← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 86 · The Financial Outlook and the Road to Recovery

The Financial Outlook and the Road to Recovery

Chapter 86 of 90 · 4,105 words · Free

“Gentlemen, I am deeply impressed by the size and importance of the interests represented by this association.”

“The National Association of Cotton Manufacturers represents far more than New England. Its influence extends throughout the American manufacturing industry and even into foreign markets.”

“Just consider the figures. The textile mills, print works, and bleacheries represented by your members alone have more than $334 million in capital.”

“Your mills contain more than seventeen million spindles, nearly fifteen hundred sets of woolen and worsted cards, thousands of knitting machines, and numerous printing machines.”

“These numbers show what American industry and mechanical skill have accomplished.”

“And your associate members represent another $400 million in capital invested in cotton cloth, textile machinery, mill supplies, and related businesses.”

“That means this association represents more than $734 million of American wealth.”

“And that amount will continue to grow as the country grows.”

“Better machinery, better manufacturing methods, and larger foreign markets—especially in Asia and South America—will create enormous opportunities for American manufacturers.”

“Your association therefore serves not only the cotton industry but the entire national economy.”

“Now let me turn to the main subject: the financial and trade situation and what we can expect in the future.”

“The outlook is much more encouraging than it was during the panic.”

“Business sentiment in both Wall Street and the rest of the country has become increasingly optimistic.”

“That optimism explains much of the recovery in the stock market since the crisis began in October.”

“Most of the buying has still been done by professionals rather than by the general public.”

“But confidence among wealthy investors has returned, and confidence spreads just as quickly as fear.”

“The absence of forced selling has also helped.”

“With few people under pressure to sell their stocks, powerful investors have been able to push prices higher, especially because there was a very large short interest.”

“Many bears were forced to buy back their contracts at heavy losses.”

“But the bears have not disappeared.”

“They still believe business conditions are poor, and they continue to predict trouble.”

“Wall Street, however, usually looks ahead.”

“That is why I regard it as the financial barometer of the United States.”

“Still, we should not pretend that everything is improving everywhere.”

“Reports from different parts of the country are conflicting.”

“One city may report clear improvement while another reports almost none.”

“Even businessmen in the same city sometimes disagree about whether conditions are getting better or worse.”

“This is exactly what we should expect after a financial panic.”

“We are in a period of transition.”

“The great question is how long this uncertain period will last.”

“The rise in stock prices has been encouraged by the banking community partly because higher prices help restore public confidence.”

“That recovery in confidence may well be the first sign of a genuine improvement in business.”

“But optimism must never become self-deception.”

“We must look honestly at the bad news as well as the good.”

“In New England, cotton-mill workers have already suffered a ten percent wage reduction.”

“Many cotton and woolen mills are operating only part time, while others have shut down completely.”

“That tells us how seriously the crisis has affected manufacturing.”

“Fortunately, Boston’s banks suffered less during the panic than those of almost any other major city.”

“That is strong evidence of their soundness and conservative management.”

“Boston had an advantage that New York did not.”

“It did not have speculative financiers controlling chains of important banks.”

“The panic did, however, accomplish one important thing.”

“It swept away a dangerous form of unsound banking that had become a threat to New York and to the entire country.”

“Many of the strongest banking authorities believe that genuine business improvement has already begun.”

“But the recovery is uneven.”

“Some regions and industries are improving rapidly, while others are barely moving.”

“The Southwest, particularly St. Louis, appears to be recovering more strongly than any other region.”

“Chicago, along with much of the East and Middle States, is recovering more slowly.”

“The wage question is now becoming one of the most difficult problems.”

“Railroads are under enormous pressure to reduce wages because their earnings have fallen.”

“But their employees do not want their wages cut.”

“President Roosevelt’s actions have encouraged the workers to resist reductions, and labor leaders are now asking Congress to support them.”

“But we should remember something important.”

“Capital has rights too.”

“The railroads have suggested raising freight rates instead of cutting wages.”

“Manufacturers and other shippers strongly oppose that idea.”

“State authorities and the Interstate Commerce Commission have also expressed opposition.”

“So the railroads have taken another approach.”

“They have dismissed large numbers of workers in order to reduce expenses.”

“The workers who remain are becoming more efficient because everyone wants to keep his job.”

“When jobs are scarce, a man becomes very careful not to be laid off.”

“That is one of the few healthy effects of hard times.”

