← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 41 · Women in Wall Street

Women in Wall Street

Chapter 41 of 90 · 1,572 words · Free

For a long time, women had a poor record as Wall Street speculators. The market demanded a certain kind of judgment, and, in the author's view, women generally did not have the temperament for it.

He knew that many readers would strongly disagree.

They might point to Joan of Arc, Queen Elizabeth, Catherine the Great, Mary, Queen of Scots, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Julia Ward Howe, George Eliot, George Sand, and other famous women who had achieved remarkable things.

His answer was simple: those women were exceptional. Their achievements did not, in his opinion, prove that women were naturally suited to speculation.

He argued that speculation was different from politics, literature, reform, or other fields. A successful trader had to look at an entire situation at once, weigh many forces together, and anticipate what might happen next.

To him, Wall Street was a place where emotion and impulse could be extremely dangerous.

He then turned to several women who had actually entered the financial world.

Among the most famous were the sisters Victoria Woodhull and Tennie Claflin.

At the time, Tennie Claflin was better known as Lady Cooke, while her sister had become famous as Victoria Woodhull. Their brokerage firm, Woodhull, Claflin & Co., had opened on Broad Street with the backing of Commodore Vanderbilt.

The author considered their story one of the clearest examples of what he believed happened when women entered Wall Street.

Tennie Claflin once came into his office and told him that she wanted to deposit a $7,000 check.

The check had been signed by one of the richest men in Wall Street.

The cashier accepted it without difficulty and credited the money to her account.

A few days later, Tennie returned in a cab.

She looked excited.

She told him she had a "point."

The author was not especially interested in other people's market tips, but he listened because the information supposedly came from an important source.

Tennie then told him that she wanted to buy 1,000 shares of New York Central.

He immediately became uncomfortable with the order.

Instead of executing it, he quietly told his messenger:

"Tell the cashier to close out Miss Claflin's account."

Within minutes, her money, including interest, was returned to her.

Tennie left the office.

The author thought the matter was finished.

It was not.

She went directly to the Fourth National Bank and presented the check.

A few minutes later, she came back.

"The bank wants someone to identify me," she said.

The author sent one of his employees with her to confirm her identity.

That small incident helped establish the financial credibility of Woodhull & Claflin.

Before long, people were saying that he and the Fourth National Bank had effectively sponsored the sisters' entry into the brokerage business.

When he discovered that his name was being associated with them, he privately spoke with the president of the bank.

After that, Tennie used his name much less frequently.

He insisted that he had not been tricked.

At the time, everyone knew that Commodore Vanderbilt was the real power behind the sisters.

If they had some larger scheme in mind, he said, he had managed to stay out of it.

He did not claim that every woman who entered Wall Street behaved like the Claflin sisters.

There were exceptions.

He mentioned Mrs. Hetty Green as one of them.

She had made a fortune largely through her own judgment and had become one of the most successful female investors of her time.

But even Hetty Green, he believed, was not the equal of the great male operators.

He then described what he saw as the central problem.

Women, he argued, were often too easily influenced by emotion.

They could make quick judgments about ordinary matters, but successful speculation required something different.

A trader had to see the entire market at once.

He had to understand how politics, money, railroads, public confidence, business conditions, and countless other forces interacted.

That was the kind of ability he associated with men such as Jacob Little, Commodore Vanderbilt, and Daniel Drew.

He also brought Jay Gould into the discussion.

Gould, he said, had a remarkable financial mind, although he did not regard Gould as a true speculator in the same sense as Little or Vanderbilt.

According to the author's view, Gould's great fortune came largely from taking damaged railroad properties, combining them, making investors believe they were valuable, and then selling his interests.

The author believed that women who had entered Wall Street had not demonstrated the same ability to understand and predict the broad forces driving the market.

Even Hetty Green, he argued, did not possess the power required to organize a massive bear attack like those once carried out by Charles F. Woerishoffer.

