The Governor’s Promises and the Long Road to England
Captain Denny, our new governor, brought me the medal from the Royal Society that I had mentioned earlier. He presented it to me at a dinner the city held in his honor.
He spoke warmly of his respect for me and said he had known of my character for a long time.
Later, after dinner, when everyone else was drinking as was customary in those days, he quietly took me into another room.
“Mr. Franklin,” he said, “my friends in England have advised me to become your close friend. They tell me that you are the man most capable of giving me good advice and helping me make my administration run smoothly.”
“I want us to have a good understanding,” he continued. “You can depend on me to do anything within my power to serve you.”
He also spoke at length about the proprietor's good intentions toward Pennsylvania.
“It would benefit everyone,” he said, “especially you, if the long dispute between the proprietor and the people could finally end. I am told that no one could do more than you to bring about such a reconciliation. And you may be sure that your services would be properly recognized and rewarded.”
The other guests noticed that we had not returned to the table and sent us a bottle of Madeira.
The governor drank freely, and as he did, his promises and requests became even more generous.
I answered him plainly.
“Thank God, my circumstances are such that I have no need of favors from the proprietors. And as a member of the Assembly, I could not accept such favors anyway.”
“But I have no personal hostility toward the proprietor,” I continued. “Whenever his proposed measures truly serve the interests of the people, no one will support them more strongly than I will.”
“My opposition in the past was based on one thing only. The measures he wanted us to accept were clearly designed to protect his own interests while harming those of the people.”
“I am grateful for your kind words about me, Governor. You may also depend on me to do everything I can to make your administration as easy as possible.”
“I only hope you have not brought with you the same unfortunate instructions that made your predecessor's position so difficult.”
The governor did not explain himself at the time.
But when he later began doing business with the Assembly, those same instructions appeared again. The old disputes immediately returned, and I became as active as ever in opposing them.
I wrote the Assembly's request for a copy of the governor's instructions, and afterward I wrote the Assembly's remarks on those instructions. Both can be found in the records of the time and in the Historical Review I later published.
Yet none of this created any personal hostility between the governor and me.
We continued to meet often.
He was an educated man who had traveled widely, and he was an entertaining and pleasant conversationalist.
He was also the first person to tell me that my old friend James Ralph was still alive.
“Ralph is now considered one of the best political writers in England,” he told me. “He was involved in the dispute between Prince Frederick and the king, and he has received a pension of three hundred pounds a year.”
“As a poet, however, his reputation is not nearly so good. Pope ridiculed his poetry in the Dunciad. But his prose is considered as good as anyone's.”
The Assembly eventually realized that the proprietors were determined to keep their representatives bound by instructions that violated not only the rights of the people but also the interests of the Crown.
The Assembly therefore decided to petition the king against those instructions.
They appointed me as their agent and asked me to travel to England to present and defend the petition.
At the same time, the Assembly had passed a bill granting £60,000 for the king's use. Ten thousand pounds of that amount was to be placed under the control of General Loudoun.
Governor Denny absolutely refused to approve the bill because his instructions from the proprietors forbade him to do so.
I had already arranged my passage with Captain Morris, who commanded the packet ship at New York, and my supplies had been loaded aboard.
Then Lord Loudoun arrived in Philadelphia.
He told me that he had come specifically to try to settle the dispute between the governor and the Assembly so that the king's business would not be delayed by their disagreement.
He asked the governor and me to meet with him so that he could hear both sides.
We met and discussed the matter.
I presented all the arguments supporting the Assembly. They were the same arguments I had written in the public papers and in the Assembly's records.
The governor defended himself by pointing to his instructions.
“I am bound by these instructions,” he said. “I have even given a bond promising to obey them. If I violate them, I could be ruined.”
Still, he seemed willing to take the risk if Lord Loudoun would advise him to do so.
I thought for a moment that I had almost persuaded Lord Loudoun to give him that advice.
But he would not.
Instead, he urged the Assembly to give way.
He appealed to me personally.
“Use your influence with the Assembly,” he said. “I will not spare the king's troops when they are needed to defend your frontier. But if you do not continue to provide for your own defense, your people will remain exposed to the enemy.”
I reported everything to the Assembly.
I also gave them a set of resolutions I had prepared.
