Clever Tactics and a Chaotic Showdown Between Cao Cao, Zhang Xiu and Lü Bu
Jia Xu saw straight through Cao Cao’s plan and decided to turn the tables on him.
“I’ve watched Cao Cao patrol the city for three days straight,” he told Zhang Xiu. “He’s been checking every section of the walls. The southeast corner has mismatched old and new bricks, and most of its defensive spikes are broken. That’s where he plans to break in.”
“He’s just putting on a show by stacking firewood by the northwest wall,” Jia Xu explained. “He wants to trick us into moving all our troops there. Once our northwest defenses are busy, he’ll sneak his soldiers over the southeast wall under the cover of night.”
“What should we do then?” Zhang Xiu asked quickly.
“It’s simple,” Jia Xu replied. “Tomorrow, feed and rest our best soldiers well. Have them travel light and hide inside the houses near the southeast wall. We’ll let ordinary townsfolk dress up as soldiers to guard the northwest corner and make a big show of defending it.”
“Let Cao Cao’s men climb the southeast wall unopposed tonight,” he continued. “The second they step foot inside the city, we’ll fire a cannon signal. Our hidden troops will swarm out and trap Cao Cao’s entire army.”
Zhang Xiu was thrilled with the plan and ordered his men to follow every detail exactly.
Meanwhile, Cao Cao’s scouts returned to report. “General Zhang Xiu has moved nearly all his troops to the northwest wall. They’re shouting and putting up a fierce defense there, while the southeast side looks completely unguarded.”
“He’s fallen right into my trap!” Cao Cao laughed.
He ordered his soldiers to secretly prepare ladders, shovels and all tools needed for a night siege. During the day, he only sent troops to feign attacks on the northwest wall to keep up the ruse.
When night fell and the second watch came, Cao Cao led his elite troops to the southeast corner. They crossed the moat, cut down the broken defensive spikes, and climbed over the wall with zero resistance. The entire Cao army swarmed into the city.
Just then, a deafening cannon blast rang out.
Hidden soldiers poured out from every corner. Panicked Cao troops tried to retreat at once, but Zhang Xiu personally led a charge from behind them.
Cao Cao’s army suffered a crushing defeat and fled dozens of miles outside the city. Zhang Xiu chased them until dawn before pulling his troops back.
When Cao Cao counted his remaining soldiers, he’d lost more than fifty thousand men, along with countless supplies and military equipment. Two of his key generals, Lü Qian and Yu Jin, were both wounded in the battle.
As soon as Jia Xu saw Cao Cao’s army retreating, he urged Zhang Xiu to send an urgent letter to Liu Biao, asking him to raise troops and cut off Cao Cao’s escape route.
Liu Biao was just about to mobilize his army when new scouts brought news. “Sun Ce has stationed his troops at Lake Kou.”
Kuai Liang spoke up immediately. “Sun Ce’s camp at Lake Kou is just a diversion set up by Cao Cao. Cao Cao has just been badly defeated. If we don’t strike now, he will surely become a huge threat to us later.”
Convinced, Liu Biao ordered Huang Zu to guard the mountain passes. He then led his main army to Anzhong County to block Cao Cao’s retreat path, and arranged to join forces with Zhang Xiu.
Once Zhang Xiu learned Liu Biao’s troops were on the move, he marched out with Jia Xu to attack Cao Cao’s retreating army.
Cao Cao’s army marched slowly along the road. When they reached the area around Xiangcheng and Yu River, Cao Cao suddenly burst into tears on his horse.
His officers were shocked and asked him what was wrong.
“Last year, I lost my great general Dian Wei right here,” Cao Cao sobbed. “I cannot help but grieve for him.”
He ordered his army to set up camp and hold a grand memorial ceremony. He personally burned incense and knelt to mourn Dian Wei, and every soldier in the army was deeply moved.
After honoring Dian Wei, he held rituals for his nephew Cao Anmin, his eldest son Cao Ang, and all the soldiers who had died in battle. He even paid tribute to his prized war horse that had been shot and killed in combat.
