← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 51 · Arbitration: A Better Way to Settle Business Disputes

Arbitration: A Better Way to Settle Business Disputes

Chapter 51 of 90 · 3,553 words · Free

Wall Street owes much of its prestige to the New York Stock Exchange. In a very real sense, the Exchange is Wall Street. If it ever moved somewhere else, that new location would quickly become the new Wall Street, while the old one would fade into history.

The Stock Exchange has distinguished itself in many ways, but perhaps its greatest achievement has been the successful use of arbitration to settle disputes.

Other financial organizations have tried arbitration as an alternative to ordinary court proceedings, but the Stock Exchange seems to have achieved greater success with it than any other business organization.

The large number of disputes that have been settled peacefully through arbitration in recent years suggests that the day may not be far off when arbitration becomes the final court of appeal for most civil disputes.

Why should it become so popular?

Because it is cheaper.

It is simpler.

It avoids the endless delays of the courts.

And, in many cases, it is fairer.

The men serving on arbitration committees are businesspeople. They understand business practices, recognize the important facts quickly, and make decisions according to practical business principles.

The cost is tiny compared with the enormous sums swallowed up by lawsuits.

Every year, Stock Exchange transactions involving millions of dollars are subject to arbitration if disagreements arise. Very few cases need to go beyond the arbitration committee.

If all those disputes had to be settled in court, they would probably cost at least half a million dollars a year, and perhaps another half-million in indirect expenses caused by delays and other complications. And that does not even include the fees charged by the most expensive lawyers at the bar.

The success of arbitration at the Stock Exchange seems to me to prove that the system could be extended throughout the business world.

Merchants and businesspeople everywhere could establish their own arbitration organizations and use them to settle disagreements and claims without going to court.

That is the main reason I am writing about this subject.

I hope some of the leading merchants in New York and other large cities will consider establishing arbitration systems of their own, modeled on the system that has worked so well at the Stock Exchange.

Their decisions should be final, without endless appeals.

Why the Jury System Often Fails

Experience has shown that jury trials frequently fail to deliver justice.

The problem has become even worse with what is known as “jury fixing.” Bribing jurors has become almost a secret profession, and it is so cleverly carried out that exposing it is extremely difficult.

But even without corruption, there are many reasons why a jury may fail to reach a fair decision.

Human sympathy plays a powerful role.

More precisely, class sympathy often determines the outcome.

A wealthy and powerful businessman can hardly expect a common jury to look at his case objectively when the opposing party appears poor or helpless.

If one side is a poor clerk, a woman, or someone with very limited means, jurors often feel that they must protect that person from the supposedly powerful opponent.

In such cases, the wealthy party may find it nearly impossible to receive fair treatment from the very institution that is supposed to be one of the great safeguards of liberty.

I regret saying this, but I speak from personal experience. I have been a victim of this kind of prejudice myself, in a country where all men are supposedly equal before the law.

Lawyers often make a dramatic spectacle of cases involving poor clients.

A small problem becomes a mountain.

The lawyer becomes deeply emotional about the supposed suffering of his client and presents the case as though a terrible injustice has occurred.

The jury becomes caught up in the performance.

Instead of carefully examining the evidence, jurors may be swept away by emotion, sympathy, and prejudice.

The Referee Who Changed His Mind

There are problems with referees as well, although a referee can sometimes be better than a jury.

I once witnessed a remarkable example.

A man I knew had a very large claim against a financially successful businessman. The case was sent to a referee.

After a long and exhausting examination of the evidence, the referee ruled in favor of my acquaintance and awarded him several hundred thousand dollars.

Soon afterward, the defendant approached him.

“I'll give you thirty thousand dollars to settle this matter,” he said.

“If you refuse, I'll appeal the decision or find new evidence and ask for another trial.”

The plaintiff naturally refused. Thirty thousand dollars was only a small fraction of the judgment.

The defendant then applied for a new trial, claiming that new evidence had been discovered.

The court granted it.

The entire process began again.

The lawyers went over the same ground, repeated the same arguments, and buried everyone under the same mountains of legal language.

Eventually the case was sent back to the same referee.

This time, however, the referee reached the opposite conclusion.

He ruled in favor of the defendant and awarded him a large sum of money.

