Valancy Shocks the Stirlings
Dinner dragged on in the usual slow Stirling fashion.
The dining room was chilly despite the season, so Aunt Alberta had the gas logs burning. Everyone in the family envied her those gas logs—everyone except Valancy.
In Valancy’s Blue Castle, glorious open fires would blaze in every room whenever autumn nights turned cold. But she would have frozen to death before she would ever allow a gas log in her home.
Uncle Herbert served the cold meat to Aunt Wellington with his usual joke.
“Mary, will you have a little lamb?”
Aunt Mildred told the same old story about once finding a lost ring in a turkey’s crop.
Uncle Benjamin launched into his favorite long-winded story about the time he had chased and punished a boy who later became a famous man for stealing apples.
Second Cousin Jane described every miserable detail of her ulcerated tooth.
Aunt Wellington admired the pattern on Aunt Alberta’s silver teaspoons.
“They’re lovely. It’s such a shame one of mine was lost. It ruined the whole set. I could never find another to match it. And it was a wedding present from dear Aunt Matilda.”
Aunt Isabel complained about the changing seasons.
“I don’t know what has happened to our good old-fashioned springs.”
Cousin Georgiana, as usual, brought up the latest funeral.
“I wonder which of us will be the next to pass away.”
She never used the plain word die.
Valancy thought she could probably tell her, but decided not to.
Cousin Gladys had her usual grievance.
“My visiting nephews have ruined all the buds on my houseplants. And they chased my fancy chickens all over the yard. They actually squeezed some of the poor things to death, my dear.”
“Boys will be boys,” said Uncle Herbert patiently.
“They don’t have to behave like wild animals,” snapped Cousin Gladys.
She looked around the table, waiting for everyone to admire her clever remark.
Everyone smiled except Valancy.
Cousin Gladys noticed.
A few minutes later, when Ellen Hamilton came up in conversation, Gladys said pointedly,
“She’s one of those shy, plain girls who can’t get husbands.”
She glanced straight at Valancy.
Uncle James decided the conversation was sinking into vulgar personal gossip.
He tried to rescue it.
“Perhaps we should discuss something more meaningful. What do you think is the greatest happiness in life?”
Everyone was expected to give an answer.
Aunt Mildred spoke first.
“For a woman, I think the greatest happiness is to be a loving wife and mother—and to be loved in return.”
Aunt Wellington said,
“To travel through Europe.”
Olive said,
“To become a great singer, like Tetrazzini.”
Cousin Gladys sighed.
“My greatest happiness would be to be completely free of neuritis.”
Cousin Georgiana looked sad.
“Mine would be to have my dear dead brother Richard back.”
Aunt Alberta spoke vaguely.
“The greatest happiness is found in the poetry of life.”
Then she quickly turned to her maid and gave her several instructions, making sure nobody had the chance to ask what she meant.
Mrs. Frederick folded her hands.
“The greatest happiness is to spend your life in loving service to others.”
Cousin Stickles agreed.
“So do I.”
Aunt Isabel agreed too, though she looked slightly annoyed. Mrs. Frederick had stolen the answer she had wanted to give.
“We are all too inclined,” Mrs. Frederick continued, warming to her subject, “to live in selfishness, worldliness, and sin.”
The women around the table suddenly felt as though they had been scolded.
Uncle James felt that the conversation had finally reached a properly elevated level.
Then Valancy spoke.
“The greatest happiness is being able to sneeze when you want to.”
Everyone stared at her.
Nobody knew what to say.
Was she joking?
It was almost impossible to believe.
Mrs. Frederick had been breathing more easily because Valancy had behaved herself throughout most of dinner. Now she began trembling again.
She wisely said nothing.
Uncle Benjamin was not so wise.
“Doss,” he chuckled, “what’s the difference between a young girl and an old maid?”
“One is happy and careless, and the other is cappy and hairless.”
Valancy smiled.
“You’ve told me that riddle at least fifty times, Uncle Ben. Why don’t you find a new one if you absolutely have to tell riddles? It’s a terrible mistake to try to be funny when you aren’t.”
Uncle Benjamin stared at her.
Never in his life had anyone spoken to Benjamin Stirling of Stirling and Frost like that.