The next day, a messenger sent by Xun Yu arrived with urgent news. “Liu Biao has joined forces with Zhang Xiu and stationed troops at Anzhong County to block your way back.”
Cao Cao wrote back at once: “I have been marching slowly on purpose. I know full well the enemy will chase and ambush us. But I already have a plan to defeat them at Anzhong. Do not worry.”
He then ordered his troops to advance quickly to the border of Anzhong County. Liu Biao had already seized all the strategic high ground, and Zhang Xiu’s army soon caught up to join the attack.
That night, Cao Cao ordered his soldiers to secretly clear a hidden path through the dangerous mountain terrain and lay ambush troops in secret positions.
At dawn, Liu Biao and Zhang Xiu’s combined forces saw how few soldiers Cao Cao had in sight. They assumed Cao Cao was fleeing in panic and rushed blindly into the narrow mountain pass to chase him down.
Cao Cao’s hidden troops sprung their ambush all at once, completely routing the allied army of Liu Biao and Zhang Xiu.
Cao’s army marched out of the Anzhong pass and set up camp safely outside.
Liu Biao and Zhang Xiu gathered their defeated troops and met each other. “I never thought we would fall for Cao Cao’s trick,” Liu Biao sighed.
“We can plan our next move,” Zhang Xiu said, and the two armies camped together at Anzhong to regroup.
Soon after, Xun Yu received intelligence that Yuan Shao planned to attack Xuchang. He sent a night messenger to warn Cao Cao immediately.
The news made Cao Cao anxious. He ordered an immediate full retreat back to Xuchang.
Scouts reported Cao Cao’s withdrawal to Zhang Xiu, who prepared to lead his troops in pursuit.
“Do not chase them,” Jia Xu warned. “You will definitely lose if you attack now.”
“We cannot let this perfect chance slip away!” Liu Biao insisted. He pressured Zhang Xiu to join him with more than ten thousand soldiers to chase Cao Cao’s retreating army.
They caught up with Cao Cao’s rear guard after marching more than ten miles. But Cao’s soldiers fought fiercely. Zhang Xiu and Liu Biao’s troops were soundly defeated and forced to retreat.
Zhang Xiu turned to Jia Xu, frustrated. “I ignored your advice, and we suffered a defeat just as you said we would.”
“Now is the perfect time to chase them again,” Jia Xu said unexpectedly.
Both Zhang Xiu and Liu Biao were confused. “We just lost a battle badly. How can we attack again so soon?”
“This pursuit will bring us a great victory,” Jia Xu vowed. “If I am wrong, you may take my head.”
Zhang Xiu trusted Jia Xu and prepared his troops to go. Liu Biao remained doubtful and refused to join him.
Zhang Xiu chased Cao Cao’s army alone, and sure enough, he found Cao’s troops completely disorganized. Weapons, armor and supplies were abandoned all along the road as they fled.
Zhang Xiu was about to press the attack when a sudden troop unit charged out from behind the mountains. Unsure of the new enemy’s strength, Zhang Xiu halted his pursuit and led his troops back to Anzhong.
Liu Biao asked Jia Xu in confusion: “Earlier, you said our elite troops would fail chasing a retreating enemy, and you were right. Then you said our defeated troops would win chasing a victorious enemy, and that also came true. How do you explain this?”
“It is quite simple,” Jia Xu replied calmly. “You are a capable general, but you are no match for Cao Cao. When Cao Cao retreated the first time, he left his fiercest warriors to guard the rear. Our best soldiers could not overcome their defense, so defeat was certain.”
“Cao Cao rushed back because there was an emergency in Xuchang,” he continued. “After beating our first pursuit, he hurried his men forward without setting up any more defenses. We caught him off guard, which is why we won the second chase.”
Liu Biao and Zhang Xiu were both utterly impressed by Jia Xu’s brilliant judgment.