The plaintiff was stunned.

He immediately went to see the defendant.

“I am outraged by this reversal,” he said. “I will never accept such a decision.”

The defendant looked at him.

“What do you want me to do?”

“I only want to be released from this judgment.”

“That will satisfy you?”

“Yes. I've had enough of this kind of law. I simply want to get rid of the whole affair.”

“All right,” the defendant replied. “I'll do it. I'll give you a receipt in full satisfaction of every claim.”

The matter was settled.

Then the defendant added quietly:

“I wish you had accepted the thirty thousand dollars I offered you. I would rather you had received it than anyone else, because I had to pay it anyway.”

The old biblical lesson had been completely reversed.

The first had become last, and the last had become first.

The Real Cost of Going to Court

Litigation does more than cost money.

It creates bitterness.

As a case drags through one stage after another, the relationship between the two sides usually becomes worse. Accusations and counteraccusations multiply.

Private family matters are dragged into public view.

People who have nothing to do with the dispute may have their personal affairs exposed.

Their reputations can suffer for years, sometimes long after the original litigants are dead.

The damage caused by litigation can therefore reach far beyond the people who started the dispute.

Then there is the financial cost.

The expense of a lawsuit often depends only on how much money the two sides can afford to spend.

Time is another enormous cost.

A businessman whose success depends on his personal attention to his company may have to spend years dealing with a lawsuit.

A case can begin in a lower court, move through several appeals, and eventually reach the highest courts. If a new trial is ordered, much of the process may have to be repeated.

Five or ten years can disappear in this way.

By the time the case ends, one or even both parties may be financially ruined.

Anyone who has never been involved in a lawsuit cannot imagine the mental strain.

The plaintiff or defendant must appear in court day after day, often accompanied by witnesses.

Books and documents must be carried back and forth.

The entire business operation may have to be disrupted simply to accommodate the court schedule.

Employees are pulled away from their regular duties.

The two businesses involved can be thrown into disorder.

And each side often tries to make life as difficult as possible for the other.

That is the spirit litigation tends to create.

A lawyer with half a dozen ordinary cases can therefore keep himself fully occupied.

As long as his clients avoid bankruptcy, his income may be as reliable as an insurance annuity—and sometimes more secure.

Let Businesspeople Settle Business Disputes

The system I am proposing might make life less comfortable for some lawyers.

But merchants and businesspeople would gain far more than lawyers would lose.

The benefit to society as a whole would be enormous.

Arbitration could be organized throughout the country.

There could be a central association in New York or another major city.

Other major cities could have their own regional associations, each serving the commercial interests of its surrounding area.

Smaller cities and towns could establish branch organizations connected directly with the larger associations.

They could share information, statistics, and important decisions from previous cases.

Each local association should have authority over its own affairs.

The central organization would mainly serve as an advisory body.

Each association should also have a governing committee that would act as its final court of appeal.

Its decision should be final.

People who submitted a dispute to arbitration should first be given a clear explanation of the rules.

They should then agree in advance to accept the committee's decision.

This would make the system much more effective.

The committees should also meet as close as possible to the largest number of witnesses involved in each case.

That would save both time and money.

Such a system would greatly reduce the workload of the courts.

Judges would then have more time to deal with the important and unusual cases that truly require judicial attention.

There are plenty of such cases without forcing the courts to handle every ordinary business disagreement.

One of the most irritating parts of court proceedings is being required to appear again and again even when nothing important is happening.

Meanwhile, legal expenses continue to grow.

Lawyers do not attend court for free.

Their clients must pay for every hour.

An arbitration system would not destroy the legal profession.

There would still be plenty of work for capable lawyers.

But it would relieve overworked judges and make justice faster and more practical.

It would also eliminate much of the business now enjoyed by petty lawyers whose main talent is prolonging disputes.

Technicalities That Waste Years

Court proceedings often waste enormous amounts of time on technical questions and side issues before anyone gets to the real substance of a dispute.

Businesspeople could settle many of these matters quickly by using ordinary common sense.

Arbitration would also eliminate the unnecessary burden of posting bonds in many cases.

The bonding process is often little more than a formality.

Sometimes the bonds are backed by people who are technically qualified but have no real ability to pay.

