The Financial Crisis and What It Taught Wall Street
“Mr. President, members of the Kentucky Bankers’ Association, we have just come through a serious crisis of confidence on Wall Street.”
“Investors lost faith in corporate credit, railroads, industrial companies, and their stocks. The result was what I would call a slow-motion panic—a long and painful fall in stock prices as investors and speculators rushed to sell.”
“This trouble had been building for years. We already saw a serious warning in the spring, when the stock market collapsed in March. But the situation became much worse after a federal court in Chicago imposed a staggering $29.24 million fine on the Standard Oil Company of Indiana.”
“That fine frightened investors and the great capitalists of Wall Street.”
“The large speculators were especially nervous. They had accumulated enormous amounts of stock and had been trying to push prices higher so they could sell at a profit. But the public had largely stayed out of the market.”
“When the huge fine was announced, these men suddenly feared that the government might begin confiscating corporate property. If Standard Oil could be hit so hard, they reasoned, other corporations might suffer the same fate.”
“So they changed their strategy.”
“They stopped supporting the rising market and began selling their own stocks to protect themselves.”
“The ordinary bulls saw prices collapsing and followed them out of the market. The bears then attacked aggressively, pushing prices down even faster.”
“The bankers were unwilling to step in and stop the fall.”
“The strongest and most expensive stocks suffered the greatest losses. For roughly two weeks, stocks poured onto the market while prices collapsed.”
“Wall Street was terrified.”
“The shortage of money made everything worse. Loans became harder to obtain and interest rates rose. This undermined confidence in the money market and raised fears that corporations desperately needing cash would not be able to borrow against their assets.”
“Those fears soon appeared justified.”
“A large New York iron and construction company failed. Then the Pope Manufacturing Company went into receivership.”
“The selling became even more intense.”
“The bears were having the time of their lives.”
“Many people began to fear that these failures were only the beginning. They worried about more bankruptcies, more government attacks on railroads and industrial companies, and further destruction of corporate credit.”
“People often fear what they imagine more than what is actually happening.”
“The biggest problem was the shortage of money available to large corporations.”
“Many of these companies owned valuable factories, equipment, land, and materials, but they did not have enough cash to operate their businesses comfortably.”
“They depended heavily on banks.”
“Once falling stock and bond prices caused banks to lose confidence, banks began reducing or refusing credit.”
“These companies had little cash of their own to fall back on.”
“They were caught between a rock and a hard place.”
“This shortage of liquid assets was a serious weakness throughout American business, large and small.”
“Companies should learn from this.”
“It is better to operate a smaller business on a safe financial foundation than to expand aggressively through heavy borrowing and risk collapse when an unexpected crisis arrives.”
“The desire for profit must be balanced by patience and caution.”
“Unfortunately, most people are in a hurry. They want the fastest possible road to success.”
“The August crisis, like most panics, was made much worse by fear, rumors, and exaggerated expectations of disaster.”
“Public opinion can be almost as powerful as facts.”
“People had become extremely sensitive to bad news. They ignored encouraging signs and focused almost entirely on the negative.”
“That gave the bears all the ammunition they needed.”
“They kept selling and driving prices lower, adding to the liquidation already being caused by frightened investors and speculators.”
“But even after all this, the bears still wanted more.”
“Much of the fear came from government investigations of railroads and industrial corporations and from state governments cutting railroad rates.”
“Some of these state laws were too restrictive. I believe many will eventually be changed or overturned.”
“People kept asking, ‘Where will this campaign against the railroads and trusts end?’”
“The bears and the alarmists pointed again and again to the $29 million fine as proof that other corporations could also be destroyed.”
“A relatively isolated event was turned into a supposed threat to the entire country.”
“The bears competed with one another to predict disaster.”
“The aggressive statements made by some government lawyers frightened investors almost as much as the accusations against the corporations themselves.”
“Investors feared that corporations might be damaged beyond repair before their legal cases were finally settled.”
“They worried that stock prices would collapse and that interest and dividends might even be suspended.”
“In other words, they were borrowing trouble before it actually arrived.”
“With this kind of fear dominating the public mind, it was no surprise that stock exchanges throughout the United States became nervous.”
“The fear even spread temporarily to London and the European markets.”
“For a while, the situation looked almost hopeless.”
