← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 24 · Henry N. Smith: From Wall Street Success to Financial Ruin

Henry N. Smith: From Wall Street Success to Financial Ruin

Chapter 24 of 90 · 1,781 words · Free

Henry N. Smith had already appeared in this story as a member of the firm Smith, Gould & Martin. But his career was so important—and so dramatic—that he deserves a story of his own.

Smith was born in Buffalo and started out in the mercantile business there. When he first arrived on Wall Street, people called him “the young man from Buffalo.”

He had a striking appearance: a reddish-blond complexion, a full auburn beard, sharp eyes, and an unmistakable air of confidence.

He had made some money in Buffalo, and his first Wall Street ventures went well. He was one of the few speculators who came through the panic of 1864 with money in his pocket.

Success made Smith bolder.

He became an aggressive operator and accumulated a considerable fortune. When he trusted his own judgment, he was usually successful.

But his first great disaster came in the panic of 1873.

Before the crash, Commodore Vanderbilt had taken an interest in Smith and persuaded him to buy Western Union stock.

When Western Union collapsed, Smith was nearly wiped out.

He lost practically all of his cash.

All he had left was his New York home and a stock farm.

But Smith was not the kind of man to stay down for long.

He started over.

Within a surprisingly short time, he had rebuilt his position and once again became a powerful figure on Wall Street.

Despite repeated market crashes and violent swings in prices, Smith managed for years to stay ahead of the market.

He became a successful and relatively wealthy speculator.

One of Smith's greatest strengths was his ability to win the confidence of wealthy people.

He repeatedly surrounded himself with men who had much more capital than he did.

Because of these relationships, he could obtain enormous amounts of credit compared with his actual wealth.

That credit would eventually become one of the main causes of his downfall.

A few years later, after returning from Europe, Smith met W. K. Vanderbilt.

The two men began discussing where they thought the stock market was headed.

Vanderbilt had been a strong bull for some time.

The two decided to speculate together on the assumption that stock prices would rise.

It turned into a disaster.

Vanderbilt lost several million dollars and came dangerously close to putting a large portion of his expected inheritance from his father at risk.

Smith suffered badly as well.

Then something happened that completely changed Smith's view of the market.

On his way to Long Branch one day, Smith met the famous speculator Woerishoffer.

Woerishoffer was one of the most powerful bears on Wall Street.

At that time, Smith and Vanderbilt were still among the leading bulls.

Woerishoffer tried to convince Smith that he had chosen the wrong side.

“Your position is wrong,” Woerishoffer told him in effect. “You should sell what you own and come over to the bear side.”

Smith listened.

Woerishoffer's confidence and force of personality made a powerful impression on him.

More importantly, Woerishoffer had something even more persuasive than words.

He had results.

He had made money by betting against the market.

For a Wall Street speculator, there could hardly be a stronger argument.

Smith followed his advice.

The change worked.

Smith soon recovered much of what he had lost.

But something more dangerous happened at the same time.

He became obsessed with the bearish view.

He began to believe almost completely in Woerishoffer's judgment.

Soon he had nearly as much faith in his own bearish predictions as he had in Woerishoffer's.

From that point on, Smith saw disaster everywhere.

Whenever the market rose, he believed the advance could not last.

Whenever prices recovered, he saw only another opportunity to sell.

His faith in Woerishoffer became almost fanatical.

It was like the famous story of Ignatius Loyola, who supposedly said that if the Pope ordered him to row an open boat into a violent storm, he would obey without asking why.

Smith's attitude toward Woerishoffer was almost the same.

He believed that Woerishoffer's judgment about speculation was practically infallible.

To an outsider, such behavior may seem unbelievable.

But Wall Street speculation can produce a strange kind of fanaticism.

Once a speculator becomes completely committed to being a bull or a bear, facts often stop mattering.

He sees what he expects to see.

If the market rises, the bull sees confirmation of his belief.

If the market falls, the bear sees confirmation of his.

Evidence that contradicts the belief is simply ignored.

The speculator becomes his own oracle.

Once he has spoken, nothing is allowed to challenge his prediction.

This mixture of extreme confidence and stubborn fanaticism has ruined hundreds of speculators.

Smith developed a particularly severe case.

In some ways, his bearish obsession became even stronger than that of Woerishoffer himself.

Like Woerishoffer, Smith began attacking every advance in prices.

During the summer of 1885, the market continued to rise, with occasional healthy pullbacks.

Smith treated every rally as an opportunity to sell.

The market kept moving higher.

Smith kept betting against it.

Eventually, his own money was gone.

But he did not stop.

He began borrowing and building up enormous obligations with Wm. Heath & Co.