They stated clearly that we still claimed our rights and did not give them up. We were merely suspending the exercise of those rights on this particular occasion because of the pressure being placed upon us, and we formally protested against that pressure.
In the end, the Assembly agreed to abandon the original bill and prepare another that followed the proprietor's instructions.
Governor Denny approved the new bill.
I was finally free to begin my journey.
Unfortunately, by then the packet ship had already sailed with my supplies.
That caused me a considerable personal loss.
My only compensation was Lord Loudoun's thanks for my service, while he received almost all the credit for settling the dispute.
Lord Loudoun left for New York before me.
Since he controlled the departure of the packet ships, and two of them were still there, I asked him exactly when one would sail so that I would not miss it.
“I have announced that she will sail next Saturday,” he told me.
“But between ourselves, I can tell you that if you arrive by Monday morning, you will still be in time.”
“Just do not wait any longer than that.”
Because of an unexpected delay at a ferry, I did not reach New York until Monday noon.
I was afraid the ship had already sailed, especially since the wind was favorable.
But I soon learned that she was still in the harbor.
“She will not leave until tomorrow,” I was told.
I thought I was now certain to sail for Europe.
But I had not yet learned enough about Lord Loudoun's character.
Indecision was one of his strongest qualities.
I will give a few examples.
I arrived in New York around the beginning of April.
It was nearly the end of June before we finally sailed.
Two packet ships had already been sitting in the harbor for a long time, waiting for the general's letters.
Every day those letters were expected to be ready “tomorrow.”
Then another packet arrived.
That ship was detained too.
Before we finally sailed, a fourth packet was expected.
Our ship was sent first only because it had been waiting the longest.
All of the ships were full of passengers.
Some were extremely eager to leave.
Merchants were becoming increasingly anxious about their letters and about insurance orders they had placed for their fall goods, especially because we were at war.
But none of their concerns mattered.
Lord Loudoun's letters were not ready.
And yet anyone who went to see him always found him sitting at his desk with a pen in his hand.
Naturally, everyone assumed he must be writing an enormous amount.
One morning I went to pay my respects to him.
In the antechamber I found a messenger named Innis from Philadelphia.
He had come by express order carrying a packet from Governor Denny for the general.
He gave me several letters from my friends in Philadelphia.
I asked him when he planned to return and where he was staying, because I wanted to send some letters back with him.
“I have been ordered to return tomorrow morning at nine to collect the general's answer to the governor,” he said. “As soon as I receive it, I am to leave.”
I handed him my letters that same day.
Two weeks later, I happened to meet him again in the same place.
“So, Innis, you have returned already?”
“Returned? No, sir. I haven't even left yet.”
“How can that be?”
“I have been coming here every morning for two weeks, exactly as I was ordered, waiting for his lordship's letter. It still isn't ready.”
“That is hard to believe. The general is such a great writer. I see him constantly sitting at his desk.”
“Yes,” Innis replied, “but he is like St. George on the signs. He is always on horseback, but he never goes anywhere.”
The messenger's joke was remarkably accurate.
Later, when I was in England, I learned that Mr. Pitt had given Lord Loudoun's removal as one reason for replacing him with Generals Amherst and Wolfe.
The minister had heard almost nothing from Loudoun and could not even tell what he was doing.
As we continued waiting day after day, all three packet ships eventually sailed down to Sandy Hook to join the fleet.
The passengers thought it safest to go aboard their ships and wait there.
They were afraid that if the general suddenly gave an order to sail, the ships might leave without them.
If I remember correctly, we remained there for about six weeks.
During that time, we used up our supplies and had to purchase more.
At last the fleet sailed.
The general and his entire army were aboard, heading for Louisburg with the intention of besieging and capturing the fortress.
The packet ships were ordered to accompany the general's ship so they could receive his dispatches whenever they were ready.
We sailed with the fleet for five days before finally receiving a letter giving us permission to leave.
Our ship then separated from the fleet and headed for England.
The other two packet ships were still detained.
Lord Loudoun took them with him to Halifax.
He stayed there for some time, drilling his soldiers by staging mock attacks against imaginary forts.
Then he changed his mind about attacking Louisburg.
He returned to New York with his entire army—and with the two packet ships and all their passengers.
While he was away, the French and their Native American allies captured Fort George on the frontier.
