A Governor Who Couldn’t Stop Arguing
That year, while traveling to Boston, I met our new governor, Mr. Morris, in New York. He had just arrived from England, and we already knew each other well.
He had been sent to replace Mr. Hamilton, who had finally resigned because he was tired of the constant disputes caused by the instructions he received from the proprietors.
Mr. Morris asked me, “Do you think I should expect the same kind of trouble during my administration?”
I replied, “Not at all. You could have a very peaceful time if you simply avoid getting into arguments with the Assembly.”
“My dear Franklin,” he said with a smile, “how can you expect me to avoid arguments? You know how much I enjoy disputing. It is one of my greatest pleasures. Still, because I respect your advice, I promise I’ll try to avoid them if I can.”
He had good reason to enjoy arguing. He was an excellent speaker, a clever debater, and usually very good at winning an argument.
He had been trained that way since childhood. I was told that his father used to encourage his children to argue with one another after dinner simply for his own entertainment.
But I never thought this was a good habit.
From what I had observed, people who are always arguing, contradicting others, and trying to prove everyone wrong often do poorly in life.
They may win arguments, but they rarely win people’s goodwill.
We then went our separate ways. He traveled to Philadelphia, while I continued on to Boston.
On my way back, I came across the Assembly’s official records in New York. They showed that, despite his promise to me, Governor Morris and the Assembly were already in a serious dispute.
In fact, they continued fighting for as long as he remained governor.
I became involved as well.
As soon as I returned to my seat in the Assembly, I was placed on nearly every committee responsible for answering the governor’s speeches and messages.
The committees usually asked me to write the replies.
Our responses were often sharp, and sometimes they became openly insulting.
Since Governor Morris knew that I was one of the Assembly’s writers, you might have thought that we would hate each other personally.
But he was such a good-natured man that our political battles never damaged our friendship.
We often had dinner together.
One afternoon, while our public dispute was at its worst, we happened to meet in the street.
“Franklin,” he said, “you must come home with me and spend the evening. I’m having some friends over, and I think you’ll enjoy their company.”
He took me by the arm and led me to his house.
After dinner, we sat drinking wine and talking cheerfully.
At one point, he jokingly told us that he greatly admired an idea from Don Quixote.
Sancho Panza, he said, had once been offered a government position and asked that he be given a government over black people. That way, if he could not get along with them, he could simply sell them.
One of the governor’s friends, sitting beside me, laughed and said, “Franklin, why do you keep siding with those damned Quakers? Why not sell them? The proprietor would pay you a good price for them.”
I replied, “The governor hasn’t made them black enough yet.”
Everyone laughed.
The governor had certainly been working hard to make the Assembly look bad in his official messages.
But the Assembly always managed to wipe away the governor’s accusations and throw them right back at him.
In the end, it began to look as though he was the one being covered in disgrace.
Both Governor Morris and Mr. Hamilton eventually became tired of the struggle and left the government.
The real cause of all these political battles was the proprietors, who were our hereditary governors.
Whenever money was needed to defend the province, they instructed their deputies not to approve any tax unless their enormous estates were specifically exempted from it.
They had even forced their deputies to sign bonds promising that they would obey these instructions.
For three years, the Assembly refused to accept this unfair arrangement.
Eventually, however, they were forced to give way.
Governor Morris was later succeeded by Captain Denny, who finally dared to ignore the proprietors’ instructions.
I will explain later how that came about.
But I have moved too far ahead in my story.
There were still several important events that took place during Governor Morris’s administration.
By this time, war with France had practically begun.
The government of Massachusetts Bay planned an attack on Crown Point and sent Mr. Quincy to Pennsylvania and Mr. Pownall, who later became governor himself, to New York to ask for assistance.
Since I was a member of the Assembly, understood its political mood, and was also from the same part of the country as Mr. Quincy, he came to me for help.
I helped him prepare his speech to the Assembly.
The Assembly received his request favorably and voted to provide ten thousand pounds in aid, which was to be spent on provisions.
But Governor Morris refused to approve the bill.
His objection was the same as always: he demanded that the bill include a clause exempting the proprietors’ estates from paying any of the tax needed to raise the money.
The Assembly strongly wanted to help New England, but now they had no obvious way to make their decision effective.
Mr. Quincy worked hard to persuade the governor to approve the bill.
But Morris refused to give in.
I then suggested another way to accomplish the same thing without the governor’s approval.
By law, the Assembly had the right to issue orders on the trustees of the Loan Office.
There was little or no actual money in the office at the time, so I proposed that the orders should become payable one year later and should carry five percent interest.
I believed that merchants could use these orders to buy the necessary provisions.
The Assembly accepted my proposal with very little hesitation.
The orders were immediately printed.
I was appointed to a committee responsible for signing and distributing them.
The money to repay these orders would come from the interest earned on all the paper currency that had already been loaned throughout the province, together with revenue from the excise tax.
Everyone knew that these sources would provide more than enough money to cover the orders.
Because of this, the orders immediately became trusted.
People accepted them as payment for provisions.
Even wealthy people who had spare cash began buying them because they could earn five percent interest while holding them and could also use them as money whenever necessary.
They became so popular that people quickly bought them all.
Within a few weeks, not a single order could be found.
In this way, I managed to complete this important project without the governor’s approval.
Mr. Quincy later sent the Assembly a gracious letter thanking them for their support.
He returned home extremely pleased with the success of his mission.
From that time forward, he became one of my closest and most affectionate friends.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!