Back to England and Newgate Prison

Chapter 34 of 50 · 2,530 words · Free

Ten days after the events I described earlier, I entered Havana again.

This time, I was a prisoner.

Two days after my capture, the Captain-General of Cuba ordered me to be sent to Havana aboard the Santa Rita, a miserable little gunboat that could barely manage four miles an hour. The trip from Puerto Novo on the south coast to Havana took eight long days.

When we reached Havana, soldiers took me directly to the common prison instead of the police barracks.

An entire corridor had been emptied to make room for me and the guards.

Pinkerton was the first person to visit.

He looked genuinely pleased to see me.

“You certainly gave us a good chase,” he said. “I have to admit, you managed your escape remarkably well. But I don't intend to let you get away from me again.”

The authorities had given him permission to watch me closely.

“I or one of my men will stay with you day and night,” he added.

I could not help respecting his determination. He was simply doing his job, and he treated me with remarkable courtesy.

On that first visit, he even brought me a letter from my wife, along with a box of cigars and a bottle of wine from himself.

One of his men, Perry, usually slept in my little room.

Every morning, Mr. Pinkerton took over and stayed with me until dinner.

We spent hours talking about all kinds of things. He told me fascinating stories about famous criminal cases in which he had taken part.

Little by little, we became friends.

One day he explained exactly how he had discovered that I was in the West Indies.

William Pinkerton had ordered him to investigate the New York side of the case and find out who F. A. Warren really was.

At first, he knew no more about me than what he had read in the newspapers.

But he quickly formed a theory.

“You're an American,” he decided. “And probably from either New York or Chicago.”

He believed this because I was young but seemed to understand finance unusually well.

So he went to Wall Street.

He obtained a list of practically every banker and broker in New York and began questioning them.

His question was always the same:

“Who is this man?”

With their help, he eventually produced a list of nearly twenty men who might be F. A. Warren.

Then he reduced the list to four.

My name was among them.

He found my home and began making quiet inquiries among my neighbors and acquaintances.

He learned that people believed I was somewhere in Europe. They also knew I had traveled there before.

More importantly, when I had returned from my last trip, I had paid off my debts and seemed to have plenty of money.

By then, Pinkerton was convinced.

I was Warren.

But there was still one problem.

Where was I?

He eventually heard one of my acquaintances repeat something I had once said:

“Whenever I have money in the bank, I ought to live somewhere in the tropics.”

That remark gave him the next clue.

He reported that he believed Warren and I were the same person and suggested that, if I was anywhere in America, I might be hiding at some fashionable resort in Florida.

So he went to Florida.

After reaching St. Augustine, he sent letters to several islands in the West Indies, including Martinique, Jamaica, and Cuba.

He asked for the names and descriptions of wealthy young Americans who had recently arrived.

One of his letters went to Dr. C. L. Houscomb, a leading American doctor in Havana.

The doctor's reply included my name.

After I was arrested, Dr. Houscomb told me how terrible he felt about what had happened.

“I thought Pinkerton was a newspaper reporter,” he explained. “I thought he only wanted the information for a story.”

But the mistake had already been made.

Once Pinkerton had my name and knew I was in Havana, the rest was easy.

His detective work had finally brought him to me.

Later, the bank authorities rewarded him handsomely and congratulated him for solving the case.

About ten days after I arrived in prison, Pinkerton brought me a copy of the New York Herald.

Two dispatches immediately caught my attention.

The first was from Madrid.

The American ambassador, General Sickles, had formally informed the Spanish government that America would agree to my extradition to Britain.

I was to be handed over to the British authorities because of my alleged involvement in the Bank of England forgery.

The second report came from London.

The British authorities were celebrating the news that Spain had agreed to extradite me.

The newspaper said there was little doubt that Bidwell and F. A. Warren were the same man.

It also reported that people were extremely curious to see me.

Stories about my escape and capture had become sensational news. One newspaper had even claimed that I had been badly wounded and had been carrying diamonds worth an enormous sum when I was captured.

