Guan Yu Defies Cao Cao and Sets Out to Rejoin Liu Bei
Yuan Shao was ready to execute Liu Bei. But Liu Bei stayed calm and composed.
“My lord,” he said, “you believe only one person’s words and cast aside our old friendship? After we separated in Xuzhou, I had no idea if my second brother Guan Yu was alive or dead. There are many men in the world with red faces and long beards. How can you assume every such man is Guan Yu? Why not investigate the truth before judging me?”
Yuan Shao was always indecisive. After hearing Liu Bei’s words, he immediately blamed Ju Shou.
“I blindly trusted your advice and nearly killed an innocent man,” he snapped.
He then invited Liu Bei back to his tent to discuss avenging Yan Liang.
At once, a general stood up from the ranks.
“Yan Liang was like a blood brother to me!” he shouted. “I will avenge his death at Cao Cao’s hands!”
Liu Bei looked over and saw a towering eight-foot warrior with a stern, fierce face. It was the renowned Hebei general Wen Chou.
Yuan Shao beamed with joy.
“Only you can defeat Cao Cao and avenge Yan Liang!” he declared. “I shall give you one hundred thousand troops. Cross the Yellow River at once and pursue the enemy!”
Ju Shou quickly stepped forward to protest.
“This is unwise!” he warned. “We should hold Yanjin and station troops at Guandu as our main defense. A hasty river crossing will leave us vulnerable. If disaster strikes, our entire army will be trapped.”
Yuan Shao grew furious.
“You and your endless hesitation ruin every great plan!” he roared. “Have you never heard that speed is the key to victory in war?”
Defeated, Ju Shou withdrew. He sighed heavily to himself.
“Our lord has great ambition but little talent. His generals only crave merit and glory. I fear none of us will make it back across this Yellow River.”
After that, he claimed illness and refused to attend any more military meetings.
Liu Bei then spoke up politely.
“I owe you great kindness, my lord, and have no way to repay you. I wish to join General Wen Chou on this campaign. I can fight for your cause, and also search for news of my brother Guan Yu.”
Yuan Shao was delighted by the offer. He ordered Wen Chou to take Liu Bei as a vanguard.
But Wen Chou disagreed openly.
“Liu Bei has always been a defeated general with poor command skills,” he said. “If you insist on him coming, I will give him thirty thousand troops to guard the rear. I will lead seventy thousand soldiers in the front advance.”
Meanwhile, Cao Cao held Guan Yu in even higher regard after he killed Yan Liang. He reported Guan Yu’s deeds to the imperial court, earning him the official title of Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion, and had a seal cast for the honor.
Soon after, scouts brought urgent news: Yuan Shao’s general Wen Chou had crossed the Yellow River and seized Yanjin.
Cao Cao first evacuated all civilians to the west of the river, then marched out with his army to meet the enemy. He issued a strange order: the rear guard would lead the march, and the front guard would fall back. Supply wagons would move ahead of the soldiers.
Lv Qian was thoroughly confused.
“Why put supplies in front and soldiers behind?” he asked.
“Supplies left in the rear are easy targets for looting,” Cao Cao replied calmly.
“But if the enemy raids them out front, we will lose everything!” Lv Qian protested.
“We will deal with the enemy when they arrive,” Cao Cao said simply.
Lv Qian could not understand the strategy, but he obeyed orders. Cao Cao lined supply caravans all the way to Yanjin and waited with his main force.
Before long, shouts and chaos erupted from the front lines. Messengers rushed back to report that Wen Chou’s army had arrived. Cao’s soldiers had abandoned the supplies and fled in panic, and the main army was too far forward to offer immediate aid.
Cao Cao pointed to a nearby southern hill.
“Retreat to high ground and take shelter there,” he ordered.
His men hurried up the slope. Cao Cao then told his soldiers to remove their armor and rest freely, and set all their horses loose on the hillside.
Wen Chou’s army charged toward the hill. Cao’s generals panicked.
“The enemy is here!” they cried. “Gather the horses and retreat to Baima at once!”
Xun You quickly stopped them.
“This is our trap to lure the enemy in!” he said. “We must not retreat!”
Cao Cao shot Xun You a knowing look and smiled. Xun You immediately fell silent, understanding his plan.
Wen Chou’s soldiers swarmed forward. They first looted all the supply wagons, then scattered to chase and capture the free horses. Their tight battle formation completely fell apart.
At that exact moment, Cao Cao ordered his entire army to charge down the hill.
Wen Chou’s troops were thrown into total disarray. Caught off guard, they trampled each other in their rush to flee. Wen Chou tried desperately to rally his men but failed. He had no choice but to turn his horse and retreat.
Standing on the hill, Cao Cao shouted, “Wen Chou is the finest general in Hebei! Who can capture him?”