After the fort surrendered, the Native Americans massacred many of the soldiers who had been defending it.
Later, in London, I met Captain Bonnell, who had commanded one of the detained packet ships.
He told me that after his ship had been held for a month, he informed Lord Loudoun that the ship's bottom had become badly fouled.
She could no longer sail as quickly as a packet ship needed to sail.
He asked permission to clean the bottom.
“How long will that take?” the general asked.
“Three days,” Bonnell replied.
“If you can do it in one day, I will give you permission,” the general said. “Otherwise, no. You must certainly sail the day after tomorrow.”
Bonnell never received permission.
Instead, the ship remained detained day after day for another three full months.
I also met one of Bonnell's passengers in London.
He was furious with Lord Loudoun for keeping him in New York for so long, then taking him all the way to Halifax, and finally bringing him back to New York.
He swore that he would sue the general for damages.
I never learned whether he actually did so.
But according to his account, the damage to his business had been enormous.
The whole experience made me wonder how such a man had ever been trusted with command of a great army.
But after seeing more of the world and learning how government positions are sometimes obtained—and why they are sometimes given away—I became less surprised.
General Shirley had taken command of the army after Braddock's death.
In my opinion, if Shirley had remained in command, he would have conducted a much better campaign than Lord Loudoun's disastrous campaign of 1757.
Loudoun's campaign was pointless, enormously expensive, and deeply humiliating to Britain.
Shirley was not a trained soldier either.
But he was intelligent and practical.
He listened carefully to good advice.
He could develop sensible plans and, more importantly, act quickly to carry them out.
Loudoun, by contrast, had a large army but failed to use it to defend the colonies.
Instead, he sat idle at Halifax while our frontier remained exposed.
That was how Fort George was lost.
He also badly disrupted our merchants and damaged trade by placing a long embargo on the export of food.
He claimed that the purpose was to prevent the enemy from obtaining supplies.
But many people suspected that his real purpose was to force prices down for the contractors supplying the army, perhaps even because he had some financial interest in their profits.
When the embargo was finally lifted, the order was not properly sent to Charlestown.
As a result, the Carolina fleet remained trapped for nearly three additional months.
The shipworms damaged their hulls so badly that many of the ships sank while returning home.
I believe General Shirley was genuinely relieved when he was removed from the burden of commanding an army.
I had been present at the dinner given by New York City to Lord Loudoun when he took command.
Shirley was there too, even though Loudoun had replaced him.
There were officers, citizens, and visitors from many places.
Some chairs had been borrowed from nearby houses.
One of them was unusually low, and it happened to be Shirley's chair.
As I sat beside him, I noticed it.
“They have given you too low a seat, sir,” I said.
“No matter, Mr. Franklin,” he replied. “I find a low seat the most comfortable.”
While I was still detained in New York, I finally received all the accounts for the supplies I had provided to General Braddock.
Some of these accounts had taken a long time to obtain because I had employed different people to help with the business.
I presented everything to Lord Loudoun and asked him to pay me the balance that was owed.
He had the accounts examined by the proper officer.
The officer carefully checked every item against its supporting document and certified that everything was correct.
Lord Loudoun then promised to give me an order on the army paymaster for the amount due.
But he kept delaying it.
Every time I went to see him, he put me off again.
Finally, just before I left, he told me that he had reconsidered the matter.
“I have decided not to mix your accounts with those of my predecessors,” he said.
“When you reach England, simply present your accounts to the Treasury. They will pay you immediately.”
I explained that I had already suffered great and unexpected expenses because I had been detained in New York for so long.
I asked to be paid immediately.
I also pointed out that it was unfair to make me suffer further trouble and delay when I had never charged a commission for the service I had provided.
“Oh, sir,” he replied, “you must not expect us to believe that you made nothing from this.”
“We understand these matters better than that. Everyone who supplies an army finds some way to put money into his own pocket.”
“I assure you, that was not the case with me,” I said. “I did not keep a single penny.”
He clearly did not believe me.
And, indeed, I later learned that people could make enormous fortunes by supplying armies.
As for the money still owed to me, I have never received it.
I will have more to say about that later.
Before we sailed, our captain had boasted proudly about how fast his ship was.
Unfortunately, once we reached the open sea, she turned out to be the slowest of the ninety-six ships in the fleet.
