← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 89 · The National Corporation Problem

The National Corporation Problem

Chapter 89 of 90 · 3,498 words · Free

“Why has the public become so hostile to the great industrial trusts?”

“The original cause was the old American hatred of monopoly. But the deeper reason was that some enormous corporations had crushed their competitors through unfair and sometimes illegal methods.”

“Then the government had to step in?”

“Yes. Once these abuses became public, people demanded laws to control the trusts. They felt that a corporation had neither a body to punish nor a soul to condemn, so the law had to deal with it firmly.”

“The railroad rebate scandal made the situation even worse, didn’t it?”

“Very much so. Railroads gave favored customers secret rebates, destroying fair competition and helping a few men build enormous fortunes. Other trusts used similar methods against weaker companies and individual merchants.”

“So public anger was understandable.”

“Certainly. Some of the laws passed in response may have gone too far, but extreme laws usually correct themselves. They are either enforced until their defects become obvious or eventually repealed.”

“I remember General Grant once gave you a memorable explanation of that.”

“He did. He told me, ‘The surest way to repeal a bad law is to enforce it.’”

“That is a practical philosophy.”

“And we have another safeguard: public opinion. In the long run, public opinion usually corrects serious mistakes, because the laws of a nation ultimately reflect the will of its people.”

“Just how large had the corporate world become by 1908?”

“Enormous. The United States had more than twenty thousand corporations listed in the major financial manuals, including banks and trust companies.”

“How were they divided?”

“There were 1,512 active railroad companies, 1,129 electric railway companies, 1,158 gas, electric-light and electric-power companies, 267 water companies, 259 telephone, telegraph and cable companies, 1,510 industrial and miscellaneous companies, 880 mining companies, and about 13,500 banking, insurance and other financial companies.”

“That is a remarkable concentration of economic power.”

“It is. The railroads alone covered about 222,000 miles and had more than $13.9 billion in capitalization and bonds at the beginning of 1908.”

“And the industrial corporations?”

“They had almost $9.85 billion in capitalization. The stocks of American corporations as a whole exceeded $33.6 billion, excluding banks, trust companies and other financial institutions.”

“How quickly had the railroads grown?”

“The change was extraordinary. In 1865, the country had only about 3,085 miles of railroad in operation. By 1879, that figure had risen to 86,556 miles.”

“So most of the great railroad expansion happened in a remarkably short time.”

“Exactly. Railroads spread from Maine to California and from the St. Lawrence to the Gulf of Mexico. At the same time, American industry, population and wealth were expanding at extraordinary speed.”

“And trust companies and industrial corporations were growing along with them?”

“Before 1880 they were still relatively uncommon. The modern era of giant corporations and industrial trusts had barely begun.”

“But now they are everywhere.”

“And they will continue to grow. Our population is expanding, and our territory is still being developed. Railroads and manufacturing companies will remain among the largest corporations in the country.”

“Then you do not believe large corporations are inherently harmful.”

“Not at all. They need regulation, but regulation must not prevent legitimate business activity or healthy expansion.”

“Where should the government draw the line?”

“It should be strict when dealing with deliberate violations of the law, fraud and abuse of power. But it should not interfere with honest enterprise merely because a corporation is large.”

“The railroads seem to be the clearest example.”

“They are. Fifty-seven major railroad systems controlled or operated 688 subsidiary or jointly controlled railroads. Together they represented about 196,425 miles of track, with more than $4.75 billion in stock and $8.18 billion in bonds.”

“So those fifty-seven systems controlled almost the entire railroad network?”

“Nearly ninety percent of the country's steam railroad mileage.”

“That sounds almost like one giant railroad trust.”

“In practical terms, it was. The remaining ten percent consisted mainly of short, independent lines, many of which were weak or barely profitable.”

“Then the railroad companies had enormous collective power.”

“They did. Those fifty-seven systems could act together for lawful purposes and, taken as a whole, represented a gigantic national economic force. Without government regulation, they could easily have become a monopoly.”

“So the national corporation problem is largely a railroad problem.”

“That is a major part of it. The central question is how the federal government can regulate railroads and other corporations in the public interest without strangling legitimate business.”

“Was this problem already well understood?”

“No. The modern corporation problem was still new. The giant industrial trusts had grown mainly during the previous twenty years, and they had transformed American business.”

“What created them?”

“Population growth, industrial expansion, rising wealth and increasingly fierce competition. Corporations appeared everywhere, and then corporations began combining with other corporations. Eventually we had the great trusts.”

“What was their original justification?”

“They claimed that larger organizations could reduce costs, use capital more efficiently and compete more effectively than small companies.”

“And they could dominate their markets.”

