When New York Belonged to Tweed
The moment I agreed to take the stolen bonds to Europe and sell them, Irving, Stanley, and White looked enormously relieved.
Their fear disappeared, and so did their secrecy.
They began talking freely, telling me how certain they were that I could sell the bonds successfully. They also said they trusted me completely.
In fact, they claimed I was the only man they would have trusted with the job.
They had no real security except my word. Under the circumstances, they could hardly ask me to sign a receipt for the bonds. Even if I had given them one, it would have meant very little if I decided to keep the money for myself.
I was now the most important man in their little operation.
“All right,” I said. “Bring me the bonds, and I'll leave immediately.”
We finally decided that I would sail for Europe on the Cunard steamer Russia, scheduled to leave at seven Wednesday morning.
They would give me the bonds Tuesday night.
“I'll need some cash for expenses,” I told them.
Their faces immediately fell.
Then I added, “Give me one thousand-dollar bond instead. I'll borrow the money from a friend and use the bond as security.”
That changed everything.
They knew there was little chance anyone would carefully check the bond's number.
“I'll repay the loan when I return,” I assured them. “Then I'll get the bond back.”
They agreed.
After that, they entertained me with a collection of ridiculous stories about where the bonds had come from and who supposedly owned them.
None of it was true.
I learned later that the bonds were part of the stolen Lord bonds.
At that time, American government bonds were extremely common in Europe, especially in Holland and Germany. Enormous quantities of them were constantly being bought and sold.
That made stolen bonds surprisingly easy to pass.
A respectable-looking American businessman could walk into a bank or financial office and sell a large amount of securities without attracting much suspicion. Under the law, an innocent purchaser who bought a bearer bond in good faith generally could not simply have it taken away.
There was another advantage for a dishonest American in Europe.
If he dressed well, people assumed he was a gentleman.
If he had money, they assumed he was respectable.
Few people bothered to ask where the money had come from.
There was also a widespread belief that Americans were wealthy.
A well-dressed American could take advantage of that belief very easily.
The next morning, Tuesday, Irving met me near the Exchange.
He looked nervous as he reached into his coat and pulled out an envelope containing the thousand-dollar bond.
I took it without even examining it.
“I'll be back in ten minutes,” I said.
Irving looked alarmed.
Like many criminals, he trusted almost no one. He probably suspected that I was setting some kind of trap for him.
He also had no idea how quickly money could be raised against a good bond.
He apparently imagined that borrowing one thousand dollars would be a long and difficult business.
It wasn't.
Ten minutes later, I walked back into the meeting place with ten hundred-dollar bills in my hand.
Irving stared at them.
He was delighted.
That little demonstration changed his opinion of me completely.
From that moment on, Jimmy Irving trusted me without reservation.
Tuesday evening, I went home and said goodbye to my mother.
I didn't tell her the real reason for my journey.
“I've been given a commission in Europe,” I explained.
That was all she knew.
After leaving her, I went to our meeting place near Broadway and Astor Place.
Irving was already there.
He handed me his share of the stolen bonds.
He called them his “boodle.”
Then he said quietly:
“When you come back, give my share directly to me.”
I agreed.
Strangely enough, Stanley and White made exactly the same request.
They wanted their shares returned to them personally.
Around eleven o'clock, the other two men arrived.
After some discussion, White finally handed over his bonds.
Stanley, however, told me he would give me his share aboard the ship before it sailed.
I had already paid my bill and sent my luggage over to Jersey City.
Around midnight, I left for the ferry.
The three men came with me.
At the ferry terminal, we shook hands again and again.
Finally, we said goodbye.
I bought my ticket, went aboard the Russia, found my cabin, and went to bed.
The next morning, Stanley appeared.
He handed me his bonds.
Ten minutes later, the ship's lines were released.
The Russia began moving down the bay.
Two hours later, Fire Island disappeared behind us.
Soon there was nothing around us but the open sea.
Alone on the ocean, I had plenty of time to think.
And that seemed like the right moment to tell the story of one of the most notorious bank robberies in New York.
It happened during the days when Boss Tweed seemed to own New York, Jim Fisk seemed to control the judges, and Captain Kelso ruled the police from Mulberry Street.
New York was a remarkable place in those days.
The men running the city openly stole from the public.
They showed no fear of public opinion.
They spent money extravagantly and seemed completely confident that no one could stop them.
The ordinary citizen could only watch and complain.
He knew that corrupt politicians were taking his money through taxes.
But even after the big thieves had taken their share, another group was waiting to take whatever remained.
These were the common criminals.
Burglars and robbers operated with astonishing freedom.
They had little reason to fear arrest.
And even if they were arrested, they often had powerful friends who could protect them.
Mulberry Street police headquarters was divided into several informal groups.
Each group had its own collection of criminals.
The criminals reported their activities to the officers who protected them.
Whenever they completed a successful job, they handed over twenty percent of the proceeds.
That twenty percent was the police headquarters' regular commission.
It was simply the price of doing business.
Some criminals specialized in stealing watches and wallets from people's pockets.
Others specialized in breaking into buildings with crowbars, wedges, and other tools.
For ordinary crimes, the twenty-percent system worked well.
But sometimes a much bigger opportunity appeared.
Then special arrangements were made.
The job was given only to the most trusted professional thieves.
Police officers from headquarters would be sent to the scene.
Their purpose was not necessarily to stop the robbery.
They were there to make sure nobody interfered with it.
If necessary, they protected the criminals they were supposed to arrest.
Many mysterious robberies took place under this system.
The police would pretend to search desperately for the thieves.
Sometimes the same officers who were supposedly hunting the criminals would later celebrate with them over drinks.