Sergeants Hayden and Green from Bow Street, together with Mr. Good of the Bank of England, were already preparing to sail for Havana.

They were coming to take me back to London.

The net was closing around me.

I said nothing about the painful meetings I had every day with my wife.

But if I had known then that she would marry another man soon after I was sentenced, perhaps I would not have felt so sorry for her.

Eventually Green, Hayden, and Good arrived in Havana and were introduced to me.

I still refused to give up.

With help from my friends, I made a determined effort to persuade the Captain-General to delay my extradition.

For a while, I succeeded.

But delays could not last forever.

After many arguments, plans, and failed attempts to stop what was coming, I was finally taken to the mouth of the harbor early one morning in May.

An English warship, the Vulture, was waiting there.

Its boat came alongside, and I was formally transferred into British custody.

Curtin, Perry, Hayden, and Green came aboard with me.

Soon the boat pulled away from Havana.

Later that day, the Moselle, the regular passenger steamer bound for Plymouth and Southampton, came out to sea.

About ten miles from shore, the Vulture's boat met her.

I and my four guards were transferred to the Moselle.

At last, I was on my way back to England.

Everything seemed to suggest that Justice would finally have her way with me.

Then I saw my wife aboard the ship.

I had secretly made up my mind that I would never allow myself to be taken back alive.

My plan was simple.

On the first night at sea, I would jump overboard.

The waters of the Gulf were warm, and ships passed through those waters regularly. Perhaps I could survive the night and be rescued.

I might even wear a cork life jacket to give myself a chance.

But Curtin had already anticipated me.

He arranged for my wife to travel on the same ship.

He treated me like an ordinary cabin passenger and allowed her to remain near me.

He had correctly guessed that I would never deliberately throw myself overboard while she was there.

He had outsmarted me again.

The journey to England was comfortable enough.

But every night I prayed for disaster.

I wished the ship would strike an iceberg or sink.

I thought that would spare my wife years of suffering and spare me the misery and humiliation of prison.

One of my servants had found a position in Havana, so he remained there.

Nunn, however, came back to England with me.

He was deeply unhappy about what he believed was waiting for me.

I was glad to know that he had kept the money I had given him.

He had about two thousand dollars, and I wanted to increase it to five thousand.

After everything he had done for me, I felt he deserved it.

At last, on a beautiful June morning, we sailed into Plymouth.

The ship stopped there to unload mail and allow passengers to take the express train to London.

I told my wife to continue on to Southampton.

I would go ashore with my guards.

The next morning, the newspapers were filled with reports of my arrival.

The London Times wrote that Bidwell, also known as F. A. Warren, had landed at Plymouth from the Moselle under the custody of Detective Sergeant Michael Hayden and William Green.

Captain John Curtin and Walter Perry of Pinkerton's staff were with them.

Two London detectives had also traveled down to meet the ship.

News of my arrival had spread quickly.

Thousands of people had gathered at Millbay Pier simply to see the prisoner.

The crowd was so large that my escort had difficulty getting me to the waiting cabs.

We were driven to the Duke of Cornwall Hotel near the railway station.

Soon afterward, we left for London on the 12:45 train.

Nearly twenty thousand people had gathered to watch us leave.

To my surprise, they cheered me.

The newspaper announced that I would be taken before the Lord Mayor at the Mansion House the following morning.

I arrived in London with six men escorting me.

It was a bright spring morning, and London was overflowing with people.

Thousands were heading toward Epsom Downs for the Derby, one of the greatest events of the English year.

The whole city was celebrating.

People dressed in their finest clothes and enjoyed the holiday atmosphere.

And I?

I was being taken to Newgate Prison.

The contrast was almost unbearable.

London was alive with excitement while I was being carried toward a prison cell.

I thought about the life I had once enjoyed.

I had chosen an easy and comfortable road, living well while ignoring honor and morality.

Now that road had brought me here.

The old saying came to my mind:

“Whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap.”

Those words suddenly seemed painfully true.