Zhang Liao and Xu Huang immediately galloped forward, yelling, “Wen Chou, stop and surrender!”
Wen Chou glanced back, set down his spear, and drew his bow. He loosed an arrow straight at Zhang Liao.
“Villain, hold your fire!” Xu Huang shouted a warning.
Zhang Liao ducked just in time. The arrow struck his helmet, slicing off the decorative plume. He pushed onward, but a second arrow hit his horse’s cheek. The horse crashed to the ground, throwing Zhang Liao off its back.
Wen Chou wheeled his horse around to strike the downed general. Xu Huang charged in with his giant axe to block the attack. But when he saw Wen Chou’s full army closing in, he knew he could not win. He turned and fled.
Wen Chou pursued him along the riverbank.
Suddenly, a dozen riders burst onto the scene, banners flying high. A mighty general charged forward on a galloping steed, blade in hand. It was Guan Yu.
“Stop right there, traitor!” Guan Yu roared.
He clashed with Wen Chou. In less than three bouts, Wen Chou’s courage failed him. He spun his horse and tried to escape along the river.
But Guan Yu’s red hare steed was unmatched in speed. He quickly caught up, swung his green-dragon blade, and struck Wen Chou dead with a single blow to the back of his head.
From the hill, Cao Cao watched the victory and ordered a full army advance. Most of the Hebei soldiers fell into the river and drowned. Cao’s forces reclaimed all their lost supplies and horses.
Guan Yu led his small troop to clear the battlefield. Just then, Liu Bei arrived with his thirty thousand rear troops. His scouts reported the news.
“The same red-faced, long-bearded general has slain Wen Chou!”
Liu Bei raced forward. Across the river, he saw a troop of elite riders flying a banner marked with seven characters: Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion Guan Yunchang.
Liu Bei silently thanked heaven. “My brother is indeed with Cao Cao!”
He longed to call out and meet Guan Yu, but Cao’s main army was pouring into the area. He had no choice but to retreat.
Yuan Shao regrouped his army at Guandu and set up camp. Guo Tu and Shen Pei came to speak to him.
“Once again, Guan Yu has killed one of our top generals,” they said. “Liu Bei knew full well what would happen and pretended ignorance.”
Yuan Shao flew into a rage.
“That big-eared traitor dares to deceive me!” he shouted.
When Liu Bei arrived moments later, Yuan Shao ordered his men to drag him out for execution.
“What crime have I committed?” Liu Bei asked calmly.
“You deliberately sent your brother to kill another of my generals!” Yuan Shao roared. “How dare you claim innocence?”
“Allow me to speak one last time before I die,” Liu Bei begged.
Yuan Shao gestured for him to continue.
“Cao Cao has always hated me,” Liu Bei explained. “Now that he knows I am by your side, he fears I will help you defeat him. So he intentionally sent Guan Yu to kill your generals. He knew you would fly into a rage and execute me. This is his scheme—to use your hand to kill me! Please think carefully, my lord.”
Yuan Shao’s anger faded at once.
“You speak the truth,” he said. “My advisors nearly made me kill a worthy man and bring shame upon myself.”
He dismissed his guards and invited Liu Bei back into the tent.
Liu Bei bowed gratefully.
“I have no way to repay your mercy, my lord. I wish to send a trusted man to deliver a secret letter to Guan Yu. Once he learns I am here, he will rush to join you. Together, you can defeat Cao Cao and avenge Yan Liang and Wen Chou.”
Yuan Shao was overjoyed.
“If I gain Guan Yu’s service, it will be worth more than ten men like Yan Liang and Wen Chou!”
Liu Bei wrote the letter immediately, though he had not yet found a messenger to send it. Yuan Shao then ordered his army to retreat to Wuyang, building connected camps stretching dozens of miles, and halted all military action.
Cao Cao left Xiahou Dun to guard the Guandu pass and returned triumphantly to Xudu. He held a grand feast to celebrate Guan Yu’s achievements.
He turned to Lv Qian and said, “My earlier plan to move supplies ahead of the army was a trap to lure the enemy. Only Xun You understood my true intent.”
All the generals present nodded in admiration.
Mid-feast, urgent news arrived. Rebel remnants of the Yellow Turbans, Liu Pi and Gong Du, were rampaging in Runan. Cao Hong had lost several battles and begged for reinforcements.
Guan Yu immediately stepped forward and volunteered.
“I will lead troops to pacify the Runan rebels!”
“You have just won great merit and have yet to receive your proper reward,” Cao Cao protested. “How can I send you to fight again so soon?”
“Idle days make me restless and weak,” Guan Yu replied. “Please let me go on this campaign.”
