← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 62 · Wall Street Booms

Wall Street Booms

Chapter 62 of 90 · 3,696 words · Free

Wall Street was going through a boom, but it was unlike almost any boom the Street had seen before.

The strangest thing about it was how quiet it was.

Stock prices were rising. Many companies were worth more than ever. By every normal measure, the market should have been the center of national excitement.

But it wasn't.

Most Americans hardly seemed to notice.

The reason was simple. This boom was not built on speculation alone. It rested on the broad prosperity of the entire country.

Farmers were making money.

Merchants were expanding.

Factory workers were busy.

Miners were prospering.

Everyone was so occupied with his own success that few people had time to worry about what was happening on Wall Street.

The same forces that were pushing stocks higher were pushing almost every other part of the American economy forward as well.

Wall Street was simply reflecting the country's prosperity.

There was another reason the boom remained so calm.

There was no single spectacular leader at its center.

Usually, a great market boom becomes identified with one powerful man. Everyone knows who is pushing prices and who is controlling the game.

This time it was different.

The market was clearly being directed by powerful interests, but the people behind the operation remained largely out of sight.

Most traders could only watch and try to understand what was happening.

A new order had arrived on Wall Street.

And behind it stood an influence more powerful than anything the Street had known before: the Standard Oil group.

They operated in the stock market exactly as they operated their businesses.

Quietly.

Patiently.

Systematically.

And with enormous power.

Compared with them, the great operators of earlier generations seemed almost small.

Jay Gould, even at the height of his power, always had to worry about losing.

Commodore Vanderbilt could sometimes control the entire market, but even he occasionally found himself trapped and forced to fight for survival.

Every great speculator had faced that kind of danger.

But the men controlling Standard Oil were different.

For them, market manipulation was becoming something very different from ordinary speculation.

Their resources were so enormous that when they decided to concentrate on a particular company or property, they could often make it do what they wanted.

They were involved in many properties that the public did not even associate with them.

Their operations were enormous, but their methods were almost invisible.

There were no dramatic performances.

No newspaper headlines announcing their next move.

No frantic crowds.

No wild excitement.

They moved slowly, steadily, and deliberately.

Nobody could say exactly how much money they had made.

But compared with their profits, the fortunes made by the great speculators of the past seemed insignificant.

The Standard Oil group had become almost completely dominant in Wall Street.

Some of the strongest financial institutions were ready to provide them with money whenever they needed it.

With that kind of money and financial support, their ability to influence the market was almost impossible to measure.

Fortunately, their influence so far had been directed mainly upward.

Their buying helped lift the market, and because the whole country was prospering at the same time, almost everyone on Wall Street was making money.

There were losses here and there.

Some were substantial.

But compared with the enormous amount of money being made throughout the Street, they hardly mattered.

The boom that came immediately before this one was completely different.

That boom had everything the present boom lacked.

It had one unmistakable leader.

It kept the Stock Exchange in constant turmoil.

The newspapers were filled with sensational stories.

Millions of dollars in paper profits were created for a huge army of followers.

And the market swung violently up and down for months.

That leader was Roswell P. Flower, former governor of New York.

Few people had ever cut a more colorful figure on Wall Street.

Flower did not look like a Wall Street leader at all.

He was plain and heavyset.

He walked with an easy, almost awkward gait and looked more like a prosperous farmer than a powerful financier.

He almost always had a huge piece of chewing tobacco in his mouth.

His office needed plenty of spittoons.

His clothes hung loosely on him like sacks.

His hat often looked as though it had not been brushed for weeks.

Sometimes he went for days without shaving.

By the standards of Wall Street, he looked completely out of place.

Yet that plain appearance became one of his greatest advantages.

People trusted him because he did not look polished or artificial.

He spoke plainly and directly.

He had not received a sophisticated college education, but that too worked in his favor.

He could concentrate on a problem without being distracted by unnecessary theories or complicated ideas.

Flower had entered Wall Street twenty or twenty-five years earlier as the manager of his brother-in-law Henry Keep's estate.

He controlled a large amount of money and increased it substantially through conservative investments.

He did not become a major speculator until after his term as governor of New York.

When he returned to Wall Street from Albany, he brought considerable prestige with him.

Former governors of New York were rare figures around the Stock Exchange.

He also brought political connections.

Republicans and Democrats alike respected him.

During his years as governor, he had built friendships with influential people in both parties, even though no one questioned his loyalty to his own party.

He was also closely connected with many of the country's wealthiest capitalists.

Once he returned to business, Flower selected several stocks as his specialties.

Chicago Gas, Federal Steel, and Rock Island were among them.

He began buying and supporting these stocks.

