The Letter Was Meant for Someone Else
Dr. Trent stared at her blankly, searching his memory.
“Er—Miss—Miss—”
“Mrs. Snaith,” Valancy said quietly. “I was Miss Valancy Stirling when I came to see you last May. A little over a year ago. I came because I was worried about my heart.”
Dr. Trent’s face suddenly brightened with recognition.
“Oh, of course! Now I remember. And really, you can’t blame me for not recognizing you at first. You’ve changed—wonderfully. And you’re married! Well, well. Marriage certainly agrees with you. You hardly look like an invalid anymore.”
He smiled.
“I remember that day very well. I was terribly upset. Hearing about poor Ned nearly knocked me flat. But Ned recovered, and apparently so did you. I told you there was nothing to worry about, didn’t I?”
Valancy stared at him.
“In your letter,” she said slowly, almost as if someone else were speaking through her, “you told me I had angina pectoris in its final stages, complicated by an aneurysm. You said I could die at any moment and that I probably had less than a year to live.”
Dr. Trent stared back at her in disbelief.
“Impossible! I could never have told you that!”
Valancy took the letter from her handbag and held it out to him.
“Miss Valancy Stirling,” he read.
“Yes,” he murmured. “Yes, of course. I wrote to you on the train that night. But I told you there was nothing seriously wrong—”
“Please read the letter.”
Dr. Trent took it from her.
He unfolded it and read.
His face slowly changed.
Then he sprang to his feet.
“Good heavens!”
He began pacing around the room.
“This is the letter I meant for old Miss Jane Sterling in Port Lawrence! She was here that same day. I sent you the wrong letter.”
He stopped and stared at Valancy in horror.
“What an unforgivable mistake! I was beside myself that night. My God—you believed it! You actually believed you were dying!”
Valancy rose to her feet.
She turned around once, looked helplessly around the room, and then sat down again.
“I believed it,” she whispered. “I didn’t see another doctor. I—I couldn’t explain it all to you. But I truly believed I was going to die.”
Dr. Trent stood before her, stricken.
“I’ll never forgive myself. What a year you must have suffered!”
He looked at her carefully.
“But you don’t look sick. I simply can’t understand.”
“Never mind,” Valancy said dully. “So there’s really nothing wrong with my heart?”
“Well, nothing serious. You had what we call pseudo-angina. It isn’t fatal. With proper treatment, it usually disappears completely.”
He paused.
“Sometimes even a great shock of happiness can cure it. Have you had any trouble with it lately?”
“Not since March.”
Valancy remembered that extraordinary feeling she had experienced when she saw Barney returning safely after the storm.
Could that have been the shock of happiness Dr. Trent was talking about?
“Then you’re probably perfectly healthy now,” Dr. Trent said. “I told you what to do in the letter you should have received. And naturally, I assumed you would consult another doctor.”
He frowned at her.
“Why didn’t you?”
“I didn’t want anyone to know.”
“You foolish girl,” he said bluntly. “I simply cannot understand such stupidity.”
He sighed.
“And poor old Miss Sterling must have received your letter saying there was nothing seriously wrong with you. Well, it wouldn’t have mattered to her. Her condition was hopeless. Nothing she could have done would have changed the outcome.”
He shook his head.
“I was actually surprised she lived another two months. She was here that day too, shortly before you.”
Dr. Trent looked embarrassed.
“I hated having to tell her the truth. You probably think I’m a hard old man. My letters certainly are blunt enough. I simply don’t know how to soften bad news.”
He gave a miserable little laugh.
“But when it comes to looking a woman in the eyes and telling her she’s going to die soon, I’m a coward. I told her there were still some details of her case I wanted to check and that I’d write to her the next day.”
He held up the letter.
“But look here. It says, ‘Dear Miss S-t-e-r-l-i-n-g.’”
“Yes,” Valancy said. “I noticed that. But I thought it was just a mistake. I didn’t know there were any other Stirlings in Port Lawrence.”
“She was the only one. A lonely old woman. She lived alone with a little girl who helped around the house.”
Dr. Trent sighed.
“She died two months after coming here. Peacefully, in her sleep. So my mistake made no difference to her.”
He looked at Valancy with deep regret.
“But you—good heavens. I gave you a whole year of misery for absolutely nothing.”
He shook his head.
“It really is time for me to retire. Especially when I can make a mistake like this. Even if my son was believed to be fatally injured that night, that’s no excuse.”
He looked at her helplessly.
“Can you ever forgive me?”
A whole year of misery.
Valancy gave him a small, tortured smile.
She thought of everything that mistake had brought her.
It had given her a year of happiness.
And now she was paying for it.
Oh, how she was paying.
If feeling so deeply was what it meant to be alive, then she was certainly alive now.
Dr. Trent examined her carefully and asked her question after question.
At last he smiled.
“You’re as fit as a fiddle. You could easily live to be a hundred.”
Valancy stood up.
She said nothing.
Then she walked silently out of the office.
There were too many terrible things waiting for her outside.
Too many things she would have to think about.
Dr. Trent watched her go, puzzled.
There was something very strange about that woman.
Anyone looking at her pale face and hopeless eyes would have thought he had just told her she was going to die.
Instead, he had just told her she was going to live.
“Snaith?” he muttered.
Who on earth had she married?
He had never heard of any Snaiths in Deerwood.
And when she had first come to him, she had been such a small, pale, faded little spinster.
Marriage had certainly changed her.
But who was this Snaith?
Then Dr. Trent suddenly remembered.
That reckless fellow who lived “up back.”
“Good Lord,” he muttered. “Did Valancy Stirling marry him?”
And somehow, her family had allowed it?
Well, perhaps that explained everything.
Maybe she had married in haste and regretted it ever since. That would certainly explain why she looked so miserable instead of delighted at discovering that she was healthy after all.
Married!
To heaven knew who.
Or what.
Perhaps he was an escaped prisoner.
A criminal.
A man who had run away from justice.
Whatever he was, things must have been terribly bad if poor Valancy had actually welcomed death as an escape.
Dr. Trent shook his head.
“Why are women such fools?”
He dismissed the matter from his thoughts.
But until the day he died, he would never forget—or forgive himself for—the terrible mistake of putting those two letters into the wrong envelopes.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!