← The Anabasis of Alexander 2026 Edition
Chapter 96 · The Debate Between Callisthenes and Anaxarchus

The Debate Between Callisthenes and Anaxarchus

Chapter 96 of 205 · 460 words · Free

Callisthenes of Olynthus was a student of the great philosopher Aristotle. He had a sharp, blunt personality, and he strongly disapproved of the flattery surrounding Alexander.

I fully agree with his judgment on the king’s growing arrogance and the court’s shameful behavior.

Even so, I believe one of Callisthenes’ recorded statements was arrogant and inappropriate.

He claimed that Alexander’s fame and legacy depended entirely on him and his historical writings.

“I did not come to Alexander to borrow glory from him,” Callisthenes insisted. “I came to make him famous across the entire world through my history.”

He even went so far as to say that Alexander’s claim of divine birth rested not on Olympias’ mysterious stories about his true father, but solely on what Callisthenes chose to write about him.

Many historians also record a bold conversation between Callisthenes and Philotas.

One day, Philotas asked him a pointed question.

“Which men do you think the people of Athens honor above all others?”

Callisthenes answered without hesitation. “Harmodius and Aristogeiton. They killed one of the tyrants and broke the tyrannical rule over Athens.”

Philotas pressed further. “If someone killed a tyrant in our time, which Greek city would safely shelter him as an exile?”

“Athens, above all others,” Callisthenes replied. “The Athenians once fought a war to defend the children of Heracles and overthrow the tyrant Eurystheus who ruled all of Greece. They have always stood against tyranny.”

Callisthenes would later openly defy Alexander over the forced ceremony of prostration—the custom of bowing flat on the ground before the king like a god.

This is the most widely accepted account of how the conflict began.

Alexander made a secret plan with the court sophists and the most powerful Persian and Median nobles in his retinue.

They agreed to bring up the topic of Alexander’s divine status during a royal wine feast, hoping to win public support for worshipping the king as a living god.

Anaxarchus stepped forward first to lead the discussion.

“Alexander is far more worthy of divine honor than Dionysus or Heracles,” he declared to the entire court.

He argued that Alexander’s countless incredible victories outweighed the legends of the old gods.

“Dionysus was only a Theban,” he said. “He has no connection to the Macedonian people whatsoever. Heracles was an Argive, unrelated to our land save for Alexander’s claimed descent from him.”

Anaxarchus went on to flatter the king shamelessly.

“We will undoubtedly worship Alexander as a god after his death,” he proclaimed. “If we will honor him in the grave, how much more right and reasonable is it to worship him while he still lives and rules? Dead men gain no benefit from empty praise. We should give him divine glory now, while he can receive it.”

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!