“The labor problem will not disappear quickly.”

“We cannot expect lasting improvement in business or the securities markets until prices, wages, and production have been adjusted to the new conditions.”

“Would it not be wiser for labor leaders to agree to a temporary arrangement?”

“For example, they might accept a twenty percent wage reduction for four months in exchange for continued employment.”

“Readjustment is really a process of restoring balance.”

“When employers and workers find a workable balance, recovery becomes much easier.”

“That is what the country needs now.”

“Everyone involved in business should cooperate.”

“There is strength in unity.”

“The cotton industry in New England has suffered much more severely than many people expected.”

“Fortunately, the large profits earned in previous years give the mills some ability to absorb these losses.”

“Even after prices were reduced, however, demand for ordinary cotton goods remained extremely weak.”

“As production fell, unsold inventories continued to accumulate.”

“Businessmen naturally wonder how long this depression will last.”

“Some grades of cotton goods that sold for 8⅜ cents a yard before the panic are now being offered at only 5½ cents.”

“That is enough to discourage even an optimist.”

“But this is precisely the moment when courage and confidence are most necessary.”

“You have my respect for facing the situation as firmly as you have.”

“America has eighty-five million people who need clothing.”

“And that does not include the rest of the world.”

“Sooner or later, demand for cotton goods must return.”

“People need clothes in summer just as they do in winter.”

“For now, we must endure.”

“Recovery will come gradually.”

“That is actually better than a sudden rebound because gradual recovery is more likely to last.”

“The dry-goods trade will also benefit once sellers stop cutting prices below reasonable levels simply to make a sale.”

“The American Federation of Labor has taken an increasingly aggressive position.”

“Its leaders have gone to Washington to demand legislation and have even attacked decisions of the Supreme Court.”

“This gives the old struggle between labor and capital a much more serious character.”

“It raises an important question: how far will organized labor go?”

“And how much political influence can it use to achieve its demands?”

“Politicians are often eager to please labor organizations because they want their votes.”

“Everyone wants justice for workers.”

“But we must also prevent injustice against employers and investors.”

“When workers refuse every wage adjustment even though the earnings and profits of their employers have fallen sharply, the result can become unfair to everyone outside organized labor.”

“Wages therefore need to be adjusted to economic reality.”

“That should be one of the first priorities.”

“Both sides must find a reasonable settlement.”

“Half a loaf is better than no bread.”

“Neither labor nor capital benefits by destroying the business that provides their livelihood.”

“Their interests are actually connected.”

“Yet labor sometimes behaves as if the two sides were natural enemies.”

“That attitude is dangerous.”

“The foreign market offers another enormous opportunity for American cotton manufacturers.”

“But our high labor costs make it difficult to compete with England, Germany, and other countries where labor is cheaper.”

“Our answer must be greater efficiency.”

“We must stay ahead through labor-saving machinery, better manufacturing methods, and constant innovation.”

“We should aim to surpass Europe not only in the quality of our goods but also in their cost.”

“Americans are exceptionally inventive and quick to adapt.”

“I believe we can overcome this disadvantage.”

“England, our greatest manufacturing competitor, has traditionally been slower to replace old machinery.”

“I once asked Andrew Carnegie what had made him so successful in the iron and steel business.”

“He told me that he always tried to stay ahead by improving his machinery and manufacturing methods.”

“He said, ‘Whenever a new invention appeared that I could use, I bought it, no matter what it cost.’”

“He once had two million dollars’ worth of new machinery ready to install.”

“Then someone showed him an improvement and offered him the patent.”

“Carnegie bought it.”

“He abandoned the two million dollars’ worth of machinery he had just purchased and adopted the new design.”

“The improvement eventually paid for the sacrifice many times over.”

“That is the kind of thinking American manufacturers need.”

“Constant improvement is essential.”

“And this association can play an important role by encouraging scientific research and better manufacturing processes.”

“Adaptability matters in cotton manufacturing just as much as it does in every other business.”

“I remember a conversation with Admiral Sir Charles Beresford when he visited New York.”

“He told me an interesting story about China.”

“The Chinese had complained for years that certain British cotton fabrics were not wide enough.”

“They repeatedly asked British agents to make wider cloth.”

“The agents sent the requests back to Manchester.”

“The manufacturers replied that changing the width would require alterations to their machinery.”

“They refused to make the change.”

“Then an American dry-goods representative arrived in Shanghai.”

