A Remarkable Chapter in American History
The past fifteen years have witnessed an extraordinary transformation in the United States. No other nation had ever developed its resources so rapidly in such a short time. The country seemed to possess an unstoppable energy, steadily moving toward control of the world’s markets. After overcoming obstacle after obstacle, America appeared almost able to turn every opportunity into gold.
One important consequence of the Vanderbilt boom of 1885 was the enormous expansion of railroad construction. In 1887 alone, some 12,000 miles of new railroad were built. At the time, many people thought this was excessive. In hindsight, however, it proved to be a remarkably accurate anticipation of the country’s coming economic expansion. That same year, American exports of manufactured goods began to rise noticeably.
The following year was unforgettable for another reason. A terrible blizzard virtually shut down New York for several days. One of its tragic consequences was the death of Roscoe Conkling, one of the most colorful and respected figures in American politics. His reputation was spotless, and he was taken from public life before he could take part in that year's presidential campaign.
I remember that great storm very clearly.
Mrs. Clews and I had gone to Newport to inspect some improvements being made at our summer home. On our way back, we took the regular boat across the bay so that we could catch the noon train from Boston to New York.
We were only halfway across when a violent squall suddenly struck.
For a moment, we seriously wondered whether we would ever reach shore.
Fortunately, we finally made it and managed to board the delayed train.
But the journey was painfully slow.
By the next morning, we had traveled only as far as New London, and there was no possibility of going farther.
Many readers will remember the railroad ferry that operated across the bay from New London. The train immediately before ours had actually been sent across, but the storm became so violent that the pilot was forced to turn back.
As more trains arrived, New London quickly became overcrowded. Hotel rooms and every other form of accommodation became extremely difficult to find.
We had no idea where we could stay.
Fortunately, we persuaded the manager of a local hotel to let us use the private rooms belonging to the proprietor. The proprietor had left for Florida with his family only the day before.
He spent the next four days stranded on the railroad somewhere between New London and New Haven, surrounded by snowdrifts six feet high.
Meanwhile, we enjoyed the comfort of his private rooms.
I cannot honestly say that we were unhappy with the arrangement.
Telegraph service to New York was completely cut off. Our children had remained in the city, so naturally we were extremely anxious to know that they were safe. We also wanted them to know that we were all right.
There was only one way to communicate.
We sent a message by telegraph to Boston. From there, it was sent by cable to Liverpool and then back to New York.
That was certainly an indirect route, but it worked.
John H. Clews
The renomination of President Cleveland in 1888, together with the growing talk of free trade, unsettled the markets from the moment of his nomination until General Harrison was elected.
Harrison’s arrival in the White House gave the country’s business activity a powerful new start. Under his administration, prosperity rose rapidly, and the final year of his term was, at that time, one of the best years in American economic history.
One of Harrison’s most important achievements was the negotiation of reciprocity treaties. His Secretary of State, James G. Blaine, handled these negotiations with remarkable skill.
But halfway through Harrison’s term came the greatest financial shock the world had experienced since the panic of 1873.
In the fall of 1890, the great London banking firm of Baring Brothers was forced to suspend operations. The consequences were severe, and international finance would not fully recover for several years.
The immediate cause was the firm's enormous exposure to Argentine investments.
An agent who had visited Argentina had painted an extremely optimistic picture of the country. Baring Brothers and many investors who followed its lead poured vast amounts of money into Argentine securities.
Eventually, the boom collapsed.
The firm found itself holding enormous quantities of securities that could no longer be sold, and it was forced to suspend payments.
Fortunately, the rescue operation was highly successful.
William Lidderdale, Governor of the Bank of England, played a leading role. The Bank of England took over roughly £7 million of Baring’s troubled obligations.
Through careful and patient management, these supposedly worthless assets were eventually turned into enough money to repay the firm's obligations in full.
The failure also triggered enormous selling of American securities by British investors. That liquidation continued for several years.
The year 1890 also brought another problem: the Sherman Silver Purchase Act.
This compromise over the silver question would produce disastrous consequences within only a few years.
After the Baring crisis had passed, the benefits of the McKinley Tariff began to appear. American exports increased, particularly grain exports, while domestic industries received strong protection. As a result, the country entered 1892 under highly favorable economic conditions.
Excellent harvests provided the foundation for what became a remarkably prosperous year.
