← The Republic 2026 Edition
Chapter 9 · The Tyrannical Man and the Misery of Uncontrolled Desire

The Tyrannical Man and the Misery of Uncontrolled Desire

Chapter 9 of 10 · 2,901 words · Free

“Glaucon, we have reached the final type of person we must examine—the tyrannical man. We must discover how he develops from the democratic man, and whether his life is happy or miserable.”

“Yes,” Glaucon replied. “He is the only type we have not yet discussed.”

“Before we continue,” I said, “there is still one question we have not fully answered.”

“What question?”

“We have not clearly defined the nature and number of human desires. Until we understand them, our investigation will remain unclear.”

“That is true,” he said. “We can still correct that mistake.”

“Very well. Consider this. Some unnecessary pleasures and desires are not lawful or proper. Almost everyone experiences them, but in some people reason and good habits control them. Their better desires overcome the lower ones, so those desires either disappear completely or become weak and rare. But in others, these desires become stronger and more numerous.”

“Which desires do you mean?”

“I mean the desires that appear when reason is asleep. When the rational part of a person rests, the wild creature inside him awakens. After being filled with food and drink, it breaks free from restraint and seeks to satisfy every impulse. At such a time, there is no madness or crime that he might not imagine—even acts like incest, unnatural relationships, murder of family members, or forbidden actions that a person would never consider while guided by reason.”

“That is certainly true,” said Glaucon.

“But when a person lives moderately, keeps his body healthy, and before sleep awakens his rational mind with noble thoughts and reflection, things are different. After satisfying his physical needs neither excessively nor insufficiently, he allows his desires to rest. Then his higher mind remains free, able to think about truth and pursue wisdom.”

“Yes,” he said.

“And if he has calmed his anger and passions, and then awakens reason before sleeping, he reaches the closest point to truth and is least troubled by wild and meaningless dreams.”

“I agree completely.”

“Although I have gone slightly off the path of our discussion, remember this point: even the best people have a lawless and savage side hidden within them. It appears in dreams when reason is no longer watching.”

“That is true,” Glaucon agreed.

“Now recall the democratic man we described. He was raised by a father who valued money above everything else. His father encouraged the desires that produced wealth but rejected unnecessary pleasures and luxuries.”

“Yes.”

“Later, this young man met people who lived in a more refined but uncontrolled way. He became attracted to their pleasures and moved toward the opposite extreme because he hated his father’s cold greed. However, because he was better than the people who influenced him, he eventually settled somewhere in the middle. He lived a life of moderate pleasure rather than complete corruption.”

“That was our description of him.”

“Now imagine that many years pass, and this democratic man has a son who is raised according to his father’s beliefs.”

“I can imagine it.”

“Then imagine the same thing happening to the son that happened to the father. He is drawn toward a completely lawless life, which his companions call true freedom. His father and friends support his moderate desires, while others encourage his wild impulses.”

“Yes.”

“When these people who create tyrants see that they are losing influence over him, they plant inside him one overwhelming desire—the desire to rule all others. It becomes the master of all his careless and wasteful passions. It is like a huge winged drone that dominates his soul.”

“That is the perfect image,” said Glaucon.

“And when all his other desires surround this creature with perfumes, celebrations, wine, pleasures, and temptations, feeding the desire that lives inside him, then this ruler of the soul becomes completely controlled by madness.”

“Yes.”

“If any sense of shame or goodness remains within him, these better qualities are driven away until only madness remains.”

“That is how the tyrannical man is born.”

“Is this not why people in ancient times called love a tyrant?”

“I would not be surprised.”

“And a drunken man also has something tyrannical in his soul, does he not?”

“Yes.”

“A person who has lost control of his mind may even believe he can rule not only human beings but the gods themselves.”

“Certainly.”

“Then the true tyrannical man appears when, through nature, habit, or both, he becomes filled with drunkenness, uncontrolled desire, and violent passion.”