“He heard the Chinese complaint and simply said, ‘Give me your order, and I will give you whatever width you want.’”

“He got the order.”

“Admiral Beresford told me, ‘That is the difference. You Americans are willing to give customers what they want.’”

“He also said the Chinese preferred American cloth because it was heavier and lasted longer.”

“That was a perfect example of American adaptability.”

“Scientific research offers another great opportunity.”

“Consider silkine, a material that looks remarkably like silk.”

“Scientists discovered that certain trees used by silkworms contained substances that could be extracted and used to create a silky fiber.”

“When combined with fine Egyptian cotton, the result was a fabric so similar to silk that only an expert could easily tell the difference.”

“That was a successful combination of science, experimentation, and manufacturing skill.”

“There are undoubtedly many other discoveries waiting to be made.”

“This association can help bring them into commercial use.”

“The world's markets offer an extraordinary opportunity to American cotton manufacturers.”

“We grow about four-sixths of the world's cotton, yet we manufacture only about one-sixth of it.”

“In other words, we export most of our raw cotton and allow England and Germany to turn it into finished products.”

“That makes little economic sense.”

“We should capture a much larger share of the foreign market ourselves.”

“Last year Britain exported about $500 million worth of cotton goods.”

“Our exports were only about $26 million.”

“Britain exported more than six billion yards of cotton piece goods.”

“We exported only about 216 million yards.”

“This is an enormous opportunity.”

“We should not continue sending our raw cotton overseas only to buy it back in finished form at a large profit for foreign manufacturers.”

“I am also impressed by another feature of the New England cotton industry.”

“You have largely avoided the speculative promotion and excessive consolidation that have damaged other industries.”

“You have also resisted the fever for trusts and giant combinations.”

“I hope you continue to do so.”

“Your strong tradition of individual enterprise is one of New England’s greatest strengths.”

“It provides a healthy restraint against excessive government control and over-centralization.”

“You have also responded intelligently to the crisis.”

“You have lowered prices, reduced production, and cut costs.”

“You have accepted the new economic conditions instead of fighting them.”

“That should allow the cotton industry to recover earlier than many other industries.”

“When recovery comes, I expect the cotton trade to be among the first to benefit.”

“Other industries have sometimes used their newly acquired power of combination to resist economic forces or maintain dividends on inflated capital.”

“You have taken the opposite approach.”

“You have adjusted yourselves to reality.”

“With honest capitalization, your mills should soon be sailing in calmer waters.”

“The trusts may still be struggling because they resisted economic realities for too long.”

“Perhaps the most encouraging development in the national economy is the agricultural outlook.”

“The wheat crop promises to be unusually large.”

“Winter wheat is in excellent condition.”

“Spring wheat was planted under unusually favorable conditions because farm work began about three weeks earlier than last year.”

“Other crops have also benefited from the favorable weather.”

“Rarely has the agricultural outlook been so promising.”

“That is a great national blessing.”

“America’s crops are the foundation of its wealth.”

“Agriculture is one of the main sources of both our domestic strength and our international power.”

“During the first eight months of this fiscal year, we built a foreign trade surplus of about $521 million.”

“Our exports continue to exceed our imports by a wide margin.”

“By the end of the year, our trade surplus should reach an extraordinary level.”

“Our reduced imports, especially of luxury goods, have also hurt European economies.”

“Europe had become accustomed to Americans being some of its best customers.”

“But Americans can economize just as effectively as they can spend.”

“When circumstances require it, we can reduce our spending quickly and decisively.”

“That is exactly what we are doing now.”

“Still, we should remember how enormous our national resources are.”

“There is every reason to believe that prosperity will gradually return.”

“Last year, according to the Department of Agriculture, our farm products were worth about $7.4 billion.”

“Mining and manufacturing were the next great sources of national wealth.”

“Mining produced about $3 billion worth of metals.”

“Manufacturing then transformed those materials into products worth about $15 billion.”

“Together, agriculture, mining, and metal manufacturing represented roughly $25.4 billion of production.”

“That is why I say this is a great country.”

“As an enthusiastic Irishman once put it, ‘Long life to it! By jabers, it can’t be beat!’”

“The cotton market has naturally suffered from the depression in the textile industry.”

“Southern planters tried to raise prices by holding their cotton off the market.”

“That strategy failed.”

“Cotton is now cheaper than it was during the crisis and is near the lowest level of the current crop year.”

