← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 74 · Publicity, Accountability, and the Reform of Big Business

Publicity, Accountability, and the Reform of Big Business

Chapter 74 of 90 · 3,613 words · Free

Years ago, I could already see where the reckless behavior of certain corporate managers and manipulators would eventually lead. I began urging companies to hire certified public accountants to examine their books and report the true financial condition of the business directly to the stockholders.

If my proposal had been adopted then, much of the government investigation that came later would have been unnecessary. The reforms would have happened years earlier, before the worldwide shortage of money created such anxiety and helped produce the disastrous panic of 1907.

In April 1906, I gave a speech at the Wharton School of Finance at the University of Pennsylvania called “Publicity and Reform.” I strongly advocated the policy of open accounts and independent examination. My argument was simple: honest businesses had nothing to fear from the truth.

“We are living in an age of rapid progress,” I said. “And we are now going through a period of necessary business reform.”

“Reform means improvement. Businessmen should help it along, not stand in its way.”

“Banks, railroads, and insurance companies have an especially important duty. They should welcome full publicity about how they operate and how they handle their business.”

“The opposition in the New York Legislature to investigating the banks was a serious mistake. Instead of calming public fears, it created more suspicion.”

“If the banks had openly welcomed a thorough investigation, public confidence would have increased rather than declined.”

The very resistance to investigation made people wonder what was being hidden.

“When a company becomes the subject of suspicion, the best thing it can do is clear its name immediately,” I argued.

“It should invite a complete examination and put everything on the table.”

“If there is something wrong, let it be exposed and corrected. If the company is sound, the investigation will prove it and leave the company stronger than before.”

New York and other states should therefore require every corporation, including banks and trust companies, to publish at least twice a year a report of its financial condition.

Those reports should be certified by qualified public accountants.

State officials should also have the authority to order special examinations whenever there was reason to suspect that a company was financially unsound or operating improperly.

Such examinations would protect the public, but they would also protect honest companies from unfair suspicion.

Only insolvent or dishonest businesses would have anything to fear.

I placed particular importance on independent accountants because their certified reports would carry authority.

Their conclusions should be accepted as a reliable statement of the company's actual condition.

An accountant who deliberately submitted a false or misleading report should face severe punishment. He should be guilty of a felony and permanently barred from practicing the profession.

Universities and colleges should also establish departments devoted to training accountants.

Students who completed such programs should receive professional degrees or diplomas, just as doctors and lawyers do.

The accounting profession was already respected, but its importance to modern business required that it be raised to an even higher standard.

Some universities had already begun training accountants under experienced professionals. Every institution of higher education should follow their example.

The resistance of New York's banking interests to investigation only made matters worse.

People naturally began asking, “Why are they so afraid of being examined?”

If there was nothing wrong, why not simply open the books?

The same problem existed in the life insurance industry.

The public had become deeply suspicious of the secretive way many insurance companies were managed.

The legislature should therefore carry its investigation through to the end and completely clean up the industry.

Anything less would be a failure of duty.

It was astonishing that the officers and trustees of the great life insurance companies thought anything short of a complete house-cleaning would satisfy their policyholders and the public.

The banking community also had a direct interest in seeing this happen.

If the insurance industry remained under suspicion, that suspicion would spread to banks, bankers, bond dealers, and trust companies that did business with insurance companies.

The bankers could not simply tell the insurance companies, “You made mistakes. Promise not to do it again.”

That would be an easy way out, but it would not solve the problem.

The entire cloud hanging over Wall Street had to be removed through complete investigation, full disclosure, and a new standard of conduct in insurance and banking.

Insurance trustees had a duty to cooperate.

If they refused to submit to examination, people could reasonably wonder whether they were afraid of what investigators might find.

If securities had been bought or sold improperly, or if other questionable transactions had taken place, those matters should be brought into the open.

Nothing should be protected simply because it was embarrassing.

Public opinion should reject every attempt to stop further investigation into the insurance business or the banks.

Banks and bankers should be above suspicion.

So should insurance managers and trustees.

The railroads presented another problem.

Stricter laws were needed wherever powerful interests could gain an advantage at the expense of everyone else.

Railroad rebates were a good example.

A simple fine was not enough.

A railroad executive who secretly gave favored customers illegal rebates should face criminal charges and possible imprisonment.

Once the threat of prison was real, executives would think twice before breaking the law.