“Then reason slowly replaced hysteria.”
“As stocks became extremely cheap, investors began buying again.”
“After about two weeks of fear and chaos, the panic gradually faded.”
“Prices began recovering, although not without occasional setbacks.”
“Whether the recovery would last remained uncertain.”
“The $29.24 million fine against Standard Oil had caused enormous damage because it triggered massive selling.”
“Combined with the legal conflict between Southern Railway and the Southern states, the fine became the immediate spark for the August collapse.”
“Yet there was little realistic chance that such an enormous fine would ever actually be collected from a corporation with only about a million dollars of capital.”
“Nevertheless, people behaved as though the money would certainly be taken.”
“The fear of confiscation led investors and speculators alike to sell their stocks at enormous sacrifices.”
“The innocent suffered alongside the guilty.”
“This episode teaches an important lesson.”
“If corporations deliberately break the law, the government should punish the individuals responsible rather than imposing enormous fines on the corporations themselves.”
“Why?”
“Because corporate fines ultimately fall on the shareholders.”
“A large fine reduces the company’s ability to pay dividends and lowers the value of its stock.”
“The shareholders may have done nothing wrong, yet they suffer the consequences.”
“The proper punishment should fall on the guilty executives.”
“If they deliberately violate the law, they should face criminal prosecution and, when convicted, imprisonment.”
“That would punish the people actually responsible.”
“It would also restore investor confidence.”
“Punishing individual wrongdoers would not necessarily reduce the value of the corporation’s stock. In fact, it could increase its value by encouraging honest management.”
“That principle should never be forgotten.”
“The collapse of Wall Street, however, was not caused solely by government prosecutions, railroad legislation, the Standard Oil fine, or President Roosevelt’s policies.”
“The deeper problem was the overall condition of the money market and the stock market itself.”
“For a long time, ordinary investors had avoided Wall Street.”
“At the same time, business was booming, and enormous amounts of money were being poured into land, mining, manufacturing, railroads, and other speculative ventures.”
“Speculation outside Wall Street had rarely been so intense.”
“Meanwhile, stocks were concentrated in the hands of a relatively small number of wealthy men.”
“These men wanted to sell, but they could only sell large amounts of stock if they could first create a strong market.”
“That was becoming increasingly difficult.”
“Money was scarce and expensive not only in America but throughout the world.”
“European markets were also overloaded with securities.”
“And there was something even worse.”
“There were almost no investors willing to buy them.”
“Europe was effectively closed to American securities.”
“The only American asset foreign investors seemed eager to obtain was gold.”
“Our wealthy speculators were therefore trapped.”
“They had once been financial giants.”
“Now much of their wealth was locked up in securities they could not easily sell.”
“Poorer people with money in savings banks were, in one important respect, in a better position.”
“They could withdraw their money whenever necessary.”
“One New York savings bank, the Bowery Savings Bank, held more than $100 million in deposits.”
“That was real liquid wealth.”
“Our great Wall Street capitalists could hardly have helped envying those ordinary depositors.”
“In proportion to their resources, the poorer people were sometimes in a stronger financial position than the rich.”
“The wealthy had simply taken on too much.”
“They had formed syndicates to finance enormous bond issues and had tried to control the stock market even when conditions were against them.”
“They had overestimated their own strength.”
“They had bitten off more than they could chew.”
“When the pressure became severe in March and again in August, banks demanded repayment of loans and additional margin.”
“The wealthy speculators were forced to sell stocks at heavy losses.”
“For once, they were genuinely short of cash.”
“The same problem existed among corporations.”
“Railroads and industrial companies had expanded aggressively to keep up with the country’s extraordinary growth.”
“They spent enormous sums on new facilities, equipment, and improvements.”
“They issued huge quantities of bonds, stocks, and short-term notes.”
“In total, these new securities were far beyond what American investors could absorb.”
“Hundreds of millions of dollars of them were still sitting with banking syndicates.”
“And those securities were already showing enormous losses.”
“Even millionaires dislike that kind of medicine.”
“Our prosperity had encouraged us to move too quickly.”
“We spent money almost without limit.”
“Railroads and manufacturers stretched their credit almost to the breaking point.”
“At the same time, railroads were overwhelmed with freight and factories were overwhelmed with orders.”