“It has fallen about three cents a pound from the season’s high.”

“That decline equals about $15 per bale.”

“On a twelve-million-bale crop, that represents about $180 million.”

“For spinners and buyers, this has created an unusually favorable opportunity to purchase cotton for summer and autumn delivery.”

“Yet spinners have bought more than a million fewer bales from this year's crop than during the same period last year.”

“According to the Census Bureau, more than eleven million bales had been ginned by March 1.”

“Taking into account the usual underreporting, the total usable crop should be around eleven and a half million bales.”

“From a statistical point of view, that is actually a favorable sign for cotton prices.”

“Consumption has fallen sharply, but there probably will not be an enormous surplus left over when the new crop year begins.”

“Another encouraging development has come from the Supreme Court.”

“The Court has challenged radical state laws regulating railroad rates.”

“It ruled that certain provisions of the Minnesota and North Carolina laws were unconstitutional.”

“The decision significantly limits a state's ability to impose rate regulations on interstate railroads.”

“That is a setback for political agitators who have been demanding aggressive state control.”

“It also clarifies the relationship between state and federal courts.”

“The Supreme Court's ruling was based largely on the unreasonable penalties contained in those state laws.”

“But it also strengthened the railroads' position.”

“A railroad can now challenge a state rate law if it can demonstrate that the law would reduce its earnings to an unreasonable level.”

“A federal judge can suspend the law until its reasonableness is determined in court.”

“This provides an important protection against confiscatory state legislation.”

“Protecting the railroads also protects investors.”

“And protecting investors strengthens confidence.”

“Confidence is exactly what the country needs during a recovery.”

“That is why we should do everything possible to strengthen it.”

“President Roosevelt has also recently spoken in ways intended to restore confidence and clarify the business situation.”

“That is a constructive development.”

“The most dramatic event of the panic was the collapse of the Knickerbocker Trust Company.”

“On October 22, 1907, depositors rushed to withdraw their money.”

“Soon afterward, its president, Charles T. Barney, took his own life.”

“The most encouraging later development was the bank's reopening on March 26, 1908.”

“On the very day it reopened, deposits exceeded withdrawals by $1.5 million.”

“That was a remarkable reversal.”

“The Oriental Bank also paid its depositors in full at almost the same time.”

“These events helped restore confidence and contributed to the recovery in the stock market.”

“The rise in stock prices had an important psychological effect, even beyond its direct financial impact.”

“Four days after the Knickerbocker failure, the New York Clearing House decided to issue Clearing House certificates to banks that needed them to settle their balances.”

“Other clearing houses across the country quickly followed.”

“At the same time, detailed weekly bank statements were temporarily suspended.”

“By the time the system was restored in February 1908, about $101 million in Clearing House certificates had been issued.”

“Almost all of them had been redeemed by the end of March.”

“The maximum amount outstanding was reached in November.”

“Yet the banks had suffered their greatest reserve deficit earlier that month.”

“It reached $54.1 million.”

“Most of the public had no idea how serious the situation really was.”

“Boston's banks had issued about $12 million of their own Clearing House certificates.”

“But they never needed to increase that amount.”

“After that, the banking situation gradually improved across the country.”

“Because banks had partially suspended ordinary cash payments, however, currency and gold traded at premiums of between one and five percent in New York.”

“That lasted from the beginning of the certificate system until the end of December 1907.”

“People were hoarding cash on an enormous scale.”

“Then, almost suddenly, the premium disappeared.”

“People began bringing their hoarded money back to the banks.”

“The scale of this crisis can be understood by comparing it with earlier panics.”

“In 1873, New York banks issued only about $26.6 million in Clearing House certificates.”

“In 1893, they issued about $41.7 million.”

“The much larger amount in 1907 reflected how enormously the country's banking system had grown.”

“The panic also caused another dramatic development.”

“Large numbers of workers lost their jobs.”

“Many were immigrants.”

“As a result, more than 114,000 steerage passengers left the United States for Europe during the first two months of 1908.”

“Only about 50,600 immigrants arrived during the same period.”

“This outward movement began in November and continued for some time.”

“For the moment, it actually served as a kind of safety valve.”

“It reduced the number of unemployed workers.”

“When American employers need their labor again, many of these workers will return.”

“They know where they can earn their living.”

“Immigration, however, is no longer as essential to America as it was during the pioneer era.”

“We should be selective about whom we allow to enter the country.”

