← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 40 · Charles F. Woerishoffer: The Man Who Led Wall Street’s Bears

Charles F. Woerishoffer: The Man Who Led Wall Street’s Bears

Chapter 40 of 90 · 2,486 words · Free

Charles F. Woerishoffer died on May 9, 1886, at the age of forty-three. With his death, Wall Street lost one of its most powerful and feared speculators.

Woerishoffer’s life was remarkable because he built his fortune around one central belief: most ambitious business ventures would eventually fail.

He had an unusual ability to study a situation, calculate the risks, and then act with extraordinary determination.

He did not simply follow the market.

He tried to force it in the direction he believed it would go.

People often called him lucky.

But his luck came from natural ability, careful observation, and the courage to act when others were afraid.

He became the leading figure among Wall Street’s bears—the traders who made money when stocks fell.

His style was completely different from the subtle manipulation used by men such as Jay Gould and Henry N. Smith.

Woerishoffer preferred a direct attack.

He believed in open combat.

When he decided a stock was too high, he sold it short.

Then he kept selling.

If the market fought back, he simply increased the size of his attack.

Sometimes he lost heavily.

But when he was right, his profits were enormous.

His basic philosophy was harsh.

He had little faith in corporations, railroads, or the grand promises of American entrepreneurs.

He believed that many new businesses began with exaggerated expectations and eventually failed to live up to them.

Railroad promoters might promise enormous earnings.

Investors might become excited and push the stock higher and higher.

Woerishoffer would study the numbers and ask a simple question:

“Can these companies really earn what everyone expects?”

If his answer was no, he sold.

And he sold aggressively.

His ability to recognize weakness in railroad enterprises made him one of the most dangerous bears in Wall Street.

Woerishoffer was born in Germany in 1843, in comparatively poor circumstances.

He came to New York in 1864, when he was only twenty-one.

He had already gained some experience in brokerage in Frankfurt and Paris, but he arrived in America with very little money.

At that time, men such as Russell Sage, Jay Gould, Henry N. Smith, D. P. Morgan, and Addison Cammack were already powerful figures in the financial world.

Few people could have imagined that the poor young German would eventually become powerful enough to challenge them.

His Wall Street career began in the office of August Rutten.

Woerishoffer eventually became the firm’s cashier.

In 1867, he left and joined M. C. Klingenfeldt.

The following year, Mr. Budge of Budge, Schutze & Co. bought him a seat on the Stock Exchange.

Soon afterward, Woerishoffer became acquainted with Mr. Plaat of L. Von Hoffman & Co.

Plaat trusted him with large orders, especially in gold and government bonds.

Woerishoffer proved himself an excellent operator.

Eventually, Plaat became a speculator himself, and Woerishoffer followed him closely.

He learned quickly.

Later he established his own firm, Woerishoffer & Co.

His first partners were Schromberg and Schuyler, both of whom eventually made fortunes and retired.

Woerishoffer soon became involved in enormous operations with some of Wall Street’s most important men.

Among his associates were James R. Keene, Henry N. Smith, D. P. Morgan, Henry Villard, Charles J. Osborn, S. V. White, Addison Cammack, and Jay Gould.

His closest speculative friend was Addison Cammack.

Both men were famous bears.

They were partners in speculation and friends in private life.

But Woerishoffer was not merely a stock trader.

He was also involved in major railroad enterprises.

He had connections with the North River Construction Company, Northern Pacific, Ontario & Western, West Shore, Denver & Rio Grande, Mexican National, several St. Louis companies, and Oregon Transcontinental.

At first, he was actually a strong believer in many of these companies.

He bought their stocks.

He promoted their prospects.

But when he saw trouble developing, his attitude changed completely.

He turned from bull to bear.

And once he changed sides, he attacked without mercy.

He sold the stocks short.

Then he sold more.

He hammered their prices downward until he had recovered his earlier losses and was making enormous profits from the decline.

His dealings in Kansas Pacific were particularly profitable.

When Kansas Pacific was eventually merged into Union Pacific, Woerishoffer was believed to have made more than one million dollars from the bonds and stock.

He was also one of the early men behind the idea of building the Denver & Rio Grande Railroad.

At first, the enterprise was enormously successful.

The stock climbed to 110.

The public became excited.

People expected even higher prices.

Woerishoffer and his friends owned large amounts of the stock.

