The Petition That Exposed the Prison’s Hypocrisy
The success of my little scheme gave me enormous satisfaction.
I had gained nothing from it, and I had never expected to. What mattered was that I had proved something important. I now had a perfect example to use if I ever needed to challenge the Home Secretary.
As it happened, that opportunity came.
A friend of mine had arrived from America to visit me. He was also trying to see whether something could be done to reduce my sentence.
Unfortunately, my warder friend—the one who usually carried my letters—was away.
That meant I had no way of sending a private letter outside.
I desperately wanted to communicate with my friend, so I applied directly to the Home Secretary.
I explained the situation and asked for permission to write two letters immediately.
Then I waited.
Eight weeks passed before I received an answer.
The Home Secretary had "carefully considered" my request, the letter said, but had found no sufficient reason to recommend that Her Majesty grant it.
I laughed when I read it.
The next day I obtained an official petition sheet from the governor.
Then I began to write.
I addressed it to Sir William Vernon Harcourt, the Home Secretary.
"Sir," I wrote, "two months ago I submitted a petition asking for permission to write two letters. I explained why the matter was urgent and pointed out that such a request was hardly unusual.
"Yesterday I finally received your answer.
"I am deeply sorry to learn that my little request has caused you eight weeks of such serious consideration.
"I sincerely hope the effort has not harmed your health.
"Still, I cannot help wondering why two letters required eight weeks of the Home Secretary's valuable time.
"After all, any prisoner who possesses, or is known to be able to obtain, a small amount of money can usually send out as many secret letters as he wants.
"Of course, doing so breaks the rules.
"Most prisoners would rather remain on friendly terms with the prison authorities than deliberately break those rules. But when the authorities refuse a small favor that would cost them almost nothing, a prisoner may simply decide to ignore the rules and take the favor for himself.
"I hope this information will save you from suffering another eight weeks of anxiety over such a matter.
"I have not had much success when petitioning for myself, but I am pleased to thank you for the attention you have given to petitions concerning other prisoners."
Then I came to the real point.
"You may remember the case of Frederick Barton, whom you released not long ago.
"You may not know that I invented his fortune.
"I also wrote the petition that gave the authorities the excuse to recommend his release.
"Mr. Barton had previously asked for mercy on the grounds that he had been only seventeen when arrested.
"That argument received very little attention.
"But when a petition arrived claiming that he had suddenly inherited a huge fortune, everything changed.
"Apparently, a young man who had inherited money and sixteen thousand acres of cotton land in India was much more deserving of mercy.
"I confess that I found the contrast extremely amusing.
"The young man had done nothing to deserve his freedom except, according to the story I invented, become rich.
"And the Home Secretary, despite having all the power of the government behind him, accepted the story after reading a single sheet of paper filled with lies.
"The petition had been delivered to the Home Office by a prisoner who had been outside Millbank for less than half an hour.
"I must admit that Mr. Smith, who delivered it, was fooled just as completely as the Home Secretary.
"Gold was held before both their eyes, and both reacted in exactly the same way.
"I had never doubted what would happen.
"The moment large sums of money became involved, I believed every distinction between a pickpocket and a powerful government official would disappear.
"And the result proved me right."
As I watched Frederick Barton happily leave the prison and return to the comfortable world he had come from, I thought of an old German saying about powerful men dealing with the devil himself.
Barton knew nothing about German.
In fact, he knew very little English either.
But if he had understood the saying, I imagined he might have whispered it to himself as he walked away.
Still, I was sure the Home Secretary believed he had acted properly.
He had simply done what he thought his duty required.
As for me, I now had every opportunity to send letters secretly whenever I wished.
So I promised him that I would never again trouble him with another request that required eight weeks of careful thought.
I signed the petition.
"Austin Bidwell."
I had no idea what Sir William Vernon Harcourt thought when he read it.
He never answered.
But I doubt very much that he felt flattered.
It had taken some nerve to send such a petition.
Fortunately, I had nothing to hope for from the Home Secretary, so I was not particularly worried about what punishment might follow.
The governor of the prison had no choice but to send it.
It was written on an official petition form, properly recorded in the prison books, and therefore could not simply be suppressed without violating the regulations.
But the governor sent for me immediately.
He was furious.
When I entered his office, he put on his most threatening expression.
"How dare you play these ridiculous tricks?" he demanded.
I smiled.
"Are you now the official critic and editor of petitions?"
He stared at me.
"Perhaps I should call you the local Home Secretary."
The governor was a strict man. Officially, he was one of the strongest supporters of discipline in the entire prison.
But personally, he was not a bad fellow.
He soon realized that threatening me was pointless.
"Don't do anything like this again," he said.
I laughed.
"Why not?"
"Because you will only cause trouble."