“People who come here to promote violence or destroy American institutions should not be welcomed.”

“Now let me turn to the stock, bond, and commodity markets.”

“Recently, Mr. Bryan and others have attacked these markets as gambling centers.”

“As one of the oldest members of the New York Stock Exchange, I can speak from long experience.”

“The Exchange is composed of men whose professional standards are high.”

“It also maintains strict discipline.”

“When a member violates its rules or engages in dishonest conduct, the governing committee investigates the matter.”

“If the charges are proved, the offender can be fined, suspended, or expelled.”

“Serious misconduct is actually quite rare.”

“It is therefore unfair to call the New York Stock Exchange a gambling arena and its members gamblers.”

“They are brokers operating in a free market.”

“They accept orders from people throughout the world.”

“Those orders may be for investment or speculation.”

“The broker's job is to execute the order, not to decide whether the customer should be investing or speculating.”

“Speculation is an essential part of every functioning stock exchange.”

“A stock exchange cannot serve its purpose unless it remains a free market.”

“Speculating in stocks is no more inherently gambling than speculating in real estate or merchandise.”

“Of course, speculation can be carried to excess.”

“But the Exchange itself should not be blamed for the irresponsible actions of individual people.”

“You would not blame gas for a person's death if that person deliberately locked himself in a room and turned on the gas.”

“The same principle applies here.”

“Those who know Wall Street understand how badly some of its critics have misrepresented it.”

“If they truly understood the financial markets, they would not make such reckless accusations.”

“Some critics have even demanded the complete abolition of the Stock Exchange.”

“That would create financial chaos.”

“Investors, banks, insurance companies, and corporations would lose the ability to buy and sell securities efficiently.”

“It would be a gigantic step backward.”

“We might as well return to the days of the canal boat and the frontier settlement.”

“That will never happen.”

“Political attacks on Wall Street are nevertheless harmful.”

“Both major political parties have used such attacks for political advantage.”

“We may hear even more of them before the November election.”

“But it is time for this kind of abuse to stop.”

“The public deserves facts, not political mudslinging.”

“Some critics also want to abolish the Chicago Board of Trade and the various grain, cotton, and commodity exchanges.”

“They apparently fail to understand how useful these markets are to farmers.”

“A farmer can sell a future crop before it is harvested if the price is attractive.”

“That allows him to protect himself against future price declines.”

“The same principle applies to coffee and other commodities.”

“If we eliminate futures trading here, those transactions will simply move to Canada, Liverpool, or London.”

“Foreign markets would then set prices for American products.”

“That would be absurd.”

“Speculation is therefore not simply gambling.”

“Every ordinary business transaction involves risk.”

“The difference is that organized exchanges make those risks easier to price, transfer, and manage.”

“Now that the panic has passed, another positive development has become clear.”

“The investigations and prosecutions that followed the crisis exposed many corporate abuses.”

“We discovered railway rate rebates, corruption, financial manipulation, and other forms of dishonest business conduct.”

“Many corrupt executives of banks, railroads, insurance companies, and other corporations were exposed.”

“The country has therefore emerged from the crisis with higher standards of business morality.”

“In a sense, we have gone through a massive house cleaning.”

“That cleaning has been painful, but it was necessary.”

“Banks, trust companies, railroads, insurance companies, and other corporations are now operating under stricter laws and closer examination.”

“Greater disclosure of accounts has also made dishonest practices more difficult.”

“When opportunities for wrongdoing are reduced, temptation becomes less dangerous.”

“As the old proverb says, opportunity makes the thief.”

“So there are many reasons to remain optimistic.”

“America possesses enormous natural resources.”

“Our people are energetic and inventive.”

“Our political institutions provide enormous freedom for individual enterprise.”

“These are national advantages that cannot easily be measured.”

“Our past growth has been remarkable.”

“But I believe our future growth will be even more remarkable.”

“The United States has every opportunity to become the leading nation in the world.”

“The cotton industry of New England and the manufacturing industries throughout the country will share in that expansion.”

“You and your successors therefore have an extraordinary opportunity ahead of you.”

“If you combine enterprise, adaptability, scientific progress, and sound business practices, there is no limit to what you may accomplish.”

“Andrew Carnegie demonstrated what American industry can achieve.”

“You should take courage from his example.”

“Hope is one of the strongest forces in the human heart.”

“And after the crisis we have just endured, I believe there is good reason to hope for a stronger and more prosperous America.”

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!