Jia Xu then advised Liu Biao to return to Jingzhou and told Zhang Xiu to defend Xiangcheng, so the two territories could support and protect each other. The two armies split ways peacefully.
On Cao Cao’s march back, he got word that his rear army had been ambushed. He rushed back with his generals to provide support, only to find Zhang Xiu’s troops had already withdrawn.
His defeated soldiers reported: “If a troop of soldiers hadn’t blocked the enemy’s path from the mountains, we would have all been captured.”
Cao Cao hurried to ask who had saved them. A general rode forward, dismounted, and knelt to greet him. This was Li Tong, courtesy name Wenda, a general from Pingchun in Jiangxia.
“I have been stationed in Runan recently,” Li Tong explained. “When I heard you were fighting Zhang Xiu and Liu Biao, I rushed here to assist you.”
Cao Cao was overjoyed. He named Li Tong a meritorious lord and put him in charge of the western border of Runan to defend against Liu Biao and Zhang Xiu. Li Tong thanked him and left for his post.
After returning to Xuchang, Cao Cao submitted a memorial praising Sun Ce’s contributions. He had the court appoint Sun Ce General Quelling Rebellions and Marquis of Wu, then sent an imperial edict to Jiangdong ordering Sun Ce to guard against and attack Liu Biao.
Back at his residence, Cao Cao met with his officials. Xun Yu asked: “When you marched slowly to Anzhong, how did you know for certain you would win the battle?”
“The enemy had no way to retreat and would fight to the death,” Cao Cao explained. “I slowed our pace to lure them into a reckless attack, then ambushed them. That is why I knew we would triumph.”
Xun Yu bowed in complete admiration.
Just then, Guo Jia arrived.
“Why are you late?” Cao Cao asked.
Guo Jia pulled a letter from his sleeve. “Yuan Shao sent a messenger. He plans to attack Gongsun Zan and wants to borrow troops and grain from you.”
“I heard Yuan Shao intended to seize Xuchang,” Cao Cao said. “Now that I have returned safely, he is making up new excuses.”
He opened the letter and found its tone extremely arrogant. He turned to Guo Jia. “Yuan Shao is extremely disrespectful. I want to attack him, but I fear our army is not strong enough. What should I do?”
Guo Jia replied with confidence: “You know the story of Liu Bang and Xiang Yu. Liu Bang won with wisdom, even though Xiang Yu was far stronger in military power. Yuan Shao has ten fatal flaws, while you have ten decisive advantages. His large army is nothing to fear.”
“Yuan Shao relies on rigid, complicated rituals, while you act naturally and flexibly – this is your superiority in principle,” Guo Jia elaborated.
“He acts as a rebel, while you fight with imperial authority on your side – this is your superiority in righteousness.”
“The previous dynasties failed due to lenient governance. Yuan Shao indulges weakness with more leniency, while you enforce strict discipline to correct chaos – this is your superiority in policy.”
“He appears generous but is suspicious and favors relatives, while you are plain-spoken but perceptive, and promote people purely by talent – this is your superiority in tolerance.”
“Yuan Shao has countless plans but never makes up his mind, while you act immediately once you find a good strategy – this is your superiority in judgment.”
“He chases fame and superficial praise, while you treat people with sincere honesty – this is your superiority in virtue.”
“He only cares for his inner circle and ignores distant allies, while you consider every detail and care for all people – this is your superiority in benevolence.”
“He believes slanderous rumors, while you stay clear-headed and untainted by gossip – this is your superiority in wisdom.”
“He confuses right and wrong, while you enforce strict and clear laws – this is your superiority in governance.”
“He loves empty posturing and knows nothing of real warfare, while you win battles with few troops and fight like a god – this is your superiority in military skill.”
“With these ten advantages, defeating Yuan Shao will be no difficult feat.”
Cao Cao smiled. “I am hardly worthy of such high praise.”
Xun Yu agreed firmly. “Guo Jia’s ten-win theory is exactly what I think. Yuan Shao’s massive army is nothing to fear.”