“So prosperity itself became a danger.”
“The companies had pushed their operations, working capital, and credit too far.”
“The desire for enormous profits also encouraged dishonest practices, illegal arrangements, and corruption.”
“Those abuses eventually came to light.”
“That naturally damaged public confidence.”
“Investors became reluctant to buy stocks and began looking for opportunities elsewhere.”
“The public demanded government action.”
“President Roosevelt took the lead in investigating and correcting these abuses.”
“His goal was not to destroy the railroads or ruin their shareholders.”
“His goal was to eliminate corruption and force corporations to operate within the law.”
“He wanted investors to be protected.”
“He also wanted farmers, manufacturers, and merchants to receive fair railroad rates instead of special treatment for powerful corporations.”
“Large companies, in his view, had to obey the law just as ordinary citizens did.”
“If the laws had been viewed calmly, enforcing them should not have frightened investors.”
“It is unfair to blame President Roosevelt for the $29 million fine that triggered the August panic.”
“The fine was the last straw.”
“The financial system was already under enormous pressure.”
“The judge who imposed that extraordinary penalty must bear much of the responsibility for starting the immediate collapse.”
“August 1907 became one of the most extraordinary months in Wall Street history.”
“At the beginning of the month, almost everyone was pessimistic.”
“Investors and speculators were selling at almost any price.”
“The bears and the alarmists were predicting disaster.”
“Yet twelve days later, the situation had changed dramatically.”
“The market began recovering.”
“Confidence returned.”
“People who had desperately wanted to sell were suddenly eager to buy.”
“Even the bears began covering their positions and buying stocks.”
“The mood of Wall Street changed from despair to optimism.”
“When prices reached their lowest point, many leading stocks hit their lowest levels in years.”
“New York Central, for example, fell to $99.50, its lowest price since 1898.”
“In those twelve days, the total market value of stocks on the New York Stock Exchange fell by roughly $3 billion.”
“That sounds enormous.”
“But the actual losses were much smaller than that figure suggests because much of the decline represented changes in market valuation rather than money that had literally disappeared.”
“Wall Street forgets its pain almost as quickly as it forgets its victories.”
“At the bottom, Amalgamated Copper had lost about $43 million in market value.”
“Union Pacific had lost $51 million.”
“Northern Pacific had lost $36 million.”
“Great Northern had lost $34 million.”
“New York Central had lost $25 million.”
“Pennsylvania had lost $28 million.”
“Southern Pacific had lost $21 million.”
“Standard Oil lost about $80 million in market value on the Curb.”
“American Tobacco lost about $32 million.”
“That was enough oil to cover a great deal of water, and enough tobacco to send up a great deal of smoke.”
“Then something interesting happened.”
“Cotton prices began rising.”
“Middling cotton reached 13½ cents a pound, the highest price in thirty-two years.”
“And there was no shortage of cotton.”
“There was no corner in the market.”
“We even entered the new crop year with a visible American supply of about 1.2 million bales and a total world supply of roughly 2.3 million bales.”
“The numbers may sound dry, but they tell an important story.”
“Cotton remains king in the South.”
“The South is no longer dependent on cotton alone, however.”
“It has developed manufacturing, mining, transportation, and other industries.”
“That diversification is a great advantage.”
“It means the South does not have all its eggs in one basket.”
“Wall Street’s ability to recover from such a crisis reflected the strength of the entire American economy.”
“Our people can move quickly from one extreme to another.”
“We are a large and progressive nation, and we have repeatedly shown an ability to recover from terrible disasters.”
“We saw it after the San Francisco earthquake and fire.”
“We saw it after the Civil War.”
“But what we need now is stability.”
“The recent recovery in stocks was partly the result of calmer thinking.”
“It was also helped by the Treasury Secretary’s plan to make weekly deposits into national banks in the major cities until the middle of October.”
“This eased fears about the money supply.”
“It helped ensure that money would remain available to businesses during the critical crop-moving season.”
“Early in September, New York City bonds worth $40 million attracted bids totaling five times the amount offered.”
“That was a powerful sign that confidence was returning.”
“There is, however, one serious problem.”
“Copper prices and copper stocks have fallen sharply.”
“Calumet and Hecla and Quincy have already reduced their dividends.”
“Other copper companies will probably do the same.”