Their prices climbed rapidly.

They became active and unusually strong.

The bears repeatedly attacked his positions.

Sometimes they managed to push him into a difficult corner.

But Flower always fought his way back.

Each time, he emerged stronger.

Then, after establishing himself in his favorite stocks, he suddenly turned his attention to Brooklyn Rapid Transit.

For months, he kept the market in a state of excitement.

He began buying the stock when it was around six dollars a share.

Before long, he had pushed it above $138.

Politicians throughout New York State made fortunes on paper.

The Wall Street reporters loved Flower.

Their enthusiastic newspaper stories helped drive the boom even higher.

As Brooklyn Rapid Transit surged, almost every other stock on Wall Street began rising.

The bears could barely make an attack without causing Flower's stocks to rise another step.

Flower preached confidence in American business.

He convinced people that if a company was based in America and its underlying property was sound, its stock could be bought at almost any price.

Only one thing prevented this boom from ending in a terrible panic.

Roswell P. Flower died.

Had he lived another month, the bubble would almost certainly have burst.

The consequences could have been disastrous.

Flower went to the country for a day's rest.

He ate a heavy meal of ham and radishes and washed it down with a large amount of ice water.

Within hours, he died from acute indigestion.

His death, strangely enough, may have saved Wall Street from a much greater disaster.

Rockefeller, the Vanderbilts, and other wealthy friends rushed into the market with millions of dollars.

They supported stock prices.

They argued that Flower's death should not be allowed to destroy the value of otherwise sound companies.

They told the public that the decline caused by his death was irrational.

Newspapers repeated this argument everywhere.

The result was that the expected collapse never came.

Instead of a complete breakdown, the market suffered only a moderate decline.

The Standard Oil group and other powerful interests stepped in at exactly the right moment and helped prevent a major crash.

Small speculators trading on narrow margins were almost wiped out.

Many larger operators, however, survived.

It may be the only time in Wall Street history when the death of a great speculator actually prevented a general market disaster.

Many politicians and small traders who had expected to walk away with comfortable fortunes instead lost everything.

There was another remarkable part of the Flower boom.

It had been helped, indirectly, by the earlier speculation of young Joe Leiter.

Leiter himself had already gone bankrupt, but his attempt to corner the wheat market had created conditions that greatly benefited Flower's boom.

When Leiter began buying wheat aggressively, wheat was selling for around sixty cents a bushel.

He pushed it above one dollar before his own position collapsed.

That rise allowed thousands of farmers to sell their crops at much higher prices.

Farm country suddenly became prosperous.

Farmers used their new money to pay off their mortgages.

Those mortgages were often held by banks and investors in the East.

Hundreds of millions of dollars were therefore released from mortgage investments.

All that money suddenly became available for new investments.

When Flower's Wall Street boom appeared, investors were delighted to have somewhere to put their newly available capital.

That made it much easier to push stock prices higher.

Another major figure of this period was J. Pierpont Morgan.

Morgan had begun his career as a clerk at the famous banking house of Duncan, Sherman & Co.

Later he became associated with Anthony J. Drexel, one of the richest bankers in America.

Their partnership eventually became Drexel, Morgan & Co., with Morgan managing the New York business.

After Drexel died, Morgan took control of the entire firm.

Then, after his father's death, Morgan also became head of the London firm J. S. Morgan & Co.

He was now in an extraordinarily powerful financial position.

He soon demonstrated that power by reorganizing the bankrupt Richmond & West Point Terminal Railway & Warehouse Company.

He renamed it the Southern Railway Company.

He then brought several smaller railroads into the system.

Many of them were financially weak and poorly managed.

Morgan combined them into one organization under unified management.

That railroad system eventually became one of the country's great properties.

Morgan next turned his attention to the Reading and Erie railroads.

Both were in serious trouble.

Morgan reorganized them and brought order out of chaos.

Railroad stocks began rising throughout the market.

But Morgan did not accomplish this without opposition.

Some major shareholders resisted his plans because they considered his methods too severe.

Morgan sometimes responded in the traditional Wall Street fashion.

He allowed prices to fall, then bought stock at the lower prices.

By doing so, he strengthened his position and increased his control.

People who followed Morgan's lead generally made money.

There was another very different kind of Wall Street deal engineered several years earlier by S. V. White, better known as Deacon White.

He earned the nickname because he was a deacon at Plymouth Church.

White was one of the oldest and most colorful operators on the Street.

He had made several large fortunes through speculation and then lost them.

Yet he never seemed discouraged.

Even after turning seventy, he remained active in the market every day.

One of the strangest stock deals in Wall Street history involved Joseph Bannigan, the president of the Rubber Trust.

