← From Wall Street to London Prison: Fifteen Years in Solitude 2026 Edition
Chapter 44 · Friends in Prison: McCarty and O’Brien

Friends in Prison: McCarty and O’Brien

Chapter 44 of 50 · 1,306 words · Free

For years, I had heard stories about the Fenian prisoners held in English prisons, especially Sergeant McCarty and William O’Brien.

Not long after I arrived at Chatham, I was assigned to the same work party as both men.

At first, the three of us barely spoke.

We were naturally curious about one another, but none of us wanted to make the first move. Talking between prisoners was strictly forbidden.

Still, prison rules were one thing and prison life was another.

There were plenty of chances to exchange a few words, especially when a man was keeping up with his work. The officers were judged by how much their prisoners accomplished. If someone fell behind, the officer could be punished or fined.

So whenever a prisoner worked slowly, the officer watched him closely.

One day, shortly after McCarty and O’Brien joined my party, I helped O’Brien fix his work run.

We exchanged a few quiet words.

That was all it took.

The silence between us was broken, and before long we became close friends.

Our friendship lasted until they were finally released years later.

Both men were brave, decent, and thoroughly good-hearted. As time passed, I grew deeply attached to them.

McCarty had served in the English army for nearly twenty years.

He had fought during the Indian Mutiny and earned an excellent record. His superiors had even recommended him for a commission.

But beneath the British uniform, McCarty had never stopped loving Ireland.

In 1867, his artillery battery was stationed in Dublin.

That was when he learned that a group of committed Fenians planned to seize Dublin and begin a much larger rebellion against British rule.

McCarty knew the plan was dangerous.

He joined them anyway.

He soon discovered that several soldiers in his own battery supported the cause.

The plan was to take control of the battery and turn its guns against the British.

But the uprising failed.

McCarty was arrested along with many others.

He was charged with treason.

The verdict was almost inevitable.

He was sentenced to death by hanging, drawing, and quartering.

Fortunately, the terrible sentence was later changed to life imprisonment.

That was how a man who had once been a respected army sergeant ended up working beside me in the Chatham prison ship basin.

O’Brien had taken a very different path.

He was only seventeen when he became involved.

He was young, slim, and full of enthusiasm for Ireland.

He had deliberately joined a regiment stationed in Ireland.

His purpose was not to build a military career.

He wanted to learn how the army worked, persuade other soldiers to support the Fenian cause, and be ready to seize weapons when the rebellion began.

The rebellion failed before he could accomplish what he had planned.

And so this young patriot found himself in prison beside us.

Every day, McCarty, O’Brien, and I worked together in the great Chatham ship basin.

Our job was to load trucks with mud and clay.

Each truck could carry about four tons.

Three prisoners were assigned to each truck.

Our daily quota was nineteen trucks.

The work was exhausting.

We were constantly pushed by officers who were afraid that their prisoners would fail to complete the required amount.

The sea air was cold.

The mud was heavy.

And we were desperately hungry.

The food was hardly enough to keep a man alive.

Breakfast consisted of black bread and a pint of thin gruel.

Supper was more black bread.

For dinner, we received about a pound of boiled potatoes and five ounces of black bread.

Only three days a week did we receive meat.

That amounted to just fifteen ounces of meat for an entire week.

For men doing hard physical labor in the cold sea air, it was nowhere near enough.

We were always hungry.

Not simply hungry, but close to starvation.

There were times when we would have eaten almost anything if we could get our hands on it.

And the punishment system made everything worse.

The officers were harsh, and they handed out punishments freely.

Most prisoners were willing to work.

The problem was that hunger gradually destroyed their strength.

Then came the endless shouting, insults, and bullying from the officers.

Some prisoners could no longer bear it.

Every year, several men killed themselves.

Others found another terrible way out.

When railway trucks were being moved, some prisoners deliberately placed an arm or leg beneath the wheels.

They knew exactly what would happen.

They wanted the limb crushed.

In 1874 alone, twenty-two prisoners deliberately injured themselves this way.

Their purpose was not to die.

They wanted to escape the mud and heavy labor.

A prisoner who lost an arm or leg could no longer handle a shovel.

He would therefore be transferred to an indoor work party for disabled prisoners.

There he might be assigned to easier work, such as picking oakum or breaking stones.

He would also be protected from the worst weather.

Most importantly, he would not be worked as hard or watched as closely.

For a starving prisoner, that could mean the difference between continuing to suffer and finally getting some relief.

O’Brien was particularly vulnerable.

He was a small, delicate young man and physically unsuited to such brutal work.

But he was courageous.

His spirit carried him through hardships that would have broken stronger men.

Many prisoners who were physically much stronger eventually collapsed.

Some died.

Others became so weak that they had to be sent to an invalid station, barely recognizable as the men who had entered the prison.

McCarty and I tried to protect O’Brien.

Whenever we could, we did extra work for him.

If we managed to fill our trucks on time, the officer had no reason to complain.

We were willing to work harder so that O’Brien would not be pushed beyond his strength.

The prisoners often helped one another in this way.

Even in such a cruel place, there was still kindness among the men.

The stronger prisoners did what they could to help the weaker ones.

They shared what little comfort they could find and tried to keep one another from losing hope.

In 1877, the day finally came when McCarty and O’Brien were released.

I was happy for them.

At the same time, I felt a deep sense of loss.

I had grown so accustomed to having them beside me that their absence left a painful emptiness.

McCarty had suffered terribly during his years in prison.

His body had been damaged beyond recovery.

He survived his release by only a few days.

He returned to Dublin and died there.

His death was mourned throughout Ireland.

O’Brien was luckier.

After his release, he opened a tobacco shop in Dublin.

As far as I knew, he remained there.

I also knew many of the men who had later become known as the dynamiters—Curtin, Daly, Dr. Gallagher, Eagan, and others.

I did not agree with their methods.

They had clearly taken a dangerous and misguided path.

But I could not deny that they believed they were serving Ireland.

They paid an enormous price for that belief.

I felt especially sorry for Dr. Gallagher.

Prison had placed an enormous strain on him.

Eventually, the pressure began to destroy him.

His appearance changed completely.

His face became gloomy and hopeless.

His shoulders were permanently bent forward.

He walked slowly and without energy.

Whenever I saw him, I thought the end could not be far away.

Yet he possessed an extraordinary strength of life.

He was still alive when I was finally released.

But he had become a pitiful sight.

If he was ever to see freedom again, his friends would have to act quickly.

Otherwise, I feared that prison would slowly destroy him before he ever had the chance to breathe the air of a free man again.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!