Reliable sureties, when available, may be subjected to humiliating examinations about their private finances.

Much of this information is irrelevant to the actual case.

A person who voluntarily agrees to help a friend may be treated as though he were a criminal hiding something.

Some of this behavior comes from the rude and aggressive manner of certain lawyers.

As a result, responsible people who understand what being a surety involves often refuse to help friends at all.

That makes it easier for professional “straw men” to become sureties.

There may even be an understanding between these professional sureties and certain lawyers based on money and improper payments.

I once experienced a case that illustrates this problem particularly well.

A $16,000 Claim Becomes a $132,000 Judgment

My firm once sued a client for a legitimate debt of sixteen thousand dollars.

The case was sent to a referee whose reputation was excellent at the time.

He was a respected member of his profession and came from a prominent family.

Both sides were satisfied with his appointment.

The case dragged on for years.

The record became filled with enormous amounts of irrelevant material.

Legal fees were repeatedly demanded from both sides.

There was no practical alternative but to keep paying.

Eventually, after years of delay, the lawyers finally agreed that all the evidence had been presented.

Both sides breathed a sigh of relief.

Each believed victory was near.

Shortly before the case ended, the referee spoke to me privately.

“You should settle this case,” he advised.

“I intend to rule against your firm.”

I refused.

“I intend to fight it to the end.”

The result was astonishing.

My firm did not receive the sixteen thousand dollars we were owed.

Instead, the referee ruled against us and awarded the defendant $132,000.

I considered this such an outrageous miscarriage of justice that I obtained a stay and appealed.

In my appeal, I specifically mentioned the referee's advice that I settle before the case was finished.

Judge Fancher wrote the opinion for the court.

His decision completely condemned the referee and overturned his ruling.

That ended the matter.

When Sympathy Defeats Evidence

Another case from my own experience shows how strongly sympathy can influence juries.

I once employed a clerk at a salary of $2,000 a year.

Unfortunately, he was a great disappointment.

He was incompetent for the work I had hired him to perform and showed very little interest in improving.

At the end of his first year, I told him, in front of two witnesses, that I would not need him after the year ended.

I advised him to begin looking for another position immediately.

On the last day of the year, he came to me with tears in his eyes.

“I haven't been able to find another job,” he said.

“Times are terrible.”

“My family depends entirely on me.”

“Please keep me on a little longer until I can find another position.”

His story was convincing and pathetic.

I felt sorry for him.

So I agreed to keep him temporarily at the same salary, provided that he made every effort to find another job.

But once the second term began, his work proved just as useless as before.

After several weeks, I called him into my office.

“Have you found another job?”

“No.”

“I've given you plenty of time. I cannot keep you any longer.”

I instructed my cashier to prepare a check for all wages due up to that date.

The check stated clearly that it was payment in full for all claims and demands.

He left.

Afterward, however, he continued visiting my office.

I assumed he was simply being polite.

Then, at the end of the second year, I received notice of a lawsuit.

He was suing me for the salary he claimed was still owed for ten months of the year.

The case eventually came before a Brooklyn court.

His only witness was his father.

The father had visited me several times after his son's dismissal and testified about conversations that supposedly took place between us.

Most of those conversations were simply untrue.

I had five or more witnesses who could confirm my version of events.

All of them were reputable people.

Yet the jury ignored the overwhelming evidence.

Instead, they were influenced by the dramatic speech of the opposing lawyer.

The lawyer was clever and persuasive.

He painted a heartbreaking picture of the young man's poverty.

He described his family as facing complete ruin.

And he blamed everything on the cruelty of a wealthy millionaire and “bloated bondholder.”

The evidence was forgotten.

Sympathy became the real basis of the verdict.

The trial lasted several days.

Five or six employees from my office had to attend court constantly.

They carried heavy books and piles of documents back and forth every day.

Our regular business was badly disrupted.

Eventually, the lawyer finished his dramatic review of the evidence.

The jury retired briefly, apparently to perform the required formality.

Then they returned.

They awarded the young clerk back pay, plus interest, for ten months during which he had performed not a single hour of work for me.

My lawyer could easily have produced additional witnesses.

He had not considered it necessary because he believed the evidence already presented was overwhelming.