The full story was known to very few people.

Most of those who knew about it were, in fact, the people who lost money because of it.

Bannigan was an uneducated Irish immigrant who could barely read or write.

He had started working in a New England rubber factory for $1.50 a day.

When he died, he had accumulated five million dollars.

He was shrewd, practical, and understood the value of money.

He saved aggressively and eventually became the owner of one of the largest rubber factories in the country, in Providence.

His knowledge of the rubber business was so extensive that he was made president of the Rubber Trust.

He owned about forty thousand shares of its stock.

Eventually, however, Bannigan became convinced that the other powerful men in the trust were treating him unfairly.

He decided to sell everything and leave.

One night he packed his stock certificates into a small suitcase.

He took the boat from Providence to New York.

After breakfast the next morning, he went straight to a broker he trusted.

“I want out completely,” Bannigan said.

“I want to sell every one of my forty thousand shares. They're all here. Put them on the market and sell them.”

The broker shook his head.

“That won't work.”

“Why not?”

“If you dump forty thousand shares onto the market, you'll destroy the price. You'll end up getting very little for them.”

Bannigan frowned.

“Then what am I supposed to do?”

“Buy.”

“Buy? I don't want to buy. I've already got more stock than I want.”

“That's exactly why you should buy. Buying will create a market for the stock. Once the price is strong enough, you can sell your own shares.”

“How much do I have to buy?”

“About $250,000 worth.”

“I don't have $250,000 in cash.”

“You can borrow it. A man in your position should have no trouble borrowing that amount.”

Bannigan strongly objected.

But eventually he agreed.

About two weeks later, the broker wrote to him again.

“You need to buy another $200,000 worth.”

Bannigan was furious.

But once again he borrowed the money and followed the broker's instructions.

The brokers now had enough capital to manipulate the market.

They began buying and selling Rubber stock carefully.

The insiders noticed that someone powerful was accumulating shares.

But they had no idea who it was.

Bannigan deliberately stayed out of sight.

His brokers bought on some days and sold on others, keeping the stock active and giving the impression of strong demand.

Then they began borrowing large quantities of Rubber stock.

That convinced the insiders that a large short position existed somewhere.

They decided to squeeze the shorts.

The insiders controlled most of the outstanding shares.

They combined their strength and pushed the stock price up to $61.

That was exactly what Bannigan needed.

By the time Rubber reached $61, he had sold all of his shares.

Bannigan was now sitting on a huge amount of cash.

The insiders were holding the stock he had sold.

They still had no idea what had happened.

They did not realize that Bannigan himself had been the seller until his shares were delivered against the stock they believed they were buying from short sellers.

Then Rubber collapsed.

The stock fell from $61 all the way to $16.

It was one of the most extraordinary deals Wall Street had ever seen.

It had everything needed for a financial drama.

A clever businessman.

A powerful group of insiders.

A hidden seller.

A manufactured market.

And a final collapse.

I have only touched on a few details of the story.

Newcomers to Wall Street rarely come out as well as Bannigan did.

Many enjoy success for a while.

They make the market boom.

They become famous.

Then the market turns against them.

A. B. Stockwell is a good example.

He could still be found around Wall Street, but he had become one of the forgotten figures of an earlier generation.

Once he had been worth many millions.

Now he was financially ruined.

Stockwell began his career as the purser of a Lake Erie steamboat.

His father reportedly operated a livery stable in Cleveland.

During one voyage, Stockwell happened to meet Elias Howe, the famous inventor of the sewing machine.

Howe was traveling with his daughter.

Stockwell paid considerable attention to the young woman.

He eventually won her affection and married her.

When Elias Howe died, Mrs. Stockwell inherited her father's millions.

That money became Stockwell's starting capital on Wall Street.

He quickly became one of the most talked-about men in the district.

He invested all of his wife's money in Pacific Mail and eventually gained control of the company.

At first he was simply Stockwell.

As stories spread about his generosity and friendliness, people began calling him Mr. Stockwell.

After he took control of Pacific Mail, Wall Street gave him an even grander title.

He became Commodore Stockwell.

People treated him like royalty.

Everyone wanted to shake his hand.

Stockwell bought Pacific Mail at around $40.

He pushed it to $107.

At that point, he was worth more than fifteen million dollars on paper.

But then he discovered a painful truth.

A stock could be quoted at $107 without actually being worth $107 when a major holder tried to sell.

Stockwell was trapped.

He tried to unload his shares.

There was no real market for them.

Then his creditors began demanding repayment of his call loans.

He had no choice but to sell at whatever price he could get.

His selling created a huge wave of pressure.

