Individualism vs. Socialism
Henry Clews argued that individual freedom and competition were the foundations of America’s prosperity, while socialism would weaken ambition, responsibility, and economic progress.
“First, let me make my position clear,” Clews said. “The kind of individualism I defend is not extreme individualism. No civilized country can operate on that basis. I mean a system in which people are generally free to manage their own affairs, own property, choose their work, and compete with one another.”
“Competition is important because it rewards ability and hard work. It encourages people to improve their skills and find better ways of doing things. In my view, competition is really another name for industrial freedom.”
“Under our system, a man can choose his profession. If he dislikes his trade, he can change it. He can work harder if he wants to earn more. He can set a price for his labor or his products. He can acquire property, save money, invest it, or spend it as he chooses.”
“If one man becomes successful because he is more talented, intelligent, or hardworking, his success gives others a reason to work harder themselves.”
“This freedom also brings out qualities that are valuable to society—energy, enterprise, patience, self-reliance, courage, sacrifice, honesty, generosity, and respect for the rights of others.”
“If the government took care of every person and made all the important decisions for them, people would have much less reason to develop these qualities.”
“The strongest people in history have usually been shaped by struggle. Men who have had to depend upon themselves, overcome difficulties, and compete with others often develop stronger characters than those who have always been protected.”
“America has become a great nation largely because its people have been free to work, save, invest, and pursue their own ambitions.”
“When capable and hardworking people are free to improve their condition, they generally rise. Skilled workers are in demand and can earn good wages. In the United States, a worker's wages buy more than wages do in most other countries.”
“Now let us consider socialism.”
“It is not always easy to define exactly what modern socialism means. In America it has appeared in several different forms—socialist communities, Fourierism, international socialism, nihilism, and Christian socialism.”
“But for the purpose of this debate, I will make the distinction simple. Individualism supports competition and private ownership where competition is possible. Socialism rejects competition as harmful and favors collective ownership of the means of production and distribution.”
“That difference goes to the heart of the issue.”
“Socialism would restrict the great field of individual opportunity. It would weaken the desire to achieve and make individual success much more difficult.”
“Think about what competition has done for America. It has helped create our industries, our wealth, and our independence. It has kept alive the American love of freedom.”
“Take away individual initiative and you take away much of what we call the American spirit.”
“The United States, of all countries, is especially unsuited to socialism.”
“Our nation was founded by people who fought against oppression. The men who created our Constitution believed deeply in individual liberty and political freedom. They risked their lives and sacrificed their property to establish a nation where people could live as free citizens.”
“For more than a century, our history has been filled with difficulties and crises, yet the country has continued to advance. Our system has passed the test of time.”
“America is a nation of freedom and equality. Millions of people have found opportunities here that were impossible in the countries they left behind.”
“Of course, Americans are not always satisfied. But I would not even call that entirely a bad thing.”
“Our national restlessness and ambition have helped drive our progress. People are constantly trying to build something better.”
“But we must distinguish between healthy dissatisfaction and destructive dissatisfaction.”
“A person who sees a strong foundation and wants to build something better upon it is helping society. A person who wants to destroy the entire system because he dislikes the results is doing something entirely different.”
“I can understand why socialism might appeal to people living under a brutal dictatorship. If a government gives its people no freedom and keeps them in poverty, it is natural that they would dream of a completely different system.”
“They might imagine a society in which the government owns the land and capital, employs everyone, and divides the wealth equally.”
“But bringing that idea to America is another matter.”
“A man who escapes tyranny and comes to America enters a country where he can vote, hold property, work, start a business, and pursue wealth.”
“He may arrive with nothing. He may have no reputation, no money, and no influence. Yet he can still become a citizen and enjoy the same legal rights as native-born Americans.”
“He has political equality. He has legal equality. He has the freedom to acquire property and build wealth.”
“If he is energetic and capable, there is no fixed limit to what he can accomplish.”
“So why should a man who has escaped oppression come to America and then demand that America adopt the very kind of system he left behind?”
The Problem With Equalizing Everything
“Socialism contains a basic contradiction,” Clews argued. “It tries to create equality, but it cannot eliminate the human desire to achieve more.”
“People naturally want to improve their condition. Even if wealth were divided equally, ambition would remain.”
“The most attractive argument for socialism is its promise to help the poor. But even William Jennings Bryan has pointed out that individualism has produced an increasing spirit of charity.”
