before we arrive. I assume there won’t be another train back.’

“‘No. You’ll have to stay the night.’

“‘Couldn’t I come earlier?’

“‘We prefer that you come late. That is why we are paying such a large fee. Still, if you wish to withdraw, you have time.’

“I thought about the fifty guineas. I desperately needed the money.

“‘No, I’ll come.’

“‘Good. But I’d like you to understand exactly what you’re being hired to do.’

“‘Of course.’

“‘And I assume no one can overhear us?’

“‘No.’

“‘Then let me explain.

“You probably know that fuller’s-earth is valuable and is found in only a few places in England.’

“‘I’ve heard that.’

“‘Some time ago I bought a small property near Reading. I discovered that one of my fields contained a deposit of fuller’s-earth.

“‘Unfortunately, the deposit is small. But it connects two much larger deposits on either side, both belonging to my neighbours.

“‘They have no idea that their land contains something so valuable.

“‘Naturally, I wanted to buy their land before they discovered the truth.

“‘Unfortunately, I didn’t have enough money.

“‘So I told a few friends about the deposit. They suggested that we secretly work the small deposit on my own property and use the profits to buy the neighbouring fields.

“‘We’ve been doing that for some time.

“‘We built a hydraulic press to help with the work.

“‘Unfortunately, the press has developed a problem.

“‘That’s why we need your advice.

“‘We must keep everything secret. If people learned that hydraulic engineers were visiting my property, questions would soon be asked. Once people discovered the truth, our plan would be ruined.

“‘That is why I insisted that you tell no one about your trip to Eyford tonight.’

“‘I understand,’ I said. ‘But there is one thing I don’t understand. How can a hydraulic press help you dig fuller’s-earth out of the ground?’

“‘We have our own method. We compress the earth into bricks so that we can move it without revealing what it is. But that’s not important.

“‘I have trusted you with the whole story. Now I expect you at Eyford at 11:15.’

“‘I’ll be there.’

“‘And remember—tell no one.’

“He shook my hand with a cold, damp grip and left.”

Hatherley paused.

“When I thought about the meeting later, I was deeply uneasy.

“The money was excellent, and the job might lead to more work.

“But I disliked Colonel Stark from the moment I met him.

“His explanation about the fuller’s-earth didn’t convince me.

“And I couldn’t understand why I had to arrive at midnight or why he was so desperate to keep my visit secret.

“Still, I pushed my doubts aside.

“I ate dinner, went to Paddington, and caught the train.

“At Reading I had to change stations as well as trains. Fortunately, I caught the last train to Eyford.

“I arrived shortly after eleven.

“I was the only passenger who got off.

“A sleepy porter stood on the platform with a lantern.

“As I passed through the gate, I saw Colonel Stark waiting in the shadows.

“He grabbed my arm without saying a word and hurried me into a carriage.

“The door was already open.

“He pulled the windows shut, tapped the side of the carriage, and the horse started moving as fast as it could.”

“One horse?” Holmes interrupted.

“Yes. Only one.”

“What colour?”

“Chestnut. I saw it clearly when I climbed into the carriage.”

“Was it tired?”

“No. It looked fresh and glossy.”

“Thank you. Please continue.”

“We drove for at least an hour.

“Stark had said the house was only seven miles away, but the journey felt more like twelve.

“He sat beside me in complete silence.

“Several times I looked at him and found him staring at me.

“The roads were terrible. The carriage bounced and shook constantly.

“I tried to look outside, but the windows were frosted. I could see nothing except the occasional blur of a passing light.

“I tried to make conversation, but Stark answered only with a word or two.

“Eventually the rough road changed to a smooth gravel drive.

“The carriage stopped.

“Stark jumped out.

“I followed him.

“He pulled me quickly through a porch and straight into the house.

“I never even got a proper look at the outside.

“The moment I crossed the threshold, the door slammed behind me.

“I heard the carriage wheels fading into the distance.

“Inside, it was completely dark.

“Stark searched for matches, muttering to himself.

“Then a door opened at the far end of the hallway.

“A long strip of golden light appeared.

“It widened.

“A woman stepped out holding a lamp above her head.

“She was beautiful. She wore a dark dress made of expensive-looking material.

“She spoke a few words in a foreign language.

“Stark answered with a single rough word.

“She nearly dropped the lamp.