“This is perhaps the weakest part of the current situation.”
“It suggests that demand for copper is falling and that copper mining will have to be reduced.”
“The Treasury’s plan is only a temporary solution.”
“The deeper problem lies in our outdated currency system.”
“We should abolish the independent Treasury and Sub-Treasury system and keep government funds in the national banks.”
“That would keep money in active circulation.”
“Congress should make this change.”
“Our current system has simply outgrown the needs of a modern commercial nation.”
“When conditions improved in America, confidence also returned in London and Berlin.”
“European investors had feared that the American crisis would spread across the Atlantic.”
“When they saw America regain its composure, their own fears began to fade.”
“Still, we should not assume that the danger has completely disappeared.”
“There are still weak businesses and financial pressures.”
“A sudden return of confidence could itself become dangerous if people forget the lessons of the crisis.”
“The government’s campaign against corruption will ultimately strengthen corporate America.”
“By forcing railroads and trusts to operate honestly, it will make their securities safer.”
“It will also make it harder for a few people to build enormous fortunes through dishonest practices.”
“Everyone involved in corporate management should obey federal law.”
“If a law is unfair or unnecessarily burdensome, Congress can change it.”
“The same principle applies to state railroad rates.”
“Until the Supreme Court rules on their legality, the companies should comply with them.”
“Once businesses begin cooperating with the law, the public anger against railroads and trusts will gradually disappear.”
“And President Roosevelt is unlikely to retreat from his policy of enforcing the law.”
“Secretary Taft has strongly supported that policy, and President Roosevelt has repeated it himself.”
“But again, I believe the punishment should fall primarily on the individual officers who break the law.”
“Imprisonment is a much better deterrent than simply fining the corporation.”
“If railroad and industrial leaders cooperate with the government and obey the Interstate Commerce Act and the Sherman Anti-Trust Act, they will actually strengthen their companies.”
“They will improve the value of their stocks.”
“They will improve their credit at home and abroad.”
“And they will create a stronger culture of responsibility among their employees.”
“During the crisis, Wall Street became so nervous that people began seeing danger everywhere.”
“When Attorney General Bonaparte joked that there was a whole flock of wealthy corporate leaders who could be brought down, Wall Street treated the remark as another threat.”
“The fight between Southern Railway and the Southern states caused another wave of anxiety.”
“When Alabama canceled the railway’s license, investors became frightened again.”
“When the railway later surrendered to the state in order to recover its license, the market saw another warning sign.”
“People feared that the anti-corporate movement would destroy American business.”
“But after every storm comes a calm.”
“The country as a whole remained strong.”
“We must remember that investors and some weaker businesses have suffered because of the government’s strict enforcement of the law.”
“Confidence was damaged.”
“Business expansion temporarily slowed.”
“But this painful experience may ultimately produce good results.”
“The East has exaggerated the danger more than the West and South.”
“The West and South remain highly prosperous.”
“The reason is simple.”
“The East has much more capital invested in stocks and bonds.”
“Therefore, it is naturally more sensitive to Wall Street.”
“The West and South are more closely tied to agriculture, manufacturing, natural resources, and local commerce.”
“They have less reason to panic when Wall Street falls.”
“The East is more likely to borrow trouble.”
“Especially when it cannot borrow money.”
“Businessmen and corporations became even more frightened when banks stopped accepting many securities as collateral.”
“Assets that had previously supported large loans suddenly became unacceptable.”
“Even companies with excellent collateral sometimes could not borrow the money they needed.”
“This created a serious squeeze.”
“Some businesses had to reduce operations.”
“A few failed.”
“This shows how closely finance and business are connected.”
“When stock and bond prices fall sharply, banks become suspicious of credit.”
“When banks restrict credit, businesses suffer.”
“When businesses suffer, they reduce spending and employment.”
“So the effects spread far beyond Wall Street.”
“Yet the reduction in business activity was not entirely harmful.”
“It acted like a safety valve.”
“It slowed excessive trading, excessive borrowing, excessive inventories, excessive capitalization, and excessive expansion.”
“It prevented some poorly financed businesses from moving even closer to collapse.”
“In that sense, the correction made the financial system healthier.”
“Banks should welcome the elimination of irresponsible borrowers.”
“Wall Street is the great financial clearinghouse of America.”
