Drew and Vanderbilt’s Battle for Erie
Vanderbilt had already shown what he could do with Harlem, Hudson River, and New York Central. Now he set his sights on Erie Railroad.
He believed he could take control of Erie through the same combination of stock-market pressure, financial maneuvering, and legal action that had worked before.
But this time he had badly underestimated his opponents.
Erie was controlled by a powerful group led by Daniel Drew, with Jay Gould and Jim Fisk among its most aggressive operators. They were every bit as skilled at manipulating the courts and the stock market as Vanderbilt was.
Vanderbilt first tried negotiation.
He wanted Erie consolidated with his own railroad interests, but the talks failed. He then decided to attack Drew directly.
He brought Frank Work into the fight and obtained an injunction from Judge Barnard.
The order prevented Drew from paying interest on $3.5 million of Erie bonds while the court investigated his accounts as treasurer.
Vanderbilt followed with another legal move to have Drew removed from his position.
The purpose was obvious.
If Drew could be prevented from using the bonds and the stock they could be converted into, Vanderbilt could limit the supply of Erie shares and create a powerful corner.
Vanderbilt was trying to force Drew into a position where he would have no choice but to destroy himself financially.
But the Erie people had already found ways around the rules.
New York law allowed a railroad to issue its own stock in exchange for stock in another railroad that it leased.
The Erie group had acquired the nearly worthless Buffalo, Bradford & Pittsburgh Railroad and used this law to manufacture additional Erie stock.
They leased their own railroad to a company controlled by themselves.
Then they issued stock to themselves under the authority of the law.
They had also caused the smaller railroad, whose nominal value was only $250,000, to issue $2 million in bonds.
To Vanderbilt, this meant one thing: unless the supply of Erie stock could be stopped, his planned corner could become an expensive disaster.
He therefore demanded that Drew return 68,000 Erie shares to the company treasury.
Those shares supposedly remained from the unsettled transactions of the Erie corner of 1866.
Vanderbilt was now fighting on two fronts at once.
He was manipulating the stock market while using the courts to restrict his opponent.
But Drew and his allies understood both games.
At this point three groups were competing for control of Erie.
There was Drew’s group.
There was Vanderbilt’s group.
And there was the Boston, Hartford & Erie group.
Drew tried to reach an understanding with Vanderbilt.
He visited the Commodore at his home and offered to ease the pressure against him. In return, Vanderbilt agreed not to push the court proceedings so aggressively and would have greater freedom to buy Erie stock.
At first, Vanderbilt and the Boston interests had planned to remove Drew from the Erie board.
Then Vanderbilt changed his mind.
He decided that Drew should remain.
The plan was cleverly disguised.
Drew would first be left off the new board, making it appear that the original agreement was still being carried out. Then a vacancy would be created, allowing Drew to return.
The election went exactly according to plan.
Drew was left off the board.
The next day, a vacancy was created.
Drew was elected back onto the board.
Wall Street was stunned.
Nobody knew what was really happening.
Frank Work was elected to the board on Vanderbilt’s behalf, and a pool was formed to raise the depressed Erie stock.
Drew was given control of the pool and responsibility for managing the market.
But the proposed consolidation with Vanderbilt soon collapsed.
The Erie group believed Vanderbilt was asking too much. He wanted one-third of the earnings even though they believed they were contributing more than half of the money to the pool.
The agreement fell apart.
Vanderbilt then decided to fight.
He would take Erie just as he had taken control of Hudson River.
His campaign began around the middle of February 1868.
The first target was Erie’s seemingly unlimited supply of stock.
Through its arrangement with the Buffalo, Bradford & Pittsburgh Railroad, the Erie clique had increased its income by $140,000 a year.
Frank Work obtained another injunction.
It prohibited Erie from issuing stock beyond the 251,058 shares reported in the railroad’s previous statement.
It also prevented Erie from guaranteeing another railroad’s bonds.
Drew was again ordered to stop dealing in Erie until he returned the 68,000 shares to the treasury.
Vanderbilt believed he had finally tied Drew’s hands.
The case was scheduled to be heard by Judge Barnard on March 10.
But just when Vanderbilt thought victory was within reach, the Erie side struck back.
Judge Balcom of Binghamton issued an injunction stopping the proceedings in Barnard’s court.
Richard Schell then went to Judge Ingraham and obtained another injunction stopping the proceedings before Judge Balcom.
The courts were now issuing injunctions against one another.
Meanwhile, the Erie directors were quietly preparing another issue of stock.
They intended to have plenty of new shares ready when Vanderbilt’s buyers came into the market.
The Erie executive committee authorized bonds to pay for improvements, extensions, and steel rails.
The bonds could be converted into Erie stock at no less than $72.50 a share.
Five million dollars' worth of these bonds were produced by Erie’s own paper mill and printing press.
The plan was simple.