Guo Jia continued with a strategy: “Lv Bu in Xuzhou is our real hidden danger. Right now, Yuan Shao is busy attacking Gongsun Zan in the north. We should take this chance to conquer Lv Bu first, secure the southeast, and then turn to fight Yuan Shao.”
“If we ignore Lv Bu and attack Yuan Shao first, Lv Bu will definitely invade Xuchang while our main army is away, and the damage will be severe,” he warned.
Cao Cao fully agreed and began planning the eastern campaign against Lv Bu.
Xun Yu suggested: “We should send a letter to Liu Bei first and wait for his reply before mobilizing our troops.”
Cao Cao followed the plan. He wrote to Liu Bei, treated Yuan Shao’s messenger generously, and petitioned the court to grant Yuan Shao high official titles and control of four northern provinces. He sent a secret reply promising to aid Yuan Shao’s attack on Gongsun Zan. Delighted, Yuan Shao marched north to fight Gongsun Zan.
Back in Xuzhou, Lv Bu held frequent banquets. At every feast, Chen Gui and his son would heap excessive praise on Lv Bu.
Chen Gong grew annoyed by their flattery. He took a chance to warn Lv Bu: “The Chen family father and son only flatter you to your face. Their true intentions are untrustworthy. You must be cautious of them.”
Lv Bu flew into a rage. “You spread baseless slander just to frame loyal men!”
After leaving Lv Bu’s hall, Chen Gong sighed bitterly. “He ignores honest advice. We will all suffer disaster because of this!”
He wanted to leave Lv Bu’s side but could not bear to abandon him, and he feared being mocked by others. From then on, he fell into constant melancholy.
One day, Chen Gong rode out with a few cavalry soldiers to hunt near Xiaopei to clear his mind. He suddenly spotted a government courier galloping down the official road.
Suspicious, Chen Gong abandoned his hunt and cut through a side road to stop the rider.
“Who do you serve, and what is your errand?” Chen Gong demanded.
The messenger panicked and stammered without a clear answer. Chen Gong searched him and found a secret reply letter from Liu Bei to Cao Cao. He immediately arrested the messenger and brought both him and the letter to Lv Bu.
Lv Bu questioned the messenger, who explained: “Prime Minister Cao sent me with a letter to Lord Liu Bei. This is his reply. I do not know its contents.”
Lv Bu opened the letter and read it. Liu Bei’s message stated: “I obey your order to plot against Lv Bu and work tirelessly for the cause. My troops are too few to act rashly, but I will lead the vanguard once your army arrives. I have prepared my soldiers and weapons and await your command.”
Lv Bu roared in fury. “That scoundrel Cao Cao dares to scheme against me!”
He executed the messenger at once and issued immediate military orders. He sent Chen Gong and Zang Ba to ally with bandit leaders in Mount Tai to seize Yanzhou’s counties in the east.
He ordered Gao Shun and Zhang Liao to lead an attack on Liu Bei at Xiaopei. He sent Song Xian and Wei Xu to capture Runan and Yingchuan in the west. Lv Bu himself commanded the central army to support all three fronts.
As Gao Shun’s army marched toward Xiaopei, scouts rushed to report the news to Liu Bei.
Sun Qian urged Liu Bei: “Send an urgent plea for help to Cao Cao at once!”
“Who can ride to Xuchang to deliver our request?” Liu Bei asked.
A man stepped forward at once. It was Jian Yong, a fellow townsman of Liu Bei and his trusted advisor. Liu Bei wrote a desperate letter and sent Jian Yong racing to Xuchang overnight.
He then divided his forces to defend the city. Liu Bei guarded the south gate, Sun Qian the north gate, Guan Yu the west gate, and Zhang Fei the east gate. Mi Zhu and his brother Mi Fang held the central camp to protect the entire family.
Since Mi Zhu’s sister was Liu Bei’s wife, the two families were related by marriage, so Liu Bei trusted them with his most vulnerable position.