During 1892, Jay Gould, aided to a large extent by his son George, made one of his characteristic financial moves and gained control of the Union Pacific system while Mr. Huntington was still considering what to do.
Gould’s control did not last long.
In December of that year, Jay Gould died after a remarkably active and adventurous career, which has been discussed elsewhere in this book.
J. B. Clews
The Democratic Party remained loyal to President Cleveland, and he was nominated again in 1892.
In one of those strange shifts in public opinion, voters decided they wanted a change in administration even though the country was enjoying prosperous times. Cleveland won the election and returned to Washington the following March with the confidence of a large majority of the people.
Almost immediately, Wall Street began to weaken.
The main source of fear was the possibility of free-trade legislation.
Late in the year, the Treasury’s gold reserve began to decline. Apart from a few temporary rallies, including one important rally the following January, stock prices continued to fall.
At the same time, rumors spread that the Secretary of the Treasury might interpret the word “coin” in government obligations to mean that the government could redeem its bonds in either gold or silver, depending on its choice.
Any uncertainty about such an important issue was enough to damage public confidence.
For many years, the Treasury had not operated with a deficit. Now it did.
Conditions were steadily getting worse.
The first major collapse in stock prices came in May, when the famous Cordage Trust failed. Sugar stock and the few other industrial stocks then listed also plunged sharply.
By the middle of the year, the Treasury’s gold reserve had fallen to dangerously low levels.
Public pressure finally forced Congress to convene a special session to repeal the silver-purchase provision of the Sherman Act.
That provision had become a terrible burden on the country, threatening to choke business activity everywhere.
Congressional delays and obstruction in the Senate caused further damage to trade and finance.
When repeal finally came, the country’s economic strength had already been weakened so badly that it took years for confidence and normal business energy to return.
Early the following year, the government had to issue $50 million in bonds simply to prevent the gold reserve from falling toward exhaustion.
Then President Cleveland’s tariff message to Congress in December 1893 created another wave of uncertainty.
Businessmen had hoped that the disastrous summer was finally behind them.
Instead, just as the fear of unlimited silver began to fade, tariff reform created another period of anxiety and delay.
The following year, the Wilson tariff measure finally became law after being burdened with 640 Senate amendments.
William L. Wilson, whose name the bill carried, was a thoughtful and honorable man. Fortunately, the final legislation did not include an income tax.
Some people believe an income tax is a fair form of taxation.
I have never been able to see it that way.
To me, it seems to reward idleness while placing a penalty on thrift.
Roswell P. Flower
Another $50 million bond issue became necessary before the year ended.
Even after this replenishment, gold continued flowing out of the country to pay European investors for the American securities they were sending back to us in enormous quantities.
Another bond issue became unavoidable the following February.
This time the government purchased 3.5 million ounces of gold at a cost of $62.5 million.
The famous syndicate that agreed to supply the gold also promised to do everything possible to strengthen the Treasury reserve. It agreed to make additional gold deposits and, as far as possible, help stabilize foreign-exchange rates.
Its assistance was unquestionably important.
By strengthening confidence in the government's ability to meet its obligations, the syndicate probably prevented many additional business failures.
It fully honored its agreement and, in August alone, deposited roughly $7.5 million in gold with the Treasury.
Few people remember today the unfortunate Barney Barnato.
He possessed an enormous fortune on paper, but eventually that fortune became too much for a man whose education had not prepared him to handle it.
Barnato was a colorful figure and a striking example of what can happen when material wealth overwhelms the judgment of the person who possesses it.
The sharp collapse in South African mining shares in London during October naturally affected American markets as well.
But still worse trouble was ahead.
President Cleveland’s famous Venezuela message to Congress in December 1895 struck Wall Street like an earthquake.
It shook the markets to their foundations and wiped out hundreds of millions of dollars in market value before the panic subsided.
The eventual outcome of the dispute between Great Britain and Venezuela largely supported Britain’s position.
Still, the episode should be remembered as a step toward a better principle—the use of arbitration as the proper solution to international disputes.
In 1896, we finally began to see the end of our troubles, although not without considerable anxiety.
Another $100 million bond issue was needed to cover government deficits, bringing the total issued during two years to $262.5 million.
It had been an extraordinarily expensive administration.
And as the old saying goes, troubles rarely come one at a time.
J. Pierpont Morgan
The presidential campaign of 1896 brought back memories of the wild free-silver agitation of four years earlier.
