← The Odyssey 2026 Edition
Chapter 19 · The Scar

The Scar

Chapter 19 of 24 · 2,258 words · Free

Odysseus stood alone beneath the colonnade, turning over the same thought again and again: how could he destroy the suitors with Athena’s help?

At last, he called quietly to Telemachus.

“Tonight, we need to move all the weapons out of the hall.”

Telemachus looked at him carefully. “What should I tell the suitors if they notice?”

“Say the smoke has ruined them,” Odysseus said. “Say they are no longer as bright as they were when your father left for Troy, and that you moved them somewhere safe.”

He paused.

“Then say you fear they may start fighting after too much wine. A weapon can tempt a man to use it.”

Telemachus understood at once.

He called for Eurycleia.

“Old nurse, lock the women in their rooms. The stranger and I are taking the weapons down to the storeroom.”

Eurycleia frowned. “You should take full charge of this house, my child. But who will carry a light for you? Why not let the maids help?”

“The stranger will carry the light,” Telemachus said. “Anyone who eats in my house should be willing to work.”

Eurycleia did as she was told. She shut the women away, and Odysseus and Telemachus hurried to gather the helmets, shields, and spears.

Athena walked before them, holding a golden lamp.

Its light was soft, clear, and brighter than fire.

Telemachus stared in wonder.

“Father,” he whispered, “look at the walls. Look at the beams. Everything is glowing. Surely a god has come down from heaven.”

“Be quiet,” Odysseus said. “Do not ask questions. This is how the gods work.”

Then he added, “Go to bed. Leave me here. Your mother will come down, and she will have many questions for me.”

Telemachus went to his room and slept until morning.

Odysseus remained below, waiting and planning.

Not long after, Penelope came down from her chamber.

She moved with a quiet grace that made her seem almost divine. Her attendants placed her familiar chair beside the fire, carved with ivory and silver, and covered it with soft fleece.

The maids cleared away the suitors’ tables, gathered the leftover bread and cups, and built up the fire.

Then Melantho turned on the stranger again.

“Are you planning to stand around here all night, staring at the women?” she snapped. “Get out. Go eat somewhere else before someone drives you away with a burning stick.”

Odysseus gave her a cold look.

“Why are you so angry with me?” he asked. “Because my clothes are torn? Because I am dirty? Because I have had to beg for food?”

His voice hardened.

“I was rich once. I had a fine home, servants, land, and more food than I could eat. Beggars came to my door, and I gave them what they needed.”

He leaned closer.

“But Zeus took everything from me. So be careful. One day, you may lose the place you are so proud of. Your mistress may turn against you. And Odysseus may yet return.”

Melantho’s face changed.

“Even if he is dead,” Odysseus continued, “his son is alive. Telemachus is no longer a child. He sees what the servants do.”

Penelope had heard every word.

“You shameless girl,” she said sharply to Melantho. “I know exactly how badly you are behaving. You knew I wanted to speak to this stranger and ask him about my husband.”

Then she turned to Eurynome.

“Bring him a chair and cover it with fleece. I want to speak with him.”

When Odysseus was seated, Penelope studied him.

“Stranger, tell me who you are. Where do you come from? Who were your parents?”

Odysseus bowed his head.

“My lady, no one on earth could speak badly of you. Your name reaches heaven itself. You rule this household with the wisdom of a just king.”

Penelope waited.

“But please,” he said, “do not ask about my family. Those memories bring me too much pain. I have wandered for many years. I have lost much.”

Penelope’s eyes grew sad.

“The gods took my beauty when my husband sailed for Troy,” she said. “If Odysseus returned, I would be honored again. My life would have meaning.”

She looked toward the dark hall.

“Instead, the nobles from Ithaca and the nearby islands surround me. They demand that I choose one of them. They eat my food, drink my wine, and waste my husband’s wealth.”

Her voice trembled.

