← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 25 · Keene’s Rise and Fall

Keene’s Rise and Fall

Chapter 25 of 90 · 2,515 words · Free

One of the most dramatic fortunes ever made and lost on Wall Street belonged to James R. Keene. His rise was astonishing, and so was his fall.

Keene was born in London to English parents. At seventeen, he came to America, lived in the South, and studied law.

In 1853, he moved to San Francisco. While practicing law there, he handled several mining cases and quickly became familiar with the mining business.

He also spent some time working for a Western newspaper.

But California was caught up in a huge speculative boom, and Keene soon caught the fever himself.

He gave up both law and journalism and became a broker.

For a while, things did not go well.

He struggled simply to make a living, and the hard life of the West seriously damaged his health.

Finally, his doctor warned him:

“You must stop working. If you want to save your life, you need to take a long sea voyage.”

Keene followed the advice and booked passage to the East.

That trip changed everything.

Before he left California, someone persuaded him to put a few hundred dollars into a mining stock that was selling at a very low price.

Once he sailed away, the investment almost disappeared from his mind.

Communication between California and the East was extremely slow in those days. News could take months to travel across the country.

To understand just how slow things were, consider the discovery of gold in California.

Gold was discovered on January 19, 1848, but news of it did not reach the Eastern states until December.

When Keene finally returned to California after nearly a year away, he could hardly believe what he saw.

Mining stocks had exploded in value.

The little mining investment he had almost forgotten had become a fortune.

The few hundred dollars he had put into the stock was now worth more than $200,000.

Had Keene remained in California, he probably would have sold the stock as soon as it made him a few thousand dollars.

His forced absence had saved him from selling too early.

For a man who had recently been struggling to survive, $200,000 was an extraordinary windfall.

But instead of making Keene cautious, it made him hungry for even greater success.

The speculative fever in California was everywhere.

Waiters and chambermaids seemed to become millionaires overnight.

Keene bought a seat on the Stock Board and began doing business on a huge scale.

Flood, Mackay, Fair, and O’Brien were among the leading operators of the day.

Speculation spread rapidly throughout California and soon influenced markets across the country.

Keene continued to make money.

Then he noticed something that reminded him of Daniel Drew's old theory:

“When a stock rises too far and too fast, sooner or later it has to come down.”

The Comstock mining stocks had risen to extraordinary levels.

Most investors refused to believe they could fall.

Keene did.

He began selling them short.

It took considerable courage.

The powerful group led by Flood, Mackay, Fair, and O’Brien, backed by the Bank of California, regarded Keene as an enemy.

They did everything they could to break him.

But Keene kept selling.

Eventually, the market began to weaken.

The stocks that had climbed so spectacularly started falling even faster.

Keene made millions on the decline.

He earned about $2.5 million from Belcher and Crown Point and more than half a million dollars from Ophir.

In only a few years, the struggling lawyer, journalist, broker, and invalid had become a millionaire many times over.

His name was now famous from coast to coast.

When the great mining bubble finally burst, Keene was still on the winning side.

The Bank of California collapsed.

Its president, William Ralston, later drowned himself in the Pacific Ocean while pretending to take a bath.

Keene's reputation only grew.

In 1877, he decided to travel to Europe to improve his health.

On the way, he stopped in New York and visited Wall Street simply to see how business was done there.

But Wall Street immediately captured him.

He had come to look at the market.

Instead, the market captured him.

Keene soon discovered that California methods did not work in New York.

He tried selling stocks short.

But when he sold 10,000 shares, the market barely moved.

Instead of collapsing, it quickly recovered.

Keene realized what was happening.

He was pouring his California money into the market and getting almost nothing in return.

So he stopped.

Soon afterward, Keene formed a pool with Jay Gould to drive Western Union lower.

Keene and Major Selover sold huge blocks of the stock.

But someone kept buying everything they sold.

The shares disappeared as quickly as they were offered.

Suspicion grew that Gould himself was secretly buying the stock.

Selover became furious.

One morning, Keene and Selover met near the rear entrance of the Stock Exchange on New Street.

They exchanged a knowing look.

Selover then walked down the street looking for Gould.

He found him at the corner of New Street and Exchange Place.

