← The Blue Castle 2026 Edition
Chapter 42 · The Truth Barney Had Been Hiding

The Truth Barney Had Been Hiding

Chapter 42 of 45 · 2,878 words · Free

It was early the next afternoon when an ancient, noisy car came clattering up Elm Street and stopped in front of the brick house.

A man without a hat jumped out and hurried up the steps.

He slammed the doorbell so hard and so urgently that Uncle Benjamin hurried to answer it.

He had been waiting for this.

Earlier that day, Uncle Benjamin had “just happened to drop in” to ask how dear Doss—Valancy—was doing.

He had been told that Valancy was exactly the same.

She had come down for breakfast, but had not eaten anything. Then she had gone back upstairs.

She had come down for dinner, but had not eaten that either. Then she had returned to her room.

She had said almost nothing.

Everyone had wisely left her alone.

“Very good,” Uncle Benjamin had said. “Redfern will be here today.”

And now his prediction had come true.

Barney was standing at the door.

“Is my wife here?” he demanded.

Uncle Benjamin gave him a knowing smile.

“Mr. Redfern, I presume? Very pleased to meet you. Yes, that naughty little girl of yours is here. We’ve been—”

“I want to see her.”

Barney cut him off without the slightest hesitation.

“Of course. Come in. Valancy will be down in a minute.”

Uncle Benjamin led him into the parlor, then hurried into the sitting room to find Mrs. Frederick.

“Go upstairs and tell Valancy her husband is here.”

But Uncle Benjamin wasn't at all sure Valancy would actually come down in a minute.

So he quietly followed Mrs. Frederick upstairs and waited in the hall.

Mrs. Frederick knocked gently on Valancy's door.

“Valancy, dear, your husband is here. He wants to see you.”

Valancy had been standing by the window.

She turned around and wrung her hands.

“Oh, Mother. I can't see him. I can't. Tell him to leave. Please ask him to go away. I can't see him.”

Uncle Benjamin leaned toward the keyhole and whispered loudly enough for her to hear.

“Tell her Redfern says he won't leave until he sees her.”

Barney had said no such thing.

But Uncle Benjamin knew enough about him to believe it was probably true.

Valancy knew it too.

There was no point in delaying.

She walked past Uncle Benjamin without even looking at him.

He didn't mind.

He rubbed his hands together happily and went downstairs to the kitchen.

There he cheerfully asked Cousin Stickles:

“Why are good husbands like bread?”

Cousin Stickles looked at him suspiciously.

“Why?”

“Because women need them.”

Uncle Benjamin beamed.

Meanwhile, Valancy entered the parlor.

She looked terrible.

The sleepless night had left her face pale and exhausted. She was wearing an old brown-and-blue gingham dress because she had left all her nice clothes behind at the Blue Castle.

Barney didn't seem to notice any of that.

He rushed across the room and pulled her into his arms.

“Valancy, darling! You little idiot! What on earth possessed you to run away like that?”

“When I came home last night and found your letter, I nearly went mad. It was already midnight, so I knew it was too late to come here. I walked around all night.”

“Then Dad came this morning, and I couldn't leave until now.”

“What got into you, Valancy?”

“Divorce, for goodness' sake! Don't you understand—”

“I know you only married me because you felt sorry for me,” Valancy interrupted weakly.

“I know you don't love me. I know—”

“You've spent too long lying awake at three in the morning,” Barney said, giving her a little shake.

“That's what's wrong with you.”

“Love you? Don't you know I love you?”

“When I saw that train coming toward you, I knew exactly how I felt.”

Valancy's eyes filled with tears.

“Oh, I knew you'd try to make me believe you cared about me.”

“Don't, Barney. Please don't.”

“I know all about Ethel Traverse. Your father told me everything.”

“Please don't torture me.”

“I can never go back to you.”

Barney slowly let her go.

He stared at her pale, determined face.

Something in her expression told him she truly meant it.

“Valancy,” he said quietly, “my father couldn't have told you everything.”

“He didn't know everything.”

“Will you let me tell you the whole story?”

“Yes,” she whispered.

She was exhausted.

And oh, how much she wanted to believe him.

She wanted to throw herself into his arms.

As he gently helped her into a chair, she could barely stop herself from reaching for his hands.

She couldn't look at him.

She was afraid that if she met his eyes, all her courage would disappear.

She knew Barney.

He was kind. He was generous. He had always put other people's needs before his own.

Of course he would pretend that he didn't want his freedom.

He felt sorry for her.

He understood how terrible her situation was.

He always understood her.

But she would never allow him to sacrifice his life for her.

Never.

“You've met Dad,” Barney began, “so you know that I'm Bernard Redfern.”

“And I suppose you've figured out that I'm John Foster too, since you went into Bluebeard's Chamber.”

“Yes.”

“But I didn't go in because I was curious. I'd forgotten that you told me not to go in.”

“Never mind.”

“I'm not going to murder you and hang you on the wall, so there's no need to call Sister Anne.”

“I only want to tell you everything from the beginning.”

“I came home last night planning to tell you.”

“Yes, I'm old Doc Redfern's son. The famous Purple Pills and Bitters man.”