Then they sold.

After getting out, they turned around and sold the stock short.

The great bear campaign began.

Woerishoffer led it.

The stock eventually fell toward 40, and some believed he covered his shorts at even lower prices.

By then, his reputation was firmly established.

In 1878, the American economy entered a powerful boom after the resumption of specie payments.

Woerishoffer organized a combination that bought large quantities of stocks while selling wheat short.

The operation brought him enormous profits.

He was becoming a millionaire.

Then came one of his most controversial operations.

When President Garfield was shot in 1881, Woerishoffer, Addison Cammack, and Henry N. Smith saw an opportunity.

They organized a major bear attack.

The operation helped create conditions that eventually contributed to the panic of 1884.

Woerishoffer’s reputation as a powerful bear continued to grow.

But his judgment was not perfect.

In 1885, he made a serious mistake.

The wheat crop was small, so he believed wheat prices would rise while stocks fell.

He positioned himself accordingly.

But the opposite happened.

Wheat did not behave as he expected.

Stocks did not collapse.

The disappointment was severe.

The strain of his enormous financial operations was already weighing heavily on him.

Soon afterward, he developed an aneurysm of the heart.

He died the following year.

One of his greatest victories had come in his battle with Jay Gould and Russell Sage over the Kansas Pacific.

In 1879, Woerishoffer represented investors in Frankfurt.

He had agreed to sell a large quantity of Denver extension bonds to the Gould-Sage syndicate for 80.

The syndicate changed its mind.

After examining the railroad, its members claimed that the bonds were worth only 70.

They refused to honor the original agreement.

Woerishoffer did not waste time arguing.

Instead, he made a move that surprised everyone.

He contacted the English and German bondholders.

He quickly secured control of a majority of the bonds the Gould-Sage group needed.

Then he deposited them with the United States Trust Company.

Afterward, he sent a message to the syndicate.

“You will not get a single one of these bonds below par.”

The Gould-Sage group had expected to control the situation.

Now they were trapped.

The syndicate needed the bonds for its foreclosure plan.

Woerishoffer controlled them.

The deal involved about six million dollars in bonds.

Woerishoffer reportedly made more than one million dollars from the operation.

The victory made his international reputation.

It also demonstrated one of his greatest strengths.

He was willing to fight much larger financial powers if he believed he could win.

His greatest battle, however, came a few years later against Henry Villard.

Villard had built an enormous speculative empire around Northern Pacific and the Oregon properties.

Investors were fascinated.

Millions of dollars poured into the scheme.

Woerishoffer was invited to join the great speculation.

He refused.

Instead, he watched.

He saw the excitement.

He saw the rising prices.

And he believed the whole thing was a bubble.

Then he did something extremely bold.

He sold the entire position short.

The Villard group decided to destroy him.

A powerful syndicate was organized to buy 100,000 shares of stock.

Some of the richest financiers in America joined the operation.

They believed that if they bought enough shares, they could force the price higher and squeeze Woerishoffer out of his short position.

At first, everything seemed to work.

They bought 20,000 shares.

The price continued rising.

The syndicate became even more confident.

They demanded the remaining 80,000 shares.

They believed they were about to crush Woerishoffer.

So they bought them.

But they did not realize who was selling.

Woerishoffer’s brokers were the sellers.

The syndicate had just purchased the stock from the very man it was trying to destroy.

The trap was complete.

Soon afterward, the Villard stocks began to collapse.

The syndicate was helpless.

The men who had intended to squeeze Woerishoffer had instead supplied him with the stock he needed to close his short position.

Woerishoffer made millions.

The battle took place in 1883.

It became one of the legendary victories of his career.

After the Villard collapse, Woerishoffer became more cautious for a while.

He was willing to be either a bull or a bear, depending on where he saw an opportunity.

When the West Shore settlement came, he recognized the potential immediately.

He became one of the strongest forces behind the resulting rise in prices.

He made enormous profits on the bull side.

But afterward, he became a relentless bear again.

His explanation was simple.

He believed railroad earnings were falling and that stock prices were too high to be justified by actual profits.

He pushed this argument to an extreme.

He paid little attention to the country’s ability to recover.

Many other bears followed him.

His influence became so great that his pessimism itself began to depress the market.

Woerishoffer had another important weapon.

He kept his plans secret.

He employed many brokers.

He frequently changed brokers.