I was a prisoner in Newgate.

Even the name frightened me.

The great stone prison stood in the middle of London like a grim fortress.

For centuries it had held prisoners from every class and every generation.

How many broken people had passed through those gates?

How many desperate cries had those walls heard?

That first night, I walked through the dark corridors.

The history of the prison seemed to rise around me.

I imagined all the suffering that had taken place there.

Then I realized something that made it even worse.

I had now become part of that endless procession of prisoners entering through those gates.

I was one more broken man inside those walls.

And I knew that a terrible sentence was waiting for me.

I had three old friends already imprisoned there.

When we had said goodbye on the wharf at Calais, we had spent the evening looking at the stars and talking about life.

None of us had imagined that we would meet again in Newgate.

It was a bitter reunion.

What shocked me almost as much as the prison itself was the way prisoners awaiting trial were treated.

I had assumed that because we had not yet been convicted, we would be treated as innocent men awaiting judgment.

I was wrong.

Newgate followed the harsh rules of a convict prison.

Silence was strictly enforced.

Newspapers were forbidden.

News from the outside world was cut off.

Friends and family were not even allowed to send us books or small comforts.

The whole system was rigid and merciless.

It made little sense.

A man awaiting trial was already suffering enough.

His mind was filled with fear, regret, and uncertainty.

Take away every book, every conversation, and every connection with the outside world, and you could drive a healthy mind toward madness.

That was exactly what began happening to me.

My past filled me with remorse.

My present filled me with misery.

My future looked hopeless.

I desperately needed something that could take my mind away from it all.

Books could have done that.

But even books were denied to us.

Again and again, my mind returned to an image from Shakespeare.

It was the fear of dying and entering an unknown world, with no idea what awaited you there.

That image haunted me.

I felt as though I were already standing at the edge of some enormous abyss.

I feared that my own mind was slipping into it.

If I had possessed the talent of Victor Hugo, I could have described what happened inside me.

Imagine a man slowly losing his grip on reason while trapped inside cold stone walls.

He fights against the darkness in his own mind.

He tries desperately to hold on.

But the walls offer nothing.

They stare back at him, silent and empty.

You begin searching them anyway.

You examine every inch of them.

You hope that some previous prisoner left behind a word, a sentence, even a tiny scratch.

Anything.

A message from another human being.

Something that says:

“I was here too.”

That instinct is deeply human.

When a person is completely isolated, he wants to leave some mark behind.

He wants to reach across time and tell another human being that he once lived, suffered, hoped, and thought.

That is why ancient peoples carved symbols into rocks.

It is why archaeologists still uncover tablets and inscriptions left by civilizations that disappeared thousands of years ago.

Those people wanted their thoughts to survive them.

They wanted someone in the distant future to find their words and understand that another human mind had once been there.

I felt that same desperate need.

Night after night, I stared at the walls of my cell.

My mind was often so overwhelmed that I could hardly think clearly.

Still, I searched the walls.

I looked for scratches.

I looked for words.

I looked for any sign that another prisoner had left behind a message.

Perhaps it would be an expression of misery.

Perhaps a cry of despair.

Perhaps simply a few words from someone who had suffered as I was suffering.

But there was nothing.

And I eventually learned why.

Previous prisoners had left messages on those walls.

Every one of them had tried to leave some small record of their existence.

But after each prisoner left, the officials had simply painted over everything.

Every trace was erased.

Every message disappeared beneath fresh paint.

I found that cruelty almost unbearable.

Even now, remembering it makes my blood boil.

The old keepers of the Tower of London had shown more humanity centuries earlier.

They had allowed the inscriptions carved by Raleigh and other prisoners to remain.

Those words survived.

And even today, visitors can see them.

Those old prisoners had left behind a small piece of themselves.

Their words crossed centuries and still speak to anyone willing to read them.

But in Newgate, the walls were deliberately silenced.

And for a prisoner like me, desperately searching for some human connection, that silence was almost as cruel as the prison itself.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!