Pacific Mail eventually fell all the way back to around $40.

In one collapse, Stockwell lost all of his paper profits.

He also lost his wife's inherited fortune.

The disaster stripped him of everything.

He went from being Commodore Stockwell back to plain Stockwell.

Some people were even cruel enough to call him “that little red-headed cuss.”

This was the most famous Pacific Mail boom of the period, although Leonard Jerome had already taken the same stock through several spectacular rises and falls.

Leonard Jerome and his brother Addison also enjoyed enormous success with Pacific Mail.

They pushed it to extraordinary heights several times.

But eventually they suffered the same fate as Stockwell.

The two brothers went from being among Wall Street's richest and most dazzling operators to being nearly wiped out.

Leonard Jerome was the father of Lady Randolph Churchill.

When he died, he had almost nothing left to leave his daughter except an interest in the house on Madison Avenue that later became the Manhattan Club.

That property produced about $15,000 a year, of which Lady Churchill received $10,000.

These were only a few of the great booms that had shaken Wall Street over the years.

There had also been the Keene booms, the Gould booms, and the Vanderbilt booms, all of which have been discussed earlier.

The rise of trusts and large business combinations had also become one of the great economic questions of the age.

One of the most important figures in this new world was John D. Rockefeller.

Future historians would almost certainly regard him as one of the most remarkable business figures of the nineteenth century.

History was changing.

It was no longer concerned only with kings, presidents, governments, and political parties.

Increasingly, historians were studying the lives and achievements of ordinary people and the great forces that shaped society.

Writers such as Lord Macaulay and John Bach McMaster had already shown the importance of this approach.

Seen from that perspective, Rockefeller was one of the most fascinating examples of America's new commercial power.

He was a pioneer.

He was a business Daniel Boone, entering territory that was still largely unexplored.

He took enormous risks.

He faced financial dangers that earlier generations had scarcely imagined.

And eventually he achieved a level of success that permanently changed American business.

His journey began in a small farmhouse in Tioga County, New York.

He was born in 1838 and was raised in a strict, church-going family.

People who knew him regarded his word as dependable.

He became known for his discipline, thrift, and determination.

His old schoolmaster appears to have been the first person to direct his attention toward petroleum refining.

At the time, Americans had long used sperm oil for lighting, and it could cost $1.50 a gallon.

The problem was how to turn the thick, foul-smelling petroleum found in Pennsylvania into something useful.

It looked like black slime.

Rockefeller discovered ways to refine it and turn it into a useful product that could be used in homes around the world.

That discovery eventually made him an enormous fortune.

Before he was twenty-one, Rockefeller entered a partnership with a man named Hewitt.

At first they were involved in warehousing and the produce business.

Then the Pennsylvania oil boom began.

Farmers who had been poor suddenly became rich.

Thousands of people rushed into the oil fields.

Rockefeller remained calm.

Some friends in Cleveland asked him to invest in oil wells for them.

He advised them not to do it.

He believed the oil boom was already becoming excessive.

Instead, he entered the refining business with Samuel Andrews, who understood the technical side of petroleum distillation.

Their firm eventually became Rockefeller, Flagler & Andrews.

It expanded rapidly.

In 1870, they organized the Standard Oil Company with one million dollars in capital.

Standard Oil built pipelines to transport crude oil to the seaports.

It found profitable uses for by-products that other companies had considered worthless.

It established markets around the world.

It continually reduced production costs.

And it steadily pushed its competitors aside.

The scale of its success was extraordinary.

In 1899 alone, its extra dividend amounted to $23 million, in addition to the regular dividends paid on the company's entire capital stock.

Rockefeller himself attributed his success largely to his early training and his willingness to persevere.

He believed that nothing comes from nothing.

Every result has a cause.

And in his view, persistence was one of the most important causes of success.

He believed that determination could overcome almost anything, even the obstacles imposed by nature itself.

In that respect, this practical businessman agreed with many of the philosophers of the ancient world.

Rockefeller and his associates naturally became a major force in the stock market.

They owned enormous amounts of railroad stocks and bonds.

At times, their influence seemed almost as powerful as gravity itself.

Rockefeller alone was believed to be the richest man in America, perhaps the richest man the world had ever known.

His fortune was thought to be the greatest ever accumulated by a single person during his own lifetime.

But enormous wealth also brought enormous responsibility.

Rockefeller clearly understood that.

He gave vast sums to schools, colleges, universities, churches, and charitable institutions.

His donations rivaled those of another famous American philanthropist, Andrew Carnegie.

Both men strongly believed that the best kind of charity was not simply giving people money, but helping them become capable of helping themselves.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!