“It does not create economic value by itself.”
“It reflects the condition of securities, commodities, businesses, and investments throughout the country.”
“It is a kind of barometer.”
“So anyone who says a stock market panic only affects Wall Street speculators is badly mistaken.”
“What happens in New York spreads across the country and increasingly across the world.”
“New York is destined to become the financial center of the world.”
“But the recent crisis also proved something important.”
“Wall Street and the broader industrial economy are no longer completely tied together.”
“A severe panic in stocks can hurt the country without necessarily causing a simultaneous collapse in trade and production.”
“Some railroads and trusts probably felt that the government was treating them harshly.”
“But they had deliberately violated the law.”
“They had only themselves to blame.”
“Still, some railroads had legitimate complaints about state laws that might eventually be declared unconstitutional.”
“The real underlying problem was excessive borrowing.”
“Railroads and industrial corporations had issued enormous amounts of bonds, stocks, and short-term notes.”
“For years they seemed determined to kill the goose that laid the golden eggs.”
“They eventually exhausted their own borrowing power.”
“They also exhausted the ability of banks and investors to absorb more securities.”
“The flood of new securities had to stop.”
“It had overwhelmed the market, overloaded underwriting syndicates, reduced prices, and destroyed investor confidence.”
“The March collapse and the August collapse were really two outbreaks of the same disease.”
“The August episode was simply made worse by the enormous Standard Oil fine.”
“The underlying distrust had been developing for years.”
“It came from excessive securities issuance, excessive borrowing, and excessive demands on the money markets of both America and Europe.”
“In the end, some of the companies that had behaved recklessly were forced to pay the price.”
“Their own excesses had come back to haunt them.”
“The crisis forced them to become more conservative.”
“The new laws also stopped many of the worst corporate abuses.”
“But there is a danger in applying the brakes too suddenly.”
“Stopping wrongdoing is necessary.”
“But aggressively prosecuting every old offense at the worst possible moment can create more economic damage than it prevents.”
“The country’s interests must come before the punishment of old corporate mistakes.”
“Future violations, however, should be punished severely.”
“Corporate executives now understand the risks.”
“If imprisonment becomes the penalty for deliberate violations, few will be willing to take that chance again.”
“We must always be careful that the cure does not become worse than the disease.”
“Another problem was the attitude of some government prosecutors toward investors.”
“Some of their public statements seemed to suggest that only wealthy speculators cared about falling stock prices.”
“That is completely wrong.”
“The ownership records of major railroads and industrial companies show thousands of small shareholders.”
“Ordinary people own these stocks too.”
“When prices fall, small investors suffer just as wealthy investors do.”
“Even people who keep their money in savings banks can be affected.”
“Savings banks invest their depositors’ money in securities.”
“When those securities fall in value, the financial position of the savings banks weakens.”
“New York’s savings banks reported more than $1.39 billion in deposits in June 1907.”
“Yet the market value of their securities had fallen enough to reduce their surplus from about $108.7 million the previous year to $95.7 million.”
“That was a decline of almost $13 million.”
“So savings banks and Wall Street are more closely connected than many people realize.”
“The August crisis contained far too much hysteria.”
“The actual economic condition of the country was not nearly as dangerous as people imagined.”
“The real problems were the shortage of money and the loss of confidence in credit.”
“The best remedy is a moderate slowing of business activity.”
“That would naturally reduce pressure on the money market.”
“Banks should continue lending to sound businesses with proven earning power.”
“But they should be cautious about companies built on speculation and weak foundations.”
“There is an old biblical principle that applies here: those who already have strength and resources should receive support, while weak and failing ventures should not be endlessly sustained.”
“Public anger toward wealthy men is also important to understand.”
“People are not necessarily opposed to wealth itself.”
“They are angry when they believe great fortunes were built through corruption, railroad rebates, stock manipulation, insider deals, watered stock, and abuse of corporate power.”
“When wealthy men openly display fortunes that the public believes were obtained dishonestly, resentment grows.”
“The public begins to believe that the rich have become rich by taking from everyone else.”
“That is why the government’s campaign against corporate abuses gained popular support.”
“The real offenders were not corporations themselves but the officers who ran them.”
“Yet those officers had often escaped personal punishment.”