Without much ceremony, Selover grabbed Gould by the collar and part of his trousers and dropped him into the entrance area of a barber shop.

Gould quietly picked himself up.

He went back to his office.

Then he made a trade that cost Selover another $15,000.

That was Gould's answer.

Keene next joined the Atlantic and Pacific Telegraph pool.

Once again, he made money.

Some people later claimed that Keene had lost heavily in the deal.

According to reliable information, the opposite was true.

The Western Union operation made Keene and Gould about $1.3 million together.

Many people believed Gould had tricked Keene.

The actual results tell a different story.

Keene then studied the entire Wall Street situation.

He saw that stock values had fallen enormously since the Panic of 1873.

He had arrived at exactly the right moment.

He had $4 million behind him.

The small losses he had suffered when he first arrived in New York meant little to him.

They were simply the price of learning how Wall Street worked.

Keene quickly studied the major stocks traded on the Exchange.

He learned remarkably fast.

Most stocks were selling at panic prices.

Many were fundamentally worth far more than their market prices suggested.

Keene began buying heavily.

Then the market turned.

The great speculative boom of 1879 and 1880 began.

Stocks rose dramatically.

Keene's fortune doubled.

Then it tripled.

The $4 million he had brought from California became roughly $13 million.

For a time, Keene must have felt like a modern Croesus.

He stood at the center of an enormous fortune, and everyone was watching him.

His fame spread throughout America and Europe.

Even the old Wall Street operators began to envy him.

His success seemed almost unbelievable.

Unlike many speculators, Keene's fortune was largely invested in solid securities.

He had no pile of worthless paper or dubious railroad claims hiding inside his wealth.

His fortune had been built with astonishing speed and appeared to be remarkably substantial.

Wall Street history offered few examples of anyone becoming so rich so quickly.

Unfortunately, this was where the story began to change.

Keene became overconfident.

He still had enormous holdings in stocks, but he began spreading his money into almost everything imaginable.

He speculated in wheat.

He speculated in lard.

He speculated in opium.

He even speculated in racehorses.

He began to believe that he simply could not lose.

His victories had convinced him that he was destined to succeed in speculation just as Napoleon had believed he was destined to win wars.

Then came his attempt to corner the wheat market.

It failed badly.

While the horse Foxhall was winning the Grand Prix in Paris, Keene was losing his own great race against the farmers of the American West.

The farmers simply sent their wheat to market faster than Keene could buy it.

Even his $13 million fortune and enormous credit could not control the supply.

Then the market tide suddenly turned.

Mr. Cammack noticed that Keene had spread himself across too many ventures.

He discussed the situation with Jay Gould.

They reached the same conclusion.

Keene could not possibly protect all his positions at once.

Sooner or later, one of his many operations would become vulnerable.

That was the opening they needed.

Gould and Cammack joined forces as bears.

They began attacking the market.

Day after day, their pressure increased.

More bears joined them.

The bulls became fewer and weaker.

The banks grew nervous.

Brokers became nervous too.

They demanded more margin.

Loans were called in.

Every weapon available to the bears was brought into action.

Prices were smashed.

Stocks that had once been considered excellent long-term investments were attacked without mercy.

Some were almost destroyed.

The market went into a genuine panic.

In the general collapse, brokers began selling Keene's stocks.

His wheat positions were also liquidated in enormous quantities at terrible prices.

The fortune that had been built so rapidly was being dismantled just as quickly.

Keene's losses were estimated at about $7 million.

But the worst was still ahead.

Instead of accepting the loss, Keene tried desperately to win his money back.

As so often happens after a huge speculative loss, every attempt to recover the money created another loss.

One disaster followed another.

The more desperate Keene became, the more he risked.

His remaining fortune was gradually consumed in unsuccessful attempts to recover what he had already lost.

Wall Street felt genuine sympathy for him.

There was another reason for that sympathy.

Keene had been extraordinarily generous.

No one in Wall Street had ever developed such a reputation for giving money away.

During his years of prosperity, he spent money on friends, brokers, acquaintances, and people who had little claim on his generosity.

At least twenty Wall Street brokers, it was said, rose from poverty to wealth largely because of the commissions they earned from Keene.

