The Man Who Could Never Escape His Past
During the many years I spent at Chatham, only about half a dozen Americans were ever sent there to keep me company.
One of them was a man named Stoneman.
He was brave, sharp-minded, and unusually honest when telling stories about his own life. I found his adventures fascinating, especially because his story proved once again that crime may bring money for a while, but it always collects its price in the end.
Stoneman came from a respectable family. In 1861, he joined the army and served well. He fought at Gettysburg and had built himself a good military record.
Then everything changed.
He had a serious quarrel with his captain and deserted the army.
After that, he became what was known as a bounty jumper. He repeatedly enlisted under different names to collect military bonuses, making a great deal of money in the process.
When the war ended, that source of easy money disappeared.
With no honest career to return to, Stoneman turned to crime.
His first major success came as an express-train robber.
His last robbery in that business took place on the New Haven Railroad near Norwalk. He made several thousand dollars from it, but the robbery eventually brought him down through an extraordinary chain of events.
One of his accomplices, a man named Riley, was arrested and locked up in Norwalk.
Stoneman hired a well-known New York criminal lawyer named Stuart to defend Riley.
Stoneman told Stuart, "I don't have any money."
"But Riley does," he added.
In reality, Stoneman had plenty of money. He simply wanted to keep his own name out of the arrangement.
He gave Riley's wife $2,500 and instructed her to be present when Stuart met her husband.
During the meeting, Riley made Stuart an offer.
"I'll pay you $2,500 if you get me completely cleared," Riley said.
"And I'll pay you $1,000 if you can get me a sentence of two years or less."
Stuart was eager to get his hands on the money.
He wrote a receipt for the full $2,500 and included the conditions they had agreed upon.
Then he put the money away and left for New York with Mrs. Riley.
Stoneman was already waiting on the train.
As soon as they started moving, he joined them.
The train was crowded, so all three had to stand.
Unfortunately for Stuart, a pickpocket had noticed him take out the money.
The thief followed him carefully.
By the time the train reached New York, the money was gone.
Stoneman had left the station quickly and knew nothing about what had happened.
When Stuart discovered the theft, he became furious.
Instead of blaming the pickpocket, he blamed Stoneman.
He immediately went to police headquarters, found a detective willing to help him, and had Stoneman arrested at a hotel he often visited.
The charge was robbery.
The situation quickly became even worse for Stoneman.
Stuart and the detectives took all the money Stoneman had with him.
Then they remembered what kind of man he was.
They knew he was dangerous, fearless, and unlikely to forget what had happened.
They also knew he would probably seek revenge.
So they decided to get rid of him.
They secretly informed the Connecticut police that Stoneman was one of the men responsible for the express-train robbery.
He was sent to Norwalk, put on trial, convicted, and sentenced to five years in prison.
He was then sent to Weathersfield.
Stoneman was a skilled mechanic, so the prison officials assigned him to the blacksmith shop.
They thought they were giving a useful prisoner a suitable job.
They had no idea what he was really doing.
Stoneman was already planning his next escape and his next crime.
Using the prison's equipment, he secretly made a complete set of extremely fine burglar's tools.
He made everything he needed—jimmies, wedges, sledges, drills, braces, bits, and other tools.
The set was too large to smuggle out with the help of prison guards, so he hid it inside the workshop where he worked.
The prison had many skilled workers.
Its machine shops produced surprisingly good work, including a workshop that manufactured silver-plated goods.
While working there, Stoneman became close friends with a prisoner who held a trusted position in the silverware factory.
The two men began making plans.
Stoneman's sentence was due to end first.
He told his friend what he intended to do.
"Once I'm outside, I'll come back."
His friend understood immediately.
They planned to rob the prison itself.
The trusted prisoner would make sure that the route to the safe was left open.
Inside the safe were silver bars used in the factory.
Eventually, Stoneman was released.
As he walked out, the warden and officers gave him the usual warning.
"Don't ever come back."
Stoneman had no intention of obeying them.
But when he returned, it was certainly not in the way they expected.
He knew the prison perfectly.
He knew where the guards stood, how they moved, and what happened at different hours of the night.
Most importantly, he knew that after eight o'clock in the evening, the wall was left completely unguarded.
Two nights after his release, Stoneman stood beneath that wall.
He had brought only one thing with him—a ladder exactly the right height.
He placed it against the wall.
Within a minute, he was standing on top.
He pulled the ladder up, moved it over the wall, and lowered it down on the inside.
Then he climbed down.
Once inside, he felt completely at home.
Every building and every path was familiar to him.
No one was watching.
The workshops were inside the prison walls but were separated from the main building where the prisoners were kept under close guard.
Stoneman went straight to the old room where he had worked.
His carefully hidden tools were still there.
He gathered the entire collection and carried it toward the wall.
One by one, he moved the jimmies, wedges, sledges, drills, braces, and other tools outside the prison.
Then he went back for the real prize.
Because of his friend's help, the route to the silver was completely open.
Stoneman didn't even need his burglar's skills.
There were about 600 ounces of silver bars waiting for him.
It was a heavy load, but he managed to carry it all in one trip.
He reached the wall, climbed over, and disappeared into the darkness.
Stoneman had planned everything carefully.
Before the robbery, he had taken one of the boats kept along the nearby river.
He loaded his silver and his tools into the boat and rowed across the river.
He traveled about two miles downstream until he reached a smaller stream that flowed into the Connecticut River.
Then he rowed upstream for a while.
He packed the silver and tools into bags and sank them beneath the water in the creek.
Afterward, he returned to the Connecticut River.
He threw the ladder into the water, abandoned the boat, and let it drift away.
By seven the next morning, Stoneman was already in New York.
Later, when everything was quiet, he returned to the creek and recovered what he had hidden there.
The burglar's tools he had made inside the prison soon went to work.
For a time, they served him extremely well.
Stoneman was clever and experienced.
He knew how to plan a robbery and how to avoid getting caught.
But sooner or later, the law caught up with him.
He escaped punishment many times.
He could not escape it forever.
For a criminal, being arrested is more than simply losing freedom.
It can destroy years of a man's life in an instant.
Stoneman became well known in criminal circles for his daring and success.
But between 1865 and 1886, he spent sixteen of those twenty-one years behind bars.
Even prison did not change him.
In 1886, he went to England with another criminal.
Only a few hours after arriving in London, the two men attacked a bank messenger on Lombard Street and snatched a parcel containing money.
This time they were caught almost immediately.
Both men were taken to the Old Bailey, convicted, and sentenced to twenty years in prison.
That was where Stoneman's long criminal career finally reached its miserable end.
He was now working under brutal prison overseers, performing exhausting labor day after day.
It was almost certain that he would die there.
He had no friends.
No family came to comfort him.
No one was waiting for him.
No one would mourn him.
Perhaps that was even better.
For even if he somehow survived long enough to be released, freedom would come far too late.
By then, the world he once knew would be gone.
He would walk out an old, broken man, with nowhere to go and nothing left to return to.
He had spent his life believing that cleverness could defeat the law.
In the end, the law had simply waited for him.
And when it finally caught him, there was almost nothing of the man he had once been left to save.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!