“That angered ordinary people.”
“From now on, individual wrongdoers should be prosecuted.”
“If convicted, rich and poor alike should go to prison.”
“Being a corporate executive does not give anyone the right to break the law.”
“Many men who would never commit a crime in their private lives somehow convinced themselves that corporate business was different.”
“That excuse is unacceptable.”
“They need to understand that corporate responsibility is still personal responsibility.”
“The public criticism of President Roosevelt, however, went far beyond reason.”
“If a company failed, people blamed Roosevelt.”
“If someone made a bad investment, they blamed Roosevelt.”
“If creditors demanded payment, Roosevelt was blamed.”
“If someone’s own business suffered, Roosevelt was blamed.”
“I would not be surprised if ladies who lost money playing bridge eventually blamed Roosevelt too.”
“Everyone seemed determined to make him responsible for every misfortune.”
“I even heard about a man on Long Island who made a living catching eels.”
“Recently, the eels stopped entering his traps.”
“So he began blaming Roosevelt for ruining his business.”
“That story is no more absurd than many of the other accusations made against the President.”
“People simply wanted someone to blame.”
“In times of fear and anger, the public always looks for a scapegoat.”
“Many wealthy people blamed Roosevelt because he had ordered the government to prosecute corporations that had violated the law.”
“They forgot why he had done it.”
“He wanted to stop illegal practices that had made enormous fortunes for a small group of favored men.”
“He wanted to prevent powerful companies from crushing competitors and exploiting the public.”
“In that sense, he was acting as the people’s champion.”
“In every major case that was actually tried on its merits, the government secured convictions.”
“Railroads such as New York Central and industrial companies such as the Sugar Trust were fined for rebating and accepting rebates.”
“But again, the punishment fell on the corporations instead of the individuals who had committed the violations.”
“That meant innocent shareholders suffered while the actual wrongdoers remained free.”
“The public was right to object.”
“I believe the roots of our present financial troubles can be traced back much further.”
“We should go as far back as the collapse of Baring Brothers in London in 1890.”
“That failure shocked confidence throughout the world.”
“It reduced credit and banking facilities internationally.”
“Baring Brothers had enjoyed a reputation second only to the Bank of England.”
“When such a famous institution collapsed, an enormous amount of financial credit disappeared with it.”
“The Boer War then placed further pressure on Britain.”
“Britain spent enormous sums on the war and lost large numbers of workers who were needed at home.”
“To finance the conflict, Britain issued large quantities of government bonds.”
“There were more bonds than investors could easily absorb.”
“Prices fell.”
“Years later, British Consols were still under pressure.”
“The Russo-Japanese War created another burden.”
“Russia and Japan both borrowed enormous amounts of money.”
“Their bonds continued to weigh on European markets.”
“France was especially exposed because French investors held huge quantities of Russian securities.”
“That left France with less ability to invest elsewhere or provide assistance during a crisis.”
“Then came the San Francisco earthquake and fire.”
“The disaster caused enormous losses.”
“It also hit Wall Street hard because many speculators were heavily invested in stocks at the time.”
“American, British, and German insurance companies suffered enormous losses as well.”
“These events created a chain reaction.”
“Their effects accumulated over time.”
“Even after the immediate disasters had passed, their financial consequences remained.”
“Fortunately, the national and state banks were generally in strong condition.”
“Conservative banking practices protected depositors and shareholders.”
“Most banks avoided becoming deeply involved in the stock market collapse.”
“That left them in a position to help the economy recover.”
“Banks themselves, however, suffered from falling securities prices.”
“Savings banks were particularly exposed.”
“If the value of their investments did not recover, they might eventually have to reduce dividends.”
“That would teach ordinary depositors an important lesson.”
“Even a savings bank account is not completely isolated from Wall Street.”
“Fortunately, America has a major advantage.”
“It is enormous.”
“Its different regions have different climates, industries, resources, and economic strengths.”
“That diversity means one region can remain strong even when another is struggling.”
“The South, West, and Northwest therefore viewed the Wall Street crisis with relative calm.”
“Bank clearings remained strong.”
“Trade remained active.”
“Agriculture and industry continued growing.”
“The country’s productive capacity was largely untouched.”
“Yet only a month earlier, many people had been convinced that America was heading toward disaster.”