The captain was deeply embarrassed.
After considering several possible causes, we eventually found ourselves sailing near another ship that was almost as slow as ours.
Yet even that ship was gradually pulling ahead of us.
The captain finally ordered everyone to move toward the stern.
Passengers included, there were about forty of us.
We all stood as close to the flagstaff as possible.
As soon as we did, the ship began to move faster.
Within a short time, we had left the other ship far behind.
The captain's suspicion was correct.
Our ship was carrying too much weight toward the front.
All the water casks had been stored in the bow.
He ordered them moved farther back.
Once that was done, the ship regained her reputation and proved to be the fastest ship in the fleet.
The captain claimed that she had once reached thirteen knots.
That means thirteen miles an hour.
One of our passengers was Captain Kennedy of the Navy.
He strongly disagreed.
“That is impossible,” he said. “No ship has ever sailed that fast. There must have been a mistake in measuring the log-line, or an error when the log was thrown.”
The two captains made a bet.
They agreed to settle it the next time there was enough wind.
Kennedy carefully examined the log-line and found no problem with it.
Then he decided to throw the log himself.
A few days later, the wind became strong and favorable.
Captain Lutwidge, our packet captain, said he believed the ship was then making thirteen knots.
Kennedy performed the test himself.
Afterward, he admitted that he had lost the bet.
This experience led me to think about a larger problem in shipbuilding.
People have long observed that you cannot know whether a newly built ship will be fast until you actually put her to sea.
Sometimes a new ship is built according to the exact model of a ship known to sail extremely well, yet the new ship turns out to be remarkably slow.
I believe this may partly result from sailors having different ideas about how a ship should be loaded, rigged, and sailed.
Every captain has his own system.
The same ship may sail much better or worse depending on which captain loads and sails her.
There is another problem as well.
The person who builds a ship is rarely the same person who rigs her.
And the person who rigs her is rarely the one who loads and sails her.
One man builds the hull.
Another puts up the rigging.
A third decides how to load and sail her.
None of them has the benefit of knowing everything the others know.
They therefore cannot make the best judgment by combining all their experience.
Even while a ship is actually at sea, I have often noticed different officers making different decisions while commanding successive watches.
The wind may remain exactly the same, yet one officer will trim the sails more tightly while another will loosen them.
It often seems as if there is no reliable rule.
I believe this could be improved through careful experimentation.
First, we could determine the best shape for a ship's hull.
Then we could determine the best size and position for the masts.
After that, we could study the best shape, size, and arrangement of the sails under different winds.
Finally, we could determine the best way to distribute the cargo.
This is an age of experiments.
I believe that a carefully organized series of experiments, with all the results combined, could be extremely useful.
I am confident that before long some clever philosopher will take up the subject.
I hope he succeeds.
During our voyage, we were chased several times.
But we sailed faster than everything that pursued us.
After thirty days at sea, we reached soundings.
We took a good observation, and the captain believed we were very close to Falmouth.
If we made good progress during the night, we might reach the mouth of the harbor by morning.
By sailing at night, we also hoped to avoid the enemy privateers that often cruised near the entrance to the Channel.
We therefore set every sail we could.
The wind was strong and favorable, and we ran directly before it at great speed.
After taking his observation, the captain set our course, believing we would pass safely to the west of the Scilly Isles.
But there is sometimes a powerful current that draws ships into St. George's Channel.
This current has been known to deceive sailors and was probably responsible for the destruction of Sir Cloudesley Shovel's squadron.
I believe it caused our trouble as well.
We had placed a lookout in the bow.
The officers repeatedly called to him.
“Keep a sharp lookout ahead!”
“Aye, aye!” he answered each time.
But he may have been half asleep with his eyes closed.
Perhaps he answered automatically.
He failed to see a light directly ahead of us.
The sails blocked the light from the man at the wheel and from the rest of the watch.
Then the ship suddenly yawed to one side, revealing it.
A terrible alarm spread across the ship.
The light looked enormous to me, almost as large as a wagon wheel.
It was midnight, and our captain was fast asleep.
Captain Kennedy immediately rushed onto the deck.
He saw the danger and ordered the ship to turn around with all sails still set.
It was a dangerous maneuver that could easily have damaged the masts.
But it carried us safely past the danger.
We had been sailing directly toward the rocks on which the lighthouse stood.