“Oh, believe me, I know it.”

“My father reminded me of it often enough.”

Barney laughed bitterly.

He walked back and forth across the room.

Uncle Benjamin, listening from the hall, heard the laugh and frowned.

Surely Doss wasn't going to be foolish enough to reject this man.

Barney finally sat down.

“Yes. As far back as I can remember, I've been the son of a millionaire.”

“But when I was born, Dad wasn't a millionaire.”

“He wasn't even a doctor.”

“He was a veterinarian, and not a very successful one.”

“He and Mother lived in a tiny village in Quebec. They were terribly poor.”

“I don't remember Mother at all.”

“I don't even have a picture of her.”

“She died when I was two.”

“She was only fifteen years younger than Father. She had been a schoolteacher.”

“After she died, Dad moved to Montreal and started a company to sell his hair tonic.”

“He said he'd dreamed up the formula one night.”

“It became a huge success.”

“Then he invented—or dreamed up—the Pills, Bitters, Liniment, and all the rest.”

“By the time I was ten, he was a millionaire.”

“We lived in a house so enormous that I always felt lost inside it.”

“I had every toy a boy could possibly want.”

“And I was the loneliest child in the world.”

“I remember only one happy day from my childhood, Valancy.”

“Just one.”

“You were better off than I was.”

“Dad went to visit an old friend in the country and took me with him.”

“He let me run around the barnyard all day.”

“I spent hours hammering nails into a piece of wood.”

“It was wonderful.”

“When we went back to that huge house in Montreal, I cried.”

“But I never told Dad why.”

“I never told him anything.”

“It's always been difficult for me to talk about things that matter to me.”

“And most things mattered very deeply.”

“I was a sensitive child.”

“I became an even more sensitive boy.”

“No one ever knew how much I suffered.”

“Dad certainly never understood.”

“When he sent me to a private school, I was only eleven.”

“The boys grabbed me and dunked me into the swimming tank.”

“They wouldn't let me out until I stood on a table and read all the advertisements for Father's ridiculous patent medicines aloud.”

“I did it.”

“I was terrified, half drowned, and completely alone.”

“But when I went to college and the older students tried the same trick, I refused.”

Barney smiled grimly.

“They couldn't make me do it.”

“But they could make my life miserable.”

“And they did.”

“I never escaped the jokes about the Pills, the Bitters, and the Hair Tonic.”

“‘After using’ became my nickname.”

“You see, I'd always had such thick hair.”

“My four years at college were a nightmare.”

“You may not know how cruel boys can be when they find someone they can make fun of.”

“I had very few friends.”

“There was always some wall between me and the people I actually liked.”

“The other sort of people wanted to be close to the rich old Doc Redfern's son.”

“But I had no interest in them.”

“I did have one friend.”

“Or at least I thought I did.”

“He was clever and loved books.”

“He wanted to become a writer.”

“That was something we had in common.”

“I had secret dreams of becoming a writer too.”

“He was older than me, and I admired him enormously.”

“For one year, I was happier than I'd ever been.”

“Then a parody appeared in the college magazine.”

“It was a vicious little story making fun of Father's medicines.”

“They changed the names, of course.”

“But everyone knew exactly who it was about.”

“It was clever.”

“Too clever.”

“Everyone at McGill was laughing about it.”

“Then I discovered who had written it.”

Valancy's tired eyes suddenly flashed with anger.

“Are you sure?”

“Yes.”

“I asked him.”

“He admitted it.”

“He said a good idea was worth more to him than a friend.”

“And then he said something even worse.”

“He told me there were some things money couldn't buy.”

“Like a grandfather.”

Barney smiled bitterly.

“That hurt.”

“I was young enough to be deeply wounded by it.”

“But the worst part was that it destroyed many of the things I'd believed about people.”

“After that, I became a bitter young man.”

“I didn't want friends anymore.”

“Then, the year after I left college, I met Ethel Traverse.”

Valancy shivered.

Barney didn't notice.

He was staring down at the floor.

“My father probably told you about her.”

“She was beautiful.”

“And I loved her.”

“I really did.”

“I won't deny that now.”

“It was the first great love of a lonely, romantic young man.”

“And it was completely real to me.”

“I thought she loved me too.”

“I was foolish enough to believe that.”

“When she agreed to marry me, I was happier than I'd ever been.”

“For a few months.”

“Then I discovered the truth.”

“I accidentally overheard a conversation.”

“I only heard a few words.”

“But that was enough.”

“A friend of hers asked how she could possibly stand being with Doc Redfern's son and his awful patent-medicine family.”

“Ethel laughed.”

“‘His money will make the Pills respectable and the Bitters taste better,’ she said.”

“‘Mother told me to catch him if I could. We're broke.’”

“‘But honestly, I can smell turpentine whenever he comes near me.’”

“Oh, Barney!”

Valancy's heart broke for him.

She had completely forgotten her own misery.

How could Ethel have been so cruel?

Barney got up and began walking around the room.

“That was the end of me.”

“I left civilization behind.”

“I went to the Yukon.”

“For five years, I wandered around the world.”

“I lived in all sorts of strange places.”

“I earned enough money to survive.”