They would also have to consider their own reputations and their families.

Secret rate-cutting disguised as rebates had helped powerful companies destroy competitors and create unfair monopolies.

Publicity would make such practices much harder to carry out.

The same sunlight that would expose illegal railroad rebates would also have prevented the reckless management of the life insurance companies.

Under stricter laws and better supervision, such abuses should become impossible.

Publicity would also help destroy the corruption and political “graft” that had spread through business and public life.

Publishing accurate accounts would protect honest companies while exposing fraudulent ones.

Any business with nothing to hide should welcome that kind of publicity.

We are living through a period of major reform—almost a revolution—in business affairs.

But that revolution can do great good.

Better business methods will create a stronger sense of responsibility and a clearer understanding of duty.

That will increase public confidence and produce more reliable results.

We will have more caution, fewer reckless speculations, and less dishonesty.

So the reform movement should be allowed to move forward without obstruction.

It will raise the financial and commercial standing of the country and bring us closer to becoming the world's leading financial center.

Many businessmen need more caution and common sense.

They would benefit from having the light of publicity shine directly on their affairs.

When one of the spectacular “successes” of the business world suddenly collapses, the damage does not stop with its owners.

The failure also hurts honest and conservative businesses because it creates suspicion of everyone.

Independent accounting and public disclosure would expose abuses, restrain them, and prevent many of the collapses caused by unchecked one-man control.

The old system of one-man domination over huge corporations must end.

An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.

Corporations should also remember that they have responsibilities toward their employees.

They should provide healthy working conditions.

They should also establish pensions or other forms of support for employees who become disabled or reach old age after many years of service.

Profit-sharing would be another useful measure.

Either approach would help narrow the dangerous gap between labor and capital.

One-man control supported by a group of obedient directors must also disappear.

Dummy directors are nothing more than decoys.

They are called directors, but they do not actually direct anything.

They are chosen by the people in control precisely because they are expected to remain silent and obedient.

That makes them a fraud on the public.

No one should accept a position as a director or trustee of a bank, railroad, industrial company, or life insurance company unless he fully understands the responsibility and is prepared to perform it honestly.

A man who deliberately accepts the role of a dummy director is doing something disgraceful.

Directors must have opinions of their own.

They must be willing to express those opinions, even when they disagree with management.

They are responsible not only for their own mistakes but also for failing to stop wrongdoing by the officers and employees under their supervision.

If a man cannot devote the necessary time and attention to the position, he should not accept it.

I once knew a very famous businessman who, during the last thirty years of his life, was constantly invited to serve as a director because he was considered the perfect “dummy director.”

He served on an enormous number of corporate boards.

He was wealthy and had retired from business.

He was certainly capable, although most of his greatest capacity seemed to be physical rather than intellectual.

His main qualification was that he never missed a directors' meeting.

He arrived on time.

He stayed until the meeting ended.

He carefully watched which way the majority was voting.

Then he voted the same way.

He was almost never heard from.

The only time he regularly opened his mouth was when lunch was served after the meeting.

Corporate managers were genuinely upset when he died.

He had been their favorite director because he never caused trouble and always approved whatever the meeting decided.

When he received his five-dollar gold coin for attending a meeting, he went home delighted.

He was a perfect example of what I mean by a silent and dummy director.

Directors should instead make it their business to understand everything important happening inside the corporations they oversee.

They should learn enough to make intelligent decisions rather than blindly approve whatever management puts before them.

They should assert their legal rights and actually direct the company, while naturally leaving day-to-day details to the officers.

They must also avoid using their positions to advance personal interests at the company's expense.

They should cooperate with state and federal authorities in enforcing the law and should never help management evade it.

All these reforms would strengthen public confidence in American business.

They would also help stabilize our financial system.

One of our greatest needs is a more stable money market in Wall Street.

The wild changes in interest rates on Stock Exchange loans that sometimes occurred in New York would cause a financial convulsion in Europe.

Yet such extreme fluctuations were not tolerated in London, Paris, or Berlin.

Why should New York be different?

We are destined eventually to become the world's financial center.

But before that can happen, we must achieve the financial stability that the great European markets already possess.

A money market that suddenly shoots to absurdly high rates and then collapses again is both dangerous and unacceptable.

It interferes with legitimate business and creates uncertainty throughout the economy.

New York should not tolerate such conditions.

In Europe, interest rates rise and fall according to supply and demand, just as they do here.