“He went over, whispered something into her ear, and pushed her back into the room.

“Then he returned to me with the lamp.

“‘Please wait here for a few minutes,’ he said.

“He opened another door.

“It led to a small, quiet room with a round table in the middle.

“Several German books lay scattered across it.

“Stark put the lamp on top of a harmonium beside the door.

“‘I won’t keep you waiting.’

“And he disappeared into the darkness.

“I looked at the books.

“Even though I couldn’t read German, I recognized two as scientific works. The others appeared to be poetry.

“I went to the window.

“I wanted to see where we were.

“But a heavy wooden shutter covered it, locked from the inside.

“The house was strangely silent.

“Somewhere in the hallway an old clock ticked loudly.

“Otherwise, there was nothing.

“I began to feel uneasy.

“Who were these German people?

“What were they doing in such an isolated house?

“And where exactly was I?

“I knew I was somewhere near Eyford, but I had no idea in which direction.

“I walked around the room, quietly humming to myself.

“At least I was earning my fifty guineas.

“Then, without warning, the door slowly opened.

“The woman stood there.

“The hallway behind her was completely dark.

“The lamp lit her beautiful face.

“She looked terrified.

“She raised one trembling finger to her lips.

“‘Be quiet,’ she whispered.

“Then she glanced nervously over her shoulder.

“‘You should go,’ she said. ‘You should not stay here. There is nothing you can do.’

“‘But I haven’t even examined the machine yet.’

“‘It doesn’t matter. You can leave. No one will stop you.’

“I smiled and shook my head.

“She suddenly clasped her hands together.

“‘For God’s sake!’ she whispered. ‘Get out before it’s too late!’

“I was stubborn by nature.

“The more difficult something became, the more determined I was to finish it.

“I thought about the fifty guineas.

“I had already traveled all this way.

“Why should I leave without doing the job?

“Perhaps this woman was simply hysterical.

“So I shook my head.

“‘I’m staying.’

“She was about to speak again when a door slammed upstairs.

“Footsteps came down the stairs.

“She listened.

“Then she raised her hands helplessly and disappeared.”

Hatherley took a breath.

“A moment later, Colonel Stark returned.

“With him was a short, heavily built man with a chinchilla beard hanging from the folds of his double chin.

“Stark introduced him as Mr. Ferguson.

“‘He is my secretary and manager,’ Stark said.

“Then he looked at the door.

“‘I thought I had left that door closed. I’m afraid you must have felt a draft.’

“‘Actually, I opened it myself. The room was rather stuffy.’

“He gave me another suspicious look.

“‘Then let us get to work. Ferguson and I will show you the machine.’

“‘Should I get my hat?’

“‘No. The machine is inside the house.’

“‘You dig fuller’s-earth inside the house?’

“‘No, no. We only compress it here. Never mind that. Just examine the machine and tell us what is wrong.’

“We went upstairs.

“Stark carried the lamp.

“Ferguson and I followed.

“The house was like a maze.

“There were long corridors, narrow passages, twisting staircases, and tiny doors.

“The floors were bare.

“There was almost no furniture upstairs.

“The plaster was falling from the walls.

“Damp green stains covered large areas.

“I tried to look calm.

“But I remembered the woman’s warning.

“I watched both men carefully.

“Ferguson was quiet and unfriendly.

“From his accent, however, I could tell that he was English.

“Eventually Stark stopped at a low door.

“He unlocked it.

“Inside was a small square room.

“There was barely enough space for three men.

“Ferguson stayed outside.

“Stark led me in.

“‘We are standing inside the hydraulic press,’ he said.

“‘It would be very unpleasant if someone switched it on.

“‘The ceiling is actually the end of the piston.

“‘When it comes down, it exerts a force of many tons against this iron floor.

“‘Water cylinders on the sides multiply the pressure.

“‘The machine still works, but it has become stiff and has lost some of its power.

“‘Please examine it and tell us how to repair it.’

“I took the lamp and inspected the machine carefully.

“It was enormous.

“It could produce tremendous pressure.

“When I stepped outside and moved the levers, I immediately heard a strange hissing sound.

“There was a leak.

“Water was being forced back through one of the side cylinders.

“I examined it more closely.

“One of the rubber seals around a driving rod had shrunk.

“It no longer fitted tightly inside its socket.