“The crop outlook was also encouraging.”
“Wheat production might decline somewhat, but existing supplies would make up much of the difference.”
“Corn and other grains were expected to exceed domestic demand.”
“The cotton crop also promised to be close to the previous year’s level.”
“Yet cotton prices were much higher.”
“American exports were enormous.”
“Cotton exports alone were worth more than $500 million.”
“Manufactured exports reached roughly $750 million.”
“Coal, iron, copper, gold, silver, and other minerals were also expected to produce more in 1907 than in 1906.”
“Industrial income was not collapsing.”
“Given these facts, there was little reason for the extreme pessimism that had gripped Wall Street.”
“The railroads would continue to have plenty of freight.”
“In fact, enforcing the law could eventually increase their profits.”
“Ending rebates would create a fairer and more stable business environment.”
“Some state and federal laws may indeed be too severe.”
“When a law is unreasonable, Congress should amend it.”
“If it is unconstitutional, the courts should overturn it.”
“Corporations deserve fair treatment just as individuals do.”
“That is what a real square deal means.”
“The Southern and Western railroads are already overwhelmed with traffic.”
“Many have nearly twice as much traffic as their existing lines can comfortably handle.”
“They have spent huge sums on locomotives, rolling stock, branch lines, double tracks, and terminals.”
“Yet they still cannot handle all the business coming their way.”
“As population grows, transportation demand will increase further.”
“So the long-term outlook for railroad shareholders remains strong.”
“President Roosevelt deserves credit for exposing and attacking the rebate system and other abuses.”
“Railroad and industrial leaders would serve both themselves and the country by cooperating with his administration.”
“They should obey the law from this point forward.”
“And I believe the government can reasonably show some mercy regarding old violations.”
“The Southern railroads have already shown that they are willing to compromise.”
“They agreed to accept state railroad rates in North Carolina, Alabama, and Virginia while waiting for the Supreme Court to rule on whether those rates were constitutional.”
“That was a wise decision.”
“The government has already accomplished much of what it set out to accomplish.”
“It has exposed abuses.”
“It has punished major offenders.”
“It has made corporate leaders understand that the old practices cannot continue.”
“Therefore, the government can afford to stop aggressively pursuing old offenses while remaining extremely strict about future violations.”
“Once punished, offenders rarely have much affection for the law.”
“As the old English saying goes, no criminal watches the gallows being prepared with love for the law.”
“There is another subject I must mention.”
“Socialism.”
“Recent socialist congresses in Britain and Germany showed how strongly some people wanted to limit individual achievement and redistribute wealth.”
“I believe such ideas threaten the incentive that drives progress.”
“Britain and Germany were already struggling with financial difficulties, and socialist agitation added to the uncertainty.”
“Berlin in particular had become a center of political and financial unrest.”
“Germany had expanded its industrial economy too rapidly.”
“Large amounts of capital were locked into factories and industrial projects.”
“Banks had also lent heavily against industrial securities that investors were no longer willing to buy.”
“That reduced the supply of available money and intensified the financial strain.”
“Germany also had an unusual monetary practice.”
“The government paid salaries largely in cash rather than by bank check.”
“That removed huge amounts of money from circulation.”
“It was another source of financial pressure.”
“France faced a different problem.”
“The Bank of France had been accumulating and protecting its gold reserves.”
“London and Berlin wanted French gold, but France resisted.”
“The country was protecting itself against possible financial trouble caused by its enormous holdings of Russian securities.”
“France had become the financial guardian of Europe.”
“Another factor has often been overlooked.”
“Gold was flowing into Egypt, India, and China.”
“India had begun demanding more gold as silver lost value.”
“China was also quietly accumulating gold, partly with the long-term goal of moving toward a gold-based monetary system.”
“Egypt was another major buyer.”
“Egypt earned large sums from cotton exports and often stored the gold privately instead of putting it into banks.”
“That meant the gold effectively disappeared from international circulation.”
“So when people ask, ‘Where is all the new gold going?’ there is part of the answer.”
“I believe future international conflict is more likely to arise around the Pacific than the Mediterranean.”
“Europe’s great powers will increasingly compete for commercial influence in Asia.”
“China, Japan, and India together represent an enormous share of the world’s population.”