But they normally move within a relatively narrow range.

There is no reason New York cannot achieve the same stability.

I hoped that the committee appointed by the New York Chamber of Commerce would find the causes of these violent fluctuations.

The committee included Vanderlip, Conant, Straus, Claflin, and Clarke.

They needed to determine whether the problem came from an inadequate supply of currency, insufficient capital or credit, sudden demands for speculative loans, or a refusal by lenders to provide money during periods of fear.

European financial centers could generally rely on monetary stability.

New York needed the same stability before it could expect the world to regard it as the leading financial center.

Fortunately, we were already moving in the right direction.

The reform movement in business and legislation could not come soon enough.

There was no sound reason why call money in Wall Street should ever have reached 100 or 125 percent a year, as it did in December of the previous year, while money elsewhere in the country was available at no more than six percent.

These violent local shortages may have been limited geographically, but their psychological effects spread much farther.

They created fear and damaged confidence throughout the financial system.

Such extreme activity was not a natural condition of the money market.

It was the result of artificial conditions and badly regulated local practices.

When interest rates jumped up and down every few minutes on the Stock Exchange, depending on the latest bids and offers of nervous borrowers and lenders, the spectacle was almost ridiculous.

It sounded like something from a comic opera.

But in banking and finance, it was a very serious problem with enormous consequences.

Such abnormal conditions did not happen every day.

But they happened often enough that we needed to understand their causes and find a permanent solution.

Ordinary movements in interest rates were not the problem.

If rates gradually rose from two percent to six percent, or later fell again, that was perfectly normal.

It simply reflected changes in supply and demand.

The same thing happened in Europe.

What was abnormal were Wall Street's sudden, almost explosive jumps in interest rates.

Those violent swings were a peculiar weakness of our financial system.

We had to grow out of them, and the sooner the better.

The main problem was not simply a lack of flexibility in the currency system.

It was also the way money was borrowed and lent to finance stock purchases.

General monetary shortages usually had obvious causes.

But when a small group of borrowers and lenders on the Stock Exchange could push the rate from five percent to ten, twenty, or even fifty percent within an hour, that was clearly a problem that could be prevented.

Both borrowers and lenders had a responsibility to prevent it.

One cause of these local shortages was the New York Sub-Treasury and, more broadly, the Sub-Treasury system.

The system locked up money that should have remained in circulation.

A Sub-Treasury functioned much like a government bank.

It gathered money but generally did not lend it back into the financial system except through government payments.

In that sense, it performed only part of what a real bank does.

Abolishing the Sub-Treasury system would make our currency more flexible.

In theory, we had no United States national bank.

In practice, every Sub-Treasury operated in some ways like one.

Until Congress changed the Sub-Treasury and currency laws, banks and trust companies could at least cooperate to prevent extreme interest rates.

They could agree not to charge more than ten percent on call loans during periods of financial stress.

Better still, they could agree on a seven-percent ceiling.

They might lose some immediate profits.

But in return they would help make New York a safer and stronger financial center.

That would eventually bring them much greater business.

Germany allowed banks to issue emergency currency during financial crises.

England had a similar mechanism.

During a panic, the government could temporarily relax the limits on the Bank of England's note issues and allow it to provide additional currency.

The resulting increase in money supply helped restore confidence and relieve the pressure.

America had no equally effective mechanism.

Our main option was for the Secretary of the Treasury to place government deposits in national banks in exchange for United States bonds, and sometimes high-quality state or municipal bonds.

But this depended on the Treasury having enough money beyond what it needed for normal operations.

At best, it was only a temporary solution.

We clearly needed a more flexible currency.

We also needed to change the way money was borrowed against securities on the Stock Exchange so that interest rates would remain reasonably stable even during periods of financial pressure.

Eventually, national bank currency would probably be backed by gold rather than government bonds.

That would bring our monetary system closer to those of the major European powers.

But there was no need to cross that bridge before we reached it.

As for the other reforms, the time to act was now.

The reform movement affecting life insurance and banking was at its strongest, not only in New York but throughout the country.

We should keep pushing until the necessary changes were completed.

First, all current and proposed investigations of banks and insurance companies should be carried out completely.

Independent experts and accountants should examine every part of their operations.

Nothing should remain hidden.

Nothing should remain uncertain.

The findings should then be published promptly in language ordinary people could understand.

The public deserved the plain truth.

