Braddock’s Defeat

Chapter 16 of 19 · 2,834 words · Free

The British government refused to let the colonies unite under the Albany Plan. They feared that if the colonies organized their own defense, they might become too strong and too independent.

Instead, they sent General Braddock with two regiments of British regular troops.

Braddock landed in Virginia and then marched into Maryland, where he stopped to find wagons for carrying his supplies.

The Pennsylvania Assembly had heard that Braddock disliked them and believed they were unwilling to support the expedition. They asked me to visit him, but not officially on behalf of the Assembly. Since I was postmaster general, I could approach him as if I were simply offering to help arrange reliable communication between him and the governors of the colonies.

My son William came with me.

We found Braddock waiting impatiently at Frederic Town. He had sent men through the countryside of Maryland and Virginia to find wagons, but they had returned with almost nothing.

I stayed with the general for several days and ate with him every day.

During that time, I explained what the Pennsylvania Assembly had already done before his arrival and what it was still willing to do to help his expedition.

By the time I was ready to leave, the wagon reports finally arrived.

There were only twenty-five wagons.

And many of them were not even fit for military use.

Braddock and his officers were shocked.

“This expedition is impossible,” they said.

“How could the ministers have sent us into a country without enough wagons to move our supplies and baggage?”

They estimated that they needed at least one hundred and fifty wagons.

I happened to say, “It is unfortunate that you did not land in Pennsylvania. Almost every farmer there owns a wagon.”

Braddock immediately turned to me.

“Then you, sir, have influence in Pennsylvania. Surely you can get the wagons for us.”

“I can try,” I said. “What will you pay the owners?”

“Put the terms you think are necessary in writing.”

I prepared the terms.

Braddock approved them at once and gave me official authority to hire the wagons and horses.

As soon as I reached Lancaster, I published an advertisement offering good payment and fair protection to anyone willing to provide wagons and horses.

The announcement explained exactly what would be paid, when payment would begin, how losses would be compensated, and that drivers would not be forced to serve as soldiers.

I also explained why I believed the people should cooperate.

The army was about to move toward Will’s Creek, and it desperately needed transportation. If the people supplied the wagons and horses, they could earn a great deal of money.

I warned them, however, that if they refused, the army might simply take what it needed by force.

I ended my message by making it clear that I had no personal financial interest in the matter.

“I have no particular interest in this affair,” I wrote. “Except for the satisfaction of trying to do some good, I shall receive nothing for my trouble.”

I received about eight hundred pounds from Braddock to make advance payments to the wagon owners.

It was not enough.

So I added more than two hundred pounds of my own money.

Within two weeks, the required one hundred and fifty wagons and two hundred and fifty-nine horses were on their way to the army.

The owners were still worried.

They did not know Braddock and did not trust his promise to pay them if their wagons or horses were lost.

So they asked me to personally guarantee the payments.

I gave them my bond.

While I was at the camp, I once had dinner with officers from Colonel Dunbar’s regiment.

Dunbar told me he was worried about his junior officers.

“They are not wealthy men,” he said. “They can hardly afford to buy everything they need for such a long march through the wilderness. There will be nowhere to buy supplies along the way.”

I felt sorry for them.

I decided to help.

I did not tell Dunbar what I planned to do. Instead, I wrote to a committee of the Pennsylvania Assembly that controlled some public funds.

“These officers need basic supplies and refreshments,” I wrote. “The Assembly should provide them with a gift.”

My son William knew something about life in military camps, so he prepared a list of what the officers would need.

The committee approved my proposal.

They acted so quickly that William was able to bring the supplies to the camp at almost exactly the same time as the wagons.

Each officer received a carefully packed parcel containing food and drink.

The officers were extremely grateful.

The colonels of both regiments wrote to thank me.

Braddock was also very pleased with my help.

He paid all the money I had spent on the wagons and thanked me repeatedly.

Then he asked me to help send food and supplies after the army as it advanced.

I agreed.

I continued working on the arrangements until we heard that Braddock had been defeated.

By then, I had advanced more than one thousand pounds of my own money.

I sent Braddock an account of everything I had spent.

Fortunately, he received it only a few days before the battle.

He immediately sent me an order for one thousand pounds from the army paymaster.

I considered that extremely fortunate, because I was never able to recover the rest of the money.

Braddock was, in my opinion, a brave man.

In a European war, he might have become a very successful officer.

But he had too much confidence in himself.

He also had an exaggerated faith in regular British troops and looked down on both Americans and Indians.

George Croghan, our Indian interpreter, joined Braddock's march with about one hundred Native American allies.