“I refused to touch a single cent of Dad's money.”

“Then one day I realized I didn't care about Ethel anymore.”

“Not even a little.”

“She was simply someone I'd known in another life.”

“But I didn't want to return to my old life.”

“I was free.”

“And I intended to stay free.”

“Eventually I came to Mistawis.”

“I saw Tom MacMurray's island.”

“My first book had been published the year before and had done surprisingly well.”

“I had some money from the royalties.”

“So I bought the island.”

“But I stayed away from people.”

“I didn't trust anyone.”

“I didn't believe real friendship existed.”

“I didn't believe true love existed either.”

“Not for someone like me.”

“Not for the son of Purple Pills.”

“I actually enjoyed all the wild stories people told about me.”

“I even encouraged some of them.”

“I'd make mysterious remarks, and people would invent the rest themselves.”

“Then you came.”

“I had to believe you loved me.”

“You couldn't possibly want to marry me for my father's money.”

“I was supposed to be a penniless, dangerous devil.”

“So there was no other explanation.”

“And yes, I felt sorry for you.”

“I won't lie about that.”

“I did marry you because I felt sorry for you.”

“But then I discovered what you were really like.”

“You became the best friend a man could ever have.”

“You were funny.”

“You were loyal.”

“You were warm and sweet.”

“You made me believe again that friendship and love were real.”

“The world seemed like a good place simply because you were in it.”

“I would have been happy to live with you forever exactly as we were.”

“I realized that the night I came home and saw the light shining from our island.”

“I knew you were there waiting for me.”

“After spending my whole life without a real home, it felt wonderful.”

“To come home hungry and know there would be a hot meal, a warm fire, and you.”

“But I didn't understand how much you meant to me until that moment beside the railway switch.”

“Then everything became clear.”

“I knew I couldn't live without you.”

“If I couldn't pull you away from that train, I knew I'd have to die with you.”

“It shocked me.”

“I couldn't think straight afterward.”

“That's why I behaved like a complete idiot.”

“But the thought that drove me into the woods was the thought that you were going to die.”

“I'd always been afraid of losing you.”

“But I'd believed there was nothing I could do about it.”

“Then suddenly I had to face the truth.”

“You were supposedly dying.”

“And I couldn't live without you.”

“When I came home last night, I'd already decided to take you to every specialist I could find.”

“There had to be something they could do.”

“I couldn't believe you were really as sick as Dr. Trent claimed.”

“Not after what happened on the railway.”

“And then I found your note.”

“I was overwhelmed with happiness.”

“And terrified.”

“I thought perhaps you didn't love me after all.”

“I thought you'd left because you wanted to escape from me.”

“But now you're here.”

“So everything is all right, isn't it, darling?”

Valancy stared at him.

Darling?

Was he really calling her darling?

“I can't believe you love me,” she whispered.

“You can't.”

“What's the point, Barney?”

“Of course you feel sorry for me.”

“Of course you want to fix everything.”

“But you can't fix it by loving me.”

“You couldn't possibly love me.”

She stood and pointed toward the mirror above the fireplace.

“Look at me.”

“Even Allan Tierney couldn't find anything beautiful in that face.”

Barney didn't even glance at the mirror.

He stared only at Valancy.

“Love you?”

“You're the very center of my heart.”

“I keep you there like something precious.”

“Didn't I promise never to lie to you?”

“Love you?”

“I love you with everything I have.”

“My heart.”

“My soul.”

“My mind.”

“Every part of me.”

“There is no one else in the world for me.”

“There is only you, Valancy.”

“You're a very good actor, Barney.”

Valancy gave him a faint smile.

Barney stared at her.

“You still don't believe me?”

“I—I can't.”

“Oh, damn!”

Valancy jumped.

She had never seen this side of Barney.

His face had gone deathly white.

His eyes were black with anger.

His lips curled into a bitter sneer.

“You don't want to believe me.”

“You're tired of me.”

“You want to be free.”

“You're ashamed of the Pills and the Liniment, just like Ethel was.”

“Your proud Stirling family can't stand being connected to old Doc Redfern's son.”

“It was fine when you thought you were dying.”

“Being married to me was an amusing little adventure.”

“But spending your whole life with the son of old Doc Redfern?”

“That is something else.”

“I understand now.”

“I've been blind.”

“But now I understand everything.”

Valancy stared at him.

Then, suddenly, she laughed.

“You darling!”

“You really mean it!”

“You really do love me!”

“You wouldn't be this angry if you didn't.”

Barney stared at her for a moment.

Then he swept her into his arms.

He gave a soft, low laugh—the laugh of a man who had finally won the woman he loved.

Outside the parlor, Uncle Benjamin had been listening at the keyhole in complete horror.

Now he finally relaxed.

He hurried back to Mrs. Frederick and Cousin Stickles.

“Everything is all right!” he announced happily.

Dear little Doss.

He would send for his lawyer immediately and change his will once again.

Valancy would be his only heir.

She deserved every penny.

Mrs. Frederick, once again comforted by her firm belief in Providence, took out the family Bible.

She opened it to the page marked “Marriages” and carefully wrote down the date.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!