We had escaped shipwreck by the narrowest possible margin.
That experience made me appreciate the value of lighthouses more than ever.
I resolved that if I ever returned safely to America, I would do what I could to encourage the building of more lighthouses there.
By morning, our soundings showed that we were very close to our destination.
But a thick fog covered the land.
Around nine o'clock, the fog began to rise.
It seemed to lift from the water like the curtain of a theater.
Suddenly, underneath it, we could see the town of Falmouth, the ships in the harbor, and the surrounding fields.
It was a beautiful sight.
We had spent so long seeing nothing but the empty ocean that the sight of land filled us with extraordinary pleasure.
It was even more welcome because we were finally free from the dangers and fears caused by the war.
I immediately set out for London with my son.
We stopped briefly along the way to see Stonehenge on Salisbury Plain.
We also visited Lord Pembroke's house and gardens at Wilton, where we saw his remarkable collection of antiquities.
We reached London on July 27, 1757.
As soon as I had settled into the lodging Mr. Charles had arranged for me, I went to see Dr. Fothergill.
He had strongly recommended me and had been advising me about how I should proceed.
He did not think I should immediately complain to the government.
Instead, he believed I should first approach the proprietors themselves.
Perhaps, he thought, some private friends could persuade them to settle the dispute peacefully.
I then visited my old friend and correspondent, Mr. Peter Collinson.
He told me that John Hanbury, the great Virginia merchant, had asked to be informed as soon as I arrived.
“He wants to take you to Lord Granville,” Collinson said. “Lord Granville is President of the Council and wants to see you as soon as possible.”
I agreed to go with him the next morning.
Mr. Hanbury came for me in his carriage and took me to Lord Granville's house.
Lord Granville received me very politely.
After asking several questions about the situation in America, he said:
“You Americans have a mistaken idea about the nature of your constitution.”
“You argue that the king's instructions to his governors are not laws, and that you are free to obey or ignore them as you please.”
“But those instructions are not like private instructions given to a minister traveling abroad.”
“They are first written by judges who are experts in the law.”
“Then they are examined, discussed, and perhaps revised by the Council.”
“After that, the king signs them.”
“So far as they concern you, they are the law of the land.”
“The king is the legislator of the colonies.”
I was surprised by this.
“My lord, that is a new doctrine to me.”
“I have always understood from our charters that our laws are to be made by our own Assemblies.”
“They are indeed presented to the king for his approval. But once he gives that approval, he cannot repeal or change them.”
“And just as the Assemblies cannot make permanent laws without the king's approval, the king cannot make laws for us without the consent of our Assemblies.”
Lord Granville assured me that I was completely mistaken.
I did not believe him.
Still, his words disturbed me.
They made me wonder whether this was truly the view held by the government in England.
As soon as I returned to my lodging, I wrote down everything he had said.
I remembered that about twenty years earlier, a bill introduced by the ministry in Parliament had contained a clause that would have made the king's instructions into laws for the colonies.
The House of Commons had rejected that clause.
At the time, we had admired them as defenders of our liberty.
But their conduct toward us in 1765 later suggested a darker explanation.
Perhaps they had not wanted the king to possess that power because they intended to claim the power for themselves.
After several days, Dr. Fothergill spoke with the proprietors.
They finally agreed to meet with me at Mr. Thomas Penn's house in Spring Garden.
At first, we exchanged polite statements about our desire to reach a reasonable settlement.
But each side probably had a different idea of what “reasonable” meant.
We then began discussing our complaints.
I explained the Assembly's position.
The proprietors defended their actions as best they could.
I defended the Assembly.
The differences between us soon appeared so great that any hope of agreement seemed almost impossible.
Still, we agreed that I should put our complaints into writing.
They promised to consider them.
I prepared the document shortly afterward.
But instead of considering it themselves, they gave it to their solicitor, Ferdinand John Paris.
Paris handled their legal affairs in their long-running dispute with Lord Baltimore, the proprietor of Maryland.
That dispute had lasted seventy years.
Paris also wrote their papers and messages in their arguments with the Assembly.
He was a proud and angry man.
I had sometimes criticized his papers in the Assembly's replies because their arguments were weak and their language was arrogant.
As a result, he had developed a deep hatred for me.
Whenever we met, his hostility was obvious.