Repeated financial crises and economic depression had left the public almost hysterical.
After William Jennings Bryan was nominated in July, people began hoarding gold.
Under those conditions, the effect on the money and securities markets was inevitable: prices plunged again.
New York Central fell to 88, its lowest level in fifteen years.
C., B. & Q. fell to 53, its lowest price in nearly forty years.
Other major stocks suffered similar declines.
I have said that our troubles ended in 1896.
In reality, they did not end until the November election.
William McKinley, the man described as the “advance agent of prosperity,” was elected President.
Bryan had previously been little known outside political circles, but his speech at the Democratic National Convention electrified the delegates and won him the nomination.
His famous words about refusing to “crucify labor upon a cross of gold” swept the convention off its feet.
But his program called for the free coinage of silver at a ratio of sixteen to one.
He then traveled across the country campaigning tirelessly and succeeded in creating an atmosphere of fear and economic depression.
The country seemed almost hysterical.
But, as Martin Van Buren once said, the people's sober second thought is usually sound.
That sober judgment finally prevailed.
Large crowds might gather to hear Bryan speak, but when Americans entered the voting booths, they chose prosperity and financial stability.
Even Bryan’s carefully prepared speech at Madison Square Garden, which he unusually read directly from his manuscript, failed to persuade New York.
It fell flat.
After Bryan’s failure in New York, the clouds finally began to lift.
The record of those four years makes one fact unmistakable: Washington had an enormous influence over the financial markets.
And it was not merely Wall Street.
Government policy had come to influence nearly every major business interest in the country.
For four years, uncertainty about what Washington might do next had almost paralyzed American business.
It is therefore a relief to turn from those difficult years to the prosperity that followed.
The election of William McKinley vindicated the good sense of the American people and finally turned the tide.
With a stable currency, business could recover.
The country was also fortunate to receive excellent harvests during McKinley’s first year in office, at a time when Russia, France, and the Danubian provinces were experiencing shortages.
American farmers enjoyed a spectacular year.
High prices and exports of roughly 120 million bushels of wheat allowed farmers to pay off mortgages on a massive scale.
That was one of the foundations of the prosperity that followed.
American exports also increased sharply.
As expected, imports surged before the Dingley Tariff became law in July. Government revenues fell immediately afterward.
Nevertheless, the record of the tariff’s operation up to that time was, in my view, strong evidence of the wisdom of its author.
The Supreme Court’s 1897 decision in the Trans-Missouri case, which declared railroad pooling illegal, initially shocked the market.
But as business improved, railroads soon had more traffic than they could handle.
They had little reason to worry about dividing business among themselves.
The year 1898 began on a very favorable note.
Gold was flowing into the country, and money was plentiful.
Then the situation in Cuba, which had been growing increasingly dangerous since the previous year, finally resulted in war with Spain in April.
The suffering in Cuba had become a disgrace to the civilized world.
The Spanish campaign against the Cuban revolutionaries involved terrible cruelty, including atrocities against women and children.
The United States demanded that Spain stop.
Spain refused.
Our government therefore intervened in what it regarded as a matter of common humanity.
The intervention represented, in my opinion, an important step forward in the history of mankind.
Few wars had ever been fought on such a scale with humanitarian motives at their center.
The United States acted with considerable courage.
Several European powers might have supported Spain, but Great Britain’s firm opposition prevented them from doing so.
Naturally, the outbreak of war initially produced economic depression.
But the depression did not last long.
Once businesses understood that the economy could adapt to wartime conditions, activity exploded.
The country quickly regained its financial strength.
The stock-market boom that began in the summer of 1898 and continued into the spring of 1899 became one of the most spectacular financial advances in American history.
It is difficult even now to imagine how rapidly trade, commerce, and financial activity expanded.
The scale of prosperity seemed almost unbelievable.
America’s oldest and most experienced merchants and financiers were astonished by the strength of the national economy.
The young American republic was beginning to rival, and in some respects surpass, the economic strength of the old European powers.
The late Governor Flower deserves special credit for boldly taking the initiative in the extraordinary rise in securities values. I shall return to that subject later.
The formal end of the Spanish-American War gave business another boost.
Prices continued rising well into the spring of 1899.
The year 1898 also marked the beginning of the greatest era of corporate consolidation the world had ever seen.
These huge combinations were becoming gigantic engines of commerce.