They could have been extremely useful as guides and scouts.

But Braddock treated them badly and paid little attention to them.

One by one, they left him.

One day, Braddock told me about his plans.

“After taking Fort Duquesne,” he said, “I will march to Niagara.”

“And after Niagara?”

“Then to Fort Frontenac, if the season allows.”

He sounded completely confident.

“Fort Duquesne should take only three or four days,” he continued. “After that, I see nothing that could stop me from reaching Niagara.”

I had already thought about the narrow road his army would have to cut through the forest.

The army would stretch for miles along that road.

I also remembered reading about an earlier French army that had been defeated after invading the territory of the Iroquois.

I was worried.

Still, I did not want to argue with a professional soldier about military strategy.

So I said carefully, “If you reach Fort Duquesne with these fine troops and all this artillery, the fort may not be able to resist for long. But I do see one possible danger.”

“What danger?”

“Indian ambushes.”

I explained that Native American fighters were highly skilled at attacking from hiding.

“Your army will stretch for almost four miles along the road. If the enemy attacks your flanks by surprise, they could cut the army into several pieces. Those units would be too far apart to support one another quickly.”

Braddock smiled at me.

“You Americans may have good reason to fear these savages because your militia is inexperienced. But against the king’s trained and disciplined troops, sir, they cannot possibly do much.”

I realized that I had gone too far in arguing with a professional soldier.

So I said no more.

The enemy did not attack the army while it was stretched out along the road, as I had feared.

Instead, they waited until Braddock's army was only about nine miles from Fort Duquesne.

The army had just crossed a river.

The front had stopped to wait for the rest of the troops to cross, so the army was temporarily gathered closer together.

They were also moving through a more open section of forest.

Suddenly, the French and Indians opened heavy fire from behind trees and bushes.

It was the first warning Braddock had that the enemy was nearby.

The advance guard broke into confusion.

Braddock immediately ordered more troops forward to support them.

But the troops rushed ahead in disorder, moving through wagons, baggage, and cattle.

Then the enemy began firing into their flank.

The British officers were on horseback, which made them easy targets.

They were shot down one after another.

The soldiers became packed together.

They could not hear their orders.

They did not know where to move.

They simply stood there while the enemy fired at them.

By the time they finally broke, nearly two-thirds of the men had been killed.

Then panic spread through the entire army.

The soldiers ran.

The wagon drivers took horses from their teams and fled.

Others followed them.

Soon the army had abandoned its wagons, food, artillery, ammunition, and supplies.

The enemy took everything.

Braddock was badly wounded and was carried away with great difficulty.

His secretary, Mr. Shirley, was killed beside him.

Of the eighty-six officers, sixty-three were killed or wounded.

Of the eleven hundred soldiers in the battle, seven hundred and fourteen were killed.

These eleven hundred men had been specially selected from the whole army.

The rest had been left behind under Colonel Dunbar with the heavier supplies, baggage, and provisions.

The fleeing soldiers reached Dunbar's camp.

They were not being pursued, but the panic they brought with them immediately spread to Dunbar and his men.

Dunbar now had more than one thousand soldiers.

The force that had defeated Braddock had probably contained no more than four hundred French and Native American fighters.

Dunbar could have moved forward and tried to recover some of the army's honor.

Instead, he ordered the supplies and ammunition to be destroyed.

He wanted more horses for his retreat and less baggage to carry.

The governors of Virginia, Maryland, and Pennsylvania begged him to station his troops along the frontier to protect the settlers.

Dunbar ignored them.

He continued retreating through the country.

He did not consider himself safe until he reached Philadelphia, where he knew the local population could protect him.

This disaster was the first time many Americans seriously questioned their belief in the power of British regular troops.

Their behavior during the march had already damaged our opinion of them.

From the moment they landed until they passed beyond the settled areas, British soldiers had robbed and stripped local inhabitants.

Some poor families were ruined.

When people complained, soldiers insulted them, abused them, and even imprisoned them.

If we had needed such defenders, that behavior alone would have been enough to make us lose all respect for them.

How different this was from the behavior of our French allies in 1781.

Their army marched nearly seven hundred miles from Rhode Island to Virginia through the most heavily settled parts of our country.

Not once did they cause a serious complaint over the loss of a pig, a chicken, or even an apple.

Captain Orme, one of Braddock's aides-de-camp, was badly wounded and was carried away with the general.

He remained with Braddock until his death a few days later.

Orme later told me that Braddock said almost nothing during the entire first day.