Impressed by his dedication, Cao Cao granted his request. He assigned fifty thousand troops to Guan Yu, with Yu Jin and Le Jin as his lieutenants. They set out the next day.
Privately, Xun Yu warned Cao Cao. “Guan Yu has always longed to return to Liu Bei. Once he hears news of his brother, he will surely leave your side. You should not send him on distant campaigns.”
“After this battle, I will keep him close and never let him fight abroad again,” Cao Cao promised.
Guan Yu’s army marched to Runan and set up camp. That night, his patrols captured two enemy scouts. To his great surprise, one of them was Sun Qian, an old follower of Liu Bei.
Guan Yu sent all his guards away and spoke privately with Sun Qian.
“We lost contact after our separation,” he said. “How did you end up here?”
“I fled to Runan during the chaos and was taken in by Liu Pi,” Sun Qian explained. “General, why are you serving Cao Cao? Are Lady Gan and Lady Mi safe and well?”
Guan Yu told him the entire story of his surrender and his time with Cao Cao.
“Liu Pi and Gong Du have sworn allegiance to Yuan Shao to fight Cao Cao,” Sun Qian continued. “Heaven has guided you here. I asked them to let me come as a scout to find you. Tomorrow, they will feign defeat in battle. You can seize this chance to take the two ladies and flee north to reunite with Lord Liu Bei.”
“I long to rejoin my brother,” Guan Yu said anxiously. “But I have killed two of Yuan Shao’s top generals. I fear he will seek revenge and harm us.”
“I will go first to check the situation and report back,” Sun Qian offered.
“I would face death a thousand times to see my brother again,” Guan Yu declared. “I will return to Xudu to take my formal leave of Cao Cao first.”
He secretly sent Sun Qian away that night.
The next day, Guan Yu marched out to battle Gong Du.
“Why do you rebel against the imperial court?” Guan Yu demanded.
Gong Du shouted back, “You are the one who abandoned your lord! How dare you question my loyalty?”
“When did I ever betray my master?” Guan Yu retorted.
“Liu Bei lives with Yuan Shao, yet you serve Cao Cao!” Gong Du replied. “That is betrayal enough!”
Guan Yu said no more. He charged forward with his blade raised. Gong Du immediately turned and fled. As Guan Yu closed in, Gong Du whispered quietly.
“Do not forget your old lord’s kindness! Advance your army. We will surrender Runan to you.”
Guan Yu understood his intent. He ordered his troops to attack. Liu Pi and Gong Du pretended to be utterly defeated and scattered their forces.
Guan Yu took control of Runan, calmed the local people, and marched back to Xudu in victory.
Cao Cao personally rode out of the city to welcome him and rewarded all his soldiers. After the celebration feast, Guan Yu returned to his residence and paid respects to his two sister-in-laws.
Lady Gan asked, “Did you learn any news of Lord Liu Bei on this campaign?”
“I did not,” Guan Yu replied.
After he left, the two ladies wept bitterly in their chambers.
“Our lord must be dead,” they cried. “General Guan only hides the truth to spare our feelings.”
An old veteran soldier stationed outside heard their weeping and spoke up.
“Do not grieve, my ladies. Lord Liu Bei is alive and with Yuan Shao in the north.”
“How do you know this?” Lady Gan asked urgently.
“I heard the enemy general speak of it on the battlefield during the campaign,” the soldier answered.
The ladies immediately summoned Guan Yu and confronted him.
“Lord Liu Bei treated you with the utmost kindness and loyalty,” they said. “Now you indulge in Cao Cao’s favors and hide the truth from us. Have you forgotten your old oath?”
Guan Yu knelt and kowtowed in shame.
“My brother is indeed in Hebei,” he admitted. “I hid this news only for fear of leaks and danger. This matter requires careful planning; we cannot act recklessly.”
“You must hurry and find a way to reunite with him,” Lady Gan urged.
Guan Yu withdrew, restless and troubled as he searched for a safe plan to leave Cao Cao’s side.
Yu Jin discovered the news of Liu Bei’s location and reported it to Cao Cao. Cao Cao sent Zhang Liao to sound out Guan Yu’s true intentions.
Zhang Liao entered Guan Yu’s residence with a smile.
“I hear you have learned news of Lord Liu Bei. Congratulations!”
“My lord lives, yet I cannot go to him,” Guan Yu sighed. “What joy is there in that?”
Zhang Liao asked, “How does your bond with Liu Bei compare to our friendship?”
“Our friendship is a bond between peers,” Guan Yu answered firmly. “My bond with Liu Bei is that of friend, brother, and lord and subject. The two cannot be compared.”
“Now that you know he lives in Hebei, will you go to him?” Zhang Liao pressed.
“I will never break my sworn oath,” Guan Yu said. “Please send my regards to Prime Minister Cao.”