"I'll agree not to, provided you allow me to write a special letter from time to time."
He hesitated.
Then he admitted that such permission could probably be arranged.
"Very well," I said. "Then we have nothing more to discuss."
And that was the end of the matter as far as the governor was concerned.
But the petition caused quite a sensation among the prison officers.
Everyone heard about it.
The fact that a prisoner had dared to send such a document to the Home Secretary added considerably to the respect some of them already had for me.
Since I am talking about petitions, there is another one that deserves to be mentioned.
Its author was a prisoner named Niblo Clark.
Poor Niblo was something of a character.
For many prisoners, reading and writing were almost impossible skills.
Every prisoner was given a small slate, and many men spent endless hours struggling to put together petitions that usually accomplished nothing.
Niblo spent an entire year working on his.
He worked on it through the heat of summer and the freezing weather of winter.
When he finally finished it, I had to admit that it was a masterpiece of its kind.
His petition began in the usual official manner.
His name was Niblo Clark.
He was forty years old and was being held at Chatham Prison.
He had been convicted of burglary at the Old Bailey in London in 1880 and sentenced to fifteen years.
Then came his appeal to the Home Secretary.
"Sir," Niblo wrote, "I humbly ask you to consider what a great benefit it would be to me if I could be removed from this cold, damp and foggy climate and sent somewhere warmer.
"The weather here is destroying my health.
"I suffer from asthma and severe chronic bronchitis.
"I have spent three years in the prison hospital and have become weaker and weaker.
"Therefore, I beg you to send me somewhere with a healthier climate."
But Niblo was not finished.
He had other complaints.
"I must also report the repeated injustice and cruelty I have suffered here.
"People have made false accusations against me.
"Whenever I am released from the hospital, the governor deals with the reports against me one by one and punishes me.
"I have sometimes been kept on bread and water for as long as six weeks.
"The officers seem to be encouraged to treat sick prisoners with cruelty.
"One officer in particular appears to have been placed here for the purpose of tormenting me.
"His name is Warder Newcombe.
"He has struck and assaulted sick prisoners while they were lying in their beds.
"Several men have complained about him to the governor.
"But nothing seems to change.
"It is almost useless to complain."
Then Niblo's petition took an unexpected turn.
He began writing poetry.
"Honorable Sir, please listen to my pain.
"You do not know half of what I suffer here.
"My terrible illness grows worse every day.
"So I beg you, please remove me without delay."
He continued:
"I hope you will not think I am joking because I have written this request in verse.
"The greatest kindness you could show me would be to send me back to Woking.
"This damp and foggy place will never allow me to recover.
"And while you are helping me, perhaps you could also grant me permission to send a special letter."
Then he remembered another matter.
"There is one more request I wish to make.
"If you would kindly listen, I believe it would cause quite a stir throughout the prison.
"I ask that Niblo Clark be sent to work on public works.
"It would create more excitement than the recent quarrel between Russia and Turkey."
He then returned to his illness.
"In this weather, with my condition, I could not survive for even an hour.
"If you doubt what I am saying, ask Doctor Power.
"Ask any doctor from the navy or the army.
"They will all tell you the same thing.
"Doctor Harrison will say the same."
Niblo insisted that his treatment had been terrible ever since he arrived at Chatham.
"Since I entered this prison, I have been one of the most unfortunate men here.
"Every time I have been in the hospital, I have suffered.
"And I assure you, Sir, I have paid dearly for whatever medical treatment I have received."
He was convinced that the officers had marked him as a troublemaker.
"I am a marked man.
"Captain Harris knows it.
"There are so many reports against me that the list could reach from here all the way to Paris.
"So I humbly ask you to grant this petition.
"I have nothing left to pay with.
"I have lost both my health and my chance of remission."
Then came another complaint.
"It is cruel and unjust to punish sick men.
"But the officers seem to take particular pleasure in reporting prisoners who are already in the hospital.
"Perhaps you think they only do this to troublesome men.
"But they do it to everyone.
"They have done it to Austin Bidwell.
"They have even done it to poor Sir Roger Tichborne."
Niblo's imagination became even more dramatic.
"The officers walk around this infirmary like savage lions.
"They wait for a sick man to say something so they can report him for talking.
"Then, when we leave the hospital, they use those reports against us.
"They take them one at a time and put us back on bread and water.
"With my chest and throat in this condition, leaving the hospital is almost like committing suicide.
"The treatment here has brought me close to the grave.
"So, in conclusion, I humbly beg you to remove me from this prison."
Finally, Niblo added one last warning.
"If this petition is not sent forward, prisoners will have no reason to write again.
"Who will explain our cases properly to the visiting director?
"I therefore beg that this petition be submitted to him."
Then he signed his name with great dignity.
"Your humble servant,
Niblo Clark."
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!