← The Blue Castle 2026 Edition
Chapter 8 · The Night Valancy Chose to Live

The Night Valancy Chose to Live

Chapter 8 of 45 · 2,977 words · Free

Valancy did not sleep that night.

She lay awake through the long, dark hours, thinking and thinking.

Then she made a discovery that surprised her.

She had been afraid of almost everything in life, but she was not afraid of death.

Death did not seem frightening at all.

And if she was going to die, she no longer had to be afraid of anything else.

Why had she always been afraid?

Because she had been afraid of life.

She had been afraid of Uncle Benjamin because she might one day grow old and poor.

But she would never grow old now.

She would never become some neglected old woman whom everyone merely tolerated.

She had been afraid of becoming an old maid for the rest of her life.

But now she would not be an old maid for very long.

She had been afraid of upsetting her mother and the whole Stirling clan because she had to live among them. If she wanted any peace, she had always had to give in to them.

But now she didn't have to.

For the first time in her life, Valancy felt strangely free.

There was only one thing she was still terribly afraid of—the fuss everyone would make when she told them.

Valancy shuddered just thinking about it.

She couldn't bear it.

She knew exactly what would happen.

First would come the outrage.

Uncle James would be furious because she had gone to a doctor without consulting him.

Her mother would be offended because Valancy had kept it secret.

"How could you deceive me like this, Doss? I'm your own mother."

And the whole clan would be angry because she had not gone to their favorite doctor, Dr. Marsh.

Then would come the concern.

They would drag her to Dr. Marsh, and when he confirmed Dr. Trent's diagnosis, they would send her to specialists in Toronto and Montreal.

Uncle Benjamin would proudly pay the bills, making a grand show of helping a poor widow and her daughter.

Afterward, he would complain for years about the outrageous fees those specialists charged just to look serious and say they could do nothing.

And when the specialists failed, Uncle James would insist on his favorite cure.

"You should take Purple Pills. I've known people recover after every doctor had given up."

Her mother would recommend Redfern's Blood Bitters.

Cousin Stickles would insist on rubbing Valancy's heart every night with Redfern's Liniment.

"It might help, and it certainly can't hurt."

Everyone else would have some miracle medicine of their own.

Then Dr. Stalling would come and sit beside her with a grave expression.

"You are very ill, Valancy. Are you prepared for what may lie ahead?"

He would probably raise that solemn forefinger of his while saying it—the same crooked finger that had somehow survived all these years without becoming any less knobby.

After that, they would watch her every minute.

She would be treated like a baby.

She would not be allowed to go anywhere alone or do anything without permission.

Perhaps they would not even let her sleep alone in case she died during the night.

Her mother or Cousin Stickles would probably insist on sleeping in the same room.

Maybe even the same bed.

Yes.

Undoubtedly.

That was what finally decided Valancy.

She could not endure it.

And she would not.

When the clock downstairs struck twelve, Valancy made up her mind.

She would tell no one.

All her life she had been taught to hide what she felt.

"It isn't ladylike to have feelings," Cousin Stickles had once told her.

Very well.

Valancy would hide her feelings with a vengeance.

But although she was not afraid of death, she was certainly not indifferent to it.

She resented it.

It seemed terribly unfair that she should have to die when she had never really lived.

As the dark hours passed, rebellion began to burn inside her.

Not because she had no future.

Because she had no past.

"I'm poor. I'm ugly. I'm a failure. And now I'm dying."

She could already imagine her obituary in the Deerwood Weekly Times, copied into the Port Lawrence Journal.

"A deep gloom has fallen over Deerwood..."

"She leaves a large circle of friends to mourn her passing..."

Lies.

All lies.

Gloom?

Who would miss her?

Her death would not matter to anyone.

Not even her mother loved her.

Her mother had always been disappointed that Valancy was not a boy—or at least a pretty girl.

Valancy looked back over her entire life between midnight and the first pale light of dawn.

It had been a dull, colorless existence.

Yet certain moments stood out in her memory with a strange force, even though they had seemed insignificant at the time.

And every one of them was unpleasant.

Nothing truly wonderful had ever happened to her.

"I've never had one completely happy hour in my whole life. Not one."

"I've just been nobody. A colorless little nobody."

"I once read somewhere that there is an hour when a woman could be happy for the rest of her life if she could only find it."

"I never found mine."

"Never."

"And now I never will."

"If I could have had that one hour, I think I could have been willing to die."

The memories came one after another, like ghosts that refused to stay buried.

She remembered being sixteen and putting too much blue into a tub of laundry.

She remembered being eight and "stealing" raspberry jam from Aunt Wellington's pantry.

She had never been allowed to forget either offense.

At almost every family gathering, someone brought them up for a laugh.

Uncle Benjamin especially loved telling the raspberry-jam story.

He had been the one to catch her, her face covered in red stains.

"I've actually done so few bad things that they have to keep bringing up the same two mistakes," Valancy thought.

"I've never even had a real quarrel with anyone."

"I don't have a single enemy."

