Trapped by the Trial
My time in Newgate Prison became one of the worst experiences of my life.
Every day, it felt as if the ground beneath us was disappearing. The authorities were tightening the net around us, and before long, we had all accepted the terrible truth: there was probably no way out.
We were not innocent. We had committed crimes and, eventually, would have to answer for them. At the time, of course, none of us wanted to admit that.
But we believed the evidence against us was extremely weak.
“If this trial were taking place in America,” one of us said, “we might have a real chance of getting free.”
I agreed.
American courts had procedures that gave an accused person more opportunities to challenge a conviction. England was different. Once an English jury reached its verdict, there was essentially no criminal appeal system like the one we knew in America.
And that made the situation frightening.
“If the judge wants you convicted,” I thought, “then there may be nothing you can do.”
We also believed the jury was heavily influenced by the judge.
The jurors were mostly ordinary shopkeepers, and in our eyes they seemed far too respectful of the upper classes.
“They don't even seem to care about the evidence,” we complained. “They watch the judge instead.”
“If the judge smiles, they think we're innocent.”
“And if he frowns?”
“They'll decide we're guilty.”
That was how we saw the English system at the time.
Then there was the matter of lawyers.
In America, a person facing criminal charges would normally hire a lawyer to handle the case. One lawyer could represent the client from beginning to end, although the cost could still be considerable.
England's legal system was much more complicated.
There were solicitors, barristers, and Queen's Counsel.
The solicitor dealt directly with the client and handled the practical business of the case.
The barrister was hired by the solicitor to argue the case in court. He normally received his instructions from the solicitor rather than dealing directly with the client.
Then there was the Queen's Counsel, a senior lawyer with a higher rank.
But even a Queen's Counsel was expected to have a barrister working alongside him.
“So a defendant may have to pay two lawyers,” I explained, “and sometimes three, simply to have a case properly represented.”
It seemed to us like a system designed to make lawyers rich.
We hired a solicitor named David Howell, whose office was at 105 Cheapside.
He was a small, thin man with a pale face, reddish hair, a short beard, and sharp little eyes. His voice was thin and unpleasant.
Unfortunately, our first impression of him turned out to be correct.
From beginning to end, Howell handled our case almost exactly as the prosecution would have wanted.
He charged us heavily, and by the time everything was over, we had paid him nearly ten thousand dollars.
And for all that money, our legal defense was dreadful.
We had eight lawyers in all—four Queen's Counsel and four barristers.
Yet we were convinced that most of them were nearly useless.
“If Howell had treated us this way in America,” one of us said bitterly, “he would probably be the one standing before a jury for robbing us.”
We came to another conclusion as well.
Of our eight lawyers, we thought only one was capable of handling even an ordinary hearing before a magistrate.
Meanwhile, our preliminary hearings continued.
I will not describe every detail of those proceedings or the trial itself. They became one of the biggest sensations of the day.
Newspapers throughout Britain, America, and the rest of the English-speaking world followed the case.
Illustrated newspapers printed full-page pictures of the trial.
Our faces were reproduced everywhere.
People who had never met us knew what we looked like.
After hearing us repeatedly before the authorities, we were finally ordered to stand trial.
The newspapers announced that the case would begin at the Old Bailey in August.
One editorial in the London Times described the enormous amount of evidence that had been collected.
The preliminary proceedings alone had produced 242 large pages of testimony and documents.
“One hundred and eight witnesses have already testified,” the newspaper reported.
There had been twenty-three separate preliminary examinations.
They had begun in March and continued until July, with additional delays caused by repeated remands.
The newspaper called it one of the most important and remarkable cases ever heard before a Lord Mayor of London.
When the August sessions of the Old Bailey opened, the crowds were enormous.
The courthouse was packed.
The streets outside were packed too.
People had come simply to see us.
Inside the courtroom sat senior officials, aldermen, lawyers, government representatives, and important figures connected with the Bank of England.
Ladies occupied many of the reserved seats.
The lawyers were there in force.
The prosecution was represented by Hardinge Gifford, Queen's Counsel, and Watkin Williams, Queen's Counsel, acting for the bank's solicitors.
Then our trial began.
For eight terrible days, we sat in the prisoners' dock while the case was argued against us.
The public stared at us as though we were some strange attraction.
We were the young Americans who had supposedly discovered a weakness in the supposedly unbreakable Bank of England.
The whole thing was unbearable.
“I would not live through another eight days like those for all the money in the world,” I thought.
The courtroom was filled with fashionable people who had come to watch our suffering.
Thousands more crowded the corridors and streets outside.
They wanted only one thing—to see the young Americans accused of one of the most sensational financial crimes England had seen.
The judge sat high above us in his scarlet robes.
Around him sat aldermen and other dignitaries dressed in their official robes and gold chains.
The lawyers filled much of the courtroom.
To us, many of them seemed more interested in jokes, drinks, and socializing than in the lives hanging in the balance.
After lunch, some appeared to be in high spirits from their punch or sherry.
They laughed and talked while we sat there facing ruin.
Captain Curtin was there too, along with more than twenty detectives.
Then the prosecution began calling its witnesses.
There were 213 of them.
About fifty had come from America.
Their job was not simply to testify about the forged documents. They were used to reconstruct our lives and movements over many years.
That was important because the forged bills had been sent through the mail.
There was no simple piece of evidence showing us directly committing the crime.
The prosecution therefore had to build its case through circumstances.
Most of the evidence seemed weak to us.
But there was one thing that worried us—the blotting paper.
That strange piece of evidence stood out from everything else.
And despite our confidence that the prosecution's case was poor, we could feel what was coming.
Our conviction seemed decided before the jury even left the courtroom.
At about seven o'clock, the jury finally withdrew to consider its verdict.
We waited.
The minutes dragged by.
Then, after only about fifteen minutes, the jury returned.
Everyone in the courtroom became silent.
We stared at the jurors.
The foreman stood up.
“Guilty.”
The word fell like a hammer.
All four of us had been convicted.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!