He changed his trading locations and methods.

As a result, other traders could never be certain what he was doing.

They were constantly trying to guess his next move.

When Woerishoffer died, he was short approximately 200,000 shares.

But all of those positions had already been covered before his death became public.

That prevented his death from causing a major panic.

Had he died only a week earlier, the consequences might have been very different.

Despite his ruthless methods in the market, Woerishoffer was personally known for his generosity.

He reportedly gave faithful brokers more than twenty Stock Exchange memberships.

Each seat was worth about $25,000.

He once gave a $500 horse to the cab driver who drove him to and from his office every day.

He was generous to his employees as well.

At Christmas, he gave substantial gifts to clerks and messenger boys.

At home, he was said to be warm, friendly, and hospitable.

He was also deeply loyal to his friends.

But his generosity did not change the nature of his speculation.

When he attacked a stock, other people could lose everything.

Woerishoffer did not necessarily intend to destroy them.

He simply followed his own judgment and pursued profit.

He believed the market was a struggle in which the strongest survived.

His personal appearance did not suggest the power he possessed.

He was small, slightly built, light-complexioned, and below average height.

On the street, he could easily have been mistaken for a bank clerk.

Yet beneath that ordinary appearance was an extraordinarily aggressive speculator.

He also loved gambling.

He reportedly broke the faro bank at Long Branch twice.

He enjoyed roulette and poker and was willing to play for very large sums.

He had an unusual personality.

He combined the calm temperament of a German with the nervous energy of an American.

During ordinary speculation, he could become extremely nervous.

But during his great battle with the Villard interests, he remained remarkably calm.

His marriage was another fortunate event in his life.

In 1875, he married Annie Uhl, the stepdaughter of Oswald Ottendorfer, publisher of the New York Staats-Zeitung.

She was understood to have brought a fortune of approximately $300,000 to the marriage.

Woerishoffer had planned to travel to Europe shortly before his death.

He knew that the enormous mental strain of Wall Street was beginning to damage his health.

He intended to rest and recover.

But he waited too long.

The strain had already gone too far.

He died at only forty-three.

He left a widow and two young daughters.

His fortune was estimated at somewhere between one and four million dollars.

His death also changed the character of Wall Street.

Before he died, the public and many members of the Stock Exchange were afraid to buy stocks because they feared his attacks.

Whenever the bulls tried to push prices higher, Woerishoffer would strike.

If 10,000 shares were not enough, he might sell four times as much.

He was known to carry short positions of 200,000 shares or more.

His power came not only from selling stocks.

He could attack the market through many different channels.

Sometimes he used the grain market.

Sometimes he moved gold.

Sometimes he worked through the London market.

He understood how the different parts of the financial system could be used together.

His death left the bears without their leader.

The market suddenly felt less dangerous.

The public could once again participate without fearing that a single powerful operator might destroy an entire rally.

Woerishoffer’s associate Addison Cammack was also a bear, but he operated differently.

Cammack usually sold short only when he had reliable information.

He also kept his positions within reasonable limits.

If the market moved against him, he accepted a small loss and got out.

Woerishoffer was different.

Once he took a position, he could hold it through almost anything.

He would continue attacking until the market finally moved in his favor.

That was his greatest strength.

It was also his greatest danger.

Woerishoffer possessed a genius for speculation that he could not easily control.

He made his fortune legally, but his success often came at the expense of others.

His career demonstrated the enormous power of determination, calculation, and courage in financial speculation.

It also demonstrated the danger of taking those qualities too far.

He became rich by betting against the success of businesses, railroads, and economic expansion.

He believed that many grand American dreams would eventually collapse.

Sometimes he was right.

Sometimes he was spectacularly wrong.

But he never lacked the courage to act on his convictions.

His greatest victory was not simply making millions.

It was proving that even a relatively small operator could stand alone against the greatest financial powers of his time—and sometimes beat them at their own game.

Yet his death carried another lesson.

A man may be strong enough to dominate a market and still be unable to withstand the pressure of his own ambition.

Woerishoffer had pushed his mind and body too far.

He had earned his fortune.

He had defeated powerful enemies.

He had become one of Wall Street’s most feared men.

But he could not buy back the years that his relentless pursuit of wealth had cost him.

His life was therefore both a story of extraordinary financial genius and a warning about the price of using that genius without restraint.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!