← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 48 · How America’s Great Fortunes Were Given Away

How America’s Great Fortunes Were Given Away

Chapter 48 of 90 · 3,338 words · Free

I want to take a brief look at some of the richest Americans who built their own fortunes, and at what they chose to do with their money after they had made it.

John Jacob Astor was one of the first Americans to attract public attention because of the size of his fortune. Before his time, there were few, if any, millionaires in America. Now there are thousands.

George Washington was certainly a wealthy man by the standards of his day. He lived comfortably and maintained an aristocratic style of life, but his total fortune probably never exceeded $200,000. Interestingly, none of his successors ever managed to accumulate even that much.

At one point, many people believed that General Grant had become a millionaire. That belief disappeared quickly when he and his family were ruined by Ferdinand Ward, one of the first great financial swindlers to gain national attention.

John Jacob Astor, the founder of the Astor family fortune and the Astor Library, died in 1848 at the age of eighty-five.

Most of his estate went to his son, William B. Astor.

He left $400,000 to the Astor Library and several smaller bequests. Altogether, including the library gift, these amounted to about $500,000.

His fortune was estimated at $20 million when he died, an enormous sum for that time.

William B. Astor died in 1875. He left another $250,000 to the library, while most of the rest of his fortune went to his sons and widow.

The Astor family became known for quietly supporting many public causes.

Their great achievement was not only the size of the fortune, but the fact that they managed to keep it together and steadily increase its value. They were also regarded as fair and popular landlords.

John Jacob Astor had come to America from Waldorf, Germany, near Heidelberg, before he was twenty.

He began his career in the fur business.

At one time, he had a grand plan to dominate the fur trade of the entire world. He calculated that such a monopoly could eventually bring him a million dollars a year.

But real estate proved even more profitable.

He turned his attention to property and made most of his fortune that way. His family continued to follow the same strategy for two generations.

Among native-born Americans, few could match George Peabody for generosity.

He began life as a poor boy in Massachusetts and, through hard work, became one of the richest men of his time.

But Peabody was more than a successful businessman. He was a philanthropist on an extraordinary scale.

His fortune probably exceeded $10 million at its peak.

During his lifetime, he gave away more than $7 million to charitable causes. It is believed that he also gave away enormous sums that were never formally recorded.

Shortly before his death in 1869, he left $2.5 million to establish housing for London's poor.

He also provided $2.1 million for education in the American South.

In addition, he left about $5 million to various relatives.

J. S. Morgan, who had been Peabody's banking partner, succeeded him in business after his death. Morgan eventually became, it was believed, even wealthier than Peabody had ever been.

Johns Hopkins, who died in Baltimore in 1873 at the age of seventy-eight, was one of the strangest of America's wealthy philanthropists.

Few people expected him to leave behind the great university and hospital that now bear his name.

He was extremely frugal—so frugal that he barely spent enough money on himself to live comfortably.

Yet his gifts to the university and hospital eventually amounted to more than $8 million.

Alexander T. Stewart, the great dry-goods merchant, was considered one of the three richest men in America, alongside Commodore Vanderbilt and John Jacob Astor.

He died in 1876.

He had no legitimate children, and his fortune was estimated at between $20 million and $30 million.

Most of it went to his wife.

He also left $1 million to Judge Hilton and $325,000 to his employees.

Stewart's two great philanthropic projects failed.

The main problem was that after his death, nobody was capable of carrying out his plans effectively.

Even if he had lived longer, the projects probably would have struggled. Most people considered them too idealistic and impractical.

The first was Garden City on Long Island.

Stewart wanted it to become a community where hardworking mechanics could live in comfortable homes far better than the ordinary housing available to working people.

A magnificent cathedral was built there in his memory, along with a beautiful crypt for his remains.

But there was a grim twist.

His body was stolen from the churchyard of St. Mark's shortly after his burial.

The workingmen and mechanics Stewart hoped would move to Garden City never came in large numbers.

Instead, the community developed slowly and attracted people from more prosperous professions.

His second major project was a residence for working women and girls at moderate cost.

