← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 49 · Southern Speculation and the Fight to Rebuild the South

Southern Speculation and the Fight to Rebuild the South

Chapter 49 of 90 · 2,648 words · Free

During the Civil War, I did everything within my limited power to support the Union. I believed the cause was just. The North was fighting to preserve the best form of government the world had yet produced, and, in my judgment, the only system truly suited to America.

No matter how we look at it, human wisdom has created nothing better than the Constitution of the United States. I will not stop to argue whether Thomas Jefferson or Thomas Paine deserves credit for its main ideas. The important fact is that the Constitution created the greatest government in the world.

What other political system could bring together so many different nationalities, religions, passions, and prejudices, and gradually turn them into one nation working toward a common good?

There is no real example to compare with it in ancient or modern history. To find anything similar, we would have to turn to the ideal political worlds imagined by writers such as Thomas More or Plato.

We were still far from their vision of a perfect society, of course. But America was moving in that direction. Each generation brought us closer to the possibility of a freer and more harmonious society.

Even the ordinary ward politician, with all his faults, was part of that process.

He still had a long way to go before reaching the heights of political wisdom.

But once he started climbing, I believed he would move forward rapidly and steadily. His progress would eventually leave behind even the ambitious young man in Longfellow's poem whose motto was "Excelsior."

Revolutions, people say, never move backward.

The same is even more true of political progress in a republic. Once a nation begins developing toward a higher ideal, it does not easily turn back. It continues pushing forward and upward.

A great many people who come to America do so because they want to escape governments that are oppressive and despotic.

They are rescued from systems that would otherwise waste their lives.

Here they not only contribute to the nation's wealth, but also become useful members of society. They raise families, and their children grow up learning to respect and appreciate the institutions of their adopted country.

America has therefore become a refuge for the oppressed of every nation.

The contrast between America and the countries these immigrants left behind also teaches our own people to appreciate the freedoms they were born into.

Without the constant arrival of immigrants, Americans might begin to think that republican government was simply their natural birthright.

They might forget how fortunate they were to have been born here.

Some Americans, especially some young women, even seemed to believe that our country suffered because we had no hereditary nobility.

A few had already learned, through painful personal experience, how foolish that idea could be.

Foreign titles sometimes looked glamorous from a distance.

Up close, they could bring disappointment, misery, and even disgrace.

I could give many examples from New York, but the sensational newspapers have already told those stories often enough.

I am not trying to write a sensational book. I only want to make the lesson clear and leave the dramatic details to those who make their living telling such stories.

Nor do I intend to criticize happy marriages such as that of Miss Jerome to Lord Randolph Churchill, or others of a similar kind.

America's enormous territory gave ambitious people from every part of the world a chance to build new lives here instead of remaining in countries where many were living under conditions that were little better than slavery, even if they went by different names.

The steady flow of immigrants into America, and their freedom to become part of our society, has been one of the great foundations of our prosperity.

I understood this clearly when the Civil War began, and I have held the same belief ever since.

That was one reason I felt so strongly about the Union cause.

The South was trying to break apart the government and destroy the national unity that held the country together.

If Horace Greeley's advice had been followed—"Let them secesh"—the nation would have committed national suicide.

Greeley meant well. He apparently believed that the Southern states would eventually regret leaving and voluntarily return to the Union.

But allowing secession would have created a permanently divided America.

The two countries would have lived under constant suspicion of each other, maintaining armies along their borders and fighting whenever some new dispute arose.

European powers would then have had an opportunity to interfere.

They could have used our weakness to bring imperial and monarchical power back onto American soil.

Napoleon III had already shown signs of such ambitions, as I have explained elsewhere.

Great Britain, too, would have been waiting for an opportunity to avenge the defeats it had suffered at Bunker Hill, Saratoga, and Yorktown.

In truth, every European power would have seen an opportunity to seize part of this enormous and valuable country.

A divided America would have been too weak to offer serious resistance to foreign aggression.

And even after Confederate independence, internal fighting would probably have continued.

Political factions would have battled one another, and new movements for independence would likely have created still more separate governments.

Napoleon understood this possibility when he decided to establish Maximilian as emperor of Mexico.