“Exactly. But their growth also meant that many smaller businesses disappeared and thousands of workers lost their jobs. That naturally created a strong public reaction.”

“Hence the cry of ‘Monopoly!’”

“Yes. But something unexpected happened. People feared that trusts would drive prices sharply higher. In many industries, that did not happen to any alarming degree.”

“So public hostility began to weaken.”

“Somewhat. But the smaller businesses that had been destroyed did not forget what had happened. Their resentment became even stronger when they discovered that the trusts were earning enormous profits.”

“Were those profits necessarily wrong?”

“No. If they were earned honestly through greater efficiency and better management, there was nothing inherently wrong with them.”

“Which industries were dominated by these trusts?”

“Petroleum and sugar refining, iron and steel, copper and other mining industries, rubber, tobacco, distilling and many other manufacturing and commercial businesses.”

“Compared with these giants, the old businesses must have looked very small.”

“They did.”

“What about the railroad rebates? Were they finally eliminated?”

“Let us hope so. Railroad discrimination between customers was one of the worst abuses. It made a fortune for some businesses while destroying others.”

“And President Roosevelt attacked it.”

“He did, and federal legislation followed. Any attempt to revive the practice should be punished with the greatest severity.”

“Wouldn't heavy fines be enough?”

“No. Large corporations can often afford fines. The real deterrent is imprisonment for both the person giving the rebate and the person receiving it.”

“Why is imprisonment so much more effective?”

“Because wealthy executives may regard a fine as a business expense. But being sent to prison is another matter. It brings disgrace upon them and their families, and that is something most people desperately want to avoid.”

“So fear of personal punishment can accomplish what financial penalties cannot.”

“Exactly.”

“What about other forms of corporate corruption?”

“Corporate looting and the use of corporate money for political contributions are equally wrong. They should be punished severely, and stolen money should be recovered.”

“Judge Anderson made a similar argument in the John R. Walsh bank-fraud trial, didn’t he?”

“Yes. His point was that when someone knowingly commits an unlawful act that causes injury or loss, the law can infer criminal intent from the act itself.”

“Why did so many corporations become involved in questionable practices?”

“Partly because many trusts were created in a speculative atmosphere. Their promoters were often interested in making money from the stock transactions used to create the combinations.”

“So they overpaid for the companies they acquired?”

“Often. They would pay extravagant prices, frequently with stock rather than cash, for properties they wanted to bring into the new trust.”

“And that created overcapitalization.”

“Exactly. Some trusts were capitalized at several times the real value of their properties.”

“Were the executives themselves paid excessively?”

“Very often. The men who controlled these organizations frequently gave themselves enormous salaries. They were working for the corporation, but they were also looking after themselves.”

“What happened when they tried to sell the stock?”

“They sometimes used exaggerated claims and misleading statements about the company's value and condition. They needed to make the stock attractive and pay dividends, even when the underlying business could not fully justify them.”

“So investors were left with the scraps.”

“That is a fair way to put it. The men in control often took the cream and left the skim milk for outside investors.”

“Were the laws too weak to stop them?”

“For many years, both state and federal laws were far too loose. Much could be done secretly. New legislation has brought greater publicity, stronger reporting requirements and severe penalties for dishonest practices.”

“Corporations also used their money in politics.”

“Yes, and that was another serious abuse. Political contributions are not necessarily wrong, but using corporate money for political purposes was both morally and legally improper.”

“Why did executives think they could do that?”

“Because many had become so accustomed to controlling corporate funds that they behaved as though the money belonged personally to them.”

“Were there examples of this in the railroads?”

“There were serious cases involving the New York City railways and other large companies. In one notorious street-railway transaction, a practically nonexistent line was purchased at a fictitious price, diverting roughly half a million dollars at the expense of shareholders.”

“And many people escaped punishment.”

“Unfortunately, yes. That gives the appearance of a failure of justice.”

“But you still believe most corporate managers were honest?”

“I believe dishonesty was the exception and honesty the general rule.”

“Should wealthy corporate offenders be punished more harshly?”

“When the offense involves theft or deliberate violation of the law, the punishment should be real. Fines alone mean little to wealthy men who are willing to break the law for personal gain.”

“Still, was public criticism of all trusts fair?”

“No. That was one of the great mistakes of the time. People often treated good corporations and bad corporations as though they were the same.”

“Yet the trusts themselves represented a major stage in American economic development.”

“Exactly. Their large capital, modern machinery and greater efficiency allowed them to produce on a scale that small businesses could not match.”

“So their success was partly a natural economic process.”

“Yes. Stronger competitors naturally replace weaker ones. The trusts were another example of the survival of the fittest.”

“Then what should the public oppose?”

“Not the existence of trusts, but injustice, fraud, lawlessness, false statements, looting and other abuses.”