When Gao Shun’s army reached the city walls, Liu Bei shouted from the tower: “I have never wronged you, General Fengxian. Why do you attack me?”
Gao Shun replied: “You colluded with Cao Cao to murder our lord. Your plot has been exposed. Surrender at once!”
He ordered his troops to charge the city. Liu Bei held fast behind closed gates and refused to fight.
The next day, Zhang Liao led his troops to attack the west gate.
Guan Yu stood on the wall and spoke to him calmly: “You have the bearing of a true hero. Why waste your talent serving a traitor?”
Zhang Liao hung his head in silence. Guan Yu saw his inner loyalty and regret, so he spoke no harsh words and refused to engage in battle.
Zhang Liao pulled his troops back and moved to attack the east gate. Zhang Fei immediately charged out to fight him. Guan Yu rushed over in time to see Zhang Liao retreating already.
“He’s running from us! Why not chase him?” Zhang Fei shouted.
Guan Yu stopped him. “Zhang Liao’s skill is equal to yours and mine. He retreated because my words stirred his conscience and made him ashamed to fight. Do not pursue him.”
Zhang Fei finally understood. From then on, they only held their defenses and refused to engage the enemy.
Jian Yong reached Xuchang and told Cao Cao every detail of the crisis at Xiaopei.
Cao Cao gathered his advisors. “I want to attack Lv Bu, but I fear Liu Biao and Zhang Xiu will attack our rear.”
Xun You replied: “They were just badly defeated and will not dare to move rashly. Lv Bu is fiercely brave. If he allies with Yuan Shu and controls the Huai and Si river regions, he will become impossible to defeat.”
Guo Jia added: “Lv Bu has just rebelled, and his troops and followers are not yet loyal. We must strike fast before his power stabilizes.”
Cao Cao agreed immediately. He ordered Xiahou Dun, Xiahou Yuan, Lü Qian and Li Dian to lead fifty thousand troops as the vanguard, while he commanded the main army behind them, with Jian Yong guiding the way.
Scouts informed Gao Shun of Cao Cao’s advancing army. Gao Shun sent an urgent report to Lv Bu, who dispatched Hou Cheng, Hao Meng and Cao Xing with two hundred cavalry soldiers to ambush the Cao army thirty miles from Xiaopei. Lv Bu followed closely with his main force.
When Liu Bei saw Gao Shun’s army retreat, he knew Cao Cao’s reinforcements were coming. He left Sun Qian to guard the city and the Mi brothers to protect his family, then marched out with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei to set up camps and coordinate with Cao Cao’s army.
Xiahou Dun’s vanguard soon met Gao Shun’s troops. He charged forward with his spear, and the two generals fought fiercely for over forty rounds.
Gao Shun could no longer hold his ground and retreated. Xiahou Dun pursued him relentlessly, circling the enemy formation.
Hidden in the ranks, Cao Xing nocked an arrow, took careful aim, and shot Xiahou Dun square in the left eye.
Xiahou Dun screamed in agony. He ripped the arrow out, tearing his eyeball free with it. “This is flesh and blood given by my parents – I will not discard it!”
He swallowed his own eyeball, then raised his spear and charged straight at the stunned Cao Xing. Before Cao Xing could react, Xiahou Dun’s spear pierced his face, killing him instantly.
Every soldier on both sides was terrified by the brutal sight.
Xiahou Dun returned to his formation, bloodied but unbroken. Gao Shun seized the chance to attack from behind, routing Cao’s vanguard army completely.
Xiahou Yuan rescued his wounded brother and retreated. Lü Qian and Li Dian led the remaining defeated troops to set up camp at Jibei.
Fresh off his victory, Gao Shun turned his army back to attack Liu Bei’s camp. Lv Bu’s main army arrived soon after.
Lv Bu split his troops into three teams with Zhang Liao and Gao Shun, launching a coordinated assault on the three camps of Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!