And certainly never Valancy.
He looked around the table for support.
Nobody offered any.
Mrs. Frederick had closed her eyes. Her lips were moving as though she were praying.
Perhaps she was.
The situation was so strange that nobody knew how to handle it.
Valancy simply continued eating her salad.
Aunt Alberta hurried to change the subject.
“A dog bit me recently.”
Uncle James immediately asked,
“Where did it bite you?”
“Just a little below the Catholic church.”
Valancy burst out laughing.
Nobody else did.
Aunt Alberta looked puzzled.
“Is that supposed to be important?”
“What do you mean?” asked Aunt Alberta.
Mrs. Frederick looked as though her entire life of religious devotion had suddenly been wasted.
Aunt Isabel decided it was time to silence Valancy.
“Doss, you’re terribly thin. You’re nothing but angles. Do you ever try to put on a little weight?”
“No.”
Valancy did not sound apologetic in the least.
“But I can tell you where there’s a beauty parlor in Port Lawrence that could reduce some of your chins.”
“Val-an-cy!”
The protest burst from Mrs. Frederick.
She had intended to sound dignified and commanding.
Instead, she sounded almost like she was begging.
“She’s feverish,” Cousin Stickles whispered anxiously to Uncle Benjamin. “We’ve thought she seemed feverish for several days.”
“She’s gone dippy,” Uncle Benjamin growled. “That’s my opinion. If she isn’t, she ought to be spanked. Yes. Spanked.”
“You can’t spank her,” Cousin Stickles protested. “She’s twenty-nine years old.”
“So that’s one advantage to being twenty-nine,” Valancy remarked.
Uncle Benjamin glared at her.
“Doss, when I’m dead, you may say whatever you like. While I’m alive, I expect to be treated with respect.”
“Oh, but you know we’re all dead,” said Valancy calmly. “The whole Stirling family. Some of us are buried already, and some aren’t yet. That’s the only difference.”
Uncle Benjamin tried another weapon.
“Doss, do you remember when you stole that raspberry jam?”
Valancy turned scarlet.
Not from shame.
She was struggling not to laugh.
She had known he would somehow drag that jam into the argument.
“Of course I remember,” she said. “It was very good jam. I’ve always regretted that you caught me before I had time to eat more.”
She suddenly pointed toward the wall.
“Oh, look at Aunt Isabel’s profile! Did you ever see anything so funny?”
Everyone turned to look, including Aunt Isabel herself.
That ruined the joke completely.
Uncle Herbert tried to help.
“I—I wouldn’t eat any more if I were you, Doss. Not because I begrudge you the food, but wouldn’t it be better for you? Your stomach seems a little upset.”
“Don’t worry about my stomach, old dear. It’s perfectly fine. I’m going to keep eating. I so rarely get the chance to enjoy a really satisfying meal.”
It was the first time anyone in Deerwood had ever been called “old dear.”
The Stirlings were convinced Valancy had invented the expression herself.
From that moment, they were afraid of her.
There was something deeply unsettling about her behavior.
But Mrs. Frederick thought the remark about the satisfying meal was the worst thing she had said yet.
Valancy had always been a disappointment to her.
Now she was a disgrace.
She felt she ought to leave the table, but she was terrified to leave Valancy sitting there alone.
Fortunately, Aunt Alberta’s maid came in to clear the salad plates and serve dessert.
Everyone seized the opportunity to ignore Valancy.
They began talking as though she were not there.
Uncle Wellington mentioned Barney Snaith.
Sooner or later, Valancy reflected, Barney Snaith managed to become the subject at every Stirling gathering.
Whatever else he might be, he was impossible to ignore.
Valancy resigned herself to listening.
Yet there was something strangely fascinating about the subject.
She had not yet admitted that to herself.
Her pulse was beating all the way to her fingertips.
Of course, they attacked him.
Nobody in the Stirling family ever had a good word to say about Barney Snaith.
All the old stories came out again.
He was supposedly a runaway cashier, a counterfeiter, an unbeliever, a murderer hiding from the law.
Uncle Wellington was furious that such a man was allowed to live anywhere near Deerwood.