Some of them later lived in luxury.

They had started with nothing more than a desk and a few plain office chairs.

Keene had helped make them rich.

Now he himself was nearly broke.

He had risen from nothing to $13 million.

Now he was almost back where he had started.

A complete record of his generosity could fill an entire book.

But one example stands out.

It involved the famous Sam Ward.

Long before Keene arrived in Wall Street, Sam Ward had become a well-known figure in Washington, New York, and European society.

His marriage to Miss Astor had helped make him prominent.

Over the years, Ward moved from one occupation to another before finally settling in Washington, where he became a lobbyist.

When Keene arrived in New York with his California fortune, Ward quickly became one of his closest companions.

Keene had arrived at an extraordinary moment.

The Panic of 1873 had destroyed fortunes.

By 1878, property values had fallen so far that many owners regarded their property as a burden rather than an asset.

People were desperate to sell simply to escape their mortgages.

Almost everyone felt poor.

And most people really were poor.

Keene arrived when everything was selling at rock-bottom prices.

He immediately became one of the most interesting men in New York.

He was not only rich.

He was also becoming a favorite of high society.

One of his first important acquaintances was Sam Ward.

Ward immediately recognized Keene's social value—and, of course, the value of his fortune.

The richer Keene became, the closer Ward stayed to him.

Soon, people joked that wherever Keene went, Ward was never far behind.

Uptown or downtown, Newport or London, the Derby or the Grand Prix—it made little difference.

If Keene was there, Ward was likely to appear soon afterward.

Keene rewarded this devotion in a very practical way.

He invested $50,000 in high-quality securities for Ward.

The securities were placed with trustees.

Ward would receive an annual income of $3,000 for the rest of his life.

That was only one example of Keene's generosity.

A California writer later described Keene in glowing terms.

He wrote that no history of the great Pacific Coast stock operators would be complete without James R. Keene.

Keene, he said, had been the fearless outsider who had dared to challenge the powerful Bonanza Kings—and had defeated them.

When Keene left California for the East, his friends expected him to return within a year.

They assumed New York would eventually destroy him.

But a few friends thought differently.

They understood his courage.

They understood his instincts.

They believed that California had simply become too small for him.

New York and Wall Street, they said, were exactly the size of market that Keene needed.

They were right.

Keene never returned to California looking for a job.

Instead, he took on the strongest operators in Wall Street and defeated them.

Even Jay Gould eventually gave up trying to beat him.

And Vanderbilt was willing to consult Keene on important matters.

The California writer described Keene's career in the market as a steady climb from the bottom.

He had started as an impulsive street broker working for powerful firms.

Little by little, he had moved upward.

Eventually, he became one of the most influential operators in the market.

He had countless friends.

They were fiercely loyal to him.

He could be blunt and rough in manner, but beneath that exterior was a remarkably generous heart.

If someone asked him for help, even if that person was only an acquaintance, Keene was often ready to open his wallet.

That generosity, more than anything else, made him the ideal figure of the market.

There was another important chapter in Keene's California career that was often overlooked.

After Ralston's death and the collapse of the Bank of California, Keene played a major role in restoring confidence in the institution.

He raised a large subscription among members of the Stock Board.

He persuaded William Sharon, D. O. Mills, and “Lucky” Baldwin to contribute $1 million each.

Keene himself contributed another $1 million.

The money gave the bank enough strength to meet immediate demands.

A new panic was avoided.

At the time of Keene's final collapse, he was also leading a syndicate that had purchased 25 million bushels of wheat.

If the syndicate had held the wheat firmly, it might soon have earned many millions of dollars.

But some of Keene's partners became frightened and sold their positions.

The entire operation collapsed.

The profits disappeared.

So did much of the capital.

Keene blamed the newspapers to a large extent.

They had created a huge public alarm over the wheat corner and warned that the speculation threatened the nation's food supply.

That publicity frightened his partners and helped destroy the operation.

Keene was also forced out of his stock positions.

The bears had carefully planned their campaign against him.

They succeeded.

The bitter irony was that the stocks Keene had been forced to sell rose sharply only a few months later.

Had he been able to hold them, those same stocks would have allowed him to recover his losses and make another $10 million.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!