It took the form of a large hotel at Park Avenue and Thirty-third Street.

But the restrictions were too severe and the prices too high.

The very people Stewart wanted to help were therefore unwilling or unable to live there.

The project eventually fell back into the hands of the Stewart estate.

The trustees took control of the property and converted it into the Park Avenue Hotel.

To carry out the vague conditions of Stewart's will would probably have consumed a huge amount of his fortune.

And even then, the project might still have failed.

If Stewart had lived a few more years, he might eventually have realized for himself that both schemes were impractical.

The public had expected much more from Stewart after his death.

During his lifetime, he had given relatively little to charity.

People therefore assumed that, when he could no longer use his money for himself, he would finally give away a large portion of it.

Instead, his will revealed that almost none of his enormous fortune had been set aside for charity.

This disappointed the public greatly.

On the very day Stewart died, I had an appointment with my dentist, Mr. Dwinell, on Thirty-fourth Street.

While I was sitting in the dentist's chair, the well-known sculptor Wilson MacDonald came in to visit him.

After we were introduced, we naturally began talking about the biggest local news of the day—the death of Stewart and what would happen to his fortune.

MacDonald invited me to his studio to see a clay bust of Stewart that he had nearly completed.

He said, “I knew Mr. Stewart hated having his portrait or photograph taken. So I prepared for that problem in advance.”

“For the past two years, I've watched him whenever I happened to see him. I went into his store and studied him from different angles.”

“I wanted to fix his appearance in my memory.”

“I think I've managed to make a fairly good likeness of him.”

MacDonald particularly wanted my opinion because I had known Stewart well.

He believed I could tell him whether the bust really looked like the man.

I promised to visit his studio as soon as I had time.

When I left the dentist, I made another appointment for the following week.

But before I could visit MacDonald's studio, something happened that made the matter even more interesting.

When I returned to the dentist, MacDonald happened to be there again.

In the meantime, Stewart's will had been published.

And it contained no significant gifts to charities or public institutions.

MacDonald reminded me that I still had not come to see the bust.

Then he said, “If you had come when you promised, you probably wouldn't recognize it now.”

“How did that happen?” I asked.

He smiled.

“As soon as I read Stewart's will in the newspapers and saw that he had left none of that enormous fortune to the public, I went back to work on the bust.”

“I toned down the bumps of benevolence, conscience, spirituality, reverence and idealism.”

“Then I emphasized acquisitiveness, possessiveness, sensuality and all the selfish and animal traits.”

“In other words, if phrenology means anything, I concluded that Stewart's will proved he had very little room in his head for generous feelings.”

“I suppose I shouldn't say it,” he added, “but there certainly wasn't much evidence of charity in that skull.”

Anyone who knew the great dry-goods merchant would probably agree that the sculptor's judgment was neither unfair nor unreasonable.

Stephen Girard

Stephen Girard was another great millionaire who rose from poverty and whose enormous fortune eventually took a strongly philanthropic direction.

Girard was a Frenchman, born near Bordeaux in 1750. Later in life he settled in Philadelphia.

He left more than $2 million to establish and support Girard College.

There is a remarkable story about how he treated a sister who had once treated him cruelly.

When Girard was about ten years old, he showed little interest in hard work.

His family was harsh with him.

One morning, an argument broke out over his laziness.

His sister became furious, grabbed a broom and attacked him.

Girard ran away, taking several hard blows across his back as he crossed the threshold of his childhood home for the last time.

He went to sea, following the profession of his father.

After years of hardship and adventure, he eventually became a millionaire in Philadelphia.

As a young sailor, Girard first worked as a cabin boy on ships trading between France, the West Indies and New York.

He saved enough money to buy a share in a small trading vessel.

That was in 1776, the year America declared its independence.

The war with Britain interrupted his trading business.

Girard then made money by renting several stores in Philadelphia and subletting them at a substantial profit.

In 1812, he bought a controlling interest in the old United States Bank.

He then became a private banker with more than $1 million in capital.