Nor, in his opinion, could she compete with Gould, Major Selover, Addison Cammack, or James R. Keene when it came to organizing a blind pool.

He then returned to Tennie Claflin.

Although she was less intellectually gifted than Victoria, he believed she had exercised considerable influence over Commodore Vanderbilt.

The reason, he claimed, was her reputation as a spiritualist medium.

During the later years of Vanderbilt's life, he had become deeply interested in spiritualism.

Before undertaking important ventures, he sometimes consulted mediums in much the same way that ancient rulers had consulted oracles.

Tennie was one of the people who benefited from this belief.

But eventually, her supposed supernatural powers were exposed.

The author claimed that the Christian Brothers had disproved her abilities, seriously damaging her influence over Vanderbilt.

Their mother had apparently been deeply superstitious herself.

She believed that her daughters had been possessed by evil spirits through Colonel Blood, Victoria's second husband.

According to the story, religious men were brought in to drive away the spirits.

After this episode, the sisters' fortunes began to improve dramatically.

Later, when young Cornelius Vanderbilt was challenging his father's will, the sisters suddenly left for England.

They apparently did not want to be forced to testify in the case.

The author regarded their departure as extremely fortunate for them.

In his sarcastic conclusion, he suggested that this was the kind of "speculation" at which women were truly successful.

Their greatest advantage, he argued, was not financial skill but their ability to influence men's emotions and weaknesses.

Victoria Woodhull herself gave a very different explanation of the sisters' rise.

She said that she and Tennie had opened their brokerage office to prove that women were just as capable as men of entering demanding professions.

She recalled that the opening caused a sensation throughout New York.

Crowds gathered around Wall Street and Broad Street simply to watch women enter the financial business.

She also claimed that the sisters used their newspaper to expose fraudulent financial schemes.

According to Victoria, they had revealed companies that claimed to operate nonexistent mines, railroads that led nowhere, and financial institutions that consumed the money of their own shareholders.

She claimed that during 1872 they had exposed and helped destroy numerous fraudulent schemes.

She also said that their campaign had helped reduce the number of life-insurance companies and had contributed to the collapse of several financial bubbles.

Some people, she claimed, had even offered them money to remain silent.

When the sisters refused, their enemies accused them of blackmail and attacked their morals.

Victoria believed that their work had helped bring about a major change in American finance.

The author did not attempt to disprove her account.

He simply presented it and left the reader to judge.

But he still believed that the sisters' experience supported his own argument.

He pointed out that even women whom he regarded as unusually capable had struggled when they tried to become professional speculators.

Jennie June, the talented wife of journalist David Goodman Croly, had also tried speculation and had not achieved great success.

His conclusion was blunt.

If women of exceptional ability could not succeed in Wall Street speculation, what chance did the average woman have?

He warned that a growing number of young and married women were becoming fascinated by speculation.

Many believed they could make a fortune within a few weeks or months.

He considered this dangerous.

Some women were apparently encouraging their friends to follow Victoria Woodhull's example, believing that she had proved women could succeed in finance.

The author strongly disagreed.

He regarded Woodhull's speculative career as a failure.

In his view, she had done much better as an investor than as a speculator.

And, with characteristic sarcasm, he suggested that her most successful "investment" had actually been her final marriage.

His broader argument was that women were too impulsive and impressionable for the brutal demands of Wall Street.

They might reach correct conclusions very quickly, he said, but often by instinct rather than by analyzing all the forces involved.

A true speculator needed to stand back, see the whole picture, and anticipate how different events would affect one another.

That, he believed, was the quality that had made the great male operators of Wall Street so powerful.

His final judgment was therefore severe.

Women could succeed in many areas of life.

But in his view, Wall Street speculation was not one of them.

He believed that those who entered the market without exceptional protection, extraordinary luck, or the guidance of experienced men were likely to lose both their money and their reputation.

And the story of the Woodhull and Claflin sisters, he believed, was the clearest warning of all.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!