"What kind of spineless person has no enemies at all?"

Then she remembered the dust pile at school when she was seven.

Whenever Dr. Stalling quoted the Bible verse about those who have being given more, while those who have little losing even that, Valancy always remembered the dust pile.

She had understood that verse perfectly.

It reminded her of Olive.

Valancy had already been going to school for a year. Olive was a year younger and had just started.

She was pretty, new, and surrounded by the excitement that always followed a new girl.

One afternoon during recess, all the girls were outside making piles of dust.

The goal was simple.

Whoever made the biggest pile won.

Valancy was good at making dust piles.

It was almost an art.

She secretly hoped hers would be the biggest.

Then Olive's pile suddenly became larger than everyone else's.

Valancy wasn't jealous.

Her own pile was big enough to make her happy.

Then one of the older girls had an idea.

"Let's put all our dust on Olive's pile and make it enormous!"

The girls immediately became excited.

They grabbed their buckets and shovels and attacked the dust piles.

Within seconds, Olive's pile had become a huge pyramid.

Valancy tried desperately to protect her own little pile.

But the older girls simply pushed her aside and dumped her dust onto Olive's.

Valancy turned away and started another pile.

A moment later, someone attacked that one too.

Valancy stood in front of it, red-faced and furious, her thin arms spread wide.

"Please don't take it."

"Why not?" the older girl demanded.

"Why don't you help us make Olive's pile bigger?"

"I want my own little dust pile," Valancy pleaded.

Nobody listened.

While she tried to argue with one girl, another scooped up her pile.

Valancy turned away with tears burning in her eyes.

"You're jealous!" the girls teased.

"You're very selfish," her mother told her coldly that night.

That was the first and last time Valancy ever took one of her troubles to her mother.

She hadn't been jealous.

She hadn't been selfish.

She had simply wanted a dust pile of her own.

It didn't matter whether it was big or small.

Then a team of horses came down the street and scattered Olive's giant pile everywhere.

The school bell rang.

The girls went inside.

Before they even reached their seats, they had forgotten the whole thing.

Valancy never forgot.

Even now, all these years later, she still felt the old injustice deep inside.

Wasn't that what her whole life had been like?

"I've never been allowed to have my own dust pile," she thought.

Then she remembered the enormous red moon she had seen when she was six.

She had been sick and cold that evening when the moon suddenly appeared at the end of the street.

It had seemed enormous.

Terrifying.

Far too close.

She had run to her mother, trembling.

Her mother had laughed at her.

That night Valancy had hidden beneath her blankets, terrified that she might look toward the window and see that horrible moon staring in at her.

Then there was the boy at the party when she was fifteen.

He had tried to kiss her.

She had escaped and run away.

He was the only boy who had ever tried to kiss her.

Fourteen years later, Valancy found herself wishing she had let him.

She remembered the time she had been forced to apologize to Olive for something she had never done.

Olive claimed Valancy had deliberately pushed her into the mud and ruined her new shoes.

Valancy knew it wasn't true.

It had been an accident.

And even the accident had not been her fault.

But nobody believed her.

She had been forced to apologize.

Then she had been forced to kiss Olive to make peace.

The injustice of it still burned inside her that night.

Then came the summer when Olive had owned the most beautiful hat Valancy had ever seen.

It was trimmed with soft yellow netting, red roses, and little ribbons beneath the chin.

Valancy had wanted a hat like that more than she had ever wanted anything.

She begged for one.

Everyone laughed.

All summer she had to wear an ugly little brown sailor hat with elastic that cut into the backs of her ears.

None of the other girls wanted to be seen with her because she looked so shabby.

Only Olive would walk with her.

Everyone thought Olive was wonderfully sweet and generous.

"I made an excellent background for her," Valancy thought.

"She probably knew that even then."

She remembered trying to win a Sunday School attendance prize.

Olive won it.

Valancy had been forced to miss too many Sundays because of colds.

She remembered trying to recite a poem at school one Friday afternoon.

She had forgotten the words halfway through.

Olive was always good at reciting.

She never got stuck.

Then came the night she spent in Port Lawrence with Aunt Isabel when she was ten.

Byron Stirling had been there, too.

He was twelve, visiting from Montreal, and already terribly conceited.

During family prayers the next morning, Byron reached over and pinched Valancy's thin arm as hard as he could.

She cried out in pain.

After prayers, Aunt Isabel summoned her for questioning.

Valancy explained what Byron had done.

But Byron denied it.

He claimed the kitten had scratched her.

He said Valancy had put the kitten on her chair and had been playing with it instead of listening to Uncle David's prayer.

They believed him.

In the Stirling family, boys were always believed before girls.

Valancy was sent home in disgrace for her terrible behavior during prayers.

She wasn't invited back to Aunt Isabel's for a very long time.

Then she remembered Cousin Betty Stirling's wedding.

Somehow, Valancy had heard that Betty might ask her to be one of the bridesmaids.

For a little while, Valancy had felt wonderfully important.

Being a bridesmaid would have been delightful.