Later, he lent the United States government $5 million to help pay the costs of war.

Meanwhile, the sister who had once beaten him with a broom remained poor.

She had heard that her brother had become extremely wealthy.

But she did not even have enough money to pay for a voyage to America.

Finally, she went to the captain of a Philadelphia ship while it was in a French port.

She told him she was Stephen Girard's sister, that she had no money, and that she wanted to go to America to see her brother.

The captain knew Girard well and gave her the best accommodations his ship could provide.

When they reached Philadelphia, the captain personally escorted her to Girard's mansion.

He left her in the hallway and went inside.

He told Girard that a lady outside wished to see him.

The captain expected an emotional reunion between the brother and sister who had been separated for so many years.

Instead, Girard recognized her immediately.

“C'est vous,” he said.

“It is you.”

“Yes,” she replied.

That was the entire reunion.

There was no embrace.

No tears.

No warm words.

Girard suddenly turned to the captain.

“What right did you have to bring that woman here?” he demanded.

The captain was stunned and did not know how to respond.

“Take her back at your own expense,” Girard ordered.

The captain did not waste a moment.

Girard's sister was taken from his mansion and returned to the ship.

She went back to her poor home in France without receiving even a kind farewell from her wealthy brother.

The story shows that Girard never forgot an injury.

It also reveals a narrow and unforgiving side of his character.

He was capable of extraordinary generosity toward strangers, yet unable to forgive his own sister for something she had done when they were children.

She had failed to understand what her young brother wanted from life.

She had probably believed that hard physical work was the only respectable path for him.

Girard eventually proved that he could become wealthy without following that path.

Still, he was wrong to punish her so harshly.

Her judgment had been narrow, but it was understandable from her point of view.

A man capable of giving away millions should also have been capable of forgiving an old family mistake.

Girard's eccentricity and stubbornness also appeared in the conditions he placed in his will for Girard College.

Although he gave generously to religious organizations of many different kinds and to charitable institutions, Girard himself was a freethinker influenced by the ideas of Voltaire and Rousseau.

He therefore ordered that no clergyman should have anything to do with Girard College.

He even prohibited clergymen from visiting it.

The college was intended for orphan boys between six and ten years old.

They were educated and cared for until they were sixteen, when they were trained in a trade.

The institution paid their expenses until they could support themselves.

There were eventually more than 500 beneficiaries.

Girard died in 1831 at the age of eighty-one.

He left a fortune of about $9 million.

Only a small amount went to relatives.

The great majority went to charitable institutions.

Despite his enormous generosity to society, Girard was extremely tight with money in his dealings with other men.

It was said that he had no real friends.

His only dependable friend was the one in his pocket.

And, according to the saying, that may have been the most reliable friend of all.

James Lenox

James Lenox also deserves a place among America's great philanthropists.

He tried to devote a large part of his wealth to the public good.

When he died in 1880 at the age of eighty, he was believed to be one of the five richest men in New York.

He spent $1 million establishing and supporting the Presbyterian Hospital at Seventieth Street and Madison Avenue.

He also spent more than half a million dollars building the Lenox Library at Seventieth Street and Fifth Avenue.

The building and its collection were enormous gifts.

Unfortunately, access to the library was surrounded by so many rules and formalities that the ordinary public received little practical benefit from it.

As architecture, however, the building was impressive and could perhaps educate the public simply through its beauty.

The collection itself was extraordinary.

The library occupied ten city lots and contained one of the finest collections of books in the world outside the British Museum.

It also contained valuable manuscripts and works of art.

Its collection of American books was unmatched.

Lenox's own private collection alone contained 15,000 volumes.

Many of these books were so rare that replacing them would have been nearly impossible.

That was one reason the library's managers were so reluctant to allow unrestricted public access.

There is, in fact, something to be said for protecting valuable libraries and art collections carefully.

Many members of the public do not know how to treat such treasures.

Some damage them out of ignorance.

Others do it simply for amusement.

William H. Vanderbilt eventually had to close his private art gallery to the general public for precisely this reason.

Some visitors scratched etchings with their walking sticks.