Every time the market rose, his short positions lost money.

Every time his margins disappeared, the firm had to provide more money to keep his positions alive.

The losses kept piling up.

Wm. Heath & Co. was gradually drained of its available resources.

Smith still refused to give up.

His faith in the bearish position was stronger than the evidence in front of him.

Eventually, he had lost everything he personally owned.

Worse, he owed Wm. Heath & Co. one million dollars.

That enormous debt helped bring the firm down.

Its collapse also damaged or destroyed several smaller brokerage houses.

Later, when Smith appeared before the Governing Committee of the Stock Exchange to ask for more time on his seat, he made a remarkable statement.

“On January 1, 1885, I was worth $1,400,000.”

“I had $1,100,000 in cash.”

“The remaining $300,000 was in good real estate.”

“By the following January, I had lost everything.”

“And I was $1,200,000 in debt.”

“Of that amount, one million dollars was owed to Wm. Heath & Co.”

People naturally wondered how Smith had been able to obtain such enormous credit from a single firm.

At the time, I believed—and I still believe—that the answer was the extraordinary personal influence Smith had over the older Mr. Heath.

Heath had been in poor health for some time.

Because of his condition, he had turned much of the firm's day-to-day management over to McCanless, the firm's chief clerk and general manager.

But Heath's physical and mental weakness made him unusually vulnerable to Smith's forceful personality.

Smith's confidence and determination overwhelmed him.

Heath gradually accepted Smith's judgment instead of his own.

That was a dangerous mistake.

Anyone running a large Wall Street brokerage business must be able to say no.

Not politely.

Not reluctantly.

Firmly.

And once he says no, he must have the strength to stand by it.

That requires both mental toughness and physical stamina.

A broker who cannot firmly refuse a dangerous request may eventually lose everything.

That was essentially what happened to Wm. Heath & Co.

But Smith's story had another important chapter.

Long before his final collapse, he had made a number of successful speculative trades during the rule of William M. Tweed.

Tweed was then the dominant political power in New York City.

The famous Tweed Ring had enormous influence over the city's financial system.

The city government and Wall Street were closely connected.

Money could be moved in ways that created sudden shortages of cash.

And when money suddenly became scarce, the stock market could be thrown into chaos.

Tweed had three famous sayings.

“The way to have power is to take it.”

“He is human.”

And:

“What are you going to do about it?”

Tweed followed the first principle very effectively.

He took control of the city's money.

He also gained control over several savings banks and other financial institutions that had been created with special charters from the state legislature.

During Tweed's reign, the city's available funds were enormous.

The city usually had between six and eight million dollars in cash.

That money was deposited in banks controlled by members of the Tweed organization.

Officially, the funds were under the control of the City Chamberlain.

In reality, the City Chamberlain answered to Tweed.

Smith and a few other favored members of the group understood how powerful this system could be.

They could withdraw large sums of money from the banks.

That immediately reduced the amount of money available to everyone else.

Money became scarce.

Interest rates shot up.

The stock market weakened.

And sometimes prices collapsed with astonishing speed.

Brokers and businesses outside the Tweed Ring could be ruined almost overnight.

On one particularly dramatic occasion, Smith drove to the Tenth National Bank in a cab.

This was the same bank associated with the Black Friday group.

Smith withdrew his entire balance.

It amounted to $4.1 million.

He took the money home.

Then he locked it away for several days.

At the same time, Tweed and his associates withdrew much of the money under their own control.

Altogether, nearly $20 million was temporarily removed from circulation.

In those days, that was an enormous sum.

It was enough to create a brutally tight money market.

Wall Street operators suddenly found themselves desperate for cash.

A small group of men had acquired extraordinary financial power.

They could tighten the money supply and then profit from the resulting collapse in stock prices.

At the time, Smith believed he was worth at least $5 million.

But much of that fortune would later disappear in the panic of 1873, especially through his heavy losses in Western Union stock—the same investment that Commodore Vanderbilt had encouraged him to make.

Smith also played a prominent role in the great speculative drama of Black Friday, which I have described elsewhere.

His career therefore illustrates both sides of Wall Street speculation.

A man could make a fortune through courage, intelligence, connections, and timing.

But the same confidence that made him successful could become fatal when it turned into obsession.

Smith's greatest weakness was not a lack of intelligence.

It was his inability to recognize when his own certainty had become dangerous.

Once he became convinced that the market must fall, no amount of rising prices could change his mind.

He kept selling.

He kept borrowing.

He kept demanding more credit.

And in the end, his stubborn belief did not merely destroy his own fortune.

It helped destroy the people and firms that trusted him.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!