“When people own their wealth, they can decide for themselves where to give it. They can support the causes and people they care about.”
“Would people be equally generous if the government controlled everything?”
“A socialist society also faces another problem. People are not naturally identical.”
“One doctor is more skilled than another. One lawyer is more capable. One engineer may be far more talented than his colleagues.”
“Should they all receive exactly the same reward?”
“If one doctor is much better than another, people will naturally seek his services. If he cannot charge more for his skill, how will the system recognize the difference between him and an incompetent doctor?”
“The same is true of lawyers, mechanics, craftsmen, engineers, and every other profession.”
“You cannot make unequal abilities produce equal results simply by passing a law.”
“If you reward the lazy and the hardworking equally, you weaken the incentive to work.”
“Who would willingly divide his savings with a man who refuses to work, wastes his money, and takes no responsibility for his family?”
“If the results of hard work are taken away and given to people who make no effort, why should anyone continue to struggle?”
“Competition can certainly be hard on weak or unfortunate people. But that hardship also creates opportunities for kindness, charity, patience, and generosity.”
“Human beings cannot eliminate struggle from life. Difficulties are part of nature.”
“Socialism makes the mistake of imagining that society can remove all struggle without paying a price.”
“Human beings differ in talent, intelligence, ambition, character, and ability. No political system can completely erase those differences.”
“Competition is like gravity. We may dislike its effects, but we cannot simply abolish it.”
“The problem is not the existence of natural laws. The problem comes when we pretend those laws do not exist.”
“I therefore say plainly: we cannot eliminate competition any more than we can eliminate gravity.”
Why Americans Reject Socialism
“Look at the American inventor, farmer, merchant, financier, mechanic, and professional worker.”
“Each wants to be good at his trade. Each wants to produce something better than his competitors. Each wants to overcome obstacles and succeed.”
“That ambition benefits both the individual and the country.”
“A successful worker earns money, supports his family, improves his home, and gives his children opportunities.”
“Why would we ask such people to give up these advantages for socialism?”
“Why should we replace a system that rewards ability with one that deliberately reduces the difference between ability and incompetence?”
“I cannot believe Americans would willingly make that choice.”
“The prosperity of the American people has been achieved under our existing political and economic system.”
“Of course, our system is not perfect. No system is.”
“But we should judge a system by its results.”
“And the results of American individualism are extraordinary.”
Socialism and the Risk of Losing America’s Best People
“If socialism were established in the United States, many of our most talented people would leave.”
“Why would a highly capable businessman, inventor, engineer, or professional remain in a country where his ability brings him little additional reward?”
“He would look for another country where his talents could be freely used.”
“The strongest people would leave first.”
“The result would be national stagnation.”
“Our ancestors fought for religious freedom. Later generations fought for political freedom. The nation eventually fought a terrible war over human freedom.”
“Now we must protect another kind of freedom—the freedom to work, create, compete, and succeed.”
“Socialism, if carried far enough, would destroy that freedom.”
“Great achievements cannot be produced by a system that removes the reward for achievement.”
Municipal Ownership: The First Step Toward Socialism
“Now I want to turn to a more practical question—municipal ownership.”
“Should cities own and operate railroads, streetcars, telegraph systems, lighting companies, factories, and other businesses?”
“This is not a minor question. It affects nearly every part of public life.”
“I regard municipal ownership as the entering wedge of socialism.”
“Socialists understand that Americans are suspicious of their larger program. So instead of asking the public to accept socialism all at once, they begin with something that sounds much more reasonable—public ownership of a particular service.”
“They point to existing problems, exaggerate them, and then promise that government ownership will solve everything.”
“I have also observed that municipal ownership can be used as a political tool.”
“A politician can put public ownership into his platform and use it to attract voters.”
“But public ownership is not a theory. It is a business question.”
“Running a railroad, telephone company, lighting system, or manufacturing business requires experience and exceptional management.”
“The greatest businessmen spend their entire lives learning how to operate their companies.”
“How can a city expect to manage a complicated business when its officials may remain in office for only one or two years?”
“A successful enterprise contains many different departments. Each requires people with specialized knowledge.”
“Small mistakes can produce enormous losses.”
“Neglect a detail, delay an improvement, or fail to adopt a useful invention, and the entire business can suffer.”