Mexico could serve as a back door through which France might eventually gain access to the United States when the right opportunity appeared.

I was born in Europe and spent my childhood there, so I had personally seen something of the harshness of European political systems.

Fortunately, my own circumstances protected me from their worst effects.

But I saw enough to leave a lasting impression on me.

It awakened my sympathy for people living under oppressive governments and created in me a permanent hatred of dynastic rule.

During the darkest days of the Civil War, therefore, I never hesitated to speak openly in support of the Union.

I did everything I could to help raise the money needed to carry on the war.

I devoted myself especially to selling government securities to provide the financial resources necessary for the Union.

I believe I may have helped the cause more in that way than I could have by standing on a battlefield under fire.

I made my position unmistakably clear.

I organized meetings to celebrate every important Union victory. These gatherings encouraged soldiers in the field, inspired new recruits, and gave businessmen confidence that the nation would ultimately prevail.

It required more courage than people today may realize to take such a position at that time.

New York was deeply divided over the likely outcome of the war, and for a period there was a powerful sympathy for the Southern cause.

Many people suspected of disloyalty were actually doing nothing more than keeping their opinions private because they were uncertain who would win.

I took a different position.

I believed that citizenship would mean very little if the Union were destroyed.

But once the war ended in victory and the government had been firmly preserved, I believed it was time to bury the past.

The South had to be brought back under the old flag.

I also believed that we should extend friendship to the Southern people.

Whatever their mistakes had been, they had already paid a terrible price.

Nothing good could come from continuing to crush a defeated enemy.

The Southern people were not foreign enemies. They were our own brothers who had gone badly wrong, and they could still be brought back into the national family.

I therefore believed that they should once again share in the country's friendship and prosperity.

Because my loyalty to the Union had never been in doubt during the crisis, I felt free to take an active role in reconciliation.

I did not merely offer friendship to Southern men.

I helped them whenever they came to New York.

My office, which during the war had been a headquarters for loyal Northerners and for almost every project supporting the Union, soon became a well-known meeting place for Southern generals and other Southerners.

General Beauregard was one of the leading Confederate commanders to whom I offered hospitality when he first came to New York.

I did everything I could to make his visit pleasant and showed him around the city.

I remember taking him with me to the Gold Room, which was then one of the most important institutions on Wall Street.

Gold was selling at about a 50 percent premium at the time.

As soon as we entered, word spread through the room that my distinguished guest was General Beauregard.

The president of the Board was openly hostile toward everything Southern.

On this occasion, he did not even have the good sense or ordinary courtesy to hide his feelings.

Several others reacted in the same way.

For a moment, the atmosphere became almost as hostile as if the war were still being fought.

I found their behavior deeply offensive.

I was a member of the Exchange, and I believed I had every right to bring my guest there.

I regarded the insult to Beauregard as an insult to me.

I was prepared to defend him.

He was my guest, and I intended to stand beside him as long as he wished to remain in the room.

I told the men who were most hostile that I would protect my friend regardless of what they tried to do.

That warning helped calm the situation.

Eventually, we were allowed to leave peacefully.

I then took General Beauregard to the New York Stock Exchange.

There he received an entirely different welcome.

The members treated him courteously and without any display of hostility.

I introduced him to many of them personally.

They shook his hand, exchanged friendly words, and welcomed him warmly to New York.

Beauregard was delighted by the reception at the Stock Exchange.

But he was deeply disappointed by the treatment he had received at the Gold Room.

After that, other prominent Southerners came to Wall Street from time to time and received the same hospitality from me.

Among them was General Forrest, whose name was associated with the massacre at Fort Pillow.

I could tell many other stories showing how seriously I worked for reconciliation and reconstruction.

I wanted the South to recover from the terrible destruction of the war as quickly as possible.

As reconstruction moved forward, I became increasingly interested in developing the South's internal improvements.

My later investments there demonstrate how seriously I took this belief.

I thought the South had suffered enough.

The North had suffered enough as well.

I hoped the Southern people would accept the terms that General Grant and General Lee had essentially agreed upon under the apple tree at Appomattox.

