The Thirteen Virtues

Chapter 9 of 19 · 4,086 words · Free

Around this time, I came up with what seemed like a bold and difficult goal: I wanted to become as morally perfect as possible.

I wanted to live without knowingly doing anything wrong. I wanted to overcome every bad habit or weakness that came from my natural impulses, my upbringing, or the people around me.

I believed I already knew the difference between right and wrong. So I thought, If I know what is right, why can't I simply always do it?

I soon discovered that it was much harder than I had imagined.

Whenever I focused on avoiding one fault, another would catch me off guard.

Sometimes an old habit took over before I even noticed it.

At other times, my desires were simply stronger than my reason.

Eventually, I realized that merely knowing that virtue was in my own best interest was not enough. Good behavior had to become a habit, while bad habits had to be broken.

So I developed a system to train myself.

As I read about morality, I noticed that different writers listed different numbers of virtues. They also gave the same virtue different meanings.

For example, some writers used "Temperance" only to mean eating and drinking moderately. Others used it more broadly, applying it to every kind of pleasure, desire, passion, greed, and ambition.

For the sake of clarity, I decided to use more names and give each name a simple, specific meaning.

I came up with thirteen virtues that I considered necessary or desirable. I also gave each one a short rule.

  1. Temperance

Eat only enough to stay healthy and alert. Don't drink so much that you lose control.

  1. Silence

Speak only when your words can help you or someone else. Avoid pointless conversation.

  1. Order

Keep everything in its proper place. Give every part of your work its proper time.

  1. Resolution

Decide to do what you know you should do, and then carry out your decisions without fail.

  1. Frugality

Spend money only when it benefits yourself or others. Waste nothing.

  1. Industry

Waste no time. Always be doing something useful, and eliminate unnecessary activities.

  1. Sincerity

Never deceive others in a harmful way. Think honestly and fairly, and speak according to what you truly believe.

  1. Justice

Do not hurt anyone, either by doing them harm or by refusing to give them something you owe them.

  1. Moderation

Avoid extremes. When someone wrongs you, do not become more angry than the situation deserves.

  1. Cleanliness

Keep your body, clothes, and home clean.

  1. Tranquillity

Do not let small annoyances or ordinary accidents disturb your peace of mind.

  1. Chastity

Use sex mainly for health or having children. Never let it weaken you, distract you, damage your peace of mind, or harm your reputation or someone else's.

  1. Humility

Follow the examples of Jesus and Socrates.

My goal was to make all thirteen virtues habitual.

But I knew I could not focus on all of them at once. So I decided to work on one virtue at a time.

Once I had gained control over one, I would move on to the next, until I had worked through all thirteen.

I arranged them in the order that seemed most useful.

I put Temperance first because eating and drinking moderately would help me keep a clear and calm mind. I would need that clarity if I wanted to stay alert against old habits and constant temptations.

Once Temperance became a habit, Silence should become easier.

I also wanted to gain knowledge while improving my character. Since people learn more by listening than by talking, I wanted to break my growing habit of chatting, making jokes, and playing with words merely to entertain people.

That was why I placed Silence second.

Silence and Order should also give me more time for study and for the whole project.

Resolution would strengthen my determination to acquire all the remaining virtues.

Frugality and Industry would help me pay off my debts and eventually become financially independent.

Once I had achieved that, practicing Sincerity and Justice should become easier.

I also remembered the advice of Pythagoras, who recommended examining yourself every day.

So I created a system for doing exactly that.

I made a small notebook and gave each virtue its own page.

On every page, I drew seven columns, one for each day of the week. Then I drew thirteen horizontal lines, one for each virtue.

Every evening, I would examine my behavior that day.

Whenever I found that I had violated one of the virtues, I would put a small black mark in the appropriate place.

For example, on the page for Temperance, the first line represented Temperance itself. If I had eaten too much or drunk too much that day, I would put a mark there.

I planned to spend one entire week concentrating on the first virtue.

During that week, my main goal would be to avoid even the smallest violation of Temperance.

I would still pay attention to the other virtues, but I would not actively concentrate on them. I would simply record whatever mistakes I made each evening.

If I could get through the first week without a single mark on the Temperance line, I would consider the habit stronger and the opposite habit weaker.

Then I would add Silence to my daily focus.

The next week, I would try to keep both the Temperance and Silence lines clean.

I would continue in this way until I reached all thirteen virtues.

That meant I could complete one full cycle in thirteen weeks and, in theory, go through four complete cycles every year.

I thought of it like taking care of a garden.

If you have a garden full of weeds, you don't try to pull out every weed at the same time. That would be too much work.