“Without doubt.”

“This is his origin. Now let us ask how he lives.”

“Tell me,” said Glaucon.

“I imagine that his life becomes filled with feasts, drinking, celebrations, lovers, and every kind of pleasure. Love becomes the master inside his soul and commands everything.”

“That must be so.”

“And every day and every night new desires appear. They become countless and powerful.”

“Yes.”

“Soon, if he has money, he spends all of it.”

“Of course.”

“Then comes debt, and eventually he loses his property.”

“Certainly.”

“When he has nothing left, his desires gather inside him like hungry young birds demanding food. Driven especially by love, which has become their leader, he desperately searches for ways to steal or cheat others so that he can satisfy them.”

“That is inevitable.”

“He must obtain money by any means, because otherwise he will suffer terrible pain.”

“Yes.”

“And just as his newer pleasures once defeated his older ones, now he will believe he deserves more than his parents. If he has already wasted his own inheritance, he will try to take theirs.”

“Without question.”

“If his parents refuse, he will first deceive them.”

“True.”

“And if deception fails, he will use force.”

“Most likely.”

“Even against his own parents?”

“I would not want to believe it,” Glaucon said.

“But imagine, Adeimantus. Because of some new lover who means nothing compared with his mother—the person who gave him life—would he not be capable of turning against her? Would he not place this new person above his own mother?”

“Yes,” he replied. “A person like this could do such things.”

“Then a tyrannical son becomes a terrible burden to his parents.”

“Indeed.”

“First he takes their wealth. When that disappears, his desires become even stronger. Then he turns to theft, robbery, and even crimes against sacred places. The beliefs about right and wrong that he learned as a child are destroyed. Those old beliefs once controlled his desires, but now his passions have escaped and become the guards of love.”

“Yes.”

“In his democratic youth, these desires appeared only in dreams. But now, under the rule of desire, he becomes in waking life what he once was only in dreams. He is capable of the worst actions.”

“Exactly.”

“Love becomes his tyrant. Like a ruler who forces a city to obey him, love forces his soul to commit any reckless act necessary to maintain power.”

“That is a perfect picture of his life.”

“If there are only a few such people in a city, and most citizens remain decent, they often leave and become bodyguards or soldiers for another tyrant. If there is no war, they remain in the city and create trouble.”

“What kind of trouble?”

“They become thieves, robbers, kidnappers, temple criminals, and other enemies of society. If they are skilled with words, they become false accusers and dishonest witnesses who accept bribes.”

“A long list of crimes.”

“Yes. But even these crimes are small compared with the misery caused by a true tyrant. When such people become numerous and realize their power, they choose the person among them who has the greatest tyrannical nature and make him their leader.”

“And he becomes the perfect tyrant.”

“Exactly.”

“If the people surrender to him, everything continues. But if they resist, he treats the city as he once treated his own parents. Just as he controlled his family, he now controls his homeland and forces it to obey his followers.”

“That is the final result of his passions.”

“Such people, before gaining power, flatter anyone who can help them. They pretend to love others when they need something. But once they achieve their goal, they forget those people completely.”

“True.”

“They are never true friends. They are either masters or slaves.”

“A tyrant can never experience real friendship or freedom.”

“Exactly. Such people are also deeply unjust, if our understanding of justice is correct.”

“Yes.”

“Then let us summarize the worst person. He is the waking reality of the person we saw only in dreams.”

“That is true.”

“And because he is naturally the greatest tyrant within himself, the longer he lives, the more tyrannical he becomes.”

“Certainly.”

“Now consider this: if he is the worst person, must he not also be the most miserable?”

“Yes.”

“And the longer he rules as a tyrant, the more miserable he becomes.”

“I agree.”

“Also, the tyrannical man must resemble the tyrannical city, just as the democratic man resembles the democratic city.”

“Certainly.”

“Then, comparing our original ideal city ruled by a wise king with a city ruled by a tyrant, how do they compare?”