Zhang Liao reported the conversation back to Cao Cao.
“I have my own ways to keep him here,” Cao Cao said calmly.
As Guan Yu sat worrying, a visitor asked to see him. Guan Yu did not recognize the man when he entered.
“Who are you, sir?” Guan Yu asked.
“I am Chen Zhen, a subordinate of Yuan Shao, from Nanyang,” the man replied.
Guan Yu was shocked. He immediately dismissed all attendants to speak privately.
“You must have come for an important reason,” he said.
Chen Zhen pulled out a personal letter written by Liu Bei and handed it to him.
The letter read: We swore to live and die together in the Peach Garden. How could you abandon our brotherhood and walk a separate path? If you seek fame and fortune, you may take my head and offer it to Cao Cao to advance your career. Words cannot express my longing. I await your reply.
Tears streamed down Guan Yu’s face as he finished reading.
“I never stopped searching for my brother!” he cried. “I never chose wealth and glory over our oath!”
“Lord Liu Bei waits for you in great anxiety,” Chen Zhen said. “If you remain true to your oath, you must go to him at once.”
“A true gentleman sees things through to the end,” Guan Yu said firmly. “I came to Cao Cao openly and honestly, so I must leave the same way. I will write a reply for you to take back. I will formally take my leave of Cao Cao, then escort my sister-in-laws north to reunite with my brother.”
“What if Cao Cao refuses to let you go?” Chen Zhen asked.
“I would rather die than stay here any longer!” Guan Yu swore.
“Write your reply quickly, so you do not keep Lord Liu Bei waiting,” Chen Zhen urged.
Guan Yu picked up his brush and wrote his response: Loyalty and righteousness come before all else, even life itself. I have read the tales of Yang Jiaozuo and Zuo Botao, who died for their sworn brothers, and I have always admired their faithfulness. When I held Xiapi with no supplies and no reinforcements, I chose to live rather than die uselessly, only to protect our two ladies and keep my promise to you. I have only just learned of your whereabouts in Runan. I will take my formal leave of Cao Cao at once and bring the ladies to your side. If I harbor any traitorous thoughts, may gods and men alike strike me down. I long eagerly for our reunion.
Chen Zhen took the letter and departed. Guan Yu told the two ladies the good news, then headed to the prime minister’s mansion to take his leave.
Knowing Guan Yu’s purpose, Cao Cao ordered a avoidance sign hung at the gate, refusing visitors.
Disappointed, Guan Yu returned home. He ordered his old followers to pack their carts and horses for immediate departure. He sealed up all the gold, silver, and treasures Cao Cao had given him, refusing to take a single gift.
The next day, he tried again to see Cao Cao, only to find the avoidance sign still hanging. He attempted several more times over successive days with the same result. He then went to Zhang Liao’s home to ask for help, but Zhang Liao also claimed illness and refused to see him.
Guan Yu understood the truth.
“The prime minister means to keep me from leaving,” he said. “But my resolve is fixed. I will not stay.”
He wrote a final farewell letter: I have served Liu Bei since youth, bound by an oath to live and die together. When Xiapi fell, I accepted three conditions from you to survive and protect our ladies. Now I have learned my lord lives in Yuan Shao’s camp. I cannot break my sacred oath. Your new kindness is great, but my old loyalty is unbreakable. I write to take my formal leave. I will repay your kindness another day.
He sealed the letter and sent it to the mansion. He locked all the gifted treasure in the storehouse, hung his Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion official seal in the main hall, and left the ten beautiful women Cao Cao had given him in the inner residence. He took only his original followers and personal luggage.
Guan Yu helped the two ladies board their carriage, mounted his red hare steed, gripped his green-dragon blade, and led his small party toward the northern city gate.
The gate guards tried to stop him, but Guan Yu glared and raised his blade with a fierce shout. The terrified guards scattered and fled out of his way.
Outside the city, Guan Yu ordered his followers. “Escort the carriage ahead quickly. If anyone chases us, I will hold them off. Do not alarm the ladies.”
His party hurried north along the main road.
Meanwhile, Cao Cao was discussing Guan Yu’s intentions with his generals when the farewell letter arrived. Cao Cao read it and cried out in shock.
“Yunchang has left us!”
Moments later, the northern gate guard rushed in to report that Guan Yu had forced his way out of the city with twenty riders and a carriage, heading north.
Guan Yu’s household servants also arrived to report: he had left all treasures sealed, abandoned his official title, refused all of Cao Cao’s new servants and gifts, and left with only his original men.
All the generals fell silent in surprise.
Then one general stepped forward boldly.
“I will take three thousand elite cavalry to capture Guan Yu and bring him back to you, Prime Minister!”
Everyone looked up and saw it was the general Cai Yang.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!