How My Reputation as a Scientist Took Off
In 1746, while I was in Boston, I met Dr. Spence, a man who had recently arrived from Scotland. He showed me a few experiments with electricity.
The experiments were not performed very well, because he was still inexperienced. But electricity was completely new to me, and I was fascinated.
After I returned to Philadelphia, our library received a glass tube from Mr. Peter Collinson, a Fellow of the Royal Society in London. He also sent instructions explaining how the tube could be used for electrical experiments.
I immediately began repeating the experiments I had seen in Boston.
With constant practice, I became quite skilled at performing them. I also tried the experiments described in the reports we received from England and developed several new ones of my own.
I say “constant practice” because, for a while, my house was almost always crowded with people who wanted to see these strange new experiments.
To spread the work among my friends, I had several similar glass tubes made at our local glassworks.
My friends began experimenting with them, and before long we had several people who could perform the experiments themselves.
The most talented among them was my neighbor, Mr. Kinnersley.
He had no regular business at the time, so I encouraged him to make a living by demonstrating the experiments for paying audiences.
I also prepared two lectures for him.
I arranged the experiments in a clear order, so that each one would help the audience understand the next. I also wrote explanations to go along with them.
Kinnersley bought an elegant set of equipment for his demonstrations. The instrument makers carefully rebuilt all the little devices I had made roughly for my own experiments.
His lectures became very popular.
People attended in large numbers and were delighted by what they saw.
After some time, Kinnersley traveled through the colonies, giving demonstrations in the capital towns and earning a good amount of money.
When he reached the West Indies, however, the experiments were much harder to perform because the air there was generally too damp.
I felt that Mr. Collinson deserved to know how successful we had been with the glass tube he had sent us.
So I wrote him several letters describing our experiments and what we had discovered.
He had the letters read before the Royal Society in London.
At first, however, the members did not think they were important enough to publish in the Society's Transactions.
I also wrote a paper for Mr. Kinnersley arguing that lightning and electricity were actually the same kind of phenomenon.
I sent it to Dr. Mitchel, an acquaintance of mine who was also a member of the Royal Society.
He wrote back and told me that the paper had been read at the Society.
But the experts had laughed at it.
Fortunately, the papers were later shown to Dr. Fothergill.
He believed they were too valuable to be ignored and recommended that they be published.
Mr. Collinson then gave them to Cave, the publisher of the Gentleman's Magazine.
Instead of printing them in the magazine, Cave decided to publish them as a separate pamphlet.
Dr. Fothergill wrote the preface.
Cave seems to have made the right decision for his own business, because more material arrived later and the pamphlet eventually grew into a large quarto book.
It went through five editions, and Cave never had to pay me for the rights to the material.
Even so, it took some time before my work attracted much attention in England.
Then a copy of my writings happened to fall into the hands of the Count de Buffon, a highly respected philosopher in France and throughout Europe.
He persuaded M. Dalibard to translate my work into French.
The translation was published in Paris.
This greatly angered the Abbé Nollet, who was the royal family's teacher of natural philosophy and a very capable experimenter.
Nollet had developed and published his own theory of electricity, and his ideas were widely accepted at the time.
At first, he could not believe that such a book had actually come from America.
He thought my work must have been created by his enemies in Paris to attack his theory.
Later, after he was convinced that a man named Franklin really did exist in Philadelphia, he wrote a whole book of letters, most of them addressed to me.
In those letters, he defended his own theory and claimed that my experiments were false, along with the conclusions I had drawn from them.
At first, I planned to answer him.
I even began writing a reply.
But then I thought better of it.
My writings described experiments that anyone could repeat and test for themselves.
If those experiments were true, other people could verify them.
If they could not be verified, then there was no good way for me to defend them.
Some of my other statements were only suggestions or guesses based on what I had observed. I had never presented them as unquestionable facts.
So I did not feel obligated to defend every one of them in an argument.
There was another problem.
Nollet and I were writing in different languages.
A disagreement between two people using different languages could continue for a very long time because of mistranslations and misunderstandings.
In fact, much of one of Nollet's letters was based on a mistake in the translation of my words.
I finally decided it was better to leave my writings to prove themselves.
Whatever free time I had outside my public duties would be better spent conducting new experiments than arguing about experiments I had already performed.
So I never answered Nollet.
As it turned out, I had no reason to regret that decision.
My friend M. le Roy, a member of the Royal Academy of Sciences, defended my work and answered Nollet's arguments for me.
My book was translated into Italian, German, and Latin.
Little by little, the philosophers of Europe accepted the ideas in my book and preferred them to Nollet's theory.
Nollet eventually lived long enough to see himself become the last important supporter of his own school of thought, apart from Monsieur B—— of Paris, his student and closest disciple.
What made my book famous so quickly was the success of one of the experiments I had proposed.
Messrs. Dalibard and De Lor performed the experiment at Marly, using it to draw electricity from the clouds during a storm.
The result immediately attracted attention everywhere.
M. de Lor owned equipment for demonstrating experimental philosophy and regularly gave lectures on the subject.
He decided to repeat what he called the “Philadelphia Experiments.”
After he successfully performed them before the king and the royal court, curious people from all over Paris came to see them.
I will not fill this account with the details of that famous experiment, since they can be found in histories of electricity.
Nor will I describe at length the enormous pleasure I felt when I successfully performed a similar experiment myself in Philadelphia using a kite.
Those events have already been recorded in the histories of electricity.
While Dr. Wright, an English physician, was in Paris, he wrote to a friend who was a member of the Royal Society.
He told him how highly European scholars regarded my experiments.
He also expressed their surprise that my work had received so little attention in England.
This news caused the Royal Society to reconsider the letters I had previously sent them.
The famous Dr. Watson prepared a summary of those letters, along with all the other material I had later sent to England about electricity.
He also included some complimentary remarks about me.
The summary was then published in the Society's Transactions.
Several members of the Society in London, especially the very talented Mr. Canton, then repeated my experiment of drawing electricity from clouds with a pointed metal rod.
They succeeded.
Once the Society learned that the experiment worked, they more than made up for the way they had previously treated my work.
I had never asked for any special recognition.
Yet they elected me as a member of the Royal Society.
They also decided to excuse me from the usual membership fees, which would have cost me twenty-five guineas.
From then on, they sent me their Transactions free of charge.
In addition, they awarded me the Sir Godfrey Copley Gold Medal for 1753.
When the medal was presented, the president, Lord Macclesfield, gave a very gracious speech in which he spoke of me with great honor.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!