Others touched paintings with their fingers.

Still others were constantly searching for souvenirs and had to be watched closely.

Peter Cooper

Peter Cooper was another wealthy man who believed his fortune should be used to help people, especially those who wanted an education but lacked the opportunity.

Cooper himself had struggled to obtain a proper education.

Because of that experience, he understood its value better than most wealthy men.

He was born in New York in 1791.

At seventeen, he became an apprentice to a coachmaker.

He later tried several different occupations.

He was also a natural inventor.

Among his achievements was the design and construction of the first locomotive built in America.

It was tested on part of the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad.

Cooper made his fortune primarily through the manufacture of glue.

Later, he built large ironworks in Baltimore, Maryland, and then in Trenton, New Jersey.

During his lifetime, he built Cooper Institute at a cost of $650,000.

He later added another $150,000.

The institution was designed to educate and improve the lives of working people.

It contained a large reading room, a library and a public lecture hall.

The building stood near the intersection of Third and Fourth Avenues and Eighth Street.

It offered evening classes attended by about 2,000 students.

There was also a school of design for women with about 200 students.

Another school trained women in telegraphy.

In just two years, that program produced more than 300 telegraph operators.

Income from the shops and offices in the building covered most of the institution's operating expenses.

Cooper also made provisions in his will to ensure that the institution would continue after his death.

During his lifetime, he donated money to almost every kind of charitable organization.

He also supported many labor organizations.

In 1876, he ran for president on the Greenback and Labor ticket.

He was defeated by an overwhelming majority.

Cooper believed that putting large amounts of paper money into circulation would create widespread prosperity and make everyone better off.

He died in 1883 at the age of ninety-two.

He left between $5 million and $6 million.

Most of it went to his son and daughter, who was the wife of Mayor Hewitt.

Samuel J. Tilden

One of America's greatest philanthropists was Samuel J. Tilden.

His generosity was especially surprising because few people expected such a large public gift from him.

I have already discussed his financial and political career elsewhere.

He died in August 1886 at about seventy-three years of age.

At the time of his death, he was worth roughly $5 million.

He left $4 million for public and charitable purposes.

Most of that money was intended to establish and endow a great free library.

If his wishes were properly carried out, it would become the greatest institution of its kind in America.

The Vanderbilt Clinic

The distribution of the Vanderbilt fortune has already been discussed in connection with the various members of that family.

But the medical clinic associated with the College of Physicians deserves special attention.

It had recently opened at Sixtieth Street and Fourth Avenue and might eventually become a major medical center.

Mrs. W. D. Sloane, a daughter of William H. Vanderbilt, contributed $250,000 toward the construction of the Maternity Hospital.

Her father had already provided the rest of the $1 million needed to complete the entire project.

The complex included the Clinic, the Maternity Hospital and the College Hospital.

It was said that the quality of every department and its equipment surpassed anything of a similar kind anywhere in the world.

There were many other wealthy Americans who devoted large fortunes to public causes.

James Lick of California gave millions to charity.

William W. Corcoran of Washington gave $2 million for an art gallery and a home for elderly and disabled women.

Mr. Stevens of Hoboken left $2 million, with one million going to the Stevens Battery and the other to the Stevens Institute.

Catharine Wolf, who died the previous year with a fortune of $12 million, left large sums to charity.

She also gave her magnificent art collection to the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

What a lesson these wealthy philanthropists offer to those who criticize them.

I was going to say they offer a lesson to their fellow citizens, but that would not be quite right in every case.

I especially mean the Socialists.

Many of these millionaires were denounced as heartless monopolists.

Yet they had spent their entire lives working, planning and thinking.

Many denied themselves luxuries.

Some even denied themselves ordinary comforts.

And for what?

They accumulated wealth that eventually became a source of relief and comfort for the poor, the unfortunate, the idle, the careless, and those who had fallen into difficult circumstances.

In many cases, the very people who benefited from their wealth had previously misunderstood or condemned them.

Fortunately for these benefactors, virtue can be its own reward.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!