Turn paper into bonds.
Turn the bonds into stock.
Then sell that stock to Vanderbilt’s buyers for real cash.
But there was still a legal problem.
The new Erie stock certificates had already been prepared, but the company secretary had been forbidden by injunction from issuing them.
The certificates were made on Saturday night.
On Monday morning, the secretary told a messenger to carry the books containing the certificates from the Erie office on West Street to the transfer office on Pine Street.
The messenger walked out with the books.
Less than a minute later, he returned without them.
He looked frightened.
He told everyone that Jim Fisk had been waiting outside, had grabbed the books, and had run away with them.
The certificates were now beyond the reach of the injunction.
The next day, the convertible bonds appeared on the secretary’s desk.
Soon afterward, the stock certificates began appearing in Wall Street.
Another judge, Gilbert, issued an order blocking the earlier orders of Judge Barnard.
Drew now made his move.
He suddenly threw 50,000 shares of Erie stock onto the market.
The Vanderbilt brokers were caught completely off guard.
They could not believe Drew would dare to issue new Erie stock while the courts had forbidden him to do so.
They eagerly bought the shares before they had time to investigate where the stock had come from.
Erie opened at $80.
It climbed to $83.
Then the truth became known.
The stock collapsed to $71.
The Vanderbilt party immediately bought heavily, pushing it back toward $78.
But the damage had already been done.
Drew’s huge sale had destroyed Vanderbilt’s corner.
The Commodore had been caught in his own trap.
The corner had become a boomerang.
Vanderbilt was furious.
He went back to the courts.
The pressure became so intense that the Erie leaders decided they had to escape New York.
They fled across the Hudson to Jersey City.
Drew crossed the ferry carrying a large carpetbag.
Inside was $7 million.
It was money that had just passed from Vanderbilt into Drew’s hands during the failed corner.
Gould and Fisk escaped by different routes.
The entire Erie group took refuge at Taylor’s Hotel in Jersey City.
They called the hotel their “fort.”
They believed New York law could not reach them there.
They ordered the hotel staff not to accept any letters, notes, or legal papers for them.
Only people personally known to the group were allowed to communicate with them.
The waiters were warned that anyone who broke the rule would be fired.
Vanderbilt, meanwhile, was determined to reach Drew.
He tried the courts.
He tried the legislature.
He used detectives.
But the Erie men had protected themselves carefully.
Then Vanderbilt came up with a more creative plan.
He instructed one of his men to disguise himself as a traveling salesman from the West.
The man went to Taylor’s Hotel and watched Drew for several days.
Eventually, he discovered Drew’s weakness.
Drew regularly came to the dining room for lunch.
The detective approached one of the waiters.
He offered him a deal.
The waiter would secretly hand Drew a letter from Vanderbilt.
If the waiter was fired for doing it, Vanderbilt promised him a better-paying job.
The waiter agreed.
When Drew sat down to lunch, the waiter slipped the letter into his hands.
Drew immediately became furious.
He called for the hotel manager.
The waiter was fired on the spot.
But the waiter had kept his bargain.
He soon went to work for Vanderbilt at a much higher salary.
More importantly, Vanderbilt’s letter had accomplished its purpose.
Nobody knows exactly what the Commodore wrote.
Whatever it said, it was powerful enough to change Drew’s mind.
Drew’s friends warned him not to go.
They feared Vanderbilt might have him kidnapped.
But Drew took the risk.
The following Sunday, he crossed back into New York and met with Vanderbilt.
Whatever had been said in that meeting, the dispute between the two men was settled.
While Gould and Fisk continued fighting Vanderbilt in Albany, Drew was left alone.
Gould was arrested and brought before the court for contempt and other charges that Vanderbilt’s lawyers had brought against him.
Drew, however, was free to continue his business.
The Erie battle had shown just how dangerous Wall Street could become when enormous fortunes, railroad monopolies, court injunctions, political influence, and stock manipulation were all mixed together.
Drew had survived.
Vanderbilt had failed to capture Erie.
And the fight was far from over.
Drew also became deeply involved in the political battle surrounding Erie.
As treasurer of the railroad, he quickly realized that Senator Mattoon, one of the main figures behind the legislative investigation, expected something in return for his services.
Drew thought he was using the senator.
In reality, the senator was using Drew.
Mattoon eventually cast his deciding vote in favor of Vanderbilt.
But he was also willing to help the Erie group when it suited him.
In the end, Mattoon managed to stand on the winning side of both battles.
The legislature eventually passed a bill protecting the Erie group and its enormous stock issue.
And there was plenty of money behind the political fight.
Drew had taken about half a million dollars from the Erie treasury to strengthen Gould while Gould was in Albany fighting Vanderbilt.
Mattoon, like many politicians in the Albany battles of that era, appears to have made sure that his services were not entirely unpaid.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!