“For years, I tried to delay them. I told them I must first weave a burial cloth for Laertes, Odysseus’s father.”

Odysseus listened without moving.

“Every day, I worked at the loom,” Penelope continued. “Every night, by torchlight, I unraveled what I had woven.”

A faint, bitter smile crossed her face.

“I deceived them for three years. But in the fourth year, my own maids betrayed me. The suitors caught me in the act and forced me to finish the cloth.”

She lowered her eyes.

“My parents urge me to marry. My son is angry because the suitors are consuming everything that belongs to him. I do not know how much longer I can resist.”

Then she looked back at the stranger.

“Now tell me the truth. Who are you?”

Odysseus took a slow breath.

“If you insist, I will tell you.”

He began a story he had prepared.

“I am from Crete, a beautiful island with many cities and many peoples. My name is Aethon. My older brother was Idomeneus, who sailed to Troy.”

Penelope listened closely.

“Before the war, Odysseus came to Crete. A storm had driven his ship off course. Idomeneus had already left for Troy, so I welcomed Odysseus into my own home.”

Odysseus spoke as if remembering every detail.

“He stayed with me for twelve days. I gave food and wine to him and his men. When the storm finally ended, they sailed away.”

Penelope’s eyes filled with tears.

Then she said, “If you truly knew my husband, tell me what he looked like. What clothes did he wear? Tell me about the men who traveled with him.”

Odysseus answered without hesitation.

“He wore a thick purple cloak, fastened at the shoulder with a golden brooch. The brooch showed a dog holding a spotted fawn between its paws.”

Penelope drew in a breath.

“His shirt was soft and bright in the sunlight,” Odysseus continued. “He had a servant with him named Eurybates. He was dark-skinned, with curly hair and rounded shoulders. Odysseus trusted him more than the others.”

Penelope could no longer hold back her tears.

“I gave him those clothes,” she whispered. “I folded them myself. I gave him that golden brooch.”

She pressed her hands to her face.

“I will never welcome him home again.”

Odysseus felt pity for her, but his face remained still.

“My lady,” he said softly, “do not destroy yourself with grief. I have heard news of Odysseus.”

Penelope looked up.

“He is alive.”

Her breath stopped.

“He is near the land of the Thesprotians,” Odysseus said. “He has gathered great treasure. His ship was destroyed after his companions offended the gods, but he survived.”

He spoke with calm certainty.

“The Phaeacians helped him. He has been traveling, gathering riches before returning home. The king of the Thesprotians told me this himself.”

Penelope stared at him.

“Odysseus will return,” he said. “Before this year is over. Before the end of this moon and the beginning of the next.”

“May it be true,” Penelope said.

But sadness returned to her face.

“I know better. He will not return. And no one in this house will give you the help you deserve.”

She called to the maids.

“Wash his feet. Prepare him a bed with blankets and rugs. At dawn, wash him again and give him oil. He will sit with Telemachus and eat.”

Then she looked at Odysseus.

“No one will insult you in this house. A good person must treat strangers with kindness. Wealth and power do not last. But people remember whether a man was just.”

Odysseus shook his head.

“I do not need blankets. I have slept on hard ground through many long nights.”

He glanced toward the maids.

“And I do not want young women washing my feet. But if there is an older woman here, one who has known suffering, I will allow her to help me.”

Penelope smiled faintly.

“There is such a woman. She cared for Odysseus from the day he was born.”

She called out, “Eurycleia, come wash this stranger’s feet. He is about the same age as your master would be now.”

Eurycleia came slowly. She looked at the stranger with deep sympathy.

“My poor child,” she said. “You must have suffered terribly. You are so much like Odysseus—in your voice, your body, even your feet.”

“Others have said the same,” Odysseus replied.

Eurycleia brought a basin. She mixed warm water and bent down before him.

Odysseus turned away from the firelight.

He remembered the scar on his leg.

Years ago, when he was young, he had visited his grandfather Autolycus on Mount Parnassus.

