Callisthenes Argues Against Bowing Down to Alexander
After Anaxarchus finished his speech praising Alexander and pushing for a new royal custom, everyone who’d been part of the secret plan cheered loudly. They were ready to start the formal bowing ritual right away.
Most Macedonian soldiers and officials, though, disliked the idea. They stayed quiet and uneasy.
Then Callisthenes stepped forward to speak up.
“Anaxarchus,” he said plainly, “I will say this openly. There is no noble honor Alexander does not deserve—so long as that honor fits a human being.
Humans have always drawn clear lines between honors for mortal men and honors for the gods. We build ordinary statues for people, but temples for gods. We set aside sacred grounds for deities alone. We offer sacrifices and pour ritual libations only for them. We write hymns to praise gods, and simple eulogies to honor fellow humans.
The biggest difference of all is the custom of prostration—bowing flat on the ground.
When we greet another person, we show respect with a kiss. But gods dwell far above us. We are not even allowed to touch them. That is why we bow all the way down to honor them. Different gods even have their own unique rituals and choral songs. Heroes get special honors too, ones completely separate from the worship reserved for gods.
It is wrong to blur all these boundaries.
We do not elevate mortals to divine status with excessive, godlike honors. Nor should we lower the gods to a human level by giving them nothing more than mortal praise.
Think of it this way,” Callisthenes continued. “If someone tried to vote an ordinary commoner into royal honors, Alexander would see that as an insult and a wrongdoing.
If a mere mortal being elevated to kingly rank offends him, how much more would the gods resent mortals who steal divine honors or let themselves be worshipped like gods?
Alexander is without doubt the bravest man alive, the most worthy king, and the finest military leader of our time.
Anaxarchus, you of all people should be defending this truth. You are his philosopher and teacher. You stand beside him to give wise guidance.
You should not be pushing to mix mortal and divine honors. You do not advise a tyrant like Cambyses or Xerxes. You advise Philip’s son—Alexander, a man descended from Heracles and Aeacus. His family came from Argos to rule Macedonia not by brute force, but by law and right.
The Greeks never gave Heracles divine honors while he lived. Even after his death, they waited for the Delphi oracle to officially declare him a god before they worshipped him as one.
If we are going to adopt foreign customs just because we are on foreign soil now, Alexander, you must remember why you began this entire campaign.
You marched out to unite Asia with Greece. You fought for Greek freedom.
So you must ask yourself what you will do next.
Will you go back to Greece and force freedom-loving Greek people to bow flat on the ground before you?
Or will you leave Greece out of this and only make the Macedonians follow this foreign bowing ritual?
Or will you draw a clear line yourself? Let Greeks and Macedonians honor you as a great human being, in the traditional Greek way. Let only foreign peoples use their custom of full prostration toward you.
Some say Cyrus was the first man to demand this bowing ritual, and that Persians and Medes kept up this degrading custom ever since.
But we should remember the lessons of history.
The poor, free Scythians defeated Cyrus. Other Scythians defeated Darius. The Athenians and Spartans defeated Xerxes. Clearchus and Xenophon and their ten thousand soldiers defeated Artaxerxes.
And now Alexander has conquered the very same Persian King Darius—without demanding anyone bow flat to the ground and treat him like a god.”
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!