Instead, you clear one bed first.

Once it is clean, you move on to the next.

I hoped my notebook would give me the same encouragement.

Each time I completed a virtue, I would see fewer and fewer black marks on its line.

Eventually, after repeating the process many times, I hoped to look at the book and see every page completely clean.

I put several quotations in the little book as reminders of what I was trying to achieve.

One came from Addison's Cato:

"Here will I hold. If there's a power above us
(And that there is, all nature cries aloud
Thro' all His works), He must delight in virtue;
And that which He delights in must be happy."

I also included a passage from Cicero praising philosophy as the guide of life and the discoverer and destroyer of vice.

Another quotation came from the Proverbs of Solomon:

"Length of days is in her right hand, and in her left hand riches and honour. Her ways are ways of pleasantness, and all her paths are peace."

Since I believed God was the source of wisdom, I also thought I should ask Him for help.

So I wrote a short prayer and placed it at the beginning of my daily examination:

"Powerful and generous Father, merciful Guide, increase in me the wisdom that shows me what is truly in my best interest. Strengthen my determination to follow that wisdom. Accept the good I do for others as the only return I can give for all the blessings You continually give me."

Sometimes I also used a prayer from Thomson's poems:

"Father of light and life, thou Good Supreme!
O teach me what is good; teach me Thyself!
Save me from folly, vanity, and vice,
From every low pursuit; and fill my soul
With knowledge, conscious peace, and virtue pure."

Because Order required me to give every part of my work a fixed time, I also created a daily schedule for myself.

I would begin the morning by asking myself:

"What good shall I do today?"

Then I would get up, wash, pray, plan my work, choose the main thing I intended to accomplish that day, study, and eat breakfast.

From eight until noon, I would work.

At noon, I would read or check my accounts, then have lunch.

From two until five, I would work again.

In the evening, I would ask myself:

"What good have I done today?"

Then I would put everything back where it belonged, eat supper, and spend some time with music, conversation, or another form of recreation.

Finally, I would examine my behavior for the day and go to bed at ten.

I began following this system of self-examination and continued it for quite some time, although I occasionally stopped for a while.

I was surprised to discover that I had far more faults than I had imagined.

Still, I was pleased to see that the number of faults gradually decreased.

My original notebook eventually became worn out. Whenever I wanted to start another thirteen-week cycle, I had to erase the old marks to make room for new ones, and eventually the pages became full of holes.

So I transferred the whole system to a small notebook with ivory pages.

I drew the lines with red ink, which left a permanent mark.

Then I used a pencil to record my faults. The pencil marks could easily be erased with a damp sponge.

After some time, I went through the thirteen-week program only once a year.

Later, I did it only once every several years.

Eventually, I stopped doing it altogether.

My travels and business abroad took up more and more of my time, and public affairs added even more responsibilities.

But I always carried the little notebook with me.

Of all the virtues, Order gave me the most trouble.

I eventually realized that strict Order might be possible for someone whose work allowed him to control his own schedule, such as a journeyman printer.

But it was much harder for a business owner who had to deal with people and meet them whenever their business required.

Keeping things in their proper places was just as difficult.

I had never developed that habit when I was young.

And because I had an unusually good memory, I did not immediately feel the disadvantages of being disorganized.

As a result, Order required enormous effort from me.

My repeated failures frustrated me.

I made very little progress, fell back into my old habits again and again, and eventually I was almost ready to give up.

I began to think I might simply have to accept that I was a disorganized person.

It reminded me of a man who once bought an axe from a blacksmith who lived near me.

The man wanted the entire axe to be as shiny as its cutting edge.

The blacksmith agreed to polish it, but only if the man would turn the grinding wheel himself.

So the man began turning the wheel while the blacksmith pressed the broad side of the axe hard against the stone.

It was exhausting work.

Every now and then, the man stopped turning the wheel and came over to see how much progress had been made.

Eventually, he became tired and decided to take the axe as it was.

"No," said the blacksmith. "Keep turning. We'll have it bright soon. Right now it's only speckled."

"Yes," the man replied, "but I think I like a speckled axe better."

I believe many people make the same choice.

When they discover how difficult it is to break bad habits and build good ones, they eventually convince themselves that perfection is unnecessary.

They decide that being "good enough" is better.

I had thoughts like that myself.

Sometimes I wondered whether demanding such extreme perfection from myself was simply a foolish kind of moral vanity.

Perhaps people would laugh at me if they knew how strict I was trying to be.

Perhaps being too virtuous would make people jealous or resentful.