“They are complete opposites. One is the best, and the other is the worst.”

“Exactly.”

“And the same must be true of their happiness.”

“Yes.”

“Then let us not be fooled by the appearance of a tyrant. He may be only one person with a few followers. We must examine his entire city before judging.”

“That is fair.”

“A city under tyranny is free or enslaved?”

“Completely enslaved.”

“Although there may be a few masters and free people?”

“Yes, but the majority and the best people are degraded and enslaved.”

“Then if the tyrannical man is like the tyrannical city, his soul must also be enslaved.”

“Certainly.”

“The best part of his soul is controlled by the worst and most irrational part.”

“Yes.”

“Would you call such a soul free or enslaved?”

“Enslaved.”

“And the city under a tyrant cannot act according to its own will?”

“No.”

“Nor can the soul controlled by tyranny. It is constantly troubled by desires and regrets.”

“Exactly.”

“Is such a city rich?”

“No. It is poor.”

“And is the tyrannical soul also poor and never satisfied?”

“Yes.”

“Is such a city full of fear, sorrow, and suffering?”

“Certainly.”

“And is there any person who suffers more than the tyrannical man?”

“No one.”

“Then you agree that the tyrannical state is the most miserable?”

“Yes.”

“And when the same qualities appear in the tyrannical individual, he too is miserable.”

“I agree.”

“But I think you have not yet reached the deepest misery.”

“What do you mean?”

“There is someone even more miserable—the person with a tyrannical nature who does not remain private but becomes a public tyrant.”

“I understand. He suffers even more because he gains power.”

“Exactly.”

“Let me explain with an example. Think about a wealthy person who owns many slaves. He feels safe because the entire city protects him.”

“Yes.”

“But imagine that person suddenly taken away with his family and slaves into a deserted land where no free people can help him. Would he not fear that his own slaves might kill him?”

“He would be terrified.”

“He would have to flatter his own slaves and promise them freedom just to survive.”

“Yes.”

“And if he were surrounded by neighbors who believed no one should rule over another, his situation would become even worse.”

“Certainly.”

“This is the condition of the tyrant. He is surrounded by fear, desires, and enemies. He cannot travel freely or enjoy the world like ordinary people. He lives trapped inside his own power.”

“That is true.”

“So the tyrant is actually the greatest slave. He must flatter the worst people, satisfy endless desires, and live in constant fear.”

“Yes.”

“He becomes more jealous, dishonest, unjust, lonely, and corrupt as his power increases.”

“No sensible person could deny that.”

“Then decide, Glaucon: among the five types of people—the kingly, ambitious, oligarchic, democratic, and tyrannical—which is happiest and which is most miserable?”

“The answer is easy,” he said. “The order should be judged according to virtue and vice, happiness and misery.”

“Then let us announce the judgment: the best and most just person is also the happiest. He is the person who rules himself like a king. The worst and most unjust person is the most miserable—the person who is ruled by the greatest tyranny within himself and becomes a tyrant over others.”

“Yes,” said Glaucon.

“And this is true whether others see it or not.”

“Agreed.”

“Now let us consider another proof. We divided the soul into three parts: reason, spirit, and desire. Each part has its own pleasure.”

“Explain.”

“One part seeks knowledge. Another seeks honor and victory. The third seeks physical pleasures and wealth.”

“That is true.”

“So there are three types of people: lovers of wisdom, lovers of honor, and lovers of money.”

“Yes.”

“And each has his own idea of pleasure.”

“Exactly.”

“The money-lover praises wealth. The honor-lover praises achievement and reputation. But the philosopher values the pleasure of discovering truth.”

“Certainly.”

“Which person has the greatest experience of all these pleasures?”

“The philosopher,” Glaucon replied. “He has experienced ordinary pleasures, but the money-lover has never truly experienced the pleasure of wisdom.”