He was certain we would win.

The jury proved him wrong.

It showed him that the law could mean very little when twelve people were allowed to decide according to their sympathies and prejudices.

My lawyer nevertheless presented the new evidence to the judge and requested another trial.

The judge agreed because the verdict was contrary to the weight of the evidence.

The Second Jury Does the Same Thing

Eventually the case was tried again.

This time we brought additional witnesses.

The new jury was intelligent enough, but once again its sympathy was entirely with the supposedly injured young man.

He was now seeking twelve months of salary for only two months of useful—or rather, useless—service.

His father's testimony remained unchanged.

His memory was remarkably accurate, especially when it came to statements that helped his son.

There is an old saying about people who need very good memories.

I will leave the rest to the reader.

The same lawyer appeared again.

He had little new evidence, but he had become even better at presenting his side.

He only needed to understand one side of the story, after all.

His dramatic performance was more polished than before.

And once again, the jury followed him.

The jury, supposedly one of the great safeguards of liberty, treated the case as another example of persecution by a wealthy employer.

The second verdict was even more strongly in favor of the plaintiff.

Financially, it would probably have been wiser for me simply to pay the amount demanded, along with all the legal expenses and other charges.

But I refused to be cheated merely because the process was expensive.

I asked the court for another new trial.

The judge replied:

“I have already given you one new trial and accepted the responsibility for doing so.”

“This matter has now been before two juries.”

“I am not willing to take any additional responsibility.”

“If you believe you have further rights, you must take the matter to the Court of Appeals.”

And so the case went there.

It will probably take years before it is finally heard.

Meanwhile, the young man can enjoy the comforting thought that his judgment is a profitable investment, earning six percent interest.

The Diamond Earrings

There is another case that illustrates the old legal saying:

“You never know what a jury will do.”

I had the unfortunate experience of becoming involved in such a case.

A well-known Wall Street outside broker once came to me.

He had extensive experience handling puts, calls, and other securities for Mr. Sage and other prominent figures in the financial district.

One afternoon he asked me:

“Would you like to buy a pair of diamond earrings?”

At that time I knew almost nothing about the diamond business.

My only previous experience had been buying a wedding ring, which is one of the basic requirements of a long-term marriage contract.

So I was a complete beginner.

The broker took advantage of that.

I asked him several questions about the diamonds.

His answers sounded satisfactory.

I thought my wife would like them.

I had also had a profitable day in business, so I offered him $1,000.

He immediately accepted.

I paid him the money.

A few weeks later, a diamond dealer and his lawyer came to see me.

I had never met either man.

They introduced themselves to each other before explaining why they had come.

At first I thought they were bringing me some profitable stock business.

I was wrong.

They told me that I had a pair of earrings belonging to them.

“I will return them when you return my $1,000,” I replied.

They left.

Eventually, I received the usual legal papers.

The case finally reached court.

The young man who had sold me the diamonds testified.

He said he had received the earrings from a certain diamond broker—not from the dealer who was suing me.

In fact, he said he had never had any dealings with that dealer.

The evidence showed that the broker had been acting as the dealer's agent for years.

He had sold more than $10,000 worth of diamonds for the dealer over several years.

During the trial, a document was produced showing that the broker had received the earrings to display to a customer.

As it turned out, I was that customer.

The broker had taken my $1,000 but had never turned the money over to his employer.

I had no knowledge that the diamonds belonged to someone else.

Nor did I have any reasonable way of knowing it.

The facts were presented to the jury.

The jury nevertheless decided that I had to surrender the diamonds and lose my $1,000.

The case is now on appeal.

I have since offered to return the diamonds and accept the loss of my money simply to avoid the further expense and trouble of litigation.

But the plaintiff wants another $300 from me to cover his legal expenses.

I have not agreed to pay it.

Instead, I have decided to see whether there is still some justice left to be found in a higher court.

“Millions for defense, but not a dollar for tribute” is an expensive principle to follow.

But if a person can afford it, there may be some moral value in refusing to surrender simply because the legal process has become unreasonable.

These cases, in which I have played a rather unfortunate role, are only a few examples among many.

To me, they provide one of the strongest arguments for establishing a broad system of arbitration throughout the business world.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!