Perhaps a kind person should allow himself a few faults so that his friends would not feel bad about their own weaknesses.

The truth is, I never managed to conquer my disorderliness.

Now that I am old and my memory has become weaker, I feel the consequences of it very clearly.

Still, despite my failures, the effort made me a better and happier man than I would otherwise have been.

It is like someone trying to learn beautiful handwriting by copying perfect engraved letters.

He may never reproduce them exactly.

But the effort improves his handwriting, and what he produces can still become neat and readable.

I think my descendants should know that, with God's blessing, this little system helped give me a happy and steady life well into my seventy-ninth year, which is the age I am at while writing this.

Whatever happens during the rest of my life is in God's hands.

If misfortune comes, remembering the happiness I have already enjoyed should help me face it with greater patience.

I credit Temperance with much of my long-lasting health and the strength of my constitution.

I credit Industry and Frugality with helping me become financially comfortable early in life and build my fortune.

They also gave me the opportunity to gain the knowledge that allowed me to serve my community and earn some respect among educated people.

I credit Sincerity and Justice with earning the trust of my country and the honorable public positions it later gave me.

And I believe that all thirteen virtues together, even though I never mastered them perfectly, helped give me the calm temperament and cheerful manner that made people enjoy my company, including many younger people.

I therefore hope that some of my descendants will follow this example and enjoy the same benefits.

It should be noted that my system did contain a religious element, but it did not belong to any particular religious sect.

I deliberately kept it that way.

I was convinced that my method was useful and that people of different religions could benefit from it.

I also hoped to publish it someday, so I did not want to include anything that might make people from another religious tradition reject the whole idea.

I intended to write a short explanation of each virtue.

I would explain the benefits of having the virtue and the harm caused by its opposite vice.

I planned to call the book The Art of Virtue.

The purpose would be to explain exactly how a person could develop virtue, rather than merely telling people to "be good."

Simply telling hungry or naked people that they should be fed and clothed is not enough.

You also have to show them where and how they can obtain food and clothing.

Unfortunately, I never completed the book.

From time to time, I wrote down short notes about the ideas, arguments, and explanations I wanted to include.

I still have some of those notes.

But during the early part of my life, my private business required too much attention.

Later, my public responsibilities took up even more of my time.

The book was also connected in my mind with a much larger project that would have required my complete attention.

A series of unexpected public duties kept preventing me from working on it.

So the project has remained unfinished.

My purpose in writing the book was to explain one basic idea:

Bad actions are not harmful merely because someone has forbidden them.

They are forbidden because they are harmful.

If we look simply at human nature, we can see that living virtuously is in everyone's own interest if they want to be happy, even in this life.

I also wanted to make young people understand that honesty and integrity could be among the most powerful ways for a poor person to improve his position.

The world always needs honest people.

Rich merchants, noblemen, governments, and princes constantly need trustworthy people to manage their affairs.

And truly honest people are rare.

So a young person with little money but strong integrity could have opportunities that a dishonest person might never receive.

When I first created my list, it contained only twelve virtues.

Then a Quaker friend kindly told me something I had not realized.

He said that people generally thought I was proud.

He had noticed that my pride often appeared in conversation.

Whenever I argued about something, I was not satisfied simply with proving that I was right.

I tended to dominate the discussion and sometimes even became rude.

He gave me several examples, and I had to admit that he was right.

So I decided to work on this weakness too.

I added Humility as the thirteenth virtue and gave the word a broad meaning.

I cannot claim that I truly became humble.

But I became much better at appearing humble.

I made a rule never to directly contradict another person's opinion or state my own opinion as absolute fact.

I even brought back one of the old rules from our Junto meetings.

I avoided words such as "certainly" and "undoubtedly," because they made it sound as if I believed I could not possibly be wrong.

Instead, I began saying things like:

"I think..."

"I believe..."

"It seems to me..."

"I may be mistaken, but..."

When someone said something I believed was wrong, I resisted the temptation to immediately attack the argument and point out its absurdity.

Instead, I would begin by saying that in certain circumstances the person's opinion might be correct, but that in the present situation I saw things somewhat differently.

I soon discovered how useful this change was.

My conversations became much more pleasant.

Because I presented my opinions modestly, people were more willing to listen to them and less likely to argue simply because they felt challenged.

When I was wrong, I felt less embarrassed.

And when I was right, I found it much easier to persuade other people to reconsider their mistakes.

What began as an unnatural effort eventually became completely natural to me.

In fact, this habit became so deeply ingrained that for perhaps fifty years, no one has heard me speak in a dogmatic way.