That night, he finally said, “Who would have thought it?”

The next day he was silent again.

At the end of the day, he said only, “We shall know better how to deal with them another time.”

A few minutes later, he died.

Braddock's secretary had been carrying all the general's orders, instructions, and correspondence.

When the papers fell into enemy hands, the French selected and translated many of them.

They printed them to prove that the British government had planned hostile actions before war had officially been declared.

Among those papers were letters Braddock had written to the British ministry.

In them, he spoke highly of the help I had given the army and recommended that the government recognize my service.

Years later, David Hume also told me that he had seen letters from Braddock recommending me.

But Braddock's expedition had ended in disaster.

Apparently, my services were forgotten.

Those recommendations never brought me any benefit.

I asked Braddock for only one personal favor.

I wanted him to order his officers to stop enlisting our indentured servants.

I also asked him to release those who had already been enlisted.

He readily agreed.

Several servants were returned to their masters after I applied for their release.

Dunbar was not nearly as generous.

While he was retreating through Philadelphia, I asked him to release three servants belonging to poor farmers in Lancaster County.

I reminded him of Braddock's orders.

Dunbar promised that if their masters came to Trenton, where he would soon be passing on his way to New York, he would return the men to them.

The farmers spent their own money and made the difficult journey to Trenton.

But when they arrived, Dunbar refused to keep his promise.

They suffered a serious loss because of it.

Then the news spread that the wagons and horses had been lost.

All the owners came to me demanding the money I had guaranteed.

I was in a terrible situation.

I explained that the money was already waiting with the army paymaster.

But before it could be paid, General Shirley had to issue the necessary orders.

I had already written to him, but he was far away.

An answer would take time.

I asked the owners to be patient.

They were not satisfied.

Some of them began suing me.

At last, General Shirley rescued me from the situation.

He appointed commissioners to examine the claims and ordered that the owners be paid.

The total came to nearly twenty thousand pounds.

If I had been forced to pay that amount myself, I would have been ruined.

Before we heard about Braddock's defeat, two doctors named Bond came to me with a subscription paper.

They wanted to raise money for a huge fireworks display.

They planned to celebrate the news of our victory when Fort Duquesne was captured.

I looked at them seriously.

“I think we should wait until we know there is actually something to celebrate.”

They were surprised.

One of them said, “Why the devil? Surely you don't think the fort won't be taken?”

“I don't know that it won't be taken,” I replied. “But I do know that the outcome of war is always uncertain.”

I explained why I had doubts.

They abandoned the fireworks project.

That was fortunate, because only a short time later Braddock was defeated.

If they had prepared the fireworks, they would have been deeply embarrassed.

Later, Dr. Bond told someone that he did not like Franklin's gloomy predictions.

Governor Morris had constantly pressured the Pennsylvania Assembly to pass laws raising money for the defense of the province.

But he wanted the Assembly to exempt the proprietary estates from taxation.

Whenever the Assembly sent him a bill that taxed everyone, including the proprietors, he rejected it.

After Braddock's defeat, the danger became much greater.

Morris increased his pressure.

The Assembly still refused to give in.

They believed they were defending an important constitutional right.

They believed the governor should not have the power to change the Assembly's money bills.

In one bill, the Assembly proposed raising fifty thousand pounds.

The bill said that all real and personal property should be taxed, including the proprietors' estates.

The governor wanted to change only one word.

He wanted the phrase “the proprietors not excepted” removed.

It seemed like a tiny change.

But it would have made a huge difference.

After news of the disaster reached England, our friends there—whom we had kept informed by sending them copies of the Assembly's replies to the governor—became angry with the proprietors.

They accused them of being selfish and unjust for giving the governor such instructions.

Some even argued that by obstructing the defense of Pennsylvania, the proprietors had forfeited their right to govern the province.

The proprietors became frightened by this criticism.

They ordered their receiver-general to contribute five thousand pounds of their own money to the province's defense, in addition to whatever amount the Assembly raised.

The Assembly accepted this contribution instead of requiring the proprietors to pay their share of a general tax.

A new bill was prepared with the exemption clause the proprietors wanted.

The bill passed.

I was appointed one of the commissioners responsible for spending the sixty thousand pounds raised for defense.

I had helped shape the bill and worked to get it passed.

At the same time, I drafted another bill to create and train a voluntary militia.

I managed to get it through the Assembly without much trouble because we made sure that Quakers could choose not to participate.

To encourage people to join the militia, I wrote a dialogue explaining and answering every objection I could think of.

It was printed and, in my opinion, had a powerful effect.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!