I wanted the peace to protect the interests of everyone in the country—from the most powerful Confederate general to the poorest Black citizen.

I hoped everyone would return to productive work.

They could farm, build businesses, develop industries, or do anything else that would increase the country's wealth and improve their own lives.

The war had destroyed enormous amounts of property.

The only sensible course was to rebuild.

The South actually had greater opportunities for rapid economic growth after the war than most people realized.

If those opportunities had been handled wisely, the South might have overtaken the North in the race for wealth.

Its great products—cotton, tobacco, and rice—were all worth gold in the world's markets.

The South therefore had a tremendous advantage.

It could begin producing again at low, realistic costs while selling its products in markets where prices were measured in gold.

The North, by contrast, was operating with an inflated currency and inflated wartime prices.

The enormous amount of paper money issued during the war had encouraged speculation and pushed business far above normal levels.

To me, the situation was clear.

The South had an opportunity to build its economy on a solid foundation from the beginning.

The North, meanwhile, had built much of its business structure on inflated wartime conditions.

Eventually, that inflation would have to collapse before the Northern economy could return to a healthy foundation.

The South could have used that opportunity to grow while the North was adjusting.

For my own investments, I therefore chose the two Southern states that seemed to have the strongest financial reputations, the greatest integrity and enterprise, and the brightest prospects: Georgia and Alabama.

Those states welcomed my money.

They issued state securities and county securities.

They sold me their bonds.

They encouraged me to invest heavily.

Then they repaid my confidence with what I regarded as the worst kind of ingratitude.

They repudiated their bonds and cheated me out of my money and property in every way they could.

I believe the responsibility for much of this injustice ultimately belonged to Andrew Johnson.

Because Abraham Lincoln was assassinated, Johnson unexpectedly became President of the United States.

Johnson was a Tennessee man.

During the war, he had appeared loyal to the Union and, under ordinary circumstances, I believe he might have remained so.

But Lincoln's assassination suddenly placed him in the highest office in the nation.

He had enough ability to hold the office.

But his temperament and political prejudices made him unfit to handle the position in the best interests of the country.

My own position was simple.

The war was over.

The war should be forgotten as quickly as possible.

But President Johnson helped delay that final reconciliation by encouraging hostility among the Southern people.

Congress, by contrast, was generally willing to be lenient.

Congressional leaders passed measures and framed laws intended to bring the former Confederate states back into the Union.

They worked cautiously to heal the old wounds between the victorious North and the defeated South.

But when those measures reached President Johnson, he vetoed them again and again.

His vetoes created a constant conflict between Congress and the President.

The deeper that conflict became, the stronger and more bitter the political hostility became in the South.

The Southern people were badly misled by the President they trusted.

Johnson encouraged them to believe that his vetoes were only temporary obstacles and that Congress would eventually be forced to give them better terms.

They trusted him.

They were deceived.

The resulting anger worked deeply on the Southern mind.

The South became increasingly bitter and resentful.

From the North, it sometimes appeared that our Southern brothers had become even less willing to reconcile than they had been during the worst days of the war.

This bitterness had serious financial consequences.

Bonds issued by Southern states to raise money from Northern investors were repudiated on a large scale.

Once the Southern states discovered that much of their outstanding debt was held by Northerners, revenge and greed came together.

Repudiation became a weapon.

Almost every possible method of striking back at the North was used.

Whenever an opportunity offered a political, financial, or moral advantage, it was seized.

Instead of following General Lee's example and accepting the outcome of the war, many Southern leaders were led astray by politicians who had their own interests to serve.

They spent their energy fighting political battles instead of rebuilding the economy.

They argued over politics while farms, businesses, transportation systems, and industries needed attention.

Years were wasted in political turmoil.

The South became poorer and more deeply troubled.

Many people suffered financially as a result.

Few suffered more than I did.

I had invested more than $2.5 million in Georgia securities and had at least another $1 million invested in Alabama and North Carolina through various channels.

In the end, all of it was wiped out.

I attributed this enormous loss to the bitter political spirit that President Andrew Johnson had helped create and encourage.

And I had still more to say about Johnson in another chapter.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!