← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 14 · Daniel Drew had one of the strangest careers in Wall Street history

Daniel Drew had one of the strangest careers in Wall Street history

Chapter 14 of 90 · 2,259 words · Free

Like Cornelius Vanderbilt, he proved that a man could become enormously wealthy without much formal education. Drew had little schooling, but he possessed an extraordinary instinct for speculation. At one time, he could raise more cash on short notice than almost anyone else in America.

He eventually built a fortune estimated at thirteen million dollars.

Yet that entire fortune disappeared.

Drew and Vanderbilt had something else in common. People who knew them believed that a formal education might actually have worked against them. They had little patience for books, grammar, or polished language. They trusted their own instincts instead.

Drew called shares “sheers.”

Vanderbilt had his own rough way of speaking, and neither man seemed particularly concerned about whether his English was grammatically correct.

Drew once told a broker simply:

“Gimme them sheers.”

He meant that he wanted the stock delivered to him.

Their lack of education did not prevent either man from becoming a powerful financier. If anything, both seemed to believe that their financial abilities came naturally to them.

They had little respect for men who could not compete with them in speculation. At the same time, they were fiercely jealous of anyone who tried to challenge them on their own ground.

Drew’s greatest weapons were cunning and patience.

Although he was poorly educated himself, he understood the value of education well enough to establish and endow a school in his home county.

Some people believed he did it simply to win popularity and make sure his name would be remembered.

There may have been another reason.

Drew understood that religious influence was powerful in society, and many religious people around him were financially comfortable. By making himself useful to them, he could gain their goodwill and perhaps use those connections to his advantage in business.

If that was really his motive, there was an irony in what happened later.

He eventually became unable to make the promised payments on the school, except for the interest.

At the height of his career, Daniel Drew could command enormous amounts of ready cash.

His fortune was estimated at thirteen million dollars, and much of it came from his operations in Erie stock. As treasurer and a director of the Erie Railway, Drew was in a position to know much more about the company than ordinary traders.

That gave him a tremendous advantage.

While other traders were guessing what Erie stock might do next, Drew often knew exactly what he intended to do.

The Street was repeatedly shocked by enormous movements in Erie.

The stock could rise or fall twenty or thirty percent in only a day or two.

Drew was usually behind those moves.

But everything changed when Jay Gould entered the picture.

Gould gradually took control of Erie, and Drew's position began to collapse.

Gould was rising rapidly toward the top of the speculative world while Drew was moving in the opposite direction.

Drew himself summed up the change in fortunes with a bitter remark:

“His touch is death.”

His losses came one after another.

The thirteen million dollars disappeared.

Eventually, Drew died deeply in debt and broken in spirit.

His final years became a grim warning about what greed and overconfidence can do to a man who already seems to have everything.

I once attended a dinner given in Drew's honor when he was still at the height of his success.

He was the star of the evening.

Everyone admired him because of his enormous fortune. Some of the guests treated him almost like a god.

As usual at such dinners, speeches followed.

When it was my turn, I joined in the general praise, at least for a while.

I said:

“We are honored tonight by a man of enormous wealth, a man who can command more ready money than anyone else in America. Everything he has was created by his own efforts. He represents American enterprise and determination.”

“His wealth and his friendly personality have made him many friends.”

“But I know of one enemy that could still destroy him.”

“That enemy is not another financier.”

“It is avarice.”

Five years later, Daniel Drew was ruined.

His thirteen million dollars had vanished almost completely.

Only the wreckage of his once-great fortune remained.

People often joked that Drew used religion as a tool for speculation.

A satirical poem published in the New York Tribune captured that reputation. It imagined a countryman arriving in New York looking for Daniel Drew because he wanted advice about stocks.

The joke was that Drew's supposed religious school had attracted people who wanted to learn about finance rather than religion.

Another verse ended with a warning:

“If you want to gamble, play your own game—but don't play against Drew.”

Drew also looked nothing like the stereotypical millionaire.

He dressed like the cattle driver he had once been.

Even after becoming worth thirteen million dollars, he did not carry an expensive walking stick. Instead, he sometimes walked through Wall Street carrying the handle of an old broken umbrella.

The expression “watering stock” was also associated with Drew's cattle-trading days.

A cattleman would give his animals plenty of salt so they would become thirsty and drink large amounts of water. The extra water made them look larger and heavier when they were taken to market.

Drew applied the same basic idea to finance: make something appear more valuable than it really was.

For many years, nobody in Wall Street could easily outmaneuver him.

Then came Gould and Fisk.

Before that, Drew seemed almost unbeatable.

One famous story shows just how cleverly he could turn a joke against the people who were laughing at him.

On one occasion, Drew was badly squeezed in Northwestern stock.

The traders who had profited from his losses were delighted.

They thought they had finally caught the old fox sleeping.

For several days, young operators laughed at him openly whenever they saw him on Wall Street.

Some even stopped him just to laugh in his face.

Drew appeared to take it calmly.

He was naturally cheerful and seemed to enjoy a joke.

But he was already planning his revenge.

One evening, several of the young men were enjoying themselves at an uptown club.

Drew suddenly walked in.

He appeared to be looking for someone.

He was in a hurry and seemed excited and overheated.

Several times he pulled a large white handkerchief from his pocket and wiped his forehead.

Then he turned to leave.

As he pulled out the handkerchief once more, a small piece of white paper came out with it.

Drew did not appear to notice.

The paper drifted to the floor and landed near one of the young men.

The man quickly stepped on it.