And on some occasions, respectable men whose names would have shocked the public were involved as well.
The years after the Civil War created another kind of danger.
During the war, enormous amounts of money had passed through New York.
Some men had made fortunes through perfectly legal government contracts and financial deals.
Others had made fortunes through transactions that were far less respectable.
When the war ended, many of those opportunities disappeared.
Men who had become accustomed to easy money suddenly needed new ways to maintain their wealth.
One of the easiest methods was to gamble with someone else's money.
And that often ended badly.
When a man's losses became impossible to hide, he usually ran.
Foreign countries seemed to offer safety from American justice.
But occasionally, a man chose another path.
Instead of running, he decided to gamble everything on one enormous scheme.
If it failed, he would be ruined.
If it succeeded, he might erase the evidence of his previous crimes and become richer and safer than ever.
That is exactly what one prominent bank president decided to do.
Late in the 1860s, he sat in the parlor of a bank on Greenwich Street, anxiously studying the bank's books.
Only he knew the terrible truth.
He had stolen an enormous amount of money from the institution.
The losses were so large that discovery was becoming unavoidable.
His own family would be destroyed first.
He could not bear that thought.
He needed a way to hide the thefts.
Fortunately for him, he knew the one man in New York who could make such a plan possible.
That man was Captain Irving.
The bank president knew perfectly well how closely the police worked with professional thieves.
He also understood something else.
If his own bank were robbed, he could blame the missing money on burglars.
His defalcation could disappear inside the robbery.
So he contacted Irving.
The president explained his situation.
Then he made an extraordinary proposal.
“I want the bank robbed,” he said.
Irving listened carefully.
The president explained that he could make the robbery easy.
He could leave safes unlocked.
He could leave doors open.
He could provide keys and information.
In other words, he could make sure the burglars got inside.
Then he asked Irving:
“Can you find men who can do the job?”
New York had plenty of professional burglars.
The difficult part was finding men capable of carrying out such an important operation without making mistakes.
Irving quickly assured him:
“You can count on me. I'll find the right men.”
Among the criminals considered valuable by police headquarters at that time were Mike Hurley, Patsey Conroy, and Max Shinburn.
Irving immediately chose those three.
Finding them was not difficult.
That same night, they met at Irving's house.
When Irving explained the opportunity, they were thrilled.
The bank president, however, was another matter.
He was not an ordinary criminal.
He was a respected businessman.
He was the head of a major financial institution.
He was known in respectable society.
He was even a Sunday-school superintendent.
And yet, that night, he quietly made his way to a house where professional burglars were waiting for him.
He kept his distance from them, of course.
He had no desire to become personally acquainted with the men who would carry out his crime.
That was probably wise.
If they knew too much about him, they could blackmail him later.
Still, the fact remained that he had secretly gone to meet them.
He had become the author of a crime that would eventually ruin the lives of countless people who had trusted him.
Perhaps he felt ashamed.
Perhaps he felt disgusted.
Perhaps he felt nothing at all.
His situation was desperate.
Discovery was approaching rapidly.
If the bank's losses were uncovered, he would become a fugitive, facing disgrace and possible imprisonment.
In his mind, only one path remained.
He had chosen it.
Now he intended to follow it all the way.
And somehow, he succeeded.
No one ever publicly accused him of arranging the robbery.
If anyone suspected him, those suspicions never became public.
Who would believe that a respected bank president had secretly met with burglars in the middle of the night and planned the robbery of his own bank?
Yet that raises a much larger question.
When one person's wrongdoing causes other people to commit crimes, where does the original criminal's responsibility end?
A dishonest act rarely ends with the person who commits it.
The consequences can spread outward, ruining people who had nothing to do with the original crime.
But men rarely think about that while they are making their plans.
When the scheme is still exciting, success seems so close that conscience becomes easy to silence.
The bank president apparently felt no such hesitation that night.
Irving acted as the middleman.
He carried messages from the president to the burglars and then carried their replies back.
Eventually, everything was settled.
The burglars would receive duplicate keys to the safes.
They would also be given an easy way into the vaults.
Whatever they found inside would belong to them.
The thieves were delighted.
But there was one problem.
A bank robbery had to look like a real robbery.
If the safes were simply opened with keys, the bank's officials and shareholders would immediately become suspicious.
There had to be evidence of a violent break-in.
The vaults needed to look as though powerful burglars had fought their way inside.
So the president agreed to provide heavy burglary tools.
The thieves needed strong jimmies, wedges, and other equipment capable of forcing open the safes.
But there was a problem.
The burglars didn't have enough money to buy the tools.
That was hardly unusual.
Criminals might steal enormous sums of money, but somehow they rarely kept any of it.
Money disappeared almost as quickly as it arrived.
They themselves often couldn't explain where it had gone.
So the bank president had to pay for their equipment.
He provided about one thousand dollars for the jimmies, wedges, and other tools.
Irving took charge of the money.
He had too much at stake to let the burglars waste it.
The next step was carefully arranged.
Patsey Conroy would apply to rent a vacant basement beneath the bank.
The ceiling of that basement was directly below the floor of the room containing the bank's safes.
The president promised to make sure Conroy's application was approved.
If the bank asked for references, he would take care of the problem.
Everything happened exactly as planned.
Conroy applied for the basement.
The bank approved him.
He paid the rent in advance, which made the arrangement look completely legitimate to the bank employees.
Then he moved in.
Hurley and Shinburn joined him.
The following Saturday, they began quietly cutting through the basement ceiling.
They removed enough of it to create a hidden opening.
Only a few minutes of work would be needed to finish the hole.
Once the bank closed that evening, the burglars would have a doorway leading directly into the vaults above.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!