Rumors of bribery, corruption, graft, fraud, missing money, manipulated accounts, and hidden insolvency could then either be confirmed or disproved.

If the accusations proved false, the companies under suspicion would regain their credit and reputation.

But the reforms should not stop there.

State legislatures should pass permanent laws requiring banking and insurance departments to conduct regular examinations using independent experts.

Their findings should also be made public.

Any institution that opposed such investigations would naturally create suspicion.

That applied to banks, trust companies, insurance companies, industrial corporations, and everyone else.

Railroads and other large corporations should also be subject to strict supervision and regular financial examinations.

State attorneys general should receive stronger powers to enforce these requirements.

Large corporations should be required to provide verified information about earnings, profits, expenses, capitalization, debts, dividends, property values, assets, and liabilities.

They should no longer be allowed to operate like blind pools in which outsiders had no idea what was actually happening.

Fraud and misrepresentation could be stopped by exposing them.

And exposure was precisely what dishonest people feared most.

Those who preferred secrecy and crooked dealings would hate the new era of publicity.

Honest companies, however, would benefit enormously.

They had nothing to hide.

Secrecy is merely a shield for weakness.

The Supreme Court's recent decisions in the Tobacco and Paper Trust cases were therefore an important victory for the public.

The Court had made it clear that corporations could not hide behind secrecy.

When the law required evidence, corporations had to produce their books and papers, even when those records might reveal wrongdoing.

The constitutional protection against self-incrimination belonged to individuals.

A person could not use that personal protection to prevent a corporation from producing its records.

This decision opened a new chapter in corporate regulation.

It made it possible to examine the affairs and accounts of large trusts much more thoroughly.

It removed an important escape route that corporations had previously used to avoid exposure.

From then on, unlawful combinations and conspiracies would be much harder to conceal.

The decision was of enormous importance to the country.

Its legal and moral consequences could hardly be overstated.

It would help prevent future failures of justice caused simply by the government's inability to obtain evidence against corporations.

It also applied a higher moral standard to corporate management.

Railroads, industrial corporations, banks, trust companies, and insurance companies would all be affected.

Many long-standing abuses could be corrected simply by enforcing laws that already existed.

Secret management naturally creates opportunities for dishonesty, fraud, misuse of company money, and corruption.

It also creates rumors and suspicion that can damage an entire industry.

Honesty is not merely good business.

It is a moral obligation.

Corporations should live by the same standard of honesty as individuals.

No one should betray a position of trust for money, power, friendship, or personal advantage.

In the long run, honest business produces more lasting prosperity and greater honor than dishonest business ever can.

As the Bible asks, what does it profit a man to gain the whole world and lose his soul?

Corruption in positions of great responsibility should be eliminated from American business.

Dishonest judges and juries and bribed legislators should be considered more disgraceful than ordinary theft.

Corporate leaders and industrialists should have the same respect for truth and honor that they expect from everyone else.

Wealth should never place a criminal beyond the reach of justice.

Millions of dollars should provide no protection from punishment.

Great fortunes built through monopoly, oppression, or dishonesty are not achievements to be proud of.

They are a disgrace to their owners.

The abuse of economic power is a serious national evil.

Every businessman should take pride not only in making money but also in being honest, truthful, fair, and honorable.

We are now moving toward correcting many of the abuses that have damaged American business.

The country should welcome this reform movement.

Our greatest remedy is publicity and the enforcement of the law.

America's extraordinary growth gives us every reason to expect an even greater future.

Our population already exceeds eighty million, and with that growth will come greater national wealth and influence.

But wealth alone is not enough.

We should also develop our arts, sciences, literature, and every other part of civilization that makes a nation stronger and better.

As we move forward, we must constantly correct our mistakes, eliminate abuses, and remove the rotten parts of our public and business institutions.

Banking, insurance, manufacturing, transportation, trade, government, the professions, and every other part of economic life should operate as honestly, efficiently, and smoothly as possible.

The best way to achieve that is to encourage public responsibility and eliminate opportunities for secret wrongdoing.

Wise laws, properly enforced and supported by public opinion, can do this without becoming oppressive or unnecessarily intrusive.

They would force the crooks, grafters, illegal rebate-givers, and competition-killers of the business world out of the shadows.

They would have to operate in the open.

And sunlight alone would cure many of the country's worst business evils.

So let us have more light.

Let us have the light of PUBLICITY.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!