“A well-run trust can actually benefit the public?”

“Certainly. An honestly managed large corporation can serve the public just as legitimately as an individual business, a partnership or a small corporation.”

“But large corporations create greater opportunities for abuse.”

“That is the danger. The more power people control, the greater the temptation to misuse it.”

“Especially when they can influence railroads, competitors and government officials.”

“Exactly. Some corporate leaders used secret deals, rebates, political connections and corporate money to gain advantages that they could never have justified openly.”

“Has the situation improved?”

“Considerably. Public exposure and new laws have closed many of the doors through which fraud and graft once entered. Greater publicity has produced a healthier business atmosphere.”

“So the scandals themselves helped reform the system.”

“In an unfortunate way, yes. They awakened public opinion and created stronger resistance to corruption.”

“Should corporations have rights too?”

“Of course. Corporations, like individuals, deserve fair treatment from both state and federal governments.”

“Then should every corporation be subject to the same reporting requirements?”

“No. That is another weakness in existing legislation. We should distinguish between private corporations and corporations whose securities are owned by the public.”

“What difference does that make?”

“A large railroad or public utility whose stocks and bonds are sold to the public has a public responsibility. Its financial condition should be regularly examined and disclosed.”

“But a small private company is different.”

“Very different. If its securities have never been sold to the public, and its business affects no public investment, there is far less reason to impose the same level of government inspection.”

“How are the railroads handled?”

“They must keep their books and accounts according to government rules under the supervision of the Interstate Commerce Commission.”

“That seems reasonable.”

“It is. Their records are subject to government inspection, so there is much less room for deception.”

“But applying the same rules to every small private company would be excessive.”

“Exactly.”

“Should honest corporations fear public disclosure?”

“No. A sound and honestly managed corporation has little to fear from publicity about its finances.”

“Even if it has trade secrets?”

“Trade secrets deserve protection. Public disclosure should expose financial dishonesty, not force every legitimate business secret into the open.”

“What about public utilities?”

“Honestly managed public utilities are actually one of our strongest defenses against municipal ownership.”

“Why do you oppose municipal ownership?”

“Because in this country it would likely bring political corruption and poor service.”

“You see it as a form of socialism?”

“Yes. Socialism would conflict with our political institutions and our tradition of individual enterprise, and Americans should resist its spread.”

“Then you place great importance on public disclosure.”

“Very great importance. Regular reports of earnings and financial condition build confidence where confidence is deserved and expose weakness where it is not.”

“So publicity separates the sound companies from the weak ones.”

“Exactly. It removes dangerous institutions and protects healthy ones.”

“Then secrecy benefits the weak.”

“Usually. Weak companies naturally prefer darkness. But the public interest requires large corporations to step into the light and succeed or fail on their actual merits.”

“Does that apply only to railroads and manufacturers?”

“No. It applies equally to banks, insurance companies, trading companies and transportation corporations.”

“Then their books must be reliable.”

“Absolutely. Corporate books should be clear, systematic and easy for an examiner to understand.”

“Why emphasize bookkeeping so strongly?”

“Because poor accounting has contributed to many corporate failures. When some large companies collapsed, receivers discovered such confusion in their records that they could barely determine what assets and liabilities existed.”

“That means the executives themselves may not have known how badly their businesses were performing.”

“Precisely. Careless bookkeeping and poor office management can hide problems until it is too late.”

“What should corporations do?”

“They should supervise their clerical departments closely and hire professional accountants to conduct regular examinations and audits.”

“Accounting has become that important?”

“It has become a science. Modern business cannot afford old-fashioned methods.”

“So outdated habits must disappear.”

“Yes. Anything wasteful, unnecessary or obstructive should give way to modern methods that save time and improve efficiency.”

“What other danger do you see besides financial corruption?”

“The growing political influence of large corporations.”

“How serious is it?”

“More serious than most people realize. Their political influence is becoming an increasingly important force in both state and national affairs.”

“Have we already seen examples?”

“Yes. Large corporations have strongly protested against proposed increases in railroad freight rates. They have appealed directly to President Roosevelt because they know how much influence he has over federal regulators.”

“And the president has to think politically as well as economically.”

“Of course. He must consider how his decisions will affect business, labor and the voters.”

“What happened when the railroads proposed cutting wages?”

“President Roosevelt ordered an investigation into the proposed wage reductions. The railroads quickly abandoned the plan.”

“So his intervention prevented a wage cut.”

“Yes. He understood that a wage reduction in one region could become the beginning of a nationwide reduction and perhaps lead to a strike.”

“Then the railroads changed their strategy.”

“They shifted their attention from cutting wages to raising freight rates.”