“That was obviously the cause of the lost pressure.

“I explained it to the two men.

“They listened carefully and asked several practical questions.

“Once I had explained how to repair it, I returned to the main chamber.

“I wanted another look at the machine.

“That was when I realized the story about fuller’s-earth was complete nonsense.

“No one would build a machine this powerful simply to compress a little earth.

“The walls were wooden.

“The floor was a large iron trough.

“I noticed a strange metallic crust covering the bottom.

“I bent down and scraped at it.

“Then I heard someone mutter angrily in German.

“I looked up.

“Colonel Stark was staring down at me.

“‘What are you doing?’

“I was angry that he had deceived me so completely.

“‘Admiring your fuller’s-earth,’ I said. ‘I’d be able to advise you much better if I knew what this machine is really being used for.’

“The moment I said it, I knew I had made a terrible mistake.

“His face hardened.

“A cold, murderous light appeared in his grey eyes.

“‘Very well,’ he said. ‘You’re going to learn exactly what this machine is for.’

“He stepped backward.

“The little door slammed shut.

“I heard the key turn.

“I rushed to it.

“It was locked.

“‘Colonel! Open the door!’

“I kicked it.

“I pulled the handle.

“Nothing.

“Then I heard it.

“The levers began to move.

“The cylinder hissed.

“He had switched on the press.

“The lamp was still on the floor.

“By its light I watched the black iron ceiling begin to descend.

“Slowly.

“Jerking downward.

“But I knew exactly how much force that machine could produce.

“Within a minute, it would crush me into a shapeless mass.

“I threw myself against the door.

“‘Help! Let me out!’

“I screamed until my throat hurt.

“But the machinery drowned out my voice.

“The ceiling was now only a few feet above my head.

“I raised my hand and touched the rough iron surface.

“I realized that I was about to die.

“I wondered whether it would hurt less if I lay face down.

“Then I imagined the ceiling crushing my spine.

“I considered lying on my back.

“But could I bear to watch that enormous black slab coming down on me?

“I could no longer stand upright.

“Then something caught my eye.

“The floor and ceiling were iron.

“But the walls were wooden.

“I looked around desperately.

“A thin line of yellow light appeared between two boards.

“It grew wider.

“A small wooden panel was moving.

“For a moment I could hardly believe it.

“There was a hidden door.

“I threw myself through it.

“I collapsed on the other side.

“The panel closed behind me.

“Then I heard the lamp smash.

“A few seconds later came the terrible crash of the iron plates meeting.

“I had escaped by seconds.”

Hatherley swallowed hard.

“Someone suddenly grabbed my wrist.

“I was lying on a stone floor in a narrow corridor.

“The woman was beside me.

“She held a candle in one hand and pulled at me with the other.

“‘Come! Hurry!’ she gasped. ‘They’ll be here soon. They’ll realize you’re gone.’

“‘Please, don’t waste time!’

“This time I listened.

“I staggered to my feet.

“We ran down the corridor and descended a twisting staircase.

“At the bottom we reached another passage.

“Then we heard footsteps.

“Two men were shouting to each other, one above us and one below.

“The woman stopped.

“She looked around desperately.

“Then she opened a bedroom door.

“Moonlight poured through the window.

“‘It’s your only chance,’ she whispered. ‘It’s high, but you may survive the jump.’

“Then a light appeared at the end of the passage.

“Colonel Stark was coming toward us.

“He carried a lantern in one hand.

“In the other was a weapon like a butcher’s cleaver.

“I ran into the bedroom.

“I opened the window.

“Below me was a quiet garden bathed in moonlight.

“It couldn’t have been more than thirty feet down.

“I climbed onto the windowsill.

“But I hesitated.

“I wanted to know what would happen to the woman.

“If Stark hurt her, I intended to go back and help her.

“Before I could decide, he reached the doorway.

“He pushed past her.

“She grabbed him.

“‘Fritz! Fritz!’ she cried. ‘Remember what you promised me last time. You said it would never happen again.’

“‘He’ll keep quiet!’

“Stark shouted at her.

“‘You’re insane, Elise! You’ll destroy us! He’s seen too much. Get out of my way!’

“He shoved her aside.

“Then he rushed toward the window.

“He swung the cleaver at me.

“I had already dropped from the sill and was hanging by my hands.