“If the United States wants to avoid being dragged into a future conflict, it should reconsider its control of the Philippines.”
“The Philippines could become a source of international tension between America, Japan, and the European powers.”
“England, because of its relationship with Japan, might be in a better position to manage those islands.”
“I believe the United States should consider exchanging them for territory closer to our own interests.”
“We are not naturally a colonial power.”
“We already possess enormous territory within our own borders.”
“Europe, with its limited territory, has different needs.”
“Japan’s opening to the world has already changed the balance of power in Asia.”
“Japan became a major power.”
“It defeated China.”
“China was then forced into greater contact with the outside world.”
“China has hundreds of millions of people.”
“Japan and China will naturally seek to protect their political and commercial interests.”
“India also has hundreds of millions of people and will eventually seek greater freedom from British rule.”
“If these great Asian populations become well organized and well equipped, Europe may eventually have to unite to protect its interests.”
“But now let me return to America.”
“The rise of the South is one of the most encouraging developments in the country.”
“The South has enormous natural resources.”
“With population growth, better education, more workers, and greater industrial development, it may eventually become the richest region in America.”
“Southern bankers have a tremendous opportunity.”
“You can help farmers and manufacturers grow while also building your own banking businesses.”
“When cotton prices are high, both farmers and bankers benefit.”
“Their interests are connected.”
“The South is becoming wealthier in a healthy way.”
“I am especially encouraged that this wealth is not being concentrated in only a few hands.”
“Cities, towns, villages, factories, and farms are all participating.”
“The prosperity is spreading.”
“The soil of the South seems to reward almost every effort.”
“Last year, the South produced about $2 billion worth of crops and raw materials.”
“Its manufacturing output reached roughly $2.5 billion.”
“That was five times what the region produced in manufacturing in 1880.”
“That is the kind of expansion we want.”
“Property values in the South have also risen dramatically.”
“The increase during 1905 and 1906 alone was more than twice the increase recorded during the entire decade from 1890 to 1900.”
“This is remarkable growth.”
“And it is not artificial growth.”
“It is based on real agriculture, manufacturing, mining, transportation, and trade.”
“The South now has about $250 million invested in cotton mills.”
“That is more than the total capital invested in cotton mills throughout the entire United States in 1880.”
“The South is also producing millions of tons of pig iron.”
“Its coal production is enormous.”
“Its ports are handling hundreds of millions of dollars in exports.”
“The region has every reason to be proud.”
“With this rapid development comes an enormous demand for transportation.”
“Southern railroads will need double tracks.”
“Thousands of miles of new railways may have to be built.”
“The South should therefore continue attracting capital and new workers.”
“That is the great task before Southern bankers.”
“And now I come to Kentucky.”
“Good old Kentucky—the home of Daniel Boone and a state with a proud history.”
“We Northerners know Kentucky for many things.”
“We know it for its beautiful women.”
“We know it for its handsome men.”
“We know it for its magnificent race horses.”
“And, of course, we know it for Kentucky bourbon.”
“But the women come first.”
“They are famous not only for their beauty but also for their charm, intelligence, and refinement.”
“I know something about this personally.”
“I once believed I could never be conquered by even the most beautiful woman.”
“Then I met one of Kentucky’s finest daughters.”
“I did not exactly win her.”
“I surrendered.”
“So I am delighted to be here today among the bankers of Kentucky.”
“I almost feel that I have finally come home to my old Kentucky home.”
“As a border state, Kentucky belongs in the hearts of both North and South.”
“Your hospitality makes visitors from every region feel welcome.”
“Kentucky seems to recognize no North, no South, no East, and no West when it welcomes friends.”
“After visiting Kentucky, people may sing that there is no place like home.”
“Except Kentucky.”
“I thank God that today we know the United States as one united nation.”
“Our country has become more united, more tolerant, and more generous.”
“Each region is increasingly willing to recognize the equal rights of rich and poor.”
“And that is the spirit we must preserve.”
“Finally, I want to thank you for your kindness and for giving me the opportunity to speak to you today.”
“Your hospitality has been a great honor.”
After the Speech
“Mr. Clews has delivered a very able, interesting, and instructive address.”
“I move that the members of the Convention give Mr. Clews a vote of thanks.”
“Those in favor of the motion, please rise.”
“The vote is unanimous.”
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!