As soon as Drew had left, they picked it up and read it.

The note was written in Drew's own handwriting.

It said:

“Buy me all the Oshkosh stock you can at any price below par.”

The young operators were stunned.

Everyone believed Oshkosh had already risen too far.

Many traders had been preparing to sell it short.

But this note suggested that Drew was preparing another huge move upward.

They thought they had discovered a secret.

There was no time to waste.

The men formed a pool and arranged to buy thirty thousand shares the next day.

They bought the stock exactly as planned.

And the broker selling it to them was one of Daniel Drew's own men.

Only later did they understand the trick.

Oshkosh began falling.

Then it fell faster.

Day after day, the stock dropped roughly a dozen points.

The young operators had not discovered Drew's secret.

They had been given a secret that Drew wanted them to discover.

His handkerchief had delivered the bait.

The men had swallowed it.

Drew soon recovered more money from them and their friends than he had lost in Northwestern.

That was the beginning of a new phase in Drew's troubles.

He had entered the Erie board of directors around 1852 and remained there until he was forced out and nearly ruined in 1868.

He served as treasurer of the railroad.

Drew was born in Carmel, Putnam County, in 1797, three years after Vanderbilt.

As a young man, he drove cattle from his hometown to New York.

Later, he became the owner of the Bull's Head Tavern in New York City.

But he never abandoned the rough style of dress he had learned as a cattle driver.

Even when he was worth thirteen million dollars, he still looked more like a country drover than a Wall Street millionaire.

As treasurer of Erie, he used his position to manipulate the stock whenever he saw an opportunity.

He cared little about the interests of ordinary shareholders.

For years he was one of the market's most powerful bears.

He had some interests in steamboats, like Vanderbilt, but Erie stock became his main vehicle for building his fortune.

By the time the famous Erie War began, many people believed Drew was financially untouchable.

Then came the corner of 1866.

That was when his real troubles began.

Until then, everything had gone almost perfectly for him.

He had accumulated millions at a pace that few financiers or speculators had ever matched.

In the spring of 1866, Erie stock was selling around $95.

But the railroad desperately needed money.

The company turned to Drew, its treasurer, for help.

Drew was willing to lend the money.

But he wanted security.

At the time, Erie had twenty-eight thousand shares of stock that had not yet been issued.

The company also claimed the right to raise money by issuing bonds that could later be converted into stock.

This was not a new trick.

Erie had used similar methods before, and Jacob Little had once been saved by a comparable arrangement.

So Drew was not inventing the technique.

He was simply using it at exactly the right moment.

The twenty-eight thousand unissued shares and three million dollars' worth of convertible bonds were placed with Drew as security.

In return, he lent the railroad three and a half million dollars.

Now Drew had something extremely valuable in his hands.

Convertible bonds.

He quickly saw how they could be used.

Erie stock had been heavily bought.

At $95, the stock looked extremely strong.

Buyers were desperate to get more shares because the supply was becoming scarce.

Drew himself had many contracts to fulfill.

The big question in Wall Street was simple:

“Where will Drew get the stock to deliver?”

Many traders thought they had him trapped.

They laughed behind his back.

They imagined the old man being crushed by a gigantic short squeeze.

They were already celebrating his expected defeat.

Then Drew made his move.

He converted the three million dollars of bonds into stock.

Suddenly, fifty-eight thousand shares were thrown onto the market.

Drew delivered the shares he needed to fulfill his contracts.

And the hungry bulls got all the Erie stock they wanted.

But they got far more than they could handle.

The market could not absorb the flood of shares.

The bulls were stunned.

Before they could recover, Erie collapsed from $95 to $50.

Huge margins disappeared.

Fortunes were wiped out.

The entire army of Erie bulls was routed.

Millions were won and lost in a single day.

At the time, people regarded the operation as one of Drew's greatest coups.

His rivals were furious.

They envied his success, hated the way he had trapped them, and were horrified by the losses they had suffered.

Drew had once again shown why Wall Street feared him.

For a while, he seemed almost unbeatable.

But there was another story connected with that Erie operation that reveals even more about the way he worked.

A young man belonged to the Erie pool, but he was not part of its inner circle.

He believed the pool's purpose was to drive Erie stock higher.

So he borrowed money from Drew to buy Erie.

Drew was happy to help.

His own brokers sold the young man the stock.

Every day, the young speculator received more shares whenever he wanted them.

He thought he was participating in the great rise.

He did not know that Drew was preparing to sell.

Then came the collapse.

Drew dumped the stock.

Erie plunged.

The young man and several of his friends were devastated.

They went to Drew and asked him to restart the pool's buying campaign.

They believed the original plan was still to push Erie higher so they could recover their losses.

Drew listened calmly.

Then he told them:

“The pool doesn't own any Erie.”

“We don't want any.”

“We aren't prepared to trade in it anymore.”

The young man was stunned.

Drew continued:

“I sold all our Erie at a profit.”

“And now I'm ready to divide the money.”

Only then did the young man understand what had happened.

While he had been speculating for himself, Drew had been doing something completely different.

The young man had believed he was following the pool.

In reality, Drew had been using the pool's activity to create the opportunity to sell.

The young speculator had lost money by trading on his own assumptions.

But Drew had made sure he recovered enough from the pool's profits to soften that loss.

It was an expensive lesson.

If the young man had simply stayed inside the pool, he might have earned a handsome profit.

But then he would never have learned the lesson Drew had forced upon him:

In Wall Street speculation, believing you understand the plan is not the same as knowing the plan.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!