“The blade struck.

“I felt a terrible pain.

“My fingers lost their grip.

“I fell into the garden.”

Hatherley paused.

“I wasn’t badly hurt by the fall.

“I got up immediately and ran through the bushes.

“I knew I was still in danger.

“Then suddenly I became dizzy and sick.

“I looked at my hand.

“It was throbbing violently.

“That was when I realized my thumb was gone.

“Blood was pouring from the wound.

“I tried to wrap my hand with my handkerchief.

“But my ears began to buzz.

“The world went black.

“I collapsed among the rose bushes.”

He closed his eyes for a moment.

“I don’t know how long I remained unconscious.

“It must have been hours.

“When I woke, the moon had disappeared.

“Morning was breaking.

“My clothes were soaked with dew.

“My sleeve was covered in blood.

“The pain in my hand brought the whole nightmare rushing back.

“I jumped to my feet.

“I expected my pursuers to be nearby.

“But something was wrong.

“There was no house.

“No garden.

“Nothing.

“I was lying beside a hedge near a main road.

“A little farther away stood a long building.

“I walked toward it.

“It was the railway station where I had arrived the night before.

“Without that terrible wound, I might have believed the whole thing had been a nightmare.”

Holmes listened without interrupting.

“I went into the station and asked about the morning train.

“There was one to Reading in less than an hour.

“The same porter was there.

“I asked him if he had ever heard of Colonel Lysander Stark.

“He hadn’t.

“I asked if he had seen a carriage waiting for me the night before.

“He said no.

“I asked where the nearest police station was.

“He told me it was about three miles away.

“I was too weak to walk that far.

“So I decided to wait until I reached London.

“I arrived shortly after six.

“I had my wound treated.

“Then the doctor brought me here.

“I’m placing the whole matter in your hands, Mr. Holmes.

“I’ll follow whatever advice you give me.”

For several moments, none of us spoke.

Then Holmes stood and pulled one of his large scrapbooks from the shelf.

“I think this may interest you.”

He opened it.

“This appeared in several newspapers about a year ago.

“Listen.

“‘Missing: Jeremiah Hayling, aged twenty-six, hydraulic engineer. Left his lodgings at ten o’clock at night and has not been heard from since.’

“Interesting.”

Hatherley stared at him.

“Good heavens! Then that explains what the woman said.”

“Exactly,” Holmes replied.

“That was probably the last time Stark needed an engineer to repair his machine.”

Hatherley went pale.

“So Hayling was killed?”

“Almost certainly.”

Holmes closed the book.

“Stark is a cold and ruthless man. He will eliminate anyone who threatens his operation.”

“What do you think they were doing?” I asked.

“We’ll find out soon enough.”

He turned to Hatherley.

“If you are strong enough, we should go to Scotland Yard immediately. Then we can travel to Eyford.”

Hatherley nodded.

“I’m ready.”

About three hours later, we were on a train heading from Reading toward the small Berkshire village.

Holmes was with us.

So was Hatherley.

Inspector Bradstreet of Scotland Yard had joined us, along with a plain-clothes officer.

Bradstreet unfolded a map across the train seat and began drawing a circle with Eyford at its centre.

“There,” he said. “Ten miles from the village. You said the house was about ten miles away?”

“It took an hour to drive there.”

“And you think they carried you that far while you were unconscious?”

“They must have. I have a vague memory of being lifted and carried somewhere.”

“I still don’t understand why they didn’t kill you when they found you unconscious in the garden,” I said.

“Perhaps the woman persuaded Stark to spare him.”

“I doubt it,” Holmes said. “I have never seen a more merciless face.”

Bradstreet folded his arms.

“We’ll soon find out. I’ve drawn the circle. Now we only need to know where the house is.”

“I believe I know,” Holmes said quietly.

Bradstreet looked at him.

“You’ve already worked it out?”

“Yes.”

“Then let’s hear it.”

“I say south,” Bradstreet said. “The country is more deserted there.”

“I say east,” Hatherley added.

“I’m going west,” said the plain-clothes officer. “There are several quiet villages there.”

“I think north,” I said. “There are no hills in that direction, and Hatherley never noticed the carriage climbing.”

Bradstreet laughed.

“We’ve covered every direction. Holmes, you get the deciding vote.”

“You’re all wrong.”