“Exactly. Therefore the philosopher has the advantage because he understands all three kinds of pleasure.”

“Yes.”

“And because reason is the proper judge, the philosopher is the best judge.”

“Certainly.”

“Therefore the pleasures approved by wisdom and reason are the truest pleasures.”

“I agree.”

“So the intelligent part of the soul provides the highest pleasure, and the person ruled by reason has the happiest life.”

“Without doubt.”

“The second happiest is the person ruled by honor.”

“Yes.”

“And last is the person ruled by money.”

“Correct.”

“Then once again justice defeats injustice.”

“Yes.”

“Now let us consider the difference between true pleasure and false pleasure. Is pleasure always the opposite of pain?”

“Yes.”

“And is there a middle state between pleasure and pain?”

“Yes.”

“People often think this middle state is pleasure because it feels better than pain. For example, a sick person may think health is the greatest pleasure only because he has experienced illness.”

“That is true.”

“But when people escape pain, they often mistake relief for true pleasure.”

“Yes.”

“Therefore the absence of pain is not the same as genuine pleasure.”

“Correct.”

“Some pleasures, however, exist without previous pain, such as the pleasure of pleasant smells.”

“Yes.”

“So pure pleasure is not simply the removal of pain.”

“Agreed.”

“Those who live only for bodily pleasures are like animals. They move between hunger and satisfaction but never reach true fulfillment.”

“Your description fits many people.”

“Their pleasures are only shadows of real pleasure.”

“Yes.”

“The same is true of people driven only by ambition and anger. Without reason, their pleasures are incomplete.”

“Certainly.”

“Therefore those who combine honor and wealth with wisdom will experience the truest pleasures possible.”

“Yes.”

“When reason rules the whole soul, every part performs its proper function and enjoys its proper pleasure.”

“Exactly.”

“But when desire or ambition takes control, the soul pursues false pleasures.”

“True.”

“The tyrant is therefore farthest from true pleasure, while the kingly person is closest.”

“Yes.”

“Then the tyrant lives the least pleasant life, and the king lives the most pleasant.”

“That follows.”

“The distance between them is enormous. The tyrant is separated from true pleasure by a vast measure, while the just person enjoys a life far superior.”

“Yes.”

“Now let us answer those who claim injustice benefits the unjust person.”

“How shall we answer them?”

“Let us create an image of the soul. Imagine a creature with many heads—some gentle, some wild—able to change its forms.”

“A strange creature, but possible in imagination.”

“Now add a lion representing courage and a human representing reason. Join all three together and cover them with the appearance of a single human being.”

“I understand.”

“Those who defend injustice say it is beneficial to feed the many-headed beast, strengthen the lion, and weaken the human part.”

“Yes.”

“But the defender of justice says the opposite: reason must rule, the wild desires must be controlled, and all parts of the soul must live in harmony.”

“That is the true position of justice.”

“So in every way—pleasure, honor, and advantage—the defender of justice is correct.”

“Yes.”

“Let us ask the unjust person: Is what is noble that which places the beast under human control, or that which places the human under the beast?”

“He must admit that the first is noble.”

“Then how could anyone benefit by selling the best part of himself into slavery for money or power?”

“He could not.”

“The person who allows his lower nature to rule himself is truly miserable.”

“Yes.”

“Therefore the wise person spends his life strengthening reason, training his body moderately, and keeping harmony within his soul.”

“Certainly.”

“He does not chase wealth beyond what he needs, nor seek honors that disturb his inner order.”

“Yes.”

“He may accept honors that make him better, but he avoids those that corrupt him.”

“Agreed.”

“Such a person would truly be a ruler—not necessarily over a physical city, but over the city within himself.”

“I understand.”

“And perhaps such a perfect city exists only as an ideal model. But the wise person can look toward that model and arrange his own soul accordingly.”

“That is true,” said Glaucon. “He lives according to that ideal, whether such a city exists on earth or not.”

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!