Autolycus had been a clever, dangerous man, famous for theft and deception. He had named the infant Odysseus because he had enemies everywhere.

When Odysseus grew older, he visited his grandfather to receive gifts.

One morning, he went hunting with Autolycus’s sons.

They climbed into the wooded hills with their hounds. In a dark thicket, they found the hiding place of a huge wild boar.

The animal burst from the brush with its bristles raised and its eyes blazing.

Young Odysseus struck first with his spear.

But the boar moved faster.

It slashed him above the knee, cutting deep into his leg.

Odysseus drove his spear into the beast’s shoulder. The boar fell and died.

His uncles bound the wound and carried him home. When it healed, it left a scar that would never disappear.

Now, as Eurycleia washed the stranger’s leg, her fingers touched that old scar.

She froze.

The foot slipped from her hands and struck the basin.

Water spilled across the floor.

Eurycleia’s eyes filled with tears.

“My child,” she whispered. “It is you. You are Odysseus.”

She reached for his beard and turned toward Penelope, ready to tell her.

But Athena had drawn Penelope’s attention away.

Odysseus caught Eurycleia by the throat and pulled her close.

“Do you want to ruin me?” he whispered fiercely. “You raised me. You held me when I was a baby. Now that I have returned after twenty years, will you betray me?”

Eurycleia shook her head.

“I would never betray you,” she said. “Nothing could make me speak. I will be silent as stone.”

Then she lowered her voice.

“When you are ready, I can tell you which women have been loyal and which have dishonored your house.”

Odysseus released her.

“Do not concern yourself with that,” he said. “I will judge them myself. Keep silent and leave the rest to the gods.”

Eurycleia fetched more water and finished washing him. Odysseus moved closer to the fire and pulled his rags over the scar.

Penelope spoke again.

“Stranger, there is one more thing I must tell you.”

Her voice was tired.

“Day and night, sorrow follows me. In the daytime, I manage this house and direct the servants, but my heart is always grieving. At night, I cannot sleep.”

She looked into the flames.

“I do not know what I should do. Should I remain here with my son and protect my husband’s estate? Or should I marry one of these men and leave this house behind?”

Then she said, “I had a dream.”

Odysseus listened.

“I keep twenty geese in the yard. I love them. In my dream, a great eagle flew down from a mountain and killed every one of them.”

Her face tightened.

“I wept until my maids gathered around me. Then the eagle returned and spoke with a human voice.”

Penelope repeated its words.

“‘Do not cry, daughter of Icarius. This is no empty dream. The geese are the suitors. I am your husband, returned at last, and I will bring them all to a shameful end.’”

She looked at Odysseus.

“When I woke, the geese were alive, eating from their trough as usual.”

Odysseus answered at once.

“The dream has only one meaning. The suitors will die. Not one of them will escape.”

Penelope shook her head slowly.

“Dreams are strange things. Some come through the gate of horn and tell the truth. Others come through the gate of ivory and deceive us.”

She rose from her chair.

“Tomorrow, I will hold a contest.”

Odysseus’s eyes narrowed.

“My husband once placed twelve axe heads in a row. Then he stood at a distance, strung his bow, and shot an arrow through every opening.”

She looked toward the hall where the bow was kept.

“I will ask the suitors to do the same. Whoever can string Odysseus’s bow and shoot through all twelve axes will become my husband. I will leave this house with him.”

Odysseus met her gaze.

“Do not delay the contest,” he said. “Odysseus will return before any of them can string that bow or send an arrow through the axes.”

Penelope studied him for a long moment.

“As long as I sit here speaking with you, I do not want to sleep,” she said. “But no one can stay awake forever.”

She turned toward the stairs.

“I will go to my room.”

Surrounded by her maids, Penelope returned upstairs.

There, she wept again for her lost husband.

At last, Athena laid sweet sleep over her tired eyes.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!