I believe this habit, together with my reputation for honesty, was a major reason why I gained influence among my fellow citizens.

When I proposed new institutions or suggested changes to old ones, people were often willing to listen.

Later, when I became involved in public councils, I was often able to persuade people to support my proposals.

This was somewhat surprising because I was not a good speaker.

I was never eloquent.

I often hesitated while searching for the right words.

My language was not always grammatically correct.

Yet I usually managed to get people to accept my ideas.

Of all our natural passions, pride may be the hardest to conquer.

You can hide it.

Fight it.

Push it down.

Try to silence it.

Humiliate it.

But it never completely dies.

Every now and then, it comes back and shows itself.

You may even notice it throughout this very history.

Because even if I could convince myself that I had completely conquered my pride, I would probably become proud of how humble I had become.

The Plan for a Society of Virtue

I wrote this much while living in Passy in 1784.

I returned to the subject at home in August 1788.

Unfortunately, many of my papers had been lost during the war, so I could not rely on all the notes I had expected to find.

Still, I managed to recover some of them.

Earlier, I mentioned that I had conceived a great and ambitious project.

It seems appropriate now to explain what that project was.

The earliest record I can find of the idea is a short paper I happened to preserve.

It was dated May 19, 1731, and began with some observations I had made while reading history in the library.

I wrote:

"Great events in the world—wars, revolutions, and political changes—are usually carried out by parties.

"Each party believes it is acting in pursuit of what it considers its general interest.

"Because different parties have different interests, they create confusion.

"Even while a party is working toward a common goal, each individual member usually has his own private interests in mind.

"Once the party achieves its main objective, its members turn their attention to their individual interests.

"Those interests then begin to conflict with one another, breaking the party into factions and creating even more confusion.

"Very few people in public affairs act purely for the good of their country, no matter what they claim.

"Even when their actions genuinely benefit their country, they usually believe that their own interests and their country's interests are connected. They are not acting purely out of concern for others.

"Even fewer people in public affairs act for the good of humanity as a whole.

"It seems to me that there is a great need for a United Party for Virtue.

"It would bring together virtuous and good people from every nation and organize them into a disciplined society governed by wise and honorable rules.

"I believe good and virtuous people might actually be more willing to obey such rules than ordinary people are willing to obey ordinary laws.

"I believe that anyone who attempts such a project in the right way, and who is properly qualified to lead it, would please God and have a good chance of succeeding."

I kept thinking about this idea as something I might undertake later, once I had enough free time.

Whenever a new thought occurred to me, I wrote it down on a piece of paper.

Most of those notes were eventually lost.

But I still have one that describes what I intended to be a simple creed.

I wanted it to contain the essential beliefs shared by all major religions, while leaving out anything that might offend people of any particular faith.

It stated:

"There is one God, who created everything.

"He governs the world through His providence.

"He should be worshiped through prayer, praise, and thanksgiving.

"But the service God values most is doing good for other people.

"The human soul is immortal.

"And God will certainly reward virtue and punish vice, either in this life or in the next."

At that time, I imagined that the society should begin among young, unmarried men.

Anyone who wanted to join would first have to accept this basic creed.

But that alone would not be enough.

He would also have to complete the same thirteen-week program of self-examination and practice that I had developed.

I thought the existence of the society should initially be kept secret.

Otherwise, unsuitable people might constantly ask to join.

Instead, each member would quietly look among his acquaintances for young men who were intelligent, honest, and well-intentioned.

Then, with care and discretion, he could gradually introduce them to the idea.

The members would promise to help one another.

They would offer advice, assistance, and support whenever another member needed help with business, personal advancement, or other important matters.

I imagined calling the organization The Society of the Free and Easy.

"Free" would mean free from the control of vice because its members had trained themselves to practice virtue.

And through Industry and Frugality, they would also become free from debt.

Debt can place a person in confinement and make him, in effect, a slave to his creditors.

That is about as much of the project as I can remember now.

I did tell two young men about part of the idea, and they became enthusiastic about it.

But at the time, I had very little money and had to devote myself closely to my business.

So I postponed the project.

Then my many public and private responsibilities gave me even more reasons to postpone it.

Eventually, I kept putting it off until I was too old and weak to undertake such a major enterprise.

Even so, I still believe the plan could have worked.

It might have produced a large number of good and useful citizens.

The size of the project never frightened me.

I have always believed that one person with reasonable ability can accomplish great things and even bring about major changes in society.

But there is one condition.

He must first create a good plan.

Then he must eliminate distractions and unnecessary activities.

After that, he must make carrying out the plan his main study, his main work, and the central purpose of his life.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!