The companies created during 1898 and 1899 had a combined capitalization of approximately $3.5 billion.
The possibilities for business expansion represented by such a sum were almost beyond imagination.
The movement toward consolidation in the railroad industry had already begun with the merger of the Lake Shore Railroad and the New York Central.
The year 1899 was one of the most prosperous years in American history.
Yet it ended with one of the worst semi-panics Wall Street had experienced.
To understand the panic of December 1899, we need to look back at several major financial developments earlier in the year.
In April, the famous Amalgamated Copper Corporation was created by interests associated with Standard Oil.
Its capital stock amounted to $75 million.
The shares were reportedly subscribed five times over.
Because of its powerful sponsors, the stock quickly became popular and was held around par for some time.
But less than two months later, the price suddenly fell 25 percent.
Many experienced operators regarded the decline with suspicion.
They believed it might have been part of the larger financial arrangement.
Amalgamated was an enormous combination, holding major interests in more than thirty companies.
The famous Anaconda mines of Montana were the largest and most prominent among them.
When the panic came, copper companies suffered most severely.
The decline in the value of their share capital during the year alone was estimated at nearly $200 million.
At the same time, an unusually large amount of currency had moved to the South and West and remained there for an extended period.
Money eventually became tight.
That shortage caused a massive decline throughout the stock market.
Fortunately, the underlying condition of the American economy remained strong.
As a result, the panic did not leave permanent scars.
The final year of the remarkable nineteenth century was itself remarkable.
Since the defeat of the free-silver movement in 1896, America’s financial progress had been so rapid that it now seemed only a matter of time before New York would become the financial center of the world.
The contrast with 1895 was extraordinary.
Only five years earlier, the United States had been turning to Europe for loans simply to finance the ordinary expenses of its government.
Now the situation had completely reversed.
England found it advantageous to place $25 million of its war loan with American investors.
Germany wanted $20 million in American gold.
Russia was seeking loans from us.
Sweden also came to America for financial assistance.
And these transactions took place without creating even a ripple in our money markets.
The source of this abundance was our extraordinary growth in exports.
During the first ten months of the year, America's favorable trade balance approached $500 million.
Over the preceding three years, the total had reached roughly $1.5 billion.
There was the lever and the fulcrum with which America could begin moving the financial world.
A little more than a year earlier, Cornelius Vanderbilt, grandson and namesake of the Commodore, had died.
He had been extraordinarily generous.
His gifts to the public through art and numerous charitable causes were enormous.
But perhaps his most lasting legacy was the private charity through which he personally helped people escape poverty.
The great fortunes of recent generations have not often failed, in America, to find administrators who understood their responsibilities toward their fellow citizens.
For many wealthy Americans, giving became a privilege rather than a burden.
That is an important tribute to American citizenship and should not be forgotten by those who criticize the country.
The Currency Act passed in March 1900 also strengthened Europe’s confidence in America’s financial stability.
The presidential election later that year produced another important result.
The victory of the sound-money party appeared to eliminate the immediate danger of another serious attack on the nation’s monetary system.
For years, Americans had been learning about economics and public finance because of the campaign for unlimited silver coinage at sixteen to one.
That education had produced an important result.
The public had become better informed.
Americans were no longer willing to follow theories that threatened the financial stability of the country.
They had learned to reject what they considered false financial promises and dangerous experiments.
The modern system of large-scale business combinations certainly has weaknesses.
But I do not believe those weaknesses are inherent in the system itself.
They are problems of management and circumstance, and they can be corrected by public judgment and proper regulation.
People often complain that these giant combinations destroy competition.
But how long can they really suppress it?
Doesn't their existence itself create new forms of competition?
Running such enormous organizations also requires exceptional talent. The intellectual competition involved in managing them can itself become an important source of education and progress.
The years ahead would have to correct whatever weaknesses emerged from this new and largely untested system.
As the nineteenth century came to an end, America could look back on a national history almost unparalleled in its achievements.
The country entered the twentieth century with confidence in its institutions.
Those institutions had already survived severe tests despite America's relatively short national life.
The future appeared even more promising.
America was rapidly taking a leading position not only in commerce and finance, but also in international affairs.
That growing power demanded steadiness, self-discipline, and an unwavering commitment to national honor.
Everything suggested that these qualities would endure.
And it was especially encouraging that America entered the twentieth century at peace with the world.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!