“Private companies have strong incentives to hire the best people and use the newest technology.”
“A government enterprise faces a different pressure.”
“Politicians may care more about making the next election look good than about building a profitable and efficient business.”
“John Stuart Mill described the danger well: the trouble begins when the municipality replaces the activity of individuals with its own activity.”
The Lesson of Colonel Waring
“Consider Colonel Waring.”
“He created one of the best street-cleaning systems New York had ever seen.”
“His work was widely admired. His ability and honesty were not seriously questioned.”
“Yet when a new city administration came into power, he was forced out to make room for its own choice.”
“That is the fundamental weakness of political management.”
“A capable private executive can remain in charge as long as he produces results. A government employee can lose his position simply because the political administration changes.”
What Other Countries Teach Us
“Government ownership has already been tried in other countries.”
“The results should make us cautious.”
“England provides an especially useful example because its cities have often operated under conditions more favorable to public ownership than those found in American cities.”
“Some English municipal enterprises have worked reasonably well.”
“But some successes do not prove that the system is generally sound.”
“English cities have generally experienced less political corruption than American cities. They have also sometimes been able to attract wealthy and capable men who regard public service as a civic duty.”
“We have not yet developed such a tradition on the same scale.”
“Even in England, however, many municipal enterprises have lost money.”
“Sometimes the accounts have been arranged in ways that hide the true cost. Expenses that should have been charged to an enterprise have been transferred to the city's general accounts.”
“Some cities have accumulated so much debt that their credit has suffered.”
“The British taxpayer has increasingly questioned the cost of these projects.”
“If municipal ownership struggles even under relatively favorable English conditions, why should we assume it will work better in America?”
“Look at the British telegraph and telephone systems. They have not matched the efficiency and low cost of America's privately operated systems.”
“American railroads under private ownership have provided some of the most extensive and efficient transportation in the world.”
The Conversion of a Scottish Advocate
“There is an amusing example that deserves attention.”
“Major Dalrymple of Glasgow came to America as an advocate of municipal ownership.”
“He had been one of the strongest supporters of the system in Glasgow.”
“When he first arrived, he told Americans that there was no reason our cities could not own their street railways and operate them successfully.”
“But then he spent time studying American conditions.”
“Before returning to Scotland, he changed his mind.”
“After seeing how political machines operated in American cities, he reached the opposite conclusion.”
“He warned that giving cities control of street railways, gas companies, telephone systems, and other public utilities would create enormous political machines.”
“Imagine giving a political organization control not only over police officers and firefighters, but also over thousands of employees in public utility companies.”
“That organization could become almost impossible to defeat.”
“I came here believing in public ownership,” Dalrymple admitted, “but after studying American conditions, I now believe private ownership under proper regulation is much better for American cities.”
“The newspapers called this episode ‘The Conversion of the Scot.’”
“It was a powerful admission because it came from someone who had originally been one of the leading advocates of municipal ownership.”
America’s Answer to Socialism
“Years earlier, James Bryce had described the future of America as a struggle between two forces.”
“One force wanted to move the country forward toward greater prosperity and better government.”
“The other risked slowing that progress until the nation was overtaken by crisis.”
“Bryce wondered whether Americans would continue improving their public institutions or whether they would eventually surrender to radical solutions such as socialism.”
“Years later, when he returned to America as ambassador, the country itself seemed to provide the answer.”
“The answer could be seen in our farms, mines, factories, railroads, and businesses.”
“It could be seen in the prosperity of millions of working Americans.”
“This progress had not been produced by socialism.”
“It had been produced by individual initiative.”
The Final Argument
“Individualism in America has survived the greatest test of all—the test of time.”
“Our Constitution and our republican form of government have provided the framework in which individual freedom could produce enormous prosperity.”
“If the purpose of government is to promote prosperity and improve the happiness of its people, then we should judge our system by what it has actually accomplished.”
“And by that standard, American individualism has an extraordinary record.”
At the end of Clews's speech, the chairman, the poet Edwin Markham, turned to the audience of roughly 5,000 people.
“Ladies and gentlemen,” Markham said, “I hope you have enjoyed Mr. Clews's address as much as I have. He has covered the entire subject and left nothing more to be said from his side.”
Then Markham introduced Professor Kirkpatrick, who would take the opposite position and challenge Clews's arguments.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!