The Bank Robbery That Made a Fortune and Destroyed Others
Saturday night was chosen for the robbery. The burglars would enter the bank after it closed and stay inside until Sunday.
Members of Irving’s police ring would watch from outside. Their job was to make sure no curious passer-by or honest police officer interfered.
A carriage would wait nearby on Sunday morning. Once the police accomplices gave the signal, the burglars would leave the bank, abandoning their tools and taking only the stolen cash and securities.
Everything seemed ready. Duplicate keys had already been made, tested, and proved to work. The burglars had been carefully instructed on how to use them.
There was only one problem.
They still had no way into the vault.
The bank employed a night watchman, and he had to be dealt with.
The conspirators decided that there would be no need for kindness. The watchman would be seized, overpowered, tied up, gagged, and left helpless until Monday.
Fortunately for them, the watchman always spent Sunday nights at the bank, so his family would not immediately become suspicious of his absence.
With that, the entire plan seemed complete.
The conspirators finally separated late that night.
Early Sunday morning, the three burglars were waiting in the basement with their stolen goods.
They had been told to remain there until the signal came.
At last, the signal arrived.
The three men quickly slipped out, carrying their heavy bags.
A covered carriage was waiting on a nearby street. They hurried inside, nervous and excited, and the driver took them straight to Irving’s house.
Once they arrived, they opened the bags and examined everything they had taken.
The cash was easy enough to deal with.
But the bonds were another matter.
"What are we going to do with all these bonds?" someone asked.
None of them had a good answer.
They had stolen a fortune, but they had very little idea how to turn that fortune into usable money.
The following Monday morning, the bank was filled with confusion and panic.
When the clerks arrived, they found the vault doors standing wide open.
The heavy safes had been smashed and torn apart. Burglar tools were scattered across the floor.
Then they discovered the night watchman in a nearby room.
He was tied up and gagged, barely alive.
One of the clerks immediately jumped into a cab and rushed to Police Headquarters on Mulberry Street.
Irving was sitting in his office, going through the night's reports, when the clerk was brought in.
"There's been a terrible robbery at the bank!" the clerk exclaimed.
Irving listened with apparent shock.
"How much has been taken?"
"We don't know yet. The safes have been broken open, and the watchman was found tied up."
Irving quickly called two trusted detectives.
"We're going to the bank at once," he said.
The three men hurried back to Greenwich Street with the clerk.
Once inside, they carefully examined the scene.
After looking at the tools and the damage, the detectives announced their conclusion.
"This looks like the work of Harry Penrose," one of them said.
"And the watchman?" the clerk asked.
"He must have been working with Penrose."
The watchman was immediately arrested.
The bank president had already sent word that he was sick and would not be coming to work.
But when he heard the news, he hurried into town despite his supposed illness.
The sight of the ruined vaults left him looking genuinely horrified.
"What happened here?" he asked.
The detectives assured him that they were already working on the case.
"Don't worry, sir," one told him. "We'll find the men responsible."
The president nodded anxiously.
"We must recover the money and securities."
Later, when reporters questioned him privately, he explained that approximately four hundred thousand dollars in cash and bonds had been kept in the bank.
Every bit of it was now gone.
He appeared devastated.
When the robbery became public, panic spread among the bank's depositors and shareholders.
Customers rushed to withdraw their money.
The directors managed to satisfy the immediate demand by using their own resources and getting help from friends.
But the bank's reputation had been badly damaged.
Its stock, which had been worth about $130 a share, collapsed to only $40.
The public believed the bank had suffered a terrible criminal attack.
No one suspected that the president himself had arranged it.
There was an important lesson in what happened.
A little knowledge can be dangerous.
Irving and his criminal associates knew how to break into buildings, but they understood very little about finance.
Their fellow burglars were even less knowledgeable.
Their idea of wealth was simple: sell stolen goods cheaply, spend the money freely, give lavishly to women, and live like wealthy men until the money disappeared.
Selling large quantities of bonds was something completely different.
Fortunately for them, there was one educated man among the group.
His name was Max Shinburne.
Shinburne was German and had received a good education. Somehow, however, he had fallen from a respectable life into the company of professional criminals.
His education had survived his moral downfall.
That knowledge was about to make him very valuable.
Selling the stolen bonds in America was almost impossible.
The only people willing to buy them were criminals who dealt in stolen property, and they would pay only a small fraction of their real value.
A steamer was scheduled to leave for Europe that same day.
The group came up with a plan.
"Shinburne should take the bonds to Europe," they decided.
"Once he gets there, he can sell them before news of the robbery reaches the other side of the Atlantic."
Then he would return to America and divide the money with the others.
Shinburne agreed immediately.
But he had already begun thinking about something else.
He saw the stolen money as a chance to rebuild his own life.
Perhaps, he thought, he could use it to become respectable again.
The bank president had stolen to protect himself from disgrace.
Shinburne would steal to escape his own disgrace.