The proprietors suggested that Paris and I discuss the complaints privately.
I refused.
I would deal with the proprietors themselves, but not with Paris.
They then followed Paris's advice and sent my paper to the Attorney General and Solicitor General for their legal opinion.
The document remained with them for almost a year.
For eleven months and twenty-three days, I repeatedly asked the proprietors for an answer.
Each time, I received the same response.
“We have not yet received the opinion of the Attorney General and Solicitor General.”
I never learned what that opinion finally said.
The proprietors never showed it to me.
Instead, they sent the Assembly a long message written and signed by Paris.
It repeated my complaints, criticized me for failing to use proper formal language, and called that omission a form of rudeness.
It then offered a weak defense of the proprietors' conduct.
Finally, it said they would be willing to settle the matter if the Assembly sent someone “of candor” to negotiate with them.
The message clearly implied that I was not such a person.
The “rudeness” they complained about was probably very simple.
I had not addressed my written complaints using their full formal titles:
“True and Absolute Proprietaries of the Province of Pennsylvania.”
I had left those titles out because I did not consider them necessary.
The purpose of the paper was simply to put into writing what I had already said during our conversation.
But while the proprietors were delaying their answer, the Assembly achieved something much more important.
They persuaded Governor Denny to approve a law taxing the proprietors' estate in the same way that ordinary people's property was taxed.
This was the main issue in dispute.
Because the Assembly had now obtained what it wanted, it did not bother answering the proprietors' message.
When the new law reached England, however, the proprietors became determined to prevent the king from approving it.
Following Paris's advice, they petitioned the king and the Council.
A hearing was scheduled.
The proprietors hired two lawyers to oppose the law.
I hired two lawyers to defend it.
Their argument was that the law had been designed to place an unfair tax burden on the proprietors' estate while protecting the property of ordinary citizens.
They claimed that if the law remained in force, the proprietors—who were already unpopular with the people—would be left at the mercy of the tax assessors and would eventually be ruined.
We rejected that argument.
The law had no such purpose.
Nor would it have such an effect.
The assessors were honest and responsible men.
They had sworn to assess property fairly.
Any small benefit they might gain by lowering their own taxes and raising the proprietors' taxes was far too small to persuade them to commit perjury.
We also strongly emphasized what would happen if the law were repealed.
The Assembly had already printed £100,000 in paper money and spent it for the king's service.
That money was now circulating among the people.
If the law were repealed, the value of that money would be destroyed, causing serious losses to many people.
It would also discourage the Assembly from ever making another large grant to the Crown.
We argued that the proprietors were willing to risk such a disaster merely because they feared, without good reason, that their own property might be taxed too heavily.
During the hearing, Lord Mansfield, one of the lawyers, stood up and motioned for me to follow him into the clerk's room.
“Mr. Franklin,” he asked, “do you truly believe that the proprietary estate will suffer no unfair treatment under this law?”
“Certainly not,” I replied. “I am completely confident that it will be treated fairly.”
“Then you should have no objection to making a formal agreement guaranteeing that.”
“None at all.”
Lord Mansfield then called Paris into the room.
After some discussion, both sides accepted his proposal.
The Council clerk prepared a written agreement.
I signed it together with Mr. Charles, who was also an agent for Pennsylvania in its ordinary affairs.
Lord Mansfield then returned to the Council chamber.
The law was finally allowed to take effect.
The Council did recommend several changes.
We agreed that those changes would be made through a later law.
But the Assembly did not consider them necessary.
One year's tax had already been collected before the Council's order arrived.
The Assembly therefore appointed a committee to investigate how the assessors had handled the taxes.
Several close friends of the proprietors were placed on the committee.
After a complete investigation, every member of the committee signed a report stating that the taxes had been assessed with perfect fairness.
The Assembly considered my agreement with Lord Mansfield an important service to the province because it protected the value of the paper money already circulating throughout Pennsylvania.
When I returned, the Assembly formally thanked me.
The proprietors, however, were furious with Governor Denny for approving the law.
They removed him from office and threatened to sue him for violating the instructions he had sworn to obey.
But Governor Denny had acted at the request of General Loudoun and in what he believed was the service of the king.
He also had powerful friends at court.
So he ignored the proprietors' threats.
In the end, they never carried them out.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!