“We can’t all be wrong.”

“Yes, you can.”

Holmes placed his finger directly in the middle of the circle.

“This is where we’ll find them.”

Hatherley stared at him.

“But the drive took an hour!”

“Six miles out and six miles back.”

“How?”

“You told us the horse was fresh and glossy when you entered the carriage. How could it still be fresh after pulling a carriage twelve miles over bad roads?”

Hatherley nodded slowly.

“So the driver simply drove around and returned to the starting point?”

“Exactly,” Holmes said.

Bradstreet looked thoughtful.

“That is certainly possible.”

“There is no doubt about what this gang is doing,” Holmes continued.

“What are they doing?” I asked.

“They’re counterfeiters.

“The hydraulic press is being used to manufacture fake silver coins.”

Bradstreet nodded.

“We’ve suspected for some time that a major counterfeiting operation was active in the area. Thousands of counterfeit half-crowns have been appearing.

“We traced the gang as far as Reading.

“After that, they disappeared.

“They were obviously experienced criminals.

“But now, thanks to this unfortunate accident, I think we’ve finally found them.”

Unfortunately, Bradstreet was wrong.

As our train approached Eyford, we saw an enormous column of smoke rising behind a group of trees.

It stretched across the sky like a giant black feather.

“Is that a house on fire?” Bradstreet asked the stationmaster as we arrived.

“Yes, sir.”

“When did it start?”

“During the night, I believe. It’s getting worse. The whole place is burning.”

“Whose house?”

“Dr. Becher’s.”

Hatherley suddenly spoke.

“Is Dr. Becher German?”

The stationmaster laughed.

“No, sir. He’s English. And one of the biggest men in the parish.”

Hatherley’s face tightened.

“But does he have a foreign guest? A very thin man with a long, sharp nose?”

“Well, yes. There is a foreign gentleman staying with him. A patient, apparently. He’s certainly thin enough. I’d say some good Berkshire beef wouldn’t hurt him.”

The stationmaster had barely finished speaking before we were all running toward the fire.

We reached the top of a low hill.

A huge whitewashed building stood below us.

Flames were pouring from every window.

Three fire engines were desperately fighting the blaze.

Hatherley pointed.

“That’s it!”

His voice shook with excitement.

“There’s the gravel drive!”

“And those are the rose bushes!”

He pointed again.

“That window is where I jumped.”

Holmes studied the burning house.

“At least you’ve had your revenge.”

“How?”

“Your oil lamp.”

He pointed toward the building.

“When you escaped the press, the lamp was still inside. You said you knocked it over as you fled.

“It must have broken.

“The oil caught fire against the wooden walls.

“The criminals were too busy chasing you to notice.”

Hatherley stared at the flames.

“What about them?”

“Keep watching the crowd,” Holmes said. “Although I suspect they are already far away.”

Holmes was right.

No trace was ever found of the beautiful woman, the sinister German, or the silent Englishman.

Early that morning, a farmer had seen a cart carrying several people and a number of large boxes heading rapidly toward Reading.

After that, the trail vanished.

Even Holmes could find no clue to their whereabouts.

The firemen discovered some strange equipment inside the house.

They also found something even more disturbing.

A freshly severed human thumb lay on a second-floor windowsill.

By sunset, the fire was finally under control.

But the roof had collapsed.

The entire building had been reduced to ruins.

Only twisted metal cylinders and pipes remained of the machinery that had nearly killed Hatherley.

Large quantities of nickel and tin were found in an outbuilding.

But no counterfeit coins were discovered.

That probably explained the large boxes seen in the cart.

One mystery remained.

How had Hatherley been moved from the garden to the place where he woke up?

The soft earth gave us the answer.

There were footprints.

Two people had carried him.

One had remarkably small feet.

The other had unusually large ones.

Most likely, the quiet Englishman, who was apparently less violent than Stark, had helped the woman carry the unconscious engineer away from the house.

As we prepared to return to London, Hatherley looked sadly at his injured hand.

“Well, gentlemen, that was quite an adventure.”

Holmes smiled.

“I’ve lost my thumb,” Hatherley said, “and I’ve lost my fifty-guinea fee. What exactly have I gained?”

“Experience,” Holmes replied with a laugh.

“And if you ever tell the story properly, you’ll have something to entertain people with for the rest of your life.”

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!