“I don’t know what the police in Port Lawrence are thinking. One of these nights we’ll all be murdered in our beds. After everything he’s done, he should never have been allowed to remain at large.”
“What has he done?” Valancy suddenly asked.
Uncle Wellington stared at her.
“Done? Why, he’s done everything!”
“What has he done?”
Valancy would not let it go.
“What do you actually know he has done? You’re always condemning him. What crime has ever been proved against him?”
“I don’t argue with women,” Uncle Wellington said stiffly. “And I don’t need proof. When a man hides himself away on an island in Muskoka year after year, nobody knows where he came from, how he lives, or what he does there. That’s proof enough. Where there’s a mystery, there’s a crime.”
“The very fact that his name is Snaith is suspicious,” said Second Cousin Sarah. “The name alone is enough to condemn him.”
“I wouldn’t want to meet him in a dark lane,” shuddered Cousin Georgiana.
“What do you think he’d do to you?” Valancy asked.
“Murder me.”
“Just for the fun of it?”
“Exactly.”
Cousin Georgiana nodded solemnly.
“When there is so much smoke, there must be some fire. I suspected he was a criminal when he first came here. I could feel that he was hiding something. My intuition is rarely wrong.”
“Of course he’s a criminal,” said Uncle Wellington. “Nobody doubts it.”
He glared at Valancy.
“They say he served time in prison for embezzlement. I believe it. And they say he’s connected with that gang committing all those bank robberies across the country.”
“Who says that?” Valancy asked.
Uncle Wellington frowned.
He had no answer.
So he ignored her.
“He has the exact face of a jailbird,” Uncle Benjamin declared. “I noticed it the first time I saw him.”
Uncle James suddenly recited dramatically,
“A man marked by nature for a shameful deed.”
He looked delighted.
He had been waiting years for the perfect opportunity to use that quotation.
“One eyebrow is an arch and the other is almost a triangle,” Valancy said. “Is that why you think he’s a villain?”
Uncle James raised his eyebrows.
Usually, when Uncle James raised his eyebrows, the world seemed to stop.
This time, it continued turning.
Olive smiled slyly.
“How do you know so much about his eyebrows, Doss?”
Two weeks earlier, such a question would have reduced Valancy to speechless embarrassment.
Olive knew it.
“Yes,” Aunt Wellington demanded. “How do you know?”
“I’ve seen him twice,” said Valancy calmly. “And I looked at him closely. I thought he had the most interesting face I’d ever seen.”
Olive looked slightly annoyed.
“There’s no doubt there’s something suspicious about his past. But he can’t possibly be guilty of everything people accuse him of.”
Valancy felt irritated with Olive.
Why was she defending Barney Snaith?
What business did she have with him?
For that matter, what business did Valancy have with him?
She did not stop to ask herself.
“They say he keeps dozens of cats in that hut on Mistawis,” Second Cousin Sarah Taylor added, apparently to prove she knew something about him.
Cats.
The plural sounded strangely attractive to Valancy.
She imagined an island in Muskoka full of cats.
“That alone proves there’s something wrong with him,” Aunt Isabel declared.
“People who don’t like cats,” said Valancy, attacking her dessert with enthusiasm, “always seem to think there’s something virtuous about not liking them.”
“The man doesn’t have a friend except Roaring Abel,” said Uncle Wellington. “And if Roaring Abel had stayed away from him like everyone else, things would have been better for—for certain members of his family.”
He stopped awkwardly.
Aunt Wellington gave him a sharp look.
There were girls at the table.
Valancy understood perfectly.
“If you mean Barney Snaith is the father of Cecily Gay’s child, he isn’t.”
Her voice became fierce.
“That’s a wicked lie.”
Silence fell.
The expressions around the table were so astonishing that Valancy almost laughed.
She had not seen anything like it since she was twelve, when the family had discovered something terrible about her at Cousin Gladys’s sewing party.
They had discovered that she had—
something—
in her hair.
Lice.
Valancy had no use for euphemisms anymore.
“Hush! Hush!” begged Cousin Stickles.
“I don’t want to hush,” Valancy replied. “I’ve been hush-hushed all my life. I’ll scream if I want to. Don’t make me want to. And stop saying ridiculous things about Barney Snaith.”
Valancy did not fully understand her own anger.
Why should Barney Snaith’s supposed crimes matter to her?
And why did the accusation that he had been Cecily Gay’s lover bother her more than all the others?
It did.
She could tolerate people calling him a thief, a counterfeiter, or a jailbird.
But she could not bear the thought that he had loved and ruined poor Cecily Gay.
She remembered his face from their two chance meetings.
That crooked, mysterious, charming smile.
The sparkle in his eyes.
His thin, sensitive lips, almost severe in their delicacy.
The whole look of him—open, reckless, and full of life.
A man with a smile like that might steal something.
He might even commit a crime.
But he could not betray someone he loved.
Suddenly Valancy hated everyone who said otherwise.
“When I was a young girl, I never thought about such things, much less spoke about them,” said Aunt Wellington coldly.
“But I’m not a young girl,” Valancy shot back. “Aren’t you always reminding me of that?”
She looked around the table.
“You’re all a bunch of wicked, foolish gossips. Can’t you leave poor Cissy Gay alone? She’s dying. Whatever she did, God or the Devil has punished her enough. You don’t need to punish her too.”
Nobody spoke.
“And as for Barney Snaith, the only crime he’s committed is living his own life and minding his own business. Apparently he can manage perfectly well without any of you.”
She smiled.
“And I suppose that’s an unforgivable sin in your little snobocracy.”
Valancy had invented the word on the spot.
She liked it.
It was exactly what they were.
None of them deserved the trouble of fixing another.
“Valancy, your poor father would turn over in his grave if he could hear you,” said Mrs. Frederick.
“I imagine he’d enjoy that for a change,” Valancy replied boldly.
Uncle James spoke heavily.
“Doss, the Ten Commandments are still fairly relevant—especially the fifth. Have you forgotten that?”
“No. But I thought you had forgotten them—especially the ninth.”
Uncle James stared.
Valancy continued,
“Have you ever thought how boring life would be without the Ten Commandments? Things only become interesting when they’re forbidden.”
But the excitement was beginning to overwhelm her.
She recognized the warning signs.
Another attack of pain was coming.
It must not begin here.
Valancy rose from her chair.
“I’m going home now. I only came for dinner.”
She smiled politely at Aunt Alberta.
“The dinner was very good. Although your salad dressing needs more salt, and a little cayenne pepper would make it much better.”
Nobody at the table could think of a single thing to say.
They remained speechless until the lawn gate clanged shut behind Valancy in the evening darkness.
Then Cousin Stickles finally spoke.
“She’s feverish. I’ve been saying for days that she was feverish.”
Uncle Benjamin angrily slapped his pudgy left hand with his right.
“She’s dippy! I tell you, she’s gone completely dippy. That’s all there is to it.”
“Oh, Benjamin,” said Cousin Georgiana soothingly, “don’t judge her too quickly. We must remember what dear Shakespeare said about charity thinking no evil.”
“Charity! Nonsense!”
Uncle Benjamin snorted.
“I’ve never heard a young woman say such things in my life. Talking about things she ought to be ashamed even to think about, let alone say aloud. Blaspheming! Insulting her own family!”
He paused angrily.
“What she needs is a good dose of spank-weed, and I’d like to be the one to give it to her. H-uh-h-h!”
He swallowed half a cup of scalding coffee.
Cousin Stickles looked terrified.
“Do you suppose mumps can affect someone like that?”
“I opened an umbrella in the house yesterday,” whispered Cousin Georgiana. “I knew it meant something terrible was going to happen.”
Cousin Mildred asked,
“Have you tried taking her temperature?”
“She wouldn’t let Amelia put the thermometer under her tongue,” whimpered Cousin Stickles.
Mrs. Frederick was openly crying now.
All her self-control had disappeared.
“I have to tell you,” she sobbed, “Valancy has been behaving strangely for more than two weeks. She hasn’t been herself at all. Christine can tell you. I kept hoping it was only one of her colds coming on. But it’s not. It must be something worse.”
“This is bringing my neuritis back,” complained Cousin Gladys, pressing a hand to her head.
“Don’t cry, Amelia,” Uncle Herbert said nervously.
He pulled at his stiff gray hair.
He hated family quarrels.
It was very inconsiderate of Doss to start one at his silver wedding.
Who would ever have imagined she had it in her?
“You’ll have to take her to a doctor,” he said. “It may only be a—well—a brainstorm. People have those nowadays, don’t they?”
“I suggested seeing a doctor yesterday,” Mrs. Frederick sobbed. “She refused. She absolutely refused. Oh, surely I’ve had enough trouble!”
“And she won’t take Redfern’s Bitters,” added Cousin Stickles.
“Or anything,” said Mrs. Frederick.
“She’s even determined to go to the Presbyterian church,” Cousin Stickles continued.
She wisely left out the story about the bannister.
“That proves she’s dippy,” growled Uncle Benjamin.
“I noticed something strange about her the moment she came in tonight. In fact, I noticed it before tonight.”
He was thinking of the strange message he had seen earlier.
“Everything she said tonight showed that her mind is unbalanced. That ridiculous question—‘Was it a vital part?’ What sense did that make? None! Nothing like that ever came from the Stirlings.”
He shook his head.
“It must come from the Wansbarras.”
Mrs. Frederick was too miserable even to become offended.
“I never heard of anything like that in the Wansbarras,” she sobbed.
“Your father was odd enough,” Uncle Benjamin replied.
“Poor Pa was peculiar,” Mrs. Frederick admitted tearfully. “But his mind was never affected.”
“He talked exactly the way Valancy talked tonight,” Uncle Benjamin insisted. “And he believed he was his own great-great-grandfather born again. I heard him say it myself.”
He snorted.
“Don’t tell me a man who believed something like that was perfectly sane.”
He looked at Mrs. Frederick.
“Come now, Amelia. Stop crying. Of course Doss made a terrible spectacle of herself tonight, but she isn’t responsible. Old maids sometimes go off like that. If she had married when she was supposed to, she never would have become like this.”
“Nobody wanted to marry her,” Mrs. Frederick said bitterly.
Somehow, she felt that Uncle Benjamin was blaming her.
“Well, fortunately there’s no outsider here,” Uncle Benjamin said sharply. “We can still keep this in the family.”
He nodded decisively.
“I’ll take her to see Dr. Marsh tomorrow. I know how to handle stubborn people. That’s settled, isn’t it, James?”
“We certainly need medical advice,” Uncle James agreed.
“Good. Then it’s settled.”
Uncle Benjamin turned to Mrs. Frederick.
“In the meantime, Amelia, behave as though nothing has happened. Keep an eye on her. Don’t let her be alone.”
He paused.
“Above all, don’t let her sleep alone.”
Mrs. Frederick began crying again.
“I can’t help it. The night before last I told her Christine should sleep with her. She absolutely refused—and locked her bedroom door.”
She shook her head.
“You don’t know how much she has changed. She won’t work.”
“At least, she won’t sew.”
“She still does the ordinary housework, of course. But yesterday morning she refused to sweep the parlor, even though we always sweep it on Thursdays.”
“I asked her, ‘Would you rather sweep a dirty room than a clean one?’”
Mrs. Frederick wiped her eyes.
“She said, ‘Of course. Then I’ll have something to show for my work.’ Imagine that!”
The family imagined it.
Cousin Stickles added,
“The jar of potpourri—”
She pronounced the word exactly as it looked.
“It disappeared from her room. I found the broken pieces in the next room. She won’t tell us what happened.”
“I never would have expected this from Doss,” said Uncle Herbert. “She always seemed so quiet and sensible. A little backward, perhaps, but sensible.”
Uncle James nodded wisely.
“The only thing you can really count on in this world is the multiplication table.”
Uncle Benjamin suddenly brightened.
“Well, let’s cheer ourselves up. Why are chorus girls like good livestock breeders?”
Cousin Stickles sighed.
“Why?”
She had to ask.
Valancy was not there to ask it for her.
Uncle Benjamin chuckled.
“They like to show off their calves.”
Cousin Stickles thought that was rather improper.
Especially with Olive sitting there.
But then, Uncle Benjamin was a man.
Uncle Herbert, meanwhile, found himself thinking that the evening had become rather dull now that Doss was gone.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!