“Because they thought the president might prefer higher freight rates to lower wages.”

“That was their calculation.”

“That put Roosevelt in a difficult position.”

“Very difficult. He was caught between the railroads, organized labor and the broader business community.”

“And every side had political power.”

“Exactly. If the administration handled the matter badly, it could alienate either the corporations and merchants or the railroads and labor.”

“And the presidential election was approaching.”

“Yes. Any major conflict could influence the election.”

“What were the railroads proposing?”

“The Eastern trunk lines had agreed to increase freight rates by roughly ten to fourteen percent.”

“During a depression?”

“That was precisely the problem. Railroad earnings were already falling. In February, gross earnings were about 12.5 percent below the previous year. In March, they were down roughly 14.4 percent.”

“What was causing the decline?”

“The industrial depression, especially in iron, steel, coal, and the New England cotton and woolen industries.”

“And higher freight rates would make things worse.”

“They would raise the cost of transporting goods, and consumers would ultimately pay the difference.”

“How much had demand already fallen?”

“On average, demand for goods had contracted by about twenty-five percent.”

“Then it is easy to understand the protests.”

“Shippers, merchants and manufacturers all complained that higher freight rates were unfair during such difficult times.”

“What was the railroads’ defense?”

“They argued that major industrial combinations, including the U.S. Steel Corporation, refused to reduce the prices they charged for railroad materials. They also pointed to labor unions that were determined to preserve wages at the high levels of prosperous years.”

“Those are understandable arguments.”

“They are, but two wrongs do not make a right. Finding a fair solution between railroad costs and labor demands is itself a difficult problem.”

“Was the political power of corporations really strong enough to influence the federal government?”

“Yes. The power Congress had given the president over corporations made the corporations increasingly eager to influence the government itself.”

“They wanted control over the government that regulated them.”

“Precisely. The more power the government gained over corporations, the more valuable political influence became to those corporations.”

“So they began building political machines.”

“Quietly and deliberately. They understood that openly trying to make money power supreme would provoke public outrage.”

“Then they preferred to operate behind the scenes.”

“Exactly. As Samuel J. Tilden used to say, a political campaign often succeeds through a ‘still hunt’—quiet, persistent influence rather than noisy public action.”

“Why would corporations risk becoming involved in politics?”

“Because government policy had become increasingly important to their fortunes. If federal officials could regulate their businesses, the corporations naturally wanted influence over those officials.”

“And that could become dangerous.”

“Extremely dangerous. When industrial, railroad and financial interests combine enormous wealth with political influence, they can threaten the independence of government.”

“Then the greatest corporation problem is no longer simply monopoly.”

“Correct. The greatest problem is how to control the political power of corporations without treating legitimate business as criminal.”

“What would happen if corporations actually controlled the government?”

“That would be a national calamity. A republic cannot remain free if government policy is bought and controlled by concentrated wealth.”

“Who deserves credit for strengthening federal control over corporations?”

“President Roosevelt deserves much of the credit. Under the constitutional power of Congress to regulate interstate commerce, his administration greatly expanded federal supervision of corporations.”

“And that was not his only contribution.”

“No. He also pushed important measures involving conservation and the development of national resources.”

“Such as?”

“Irrigation of arid lands, the creation of forest reserves, and the expansion and improvement of the geological survey.”

“What about the Department of Commerce and Labor?”

“That department was also important. Its mission was to promote American foreign and domestic commerce, mining, manufacturing, fishing, labor interests and transportation.”

“So almost every part of American business was connected to it.”

“Everything except banking and finance was practically covered by the department.”

“Then cooperation between corporations and the federal government must be important.”

“Very important. The government, corporations and commercial organizations must work together to encourage legitimate business while preventing political domination by corporate wealth.”

“And the danger is not only economic.”

“Exactly. If trusts and financial interests gained control of national policy, they would threaten the principles on which the American government was founded.”

“So this may become the greatest national corporation problem of all.”

“Yes. Questions about trusts, banks and railroads are important, but they are secondary if corporations begin seeking political power for capital itself.”

“Because once capital controls government, the political system is in danger.”

“That is the heart of the matter.”

“But there is still hope.”

“There always is. Public opinion is the great court of appeal.”

“And it can restrain the trusts?”

“Yes. If the people remain alert, government will respond. The trusts, railroads, banks and every other great business interest must ultimately be kept within the law and directed toward the welfare of the nation.”

“So the real goal is not to destroy corporations.”

“No. It is to make them serve the country without allowing them to control it.”

“And as long as the public remains watchful, the system can correct itself.”

“Exactly. We must remain forewarned and therefore forearmed. Public opinion, when informed and determined, can keep even the most powerful corporations in line with the national interest and the prosperity of the people.”

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!