The steamer would not leave until noon, so Shinburne had plenty of time.
He handed the bonds over to Irving.
"I'll meet you at eleven," he said.
Then he took his share of the cash and left to handle some private business.
Years earlier, Shinburne had quietly bought several building lots near a park.
It had turned out to be an excellent investment.
Before leaving for Europe, he placed the property in the hands of a reliable agent and arranged to receive money through European drafts.
Then he returned to meet the others.
At eleven o'clock, he received nearly $200,000 in stolen bonds and set off for the steamer with Mike Hurley.
Conroy came along to see them off.
After a hurried exchange of instructions, the two men boarded.
The ropes were released exactly on schedule.
The ship began moving toward England.
Shinburne and Hurley were finally on their way.
When they reached Liverpool, the two men traveled directly to London.
Hurley knew almost nothing about foreign travel.
Shinburne easily took advantage of that.
"There are no evening trains to the Continent," he told him.
Hurley believed him.
Shinburne also kept pouring drinks for his companion.
Before long, Hurley was completely drunk.
When he was helpless, Shinburne quietly took the bonds.
He gathered his small amount of luggage and slipped away.
He never intended to see Hurley again.
He never intended to return to New York.
Shinburne went to Germany.
There, he began calling himself "Count Shinburne."
He bought an estate and started entertaining his neighbors.
Soon, everyone along the Rhine seemed to know him.
No one was more popular.
His dinners were famous.
His horses were admired.
His gardens were praised.
His house was always full of guests.
The impoverished German aristocrats were especially impressed.
"Anyone who can afford dinners like these must be an important gentleman," they thought.
They never asked where his money had come from.
Day by day, Shinburne's reputation grew stronger.
No one suspected the truth.
With enough caution, he might have lived comfortably for the rest of his life.
But he loved his new life too much.
The praise, the luxury, and the admiration had become impossible for him to give up.
Even though his spending was far beyond his means, he refused to cut back.
Then one morning, Shinburne received bad news from his bankers.
His account was overdrawn.
He had spent too much.
His fortune was disappearing.
That was when he remembered the Greenwich Street robbery.
"If I could rob a bank in New York," he thought, "surely I can rob one in a quiet European town."
He traveled to Brussels and began looking for an opportunity.
Eventually, he found a bank that seemed like a promising target.
But he soon discovered that there was a huge difference between the two situations.
In New York, the bank president had secretly helped him.
The doors had been opened for him.
The authorities were pretending to hunt for the criminals while actually protecting them.
In Brussels, the opposite was true.
The bank wanted to keep him out.
The authorities wanted to stop him.
Shinburne attempted the robbery anyway.
He was caught.
The court sentenced him to sixteen years in prison.
His German friends soon learned the truth.
The magnificent "Count Shinburne" had suddenly become a convicted criminal.
His glamorous life disappeared almost overnight.
Most people assumed that his story had ended.
They thought he would spend the rest of his life behind bars.
They were wrong.
After serving about twelve or thirteen years, Shinburne managed to obtain a pardon.
He eventually returned to America.
His first stop was the office of the agents who had been managing his park properties.
He walked in without knowing whether he was still rich or had returned as a pauper.
When he walked out, he knew the truth.
He was almost a millionaire.
During the nearly twenty years he had been away, the value of his land had risen enormously.
Shinburne was rich again.
He could have returned to his former life of luxury.
But age had changed him.
He no longer cared so much about showing off.
He returned to a world that barely remembered him.
Even today, few people who notice a kind-looking old gentleman spending an afternoon around upper Broadway would ever guess that he was once Max Shinburne, the bank burglar.
Hurley eventually woke up in London.
The first thing he realized was that Shinburne was gone.
Then he realized something worse.
The bonds were gone too.
"My partner robbed me!" he must have thought.
He was furious.
He complained bitterly about Shinburne's betrayal.
The other men felt the same way.
They were criminals, but they believed Shinburne should at least have dealt honestly with them.
"He should have played fair with us," they complained.
But there was nothing they could do.
Shinburne had disappeared.
They had no idea where he was.
They would probably never see him again.
The great robbery had promised them enormous wealth.
Instead, they received almost nothing.
Their dreams had vanished.
Their hopes had been cheated.
All they could do was imagine what they would do to Shinburne if they ever caught him.
The bank president, however, was the real winner.
His secret was safe.
He had made sure that the safes did not contain too much money when the burglars arrived.
The robbery had therefore covered up his enormous defalcation.
He was now a wealthy man.
The bank itself was not so fortunate.
The robbery had destroyed public confidence, and the bank eventually failed.
The president left banking and went into real estate.
He continued to grow richer.
He named his properties after himself and lived as though his success would last forever.
He provided comfortable lives for his children.
When he eventually died, people remembered him as a respectable and successful man.
They mourned his death.
They praised his life.
Almost no one knew that the fortune he had built—and the respectable life he had enjoyed—had begun with a terrible crime.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!