And she would have needed a new dress.

A pretty pink one.

Betty wanted her bridesmaids dressed in pink.

But Betty never asked her.

Valancy had never understood why.

Years later, Olive finally told her.

After much discussion, Betty had decided that Valancy was too insignificant.

She would "spoil the effect."

That had happened nine years ago.

Yet that night, Valancy felt the old wound open again.

Then she remembered the day, when she was eleven, that her mother had pressured her into confessing to something she had never done.

Valancy had denied it for a long time.

Eventually, just to end the argument, she had surrendered and admitted guilt.

Her mother had a way of making people lie simply by refusing to accept the truth.

Then she had made Valancy kneel on the parlor floor between herself and Cousin Stickles.

"Say it."

Valancy had obeyed.

"O God, please forgive me for not telling the truth."

She had said the words.

But when she stood up, she had whispered:

"But, O God, You know I did tell the truth."

She had never heard of Galileo then.

But she felt her fate had been much like his.

She had been punished even after admitting to something she had not done.

Then there was dancing school.

Uncle James had decided she should go and had paid for the lessons.

Valancy had been so excited at first.

Then she had discovered how much she hated it.

No boy ever chose her as a partner.

The teacher always had to order some boy to dance with her.

Usually, he looked annoyed about it.

Yet Valancy was actually a good dancer.

She was light on her feet, almost as light as thistledown.

Olive, who always had boys eager to dance with her, was heavy and awkward.

Then there was the button string.

Valancy had been ten.

Every girl at school had one.

Olive's was long and covered with beautiful buttons.

Valancy had one too.

Most of her buttons were ordinary, but six of them were special.

They had come from Grandmother Stirling's wedding dress.

They were sparkling gold-and-glass buttons, far prettier than anything Olive owned.

Valancy was proud of them.

She knew the other girls envied her.

When Olive first saw them, she examined them closely but said nothing.

The next day Aunt Wellington came to Elm Street.

She told Mrs. Frederick that Olive ought to have some of the buttons.

"Grandmother Stirling was just as much my mother as Frederick's," Aunt Wellington pointed out.

Mrs. Frederick agreed.

She couldn't afford to offend Aunt Wellington.

And besides, to her, the buttons were unimportant.

Aunt Wellington took four.

She generously left Valancy two.

Valancy ripped the remaining buttons off her string and threw them onto the floor.

She had not yet learned that a proper lady was supposed to hide her feelings.

She was sent to bed without supper for making such a scene.

Then came Margaret Blunt's party.

Valancy had tried so hard to look pretty that night.

Rob Walker was going to be there.

Only two nights earlier, on the moonlit porch of Uncle Herbert's cottage at Mistawis, Rob had seemed genuinely interested in her.

Valancy had hoped.

But at Margaret's party, Rob didn't even ask her to dance.

He barely noticed she existed.

She was a wallflower again.

That had been years ago.

By then, people in Deerwood had stopped inviting Valancy to dances altogether.

But tonight, the humiliation felt fresh.

She could still picture herself sitting there with her thin, painfully curled hair.

She had pinched her cheeks for an hour before leaving, trying to make them look rosy.

All that effort had achieved was a nasty rumor that Valancy Stirling had worn rouge to Margaret Blunt's party.

In those days, that was enough to destroy a girl's reputation.

But nobody believed Valancy could be wild even if she tried.

So they simply laughed at her.

"I've lived a secondhand life," Valancy thought.

"All the great emotions have passed me by."

"I've never even known real grief."

"And have I ever truly loved anyone?"

"Do I love Mother?"

She thought about it honestly.

"No."

"That's the truth, whether it's shameful or not."

"I don't love her."

"I never have."

"Worse than that, I don't even like her."

"So I don't know anything about love at all."

"My life has been empty."

"Empty."

"Nothing is worse than emptiness."

"Nothing!"

The last word escaped her lips aloud.

Then she groaned.

A familiar attack of pain had begun.

When it finally passed, something inside Valancy had changed.

Perhaps it was the final result of everything that had been happening in her mind since she received Dr. Trent's letter.

It was three in the morning.

The darkest, strangest hour of the night.

Sometimes, however, that hour could set a person free.

"I've spent my whole life trying to please other people, and I've failed," Valancy said.

"From now on, I'll please myself."

"I'll never pretend again."

"All my life I've lived among lies, polite little pretenses, and things nobody dared say."

"What a wonderful luxury it will be to tell the truth."

"I may not be able to do everything I want."

"But I will never again do something simply because someone else wants me to."

"Mother can sulk for weeks if she likes."

"I won't care."

"Despair is a free man. Hope is a slave."

Valancy got out of bed and dressed.

That strange feeling of freedom grew stronger with every movement.

When she finished arranging her hair, she opened the window.

Then she picked up the jar of potpourri that had sat there for years.

She hurled it across the yard.

It smashed gloriously against the faded, schoolgirl-colored wall of the old carriage shop.

Valancy looked at the broken pieces.

"I'm sick of the smell of dead things," she said.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!