Yuan Shao’s Ruin and Liu Bei’s Flight to Jingzhou
After crushing Yuan Shao’s army, Cao Cao pressed his advantage and sent his troops in hot pursuit.
Yuan Shao fled in utter disarray. With nothing but a headscarf and a plain tunic for clothes, he escaped to the northern bank of Liyang River with only eight hundred cavalry soldiers left.
General Jiang Yiqiu opened the camp gates to receive him. Yuan Shao poured out the whole story of his devastating defeat.
Jiang Yiqiu immediately set out to gather the scattered troops. When the surviving soldiers learned their lord was still alive, they flocked back to his side like ants, and Yuan Shao’s military strength slowly recovered.
The group planned to march back to Jizhou. That night, they set up camp in a desolate mountain area.
From his tent, Yuan Shao heard distant weeping. He slipped out quietly to listen.
It was his defeated soldiers huddled together, mourning their dead brothers and lost relatives. They beat their chests and cried bitterly.
“If we’d listened to Tian Feng’s advice, we’d never have suffered this disaster!” they all wailed.
Deep regret washed over Yuan Shao.
“I ignored Tian Feng’s warnings and brought this total defeat on myself,” he muttered. “How can I ever face him when I get back?”
The next day, as they marched, Feng Ji led a troop to meet them.
Yuan Shao spoke to him, weighed down with shame. “I refused to take Tian Feng’s advice, and this is the result. I have no courage to see him again.”
Feng Ji seized the chance to slander Tian Feng.
“When Tian Feng heard you’d lost the battle while he was in prison,” he lied, “he clapped his hands and laughed, saying, ‘Just as I predicted.’”
Yuan Shao flew into a rage.
“That petty scholar dares to mock me?” he roared. “I’ll have his head for this!”
He immediately sent a messenger with a sword to the prison in Jizhou to execute Tian Feng.
While in prison, Tian Feng was visited one day by the jailer.
“Congratulations, Master Tian!” the jailer said cheerfully. “General Yuan has returned defeated. You’ll surely be released and reinstated soon!”
Tian Feng smiled faintly.
“I’m going to die,” he said calmly.
The jailer was confused. “Everyone is celebrating for you. Why do you say you’ll die?”
“Yuan Shao appears generous on the surface, but he’s jealous and cruel at heart,” Tian Feng explained. “He never appreciates loyal service. If he’d won the battle and been in high spirits, he might have spared me. But now he’s ashamed and furious after his defeat. He’ll never let me live.”
The jailer refused to believe it. Moments later, the imperial messenger arrived with the sword, bearing Yuan Shao’s order to take Tian Feng’s life.
The jailer was stunned into shock.
“I knew this would happen,” Tian Feng said quietly.
The jailers all shed tears for him.
“A true man has no wisdom if he serves a lord he cannot see clearly,” Tian Feng said. “I have nothing to regret about dying today.”
With that, he drew the sword and killed himself in the prison cell. Everyone who heard of his death sighed in sorrow.
After returning to Jizhou, Yuan Shao was distraught and neglected all state affairs.
His wife Lady Liu urged him to name an heir. Yuan Shao had three sons. His eldest son Yuan Tan governed Qingzhou, the second son Yuan Xi ruled Youzhou, and the youngest son Yuan Shang — Lady Liu’s handsome, favored son — stayed by his father’s side in Jizhou.
After the Guandu defeat, Lady Liu pushed for Yuan Shang to be named successor.
Yuan Shao summoned four key officials — Shen Pei, Feng Ji, Xin Ping, and Guo Tu — to discuss the matter. Shen Pei and Feng Ji supported Yuan Shang, while Xin Ping and Guo Tu backed Yuan Tan, each faction fighting for their favored master.
“Our external troubles are far from over, so we must settle internal matters early,” Yuan Shao told them. “My eldest son Yuan Tan is harsh and quick to kill. My second son Yuan Xi is too weak to achieve great things. My third son Shang has the bearing of a hero and treats scholars with courtesy. I intend to make him my heir. What are your thoughts?”
Guo Tu spoke up firmly.
“The eldest son should inherit by right. Yuan Tan also commands troops abroad. If you discard the elder for the younger, you will plant the seeds of civil strife. Our army is already weakened, and Cao Cao’s forces press down on us. We cannot risk turning father and sons, brothers against each other. Let us first focus on repelling the enemy, and set the heir matter aside for now.”
Yuan Shao hesitated and could not make up his mind.
Just then, news arrived that Yuan Xi was marching from Youzhou with sixty thousand troops, Yuan Tan from Qingzhou with fifty thousand, and his nephew Gao Gan from Bingzhou with another fifty thousand. All were coming to Jizhou to aid their father.
Overjoyed, Yuan Shao regrouped his massive army to face Cao Cao once more.
Cao Cao’s victorious army lined up along the riverbank. Local villagers came forward with food and water to welcome the troops.
Cao Cao noticed several white-haired elders, nearly a hundred years old. He invited them into his tent, offered them seats, and spoke gently.
“Honored elders, how old are you?”
“We are almost a hundred years of age,” the elders replied.
“I apologize for my army disturbing your villages,” Cao Cao said. “It troubles me greatly.”
One elder spoke for the group.
“During Emperor Huan’s reign, an astrologer named Yin Kui lived here. He predicted that a true emperor would rise in the Liang-Pei region fifty years later. Exactly fifty years have passed. Yuan Shao crushed the people with heavy taxes and brought widespread resentment. You have raised a righteous army and defeated his massive forces at Guandu. Your victory fulfills the old prophecy, and we finally hope for peace.”
Cao Cao smiled humbly.
“I dare not accept such praise.”
He rewarded the elders with wine, food, and silk. Then he issued a strict military order: any soldier who harmed villagers or their livestock would face the same punishment as if they had killed a person.
Both soldiers and civilians were deeply impressed, and Cao Cao’s confidence grew.
Scouts reported that Yuan Shao had gathered two to three hundred thousand soldiers from his four prefectures and set up camp at Cangting.
Cao Cao rode out with his generals, and Yuan Shao appeared with his three sons, nephew, and civil and military officials.
“Yuan Shao,” Cao Cao called out, “you have run out of strategies and strength. Why refuse to surrender? Must you wait for the sword at your throat to regret your choices?”
Enraged, Yuan Shao turned to his men. “Who dares to fight him?”
Eager to prove himself before his father, young Yuan Shang brandished two blades and galloped into the open field.
Cao Cao asked his men who the young warrior was, and they told him it was Yuan Shao’s third son Yuan Shang.
Before the words faded, Shi Huan, a general under Xu Huang, charged forward with a spear. The two fought for less than three rounds before Yuan Shang feinted and rode off.
Shi Huan chased after him, but Yuan Shang spun around and loosed an arrow, striking Shi Huan square in the left eye. Shi Huan fell dead from his horse.
Elated by his son’s victory, Yuan Shao waved his whip and ordered his entire army to charge. A fierce melee ensued, and both sides retreated to their camps by day’s end.
Cao Cao gathered his generals to plan their next move. Cheng Yu proposed a brilliant ambush strategy.
“Withdraw our troops to the riverbank and set ten hidden ambush units,” he advised. “Lure Yuan Shao’s army to the water’s edge. With no retreat left, our soldiers will fight to the death, and we will claim victory.”
Cao Cao approved the plan. He split his troops into ten teams: five on the left led by Xiahou Dun, Zhang Liao, Li Dian, Yue Jin, and Xiahou Yuan; five on the right led by Cao Hong, Zhang He, Xu Huang, Yu Jin, and Gao Lan. Xu Chu would lead the vanguard from the central army.
The next day, all ten ambush units took their positions. At midnight, Cao Cao sent Xu Chu to stage a surprise raid on Yuan Shao’s camp.
Yuan Shao’s five camps mobilized at once to give chase. Xu Chu pretended to retreat and led the pursuing enemy straight toward the river.
By dawn, Yuan Shao’s army had reached the water’s edge with nowhere to run.
“We have no way back!” Cao Cao shouted to his troops. “Fight for your lives!”
His soldiers turned and charged ferociously. Xu Chu galloped ahead and slew more than ten enemy generals single-handedly. Yuan Shao’s army descended into chaos.
Yuan Shao tried desperately to retreat, but Cao’s troops closed in fast.
Before they could flee far, Xiahou Yuan attacked from the left and Gao Lan from the right. Yuan Shao and his sons and nephew fought desperately to break through.
Ten li onward, Yue Jin ambushed from the left and Yu Jin from the right, cutting down countless enemy soldiers and covering the ground with corpses.
A few li further, Li Dian and Xu Huang struck again from both sides.
Terrified and demoralized, Yuan Shao’s men fled back to their old camp. They had barely started cooking their meals when Zhang Liao and Zhang He stormed the camp from left and right.
Yuan Shao fled on horseback toward Cangting. His exhausted troops begged for rest, but Cao Cao’s main army caught up again. Forced to run for their lives, they were soon blocked by Cao Hong on the right and Xiahou Dun on the left.
“Fight or be captured!” Yuan Shao roared. He fought furiously and finally broke through the encirclement, though Yuan Xi and Gao Gan were wounded by arrows, and nearly all their troops were wiped out.
Yuan Shao collapsed to the ground, weeping bitterly as he held his three sons. His men rushed to help him up, but he coughed up blood nonstop.
“I have fought wars for decades,” he groaned. “I never thought I would end up in such a wretched state. Heaven is destroying me!”
He issued urgent orders.
“Each of you return to your prefectures! I will fight Cao Cao to the bitter end!”
He sent Xin Ping and Guo Tu back to Qingzhou with Yuan Tan to fortify defenses against a Cao invasion, ordered Yuan Xi back to Youzhou and Gao Gan back to Bingzhou to rebuild their armies, then returned to Jizhou with Yuan Shang to recover from his illness, leaving Shen Pei and Feng Ji to manage military affairs temporarily.
After his great victory at Cangting, Cao Cao rewarded his troops generously and sent scouts to spy on Jizhou’s defenses.
Scouts reported that Yuan Shao was bedridden, Yuan Shang and Shen Pei held tight control of the city, and Yuan Tan, Yuan Xi, and Gao Gan had all returned to their respective territories.
All Cao Cao’s generals urged an immediate attack, but Cao Cao refused.
“Jizhou has abundant grain supplies, and Shen Pei is a cunning strategist. The city will not fall easily. The crops are ripe in the fields now. We will wait until the autumn harvest to strike, so we do not ruin the farmers’ livelihoods.”
As they discussed their next move, a letter arrived from Xun Yu.
The letter warned that Liu Bei had gained tens of thousands of troops under Liu Pi and Gongdu in Runan. With Cao Cao’s army campaigning in the north, Liu Bei had left Liu Pi to guard Runan and marched north to attack Xuchang, leaving the capital defenseless.
Shocked by the news, Cao Cao left Cao Hong stationed on the river to bluff the enemy with a show of force, then led his main army south to confront Liu Bei in Runan.
Liu Bei had marched toward Xuchang with Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, and his troops, planning a surprise attack. His army met Cao Cao’s forces head-on near Rangshan.
Liu Bei set up camp at the foot of Rangshan and split his army into three groups: Guan Yu guarded the southeast corner, Zhang Fei the southwest, and Liu Bei stayed in the south with Zhao Yun.
When Cao Cao’s troops arrived, Liu Bei’s army charged with shouts.
Cao Cao lined up his soldiers and called Liu Bei out for a parley.
“I treated you as an honored guest,” Cao Cao shouted in anger. “How dare you betray me?”
Liu Bei replied sharply from horseback.
“You pretend to be the Han prime minister but are truly a traitor to the empire! I am a royal kinsman, tasked with the emperor’s secret edict to punish rebels!”
He then recited the imperial silk edict aloud for all to hear.
Furious, Cao Cao ordered Xu Chu to fight. Zhao Yun rode out from Liu Bei’s side to meet him. The two warriors battled fiercely for thirty rounds with no clear winner.
Suddenly, loud shouts erupted from both flanks. Guan Yu charged from the southeast and Zhang Fei from the southwest, surrounding Cao Cao’s army on three sides.
Cao’s troops were exhausted from their long march and could not hold their ground. They were soundly defeated and retreated.
The next day, Zhao Yun challenged Cao Cao’s army to fight, but Cao’s troops refused to come out for ten straight days. Zhang Fei issued another challenge, still with no response.
Liu Bei grew increasingly suspicious. Just then, urgent news arrived: Gongdu’s grain convoy was surrounded by Cao soldiers.
Liu Bei hastily sent Zhang Fei to rescue Gongdu. Before Zhang Fei could depart, another report came: Xiahou Dun had circled around to attack Runan from the rear.
Liu Bei panicked. “We are trapped with enemies front and back!”
He immediately sent Guan Yu to defend Runan.
Within a day, terrible news came. “Xiahou Dun has broken through Runan’s defenses. Liu Pi has fled the city, and Guan Yu is surrounded!”
Before Liu Bei could react, another report arrived: Zhang Fei was also trapped while rescuing Gongdu.
Liu Bei planned to retreat but feared Cao Cao would attack from behind. At that moment, Xu Chu challenged his army outside the camp.
Daring not to fight, Liu Bei waited until nightfall. He ordered his infantry to leave first and his cavalry to follow, keeping camp fires burning and night watches going to fool the enemy.
Liu Bei’s party had traveled only a few miles past a hill when torches suddenly blazed to life on the hilltop.
“Do not let Liu Bei escape!” a voice boomed. “The Prime Minister waits here for you!”
Liu Bei froze in terror, but Zhao Yun stepped forward bravely.
“Do not fear, my lord! Follow me!”
Zhao Yun charged ahead, spear in hand, cutting a path through the enemy ranks. Liu Bei followed closely with his twin swords.
Xu Chu soon caught up and clashed with Zhao Yun. Moments later, Yu Jin and Li Dian arrived with more troops. Cornered and outmatched, Liu Bei fled alone into the remote mountains as the fighting faded behind him.
At dawn, a troop of soldiers suddenly appeared on the path. Liu Bei feared it was the enemy, but it was Liu Pi leading over a thousand defeated soldiers, escorting Liu Bei’s family. Sun Qian, Jian Yong, and Mi Fang were with them too.
“Xiahou Dun’s attack was too fierce,” they explained. “We abandoned Runan and fled. Guan Yu held off the enemy to let us escape.”
“Where is Guan Yu now?” Liu Bei asked anxiously.
“General, flee first,” Liu Pi replied. “We will find a way to regroup.”
They traveled a few more miles before a drum sounded. Zhang He blocked their path with a large troop.
“Liu Bei, dismount and surrender!” he shouted.
Liu Bei turned to run, only to see red flags wave on the hilltop. Gao Lan’s army charged out from the valley, blocking his only escape route.
Trapped on both sides, Liu Bei cried out in despair.
“Why does heaven push me to such despair? I would rather die than be captured!”
He drew his sword to kill himself, but Liu Pi stopped him instantly.
“I will fight to the death to clear a path for you!”
Liu Pi charged Gao Lan, but was slain in just three rounds.
Liu Bei was about to fight himself when chaos erupted in Gao Lan’s rear ranks. A single warrior charged through the enemy formation and killed Gao Lan with one spear strike — it was Zhao Yun.
Overjoyed, Liu Bei watched as Zhao Yun cut down Gao Lan’s scattered troops, then turned to fight Zhang He. They battled for more than thirty rounds before Zhang He retreated.
Zhao Yun pressed the attack, but Zhang He’s soldiers held the narrow mountain pass, blocking their way.
Just as they struggled to break through, Guan Yu arrived with Guan Ping and Zhou Cang and three hundred soldiers. The two teams attacked from both sides, routing Zhang He’s army and seizing the mountain pass to set up camp.
Liu Bei sent Guan Yu to find Zhang Fei. Zhang Fei had arrived too late to save Gongdu, who had been killed by Xiahou Yuan. Zhang Fei fought off Xiahou Yuan but was then surrounded by Yue Jin’s troops.
Guan Yu tracked down the retreating soldiers, found Zhang Fei, and defeated Yue Jin’s army to rescue him. The two brothers returned safely to Liu Bei’s camp.
Reports soon came that Cao Cao’s main army was closing in. Liu Bei ordered Sun Qian and the others to escort his family to safety first, while he fought a rear guard action with Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, and Zhao Yun.
Cao Cao stopped his pursuit once Liu Bei’s forces were far enough away. Liu Bei’s remaining troops numbered less than a thousand, exhausted and defeated.
They finally reached the banks of the Han River. Local villagers, hearing it was Liu Bei, brought wine and meat to support them. The weary soldiers gathered on the sandy riverbank to rest and feast.
Liu Bei sighed heavily and spoke to his followers.
“All of you have the talent to assist a great ruler. Yet you have followed me, a man of doomed fate. I have no land to call my own, and I fear I am wasting your talents. Why not leave me and serve a worthy lord to win honor and success?”
His men wept openly at his words.
Guan Yu stepped forward to console him.
“Brother, you speak wrongly. Emperor Gaozu lost countless battles to Xiang Yu before winning the final victory and founding the Han Dynasty’s four-hundred-year reign. Victory and defeat are common in war. You must not give up on yourself!”
Sun Qian added his advice.
“Success and failure are fated. Do not lose heart. Jingzhou is nearby. Governor Liu Biao rules a vast territory with strong troops and abundant grain. He is also a member of the Han royal clan, just like you. Why not seek refuge with him?”
“I fear he will not accept me,” Liu Bei worried.
“I will go ahead and persuade him,” Sun Qian promised. “He will surely come out to welcome you.”
Liu Bei was overjoyed and sent Sun Qian to Jingzhou at once.
Sun Qian met Liu Biao in Jingzhou. After exchanging greetings, Liu Biao asked why he had come.
“Lord Liu Bei is a hero of the realm,” Sun Qian explained. “Though his army is small, his ambition is to restore the Han Dynasty. Even outsiders like Liu Pi and Gongdu fought and died for him. You and he share the same royal bloodline. He was tempted to flee to Wu, but I persuaded him to turn to his own clan instead. He has sent me to ask for your protection.”
Liu Biao was delighted.
“Xuande is my clansman and brother. I have long wished to meet him. I am honored that he comes to me now!”
But Cai Mao stepped forward to object, speaking maliciously.
“This is unwise. Liu Bei once served Lü Bu, then Cao Cao, then Yuan Shao — none of those alliances ended well. If you shelter him, Cao Cao will surely attack Jingzhou. We will face unnecessary war. You should behead Sun Qian and send his head to Cao Cao to win his favor.”
Sun Qian replied sternly.
“I do not fear death. Lord Liu Bei is loyal to the Han, unlike the treacherous Cao Cao, Yuan Shao, and Lü Bu. He served them only out of desperation. Now he comes to you because you share royal blood. How dare you slander a worthy man and seek to destroy him?”
Liu Biao scolded Cai Mao and dismissed him.
“I have made my decision. Speak no more of this.”
Cai Mao left, ashamed and resentful. Liu Biao sent Sun Qian back to report to Liu Bei, then rode thirty miles outside the city to welcome him personally.
Liu Bei showed great respect to Liu Biao, who treated him generously. He granted Liu Bei and his generals a fine residence inside Jingzhou city.
When Cao Cao learned Liu Bei had fled to Jingzhou, he planned to march south and attack.
Cheng Yu dissuaded him. “Yuan Shao still threatens our north. If we march on Jingzhou now, he may strike from behind, putting us in grave danger. We should return to Xuchang to rest and rebuild our strength. Next spring, we can eliminate Yuan Shao first, then seize Jingzhou, winning both northern and southern territories at once.”
Cao Cao agreed and led his army back to Xuchang.
In the first month of the seventh year of Jian’an, Cao Cao prepared for a new campaign. He left Xiahou Dun and Man Chong to guard Runan against Liu Biao, stationed Cao Ren and Xun Yu to defend Xuchang, and led his main army to garrison Guandu.
Yuan Shao had barely recovered from his serious illness and bloody cough from the previous year. He was discussing plans to attack Xuchang when news arrived of Cao Cao’s advance on Jizhou.
Shen Pei advised caution. “Our troops have not recovered from the defeats at Guandu and Cangting. We should strengthen our defenses, rest our soldiers, and restore our people’s strength.”
“If we wait for the enemy to arrive at our gates, it will be too late,” Yuan Shao argued. “I will lead the army to fight them myself.”
His son Yuan Shang pleaded with him. “Father, your illness has not healed. You cannot go on a long campaign. Let me lead the troops instead.”
Yuan Shao agreed. He sent messengers to summon Yuan Tan from Qingzhou, Yuan Xi from Youzhou, and Gao Gan